8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &(& Capítulo IV Regímenes cambiarios regionales: la experiencia europea Charles Wyplosz 1. Introducción :c \ZcZgVa! adh VXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZh h^\jZc YVcYd aj\Vg V XdcigdkZgh^Vh# 6 kZXZh hZ adh Xdch^YZgV jcV VbZcVoV eVgV adh h^hiZbVh bjai^aViZgVaZhn!Zceg^cX^e^d!hZZhi^bVfjZZabjai^aViZgVa^hbdh^ZbegZZh aVbZ_dgdeX^c#:aVg\jbZcidV[VkdgYZabjai^aViZgVa^hbdnZcXdcigVYZa gZ\^dcVa^hbd hZ Zci^ZcYZ bZ_dg Xdc gZheZXid V adh VXjZgYdh XdbZgX^VaZh/ adh VXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZh egdYjXZc jc VjbZcid YZa XdbZgX^d Zc aV gZ\^c! eZgd iVbW^c i^ZcZc Za Z[ZXid YZ YZhk^Vg Za XdbZgX^d YZa gZhid YZa bjcYd n! edg ZhV gVoc! edh^WaZbZciZ ejZYVc gZYjX^g Za W^ZcZhiVg \ZcZgVa# H^c ZbWVg\d!adhVXdciZX^b^ZcidhYZaVhai^bVhYXVYVhcdegjZWVcfjZZhid hZVVh#7VaYl^c&..,[dgbjaaVXdck^cXZciZiZdgVYZa¹Z[ZXidYdb^cº! hZ\c aV XjVa adh VXjZgYdh XdbZgX^VaZh gZ\^dcVaZh ^bejahVc adh VXjZgYdh bjai^aViZgVaZh! nV fjZ fj^ZcZh fjZYVc ZmXaj^Ydh i^ZcZc cjZkdh ^cXZci^kdh eVgVaaZ\VgVVXjZgYdhbjai^aViZgVaZhVadhfjZVciZhhZgZh^hiVc#AViZdgV Ydb^cZhY^c{b^XV0aVYZhk^VX^cYZaXdbZgX^dZhZhi{i^XV# AVVea^XVX^cYZaVegZhjcX^c\ZcZgVaZcXdcigVYZagZ\^dcVa^hbdV adhVXjZgYdhhdWgZi^edYZXVbW^dZhVcb{hZc\VdhV#:a;dcYdBdcZiVg^d >ciZgcVX^dcVa ;B> hZ XgZ Xdc Za Äc YZ egdbdkZg Za bjai^aViZgVa^hbd Zc adh VXjZgYdh hdWgZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d! eg^cX^eVabZciZ Xdbd jcV bVcZgV YZ &(' 8:E6A dedcZghZ V aV VjidYZhigjXi^kV daV YZ YZkVajVX^dcZh fjZ ¹ZbedWgZXVc Va kZX^cdº Zc Za eZgdYd ZcigZ \jZggVh# :hiV Zh aV gVoc edg aV XjVa Za ;B> n bjX]dheVhZhZhi{cYZhXdciZcidhXdcadhVXjZgYdhgZ\^dcVaZh#H^cZbWVg\d! YZWZcidbVghZZcXjZciVjcVhZg^ZYZ[VXidgZh# Eg^bZgd! cd Zm^hiZ jc h^hiZbV bdcZiVg^d ^ciZgcVX^dcVa! cd YZhYZ Za Äc YZa h^hiZbV YZ 7gZiidc LddYh# 8VYV eVh Zh a^WgZ YZ ZaZ\^g Za g\^bZc fjZXgZVb{hXdckZc^ZciZ!h^ccZXZh^YVYYZXZgX^dgVghZYZfjZhZV_jhiZVa YZ digdh eVhZh# :h kZgYVY fjZ Za 8dckZc^d 8dchi^iji^kd YZa ;B> egd]WZ bVc^ejaVX^dcZh YZa bZgXVYd XVbW^Vg^d Xdbd aVh YZa i^ed YZ ¹ZbedWgZXZg VakZX^cdº!eZgdcdZm^hiZgZ\aVVa\jcVfjZ^be^YVadhVXjZgYdhgZ\^dcVaZh# :hidhVXjZgYdhcdeZg_jY^XVcVjch^hiZbV^cZm^hiZciZ# HZ\jcYd! adh VXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZh Zm^hiZciZh cd ^cX^iVc V jc XdbedgiVb^ZcidXdaZXi^kdcZ\Vi^kd[gZciZVadheVhZhfjZcdhdcb^ZbWgdh# :aZjgdÅdiVa^WgZbZciZ!Xdbdad]VXZZaYaVgYZa8Vg^WZdg^ZciVa#:a[gVcXd 8;6Zhi{k^cXjaVYdVaZjgd#CdfjZYVXaVgdYZfjbVcZgViVaZhVXjZgYdh ejZYZcYVVgViZgXZgdh#CdhZ]VXdbegdWVYdfjZadhWadfjZhXdbZgX^VaZh egdkdfjZcYZhkdheZg_jY^X^VaZhYZaVhXdgg^ZciZhXdbZgX^VaZh!nZh^cXajhd bZcdhegdWVWaZfjZadhWadfjZhbdcZiVg^dhad]V\Vc# IZgXZgd!jcdYZadhZ[ZXidhY^gZXidhYZadhVXjZgYdhgZ\^dcVaZhZhaV Y^hb^cjX^c YZa g^Zh\d YZ Xg^h^h XVbW^Vg^Vh! fjZ bjX]Vh kZXZh egdYjXZc XdciV\^d Xdc XdchZXjZcX^Vh ^begZYZX^WaZh# Edg Z_Zbead! aVh bdcZYVh ZjgdeZVh hdaVc hj[g^g eZg^Y^XVbZciZ ViVfjZh ZheZXjaVi^kdh0 Zhd Zh ]^hidg^V YZhYZ Za VYkZc^b^Zcid YZ aV jc^c bdcZiVg^V! fjZ! Va bZcdh ]VhiVZabdbZcid!cd]VegdkdXVYd^cZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VZcZagZhidYZa bjcYd#:k^iVgaVhXg^h^hXdciV\^dhVhZhjcVYZaVhiVgZVhb{hjg\ZciZhYZa ¹h^hiZbVºbdcZiVg^d^ciZgcVX^dcVa!nhZejZYZVg\jbZciVgfjZadhVXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZhhdcaVgZhejZhiVb{hZ[ZXi^kV# :a gZX^ZciZ ^ciZgh Zc adh VXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZh hdWgZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d hZ k^d Zhi^bjaVYd edg aV ]^eiZh^h YZa ¹bZY^d ZmXaj^Ydº (hollowing-out)! iVbW^c aaVbVYV! V kZXZh! ¹hdajX^c YZ adh Ydh ZmigZbdhº! hZ\c aV XjVa cd Zm^hiZ jc ejcid bZY^d k^VWaZ ZcigZ aVh eVg^YVYZh ÅdiVciZh n g\^YVh h^hiZbVhYZXV_VYZXdckZgh^cdVYdeX^cYZjcVbdcZYVZmigVc_ZgV#9Z VXjZgYdXdcZhiVedhijgV!ZcjcbjcYdYZÅj_dhYZXVe^iVa^ggZhig^Xidhadh gZ\bZcZhigVY^X^dcVaZhYZi^edYZXVbW^dÄ_dZhi{cXdcYZcVYdhV[gVXVhVg! nadheVhZhfjZYZhZZca^b^iVgaVÅZm^W^a^YVYYZai^edYZXVbW^di^ZcZcfjZ deiVgedgeVg^YVYZhg\^YVh#AVXdcigVeVgiZgZ\^dcVaYZjcVeVg^YVYg\^YV ZhjcVjc^cbdcZiVg^V# AV XgZVX^c YZa Zjgd iVbW^c ]V Xdcig^Wj^Yd V aV XgZX^ZciZ edejaVg^YVYYZadhVXjZgYdhgZ\^dcVaZh#=VhiVZabdbZcidYZhjcVX^b^Zcid! Za egdnZXid YZa Zjgd hdaV igdeZoVg Xdc hdheZX]Vh n VYkZgiZcX^Vh YZ 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &(( YZhVhigZh^cb^cZciZh;ZaYhiZ^c!&..,#8^cXdVdhb{hiVgYZVcejZYZc ZhXjX]VghZegdchi^XdhYZfjZZaVXjZgYdZhi{egZYZhi^cVYdVa[gVXVhd!eZgd hjZcVcXVYVkZob{h]jZXdh#AVkZgYVYZhfjZZaZjgd]Vad\gVYdjcm^id VhdbWgdhd#FjZYVgdcZcZaeVhVYdadhYVhYZadhViVfjZhZheZXjaVi^kdhn adhVbea^dhY^[ZgZcX^VaZhYZ^cÅVX^cZc:jgdeV#HZZhi{YZhVggdaaVcYdjc ZcXZcY^YdYZWViZ!XdbdYZWZhZg!VXZgXVYZaYZhZbeZdYZa7VcXd8ZcigVa :jgdeZd 78:# HZ\jgVbZciZ Zh ^beZg[ZXid! Xdbd ]V h^Yd Za XVhd YZ eg{Xi^XVbZciZ idYVh aVh cjZkVh ^chi^ijX^dcZh [ZYZgVaZh# 6a\jcdh edai^Xdh edeja^hiVhZjgdeZdhXjaeVcVaZjgdedgXVYVY^ÄXjaiVYn!ZcbjX]dhXVhdh! hjhXgi^XVhZcXjZcigVcZXd!eZgdhjhVg\jbZcidhhdcYW^aZhZ^c[jcYVYdh# AVhjc^dcZhbdcZiVg^VhgZ\^dcVaZhejZYZcYVgWjZcdhgZhjaiVYdh!Va^\jVa fjZ digdh VXjZgYdh gZ\^dcVaZh! Xdbd Za bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d k^\ZciZVciZg^dgbZciZZc:jgdeV# H^cZbWVg\d!edYgVhZg^\jVabZciZZc\VdhdeZchVgfjZZaZ_Zbead ZjgdeZd ejZYZ igVchedcZghZ [{X^abZciZ V digdh aj\VgZh# 9jgVciZ adh ai^bdh*%Vdh!:jgdeV]Vad\gVYdjcZmigVdgY^cVg^d\gVYdYZ^ciZ\gVX^c ZXdcb^XVnÄcVcX^ZgV#:caVVXijVa^YVY!'*eVhZhXdbeVgiZcjcbZgXVYd c^XdYZW^ZcZhnhZgk^X^dh!n&']VcVYdeiVYdjcVbdcZYVXdbc!ZaZjgd# 9jgVciZ aV egm^bV YXVYV! Va\jcdh eVhZh hZ jc^g{c Va bZgXVYd c^Xd n digdh &% edYgVc VYdeiVg Za Zjgd# :hiZ egdXZhd iVbW^c kV VXdbeVVYd! Zc X^ZgiV bZY^YV! YZ ^ciZ\gVX^c edai^XV! bZY^VciZ Zh[jZgodh Y^g^\^Ydh V XdbeVi^W^a^oVg aVh edai^XVh ZmigVc_ZgVh Xdc aV hZ\jg^YVY ^ciZgcV# Cd dWhiVciZ! cd idYd Zh eZg[ZXid n idYVkV ]Vn YZhV[dh igZbZcYdh! VjcfjZ hdad hZ igViZ YZ bZ_dgVg aV ZhigjXijgV YZ \dW^Zgcd! Y^hZVYV ^c^X^VabZciZ eVgV adh eg^bZgdh hZ^h eVhZh fjZ [dgbVgdc aV 8dbjc^YVY :Xdcb^XV Zc &.*-#1H^cZbWVg\d!hZigViVYZjcVXjZgYdYZegd[jcY^YVYnZckZg\VYjgV h^c egZXZYZciZh! fjZ VXZgXV V eVhZh fjZ Zhijk^Zgdc Zc \jZggV jcdh Xdc digdh YjgVciZ adh ai^bdh b^a Vdh# AV \jZggV Zh ^beZchVWaZ ]dn! n Zh egZX^hVbZciZ Za YZhZd YZ Zk^iVgaV ad fjZ ]V hdhiZc^Yd Za Zh[jZgod n aV XZaZg^YVYedggZcjcX^VgV^bedgiVciZhZaZbZcidhYZaVhdWZgVcVcVX^dcVa# AV iZh^h YZ ZhiZ igVWV_d Zh fjZ Za XVhd ZjgdeZd ZcX^ZggV Va\jcVh ZchZVcoVh ^bedgiVciZh! eZgd iVbW^c kVg^Vh VYkZgiZcX^Vh# :c a hZ igViV YZ YZbdhigVg! edg Z_Zbead! fjZ Za Xdbegdb^hd YZ bVciZcZg i^edh YZ XVbW^dÄ_dhh^ZbegZ]ViZc^Ydeg^dg^YVY[gZciZVaVbdk^a^YVYYZaXVe^iVa# AVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VhZ]Vk^hidXdbdXdcY^X^cegZk^VVaV^ciZ\gVX^c XdbZgX^VanXdbdaVc^XV[dgbVYZZhiVWaZXZggZ\aVhYZ_jZ\deVgZ_VheVgV aV XdbeZiZcX^V ^ciZgcVX^dcVa# AV YZX^h^c YZ VYdeiVg jcV bdcZYV Xdbc aaZ\ bjX]d YZhejh! Vh Xdbd hZ gZhig^c\^ aV bdk^a^YVY YZ XVe^iVaZh 1 :hidheVhZh[jZgdc7a\^XV!;gVcX^V!6aZbVc^V!>iVa^V!AjmZbWjg\dnEVhZh7V_dh# &() 8:E6A YjgVciZYXVYVhnhZad\ghdadYZhejhYZ]VWZgVaXVcoVYdjcVaid\gVYdYZ ^ciZ\gVX^cXdbZgX^VanYZ]VWZgXgZVYd^chi^ijX^dcZhYZVedndedYZgdhVh# EVgV YZX^gad YZ digd bdYd! eg^bZgd k^c^Zgdc aV ^ciZ\gVX^c XdbZgX^Va gZ\^dcVa!aVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VnaVXgZVX^cYZ^chi^ijX^dcZh0aVbdk^a^YVY YZXVe^iVaZhnaVjc^cbdcZiVg^VaaZ\VgdcYZhejh#Jc^ciZggd\VciZXaVkZZh h^ZhiZdgYZchZejZYZbdY^ÄXVgnh^Zhedh^WaZVXZaZgVgZag^ibdYZaegdXZhd# AVgZhejZhiVZhfjZVbWVhXdhVhhdcWVhiVciZ^begdWVWaZh# :c aV h^\j^ZciZ hZXX^c hZ VcVa^oVc aVh gVodcZh edg aVh XjVaZh aVh eZfjZVh ZXdcdbVh VW^ZgiVh! d Zc kVh YZ VeZgijgV! hZ egZdXjeVc edg aV ZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VnYZfjbVcZgVhZejZYZVaXVcoVgZhiVZhiVW^a^YVY# HZ ZmVb^cV aV [dgbV Zc fjZ :jgdeV ]V igViVYd ZhiZ iZbV# IVbW^c hZ Zc[Vi^oVfjZaVZaZXX^cYZjcg\^bZcXVbW^Vg^dYZWZ^gYZaVbVcdYZaV ZaZXX^cYZjcg\^bZcYZbdk^a^YVYYZaXVe^iVa#:caVhZXX^c(hZYZhXg^WZ Zc YZiVaaZ Za \gVYjVa ZcYjgZX^b^Zcid YZ adh VXjZgYdh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d Zc :jgdeV# :c aV hZXX^c ) hZ VcVa^oVc aVh aZXX^dcZh fjZ ]V YZ_VYd ZhV ZmeZg^ZcX^V!nZcaVai^bVhZegZhZciVcVa\jcVhXdcXajh^dcZh# 2. La lógica de las paridades flexibles a) Elección del régimen 6eZhVgYZhZgVigVXi^kV!aV]^eiZh^hYZa¹bZY^dZmXaj^YdºcdhZ]V edY^YdYZbdhigVgZcaVeg{Xi^XV!VabZcdh]VhiVZabdbZcid#AVZm^hiZcX^V YZjcdhedXdhXVhdhW^ZcXdcdX^YdhYZVYdeX^cYZeVg^YVYZhg\^YVhZc adh Vdh cdkZciV XV_Vh YZ XdckZgh^c Zc 6g\Zci^cV! 7ja\Vg^V! :hidc^V n A^ijVc^V0 YdaVg^oVX^c Zc :XjVYdg n :a HVakVYdg cd ^bea^XV fjZ hZ ]VnV egdYjX^Yd jc kjZaXd bVh^kd ]VX^V ZhZ i^ed YZ eVg^YVY# BjX]dh eVhZh ]VcVcjcX^VYdfjZeZgb^i^g{caVa^WgZÅdiVX^cYZhjhbdcZYVh!eZgdcd h^ZbegZ ZhVh YZXaVgVX^dcZh hZ ]Vc k^hid hZ\j^YVh YZ bZY^YVh XdcXgZiVh# :c Za \g{ÄXd >K#& hZ egZhZciVc Za g\^bZc XVbW^Vg^d dÄX^Va ^c[dgbVYd Va ;B> n Za fjZ gZVabZciZ Zm^hiZ! hZ\c aVh ^ckZhi^\VX^dcZh YZ AZkn"NZnVi^ n HijgoZcZ\\Zg# HZ ejZYZ dWhZgkVg fjZ aV egdedgX^c YZ gZ\bZcZh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d Ä_d hZ gZYj_d ZcigZ &.-% n '%%%! b^ZcigVh fjZ hZ gZ\^hig jc VjbZcid ^\jVa Zc adh gZ\bZcZh YZ ÅdiVX^c a^WgZ# AZkn"NZnVi^ n HijgoZcZ\\Zg XdcÄgbVc fjZ aV edejaVg^YVY YZ adh gZ\bZcZh YZ XVbW^d Ä_d Zhi{ Y^hb^cjnZcYd! eZgd aaZ\Vc V aV XdcXajh^c YZ fjZ aV VYdeX^c YZ gZ\bZcZh ^ciZgbZY^dh kV Zc VjbZcid eVg^YVY bk^a! ÅdiVX^c XdcigdaVYV# Jc eVcdgVbV h^b^aVg hjg\Z YZ aV XaVh^ÄXVX^c YZ GZ^c]Vgi n Gd\d[['%%)!fjZji^a^oVcjcegdXZY^b^ZcidY^[ZgZciZeVgV^YZci^ÄXVgadh gZ\bZcZhXVbW^Vg^dh# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &(* Gráfico IV.1 REGÍMENES CAMBIARIOS OFICIALES SEGÚN EL FMI Y REGÍMENES OBSERVADOS EN LA PRÁCTICA (Porcentaje de todos los países) Clasificación del FMI Clasificación del LYS Fuente: Levy-Yeyati y Sturzenegger (LYS), 2002. AV Zk^YZcX^V Zc XdcigV YZ aV ]^eiZh^h YZa ¹bZY^d ZmXaj^Ydº Zh YZ Xdch^YZgVWaZ^bedgiVcX^V#:hiV]^eiZh^hhZWVhVZcZaVg\jbZcid!idiVabZciZ XdggZXid! YZ fjZ! XjVcYd Za XVe^iVa hZ bjZkZ a^WgZbZciZ! adh gZ\bZcZh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d Ä_d hdc ^cZhiVWaZh! V bZcdh fjZ a^hV n aaVcVbZciZ hZ VWVcYdcZZajhdYZaVedai^XVbdcZiVg^VnidYdhadhZh[jZgodhhZY^g^_VcV hdhiZcZgaVeVg^YVY#:cZhZXVhd!h^cZbWVg\d!aVeVg^YVYeVhVVhZgg\^YV0 cd Zm^hiZ jc XVb^cd ^ciZgbZY^d fjZ hZV hdhiZc^WaZ# AV Zk^YZcX^V eVgZXZ ^cY^XVg!edgZaXdcigVg^d!fjZbjX]dheVhZhcdYZhZVcaaZ\VgVZmigZbdh# BjZhigVc iVcid ¹b^ZYd V jcV ÅdiVX^c a^WgZº 8Vakd n GZ^c]Vgi! '%%% Xdbd¹b^ZYdVjci^edYZXVbW^dÄ_dº#AVgZh^hiZcX^VVVYdeiVgeVg^YVYZh dÄX^VaZh Ä_Vh hZ Zmea^XV edg aV egY^YV YZ ^cYZeZcYZcX^V bdcZiVg^V n Za g^Zh\d YZ egdbdkZg ViVfjZh ZheZXjaVi^kdh# AV gZh^hiZcX^V V VYdeiVg jcV ÅdiVX^ca^WgZ!edghjeVgiZ!hZZmea^XVedgZaVaid\gVYdYZkdaVi^a^YVYfjZ hjZaZbdhigVgajZ\dZai^edYZXVbW^d# AV^YZVYZfjZhZZkdajX^dcVg{cVijgVabZciZ]VX^VaVeaZcVbdk^a^YVY YZaXVe^iVaZh[jcYVbZciVaeVgVaV]^eiZh^hYZa¹bZY^dZmXaj^Ydº#H^cZbWVg\d! adfjZaVZk^YZcX^VYZbjZhigVZhfjZaVbVndgVYZadheVhZhZcYZhVggdaad hdc gZVX^dh V Za^b^cVg idYVh aVh gZhig^XX^dcZh V aV bdk^a^YVY YZa XVe^iVa n Vea^XVc edg ad YZb{h Za Zc[dfjZ YZ aV bVndgV YZ adh eVhZh YZhVggdaaVYdh# 9Z ]ZX]d! cd [jZ h^cd ]VhiV adh ai^bdh Vdh YZ aV YXVYV YZ &.-% fjZ aV bdk^a^YVY eaZcV YZa XVe^iVa hZ kdak^ cdgbV ZcigZ adh eVhZh YZhVggdaaVYdh# 8dbdY^hXji^gZbdhb{hVYZaVciZ!ZhidZhadfjZaaZkVaVVYdeX^cYZaZjgd# &(+ 8:E6A 9^X]d YZ digd bdYd! aV ZaZXX^c YZ jc g\^bZc YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d cdejZYZZhiVgY^hdX^VYVYZag\^bZcYZbdk^a^YVYYZaXVe^iVa#AV]^eiZh^h YZa ¹bZY^d ZmXaj^Ydº! gZZcXVgcVX^c YZ ad fjZ hdaV aaVbVghZ aV ¹ig^c^YVY ^bedh^WaZº!ejZYZgZ[dgbjaVghZYZaVh^\j^ZciZbVcZgV/h^jceVhdeiVedg jc g\^bZc YZ eaZcV bdk^a^YVY YZ XVe^iVaZh! adh c^Xdh gZ\bZcZh YZ i^ed YZXVbW^dhdhiZc^WaZhhdcadhfjZZhi{cZcadhZmigZbdh/eVg^YVYZhg\^YVh d ÅdiVX^c a^WgZ# H^ jc eVh hZ ^cXa^cV edg jc Vaid \gVYd YZ ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V! fjZ hZ YZÄc^g{ Xdc bVndg egZX^h^c b{h VYZaVciZ! YZWZg{ ZcidcXZhgZhig^c\^gaVbdk^a^YVYYZaXVe^iVa# b) Formas de estabilidad cambiaria :hiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V cd cZXZhVg^VbZciZ h^\c^ÄXV eVg^YVY Ä_V# Jc i^edYZXVbW^dÄ_deZgdV_jhiVWaZYZaZhi^ad7gZiidcLddYh!XdcWVcYVhYZ ÅjXijVX^c!gZegZhZciVjcV[dgbVYZad\gVgjcX^Zgid\gVYdYZZhiVW^a^YVY! VjcfjZ cd aV c^XV# :c egZhZcX^V YZ jcV ^cÅVX^c VaiV eZgd bdYZgVYV! Za i^edYZXVbW^dÄ_dYZWZYZegZX^VghZeZg^Y^XVbZciZ!edgZ_ZbeadbZY^VciZ eVg^YVYZh bk^aZh Xdc Y^kZghVh [gZXjZcX^Vh YZ V_jhiZ# Jc WjZc hjhi^ijid ejZYZhZgjcVÅdiVX^cXdcigdaVYV!YdcYZaVhVjidg^YVYZheZgb^iZc!YZhZg cZXZhVg^d!fjZZai^edYZXVbW^dhZYZegZX^ZXdcZai^Zbed!eZgda^b^iVcZa bVg\ZcYZÅjXijVX^cZcidgcdVaViZcYZcX^V# :hiVk^h^cYZZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V]VXZ]^cXVe^ZcZaXdbedgiVb^Zcid YZa i^ed YZ XVbW^d! VheZXid h^c YjYV ^bedgiVciZ! VjcfjZ cd Za c^Xd fjZ XjZciV# >\jVabZciZ ^bedgiVciZ Zh Za \gVYd YZ Xdbegdb^hd# Jc VcjcX^d YZ fjZhZkVVbVciZcZgjci^edYZXVbW^dÄ_d!nVhZVÄ_deZgdV_jhiVWaZdjcV eVg^YVY bk^a! XdbegdbZiZ Va \dW^Zgcd YZ Ydh [dgbVh# :c eg^bZg aj\Vg! aV edai^XV bdcZiVg^V YZWZ hZg gZhig^c\^YV# :hiV gZhig^XX^c ejZYZ hjVk^oVghZ! ZcX^ZgiVbZY^YV!YZhk^cXjaVcYdadhbZgXVYdhÄcVcX^ZgdhcVX^dcVaZhYZaVh XdcY^X^dcZh^ciZgcVX^dcVaZhbZY^VciZaV^bedh^X^cYZab^iZhVaVbdk^a^YVY YZ XVe^iVaZh! eZgd aV ZÄXVX^V YZ iVaZh XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa Zh a^b^iVYV# :c hZ\jcYdigb^cd!ZaVcjcX^dYZjcVWVcYVYZÅjXijVX^c!cd^bedgiVXj{c VcX]VhZV!^bea^XVfjZadhZmigZbdhZhi{cZmejZhidhVaVegZh^cZheZXjaVi^kV# 8jVcYd Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d hZ Vegdm^bV V jc ZmigZbd! aV h^ijVX^c! edg ad \ZcZgVa! hZ kjZakZ ^chdhiZc^WaZ# :c XdchZXjZcX^V! jc VcjcX^d hdWgZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d Ä_d aaZkV Xdch^\d jcV ^ck^iVX^c ^beaX^iV V aV ZheZXjaVX^c# Adh XdcigdaZhYZXVe^iVad[gZXZcX^ZgiVegdiZXX^c0ZcgZVa^YVY!ZhVaaYdcYZhdc ZÄXVXZh!nVfjZWg^cYVcjcgZhe^gdZcbZY^dYZjcVXg^h^hbdcZiVg^V#2 2 :hiVV[^gbVX^chZgZ[^ZgZhdadVaVji^a^YVYYZadhXdcigdaZhYjgVciZViVfjZhZheZXjaVi^kdh# :m^hiZ jc ZaZkVYd cbZgd YZ ejWa^XVX^dcZh hdWgZ aV ji^a^YVY YZ adh XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa n hdWgZaVhY^hidgh^dcZhfjZejZYZcXVjhVg#<gVceVgiZYZZaaVhZhZmigZbVYVbZciZXgi^XVYZ Y^X]dhXdcigdaZhYZW^YdVfjZigVZcVeVgZ_VYdhVaidhXdhidhnedXdhWZcZ[^X^dh#Gd\d[['%%' ZhVjidgYZjchZg^dZhijY^dhdWgZZaiZbV# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &(, :a g\^bZc fjZ XdWgV XVYV kZo b{h edejaVg^YVY Zh Za YZ ÅdiVX^c XdcigdaVYV# EVgZXZ d[gZXZg ad bZ_dg YZ XVYV h^hiZbV! nV fjZ eZgb^iZ V aVh Vjidg^YVYZh a^b^iVg aVh ÅjXijVX^dcZh V Xdgid eaVod n! Va b^hbd i^Zbed! hZ VYVeiVVaVhiZcYZcX^VhVaVg\deaVodnZa^b^cVZaXdbegdb^hdfjZ^ck^iVV ViVfjZhZheZXjaVi^kdh#H^cZbWVg\d!ZhiVk^h^cZhZc\VdhV#AdhbZgXVYdh hdcWjZcdheVgVYZhXjWg^gaVZhigViZ\^V^beaX^iVnejZYZcedcZgVegjZWV adh ab^iZh ^beaX^idh YZ aVh ÅjXijVX^dcZh# H^ iVaZh ab^iZh cd Zm^hiZc d hdc Y^[jhdh!ZaZ[ZXidYZZhiVW^a^oVX^chZe^ZgYZ#H^!ZcXVbW^d!aVhVjidg^YVYZh ^bedcZcab^iZh!aVY^[ZgZcX^VXdcaVhWVcYVhZmeaX^iVhgZhjaiVbZgVbZciZ hjeZgÄX^Va# Ad b^hbd kVaZ eVgV aV Vbea^ijY YZ aVh WVcYVh YZ ÅjXijVX^c# AVhWVcYVhZhigZX]Vh^bedcZcjcV[jZgiZgZhig^XX^cVaVedai^XVbdcZiVg^V0 aVh WVcYVh VcX]Vh egdYjXZc Z[ZXidh fjZ Y^ÄZgZc bjn edXd YZ adh fjZ egdkdXV jcV ÅdiVX^c a^WgZ! Xdc aV Y^[ZgZcX^V YZ fjZ ZhiVg{c ZmejZhiVh dXVh^dcVabZciZVaVegZh^cZheZXjaVi^kV# :cYZÄc^i^kV!cVYVZh\gVij^id/aVkdaVi^a^YVYYZai^edYZXVbW^dhdad ejZYZ a^b^iVghZ ^bedc^ZcYd V aV edai^XV bdcZiVg^V gZhig^XX^dcZh WVhiVciZ Zhig^XiVh# :m^hiZc kVg^Vh [dgbVh YZ ad\gVg ZhiZ dW_Zi^kd0 idYVh gZfj^ZgZc Y^hX^ea^cV#:hiVZhaVgVocedgaVXjVaVai^edYZXVbW^dÄ_d!nVhZVYZjcVj digVXaVhZ!hZadhjZaZaaVbVg¹VcXaVº#8dbdiVa!Zhjc^chigjbZcidkZciV_dhd! XdbeVgVWaZVdigVhgZ\aVhYZedai^XVbdcZiVg^V!iVaZhXdbdaVhfjZVejciVc Va Xdcigda YZ aV ^cÅVX^c d V XdcigdaVg Za XgZX^b^Zcid bdcZiVg^d# EVgV aVh eZfjZVhZXdcdbVhVW^ZgiVhejZYZhZgaVbZ_dgdeX^c!XdbdhZY^hXjiZZc aVegm^bVhZXX^c# c) Por qué es importante la estabilidad del tipo de cambio: el caso europeo :m^hiZcY^kZghVhgVodcZheVgVfjZgZga^b^iVgaVkVg^VW^a^YVYYZai^ed YZXVbW^d#AVhb{hXdbcbZciZX^iVYVhhdcaVWhfjZYVYZZhiVW^a^YVY Xdcegdeh^idhXdbZgX^VaZh!aVZhigViZ\^VYZ^bedgiVgY^hX^ea^cVbdcZiVg^V n aV VjhZcX^V YZ bZgXVYdh [^cVcX^Zgdh n XVbW^Vg^dh hj[^X^ZciZbZciZ egd[jcYdh# :hiV hZXX^c YZbjZhigV Za ]ZX]d YZ fjZ Zc :jgdeV aV bdi^kVX^cXaVkZ[jZZaXdbZgX^d# :c adh Vdh X^cXjZciV! adh bZgXVYdh ÄcVcX^Zgdh n XVbW^Vg^dh YZ :jgdeV cd ZhiVWVc bjn YZhVggdaaVYdh# 9Zhejh YZ aV VYdeX^c YZ aV XdckZgi^W^a^YVY YZ aV XjZciV Xdgg^ZciZ Zc &.*-! hZ\jVc egZkVaZX^ZcYd gZhig^XX^dcZhVaVXjZciVYZXVe^iVa!ZceVgiZYZW^YdVaVXgZZcX^VYZfjZZaad VnjYVgVVfjZZah^hiZbVYZi^edYZXVbW^dÄ_d[jcX^dcVgV#EVgVÄcZhYZaV YXVYVYZ&.,%!:jgdeVXdciVWVXdcbZgXVYdhadhjÄX^ZciZbZciZegd[jcYdh Xdbd eVgV edYZg deZgVg bZgXVYdh XVbW^Vg^dh WVhiVciZ ZÄX^ZciZh0 h^c ZbWVg\d!aVhgZhig^XX^dcZhYZXVe^iVahZ\jVch^ZcYd\ZcZgVa^oVYVh#:aGZ^cd Jc^Yda^WZgVa^ohjhbZgXVYdhZc&.,.!VjcfjZcdhZ^ciZ\gVaBZXVc^hbd &(- 8:E6A YZI^edhYZ8VbW^dBI8YZaH^hiZbVBdcZiVg^d:jgdeZd!^chi^ij^YdZhZ b^hbdVd#9ZcigdYZah^hiZbV!6aZbVc^V[jZZaeg^bZgeVhZcXVbW^VgYZ g\^bZc!Zc&.-&!nYjgVciZbjX]di^Zbed!Zac^XdkVhZb{hVYZaVciZZa XjVYgd >K#&# 9jgVciZ Zhdh Vdh egZk^dh V aV a^WZgVa^oVX^c! ]jWd bjX]Vh gVodcZhYjYdhVheVgVbVciZcZgadhXdcigdaZhYZXVe^iVanhdadjcVWjZcV/Za iZbdgYZfjZaVbdk^a^YVY^ggZhig^XiVYZXVe^iVaZhejY^ZgVedcZgZceZa^\gd aVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V# 8dc[gZXjZcX^VhZVÄgbVfjZaVbVndgVYZadheVhZhYZhZVWVji^a^oVg Xdbd VcXaV Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d cdb^cVa V Äc YZ ^cigdYjX^g aV Y^hX^ea^cV YZa 7jcYZhWVc`#:hiVZhjcVk^h^cgZk^h^dc^hiVYZaVh^ijVX^c!VabZcdh]VhiV adhVdhdX]ZciV#EVgVZbeZoVg!ZahjejZhidZcfjZhZWVhVWVZaVg\jbZcid YZ aV Y^hX^ea^cV ZgV fjZ aV iVhV YZ ^cÅVX^c ZjgdeZV hZ bVciZcYgV XZgXVcV V aV YZ adh :hiVYdh Jc^Ydh YjgVciZ Za eZgdYd YZ 7gZiidc LddYh n edhiZg^dgbZciZ hZ VXZgXVgV V aV YZ 6aZbVc^V# :hiZ Vg\jbZcid hjedcV iVbW^c fjZ aV ^cÅVX^c YZ :jgdeV hZgV ^c[Zg^dg V aV YZ digdh eVhZh ^cYjhig^Va^oVYdh fjZ ]Vc VYdeiVYd jcV ÅdiVX^c a^WgZ YjgVciZ aV bVndg eVgiZYZaeZgdYdedhiZg^dgVaYZ7gZiidcLddYh8VcVY{!?Vec!Hj^oV!GZ^cd Jc^Ydn!b{hgZX^ZciZbZciZ!6jhigVa^VnCjZkVOZaVcY^V#:a\g{ÄXd>K#'cd eZgb^iZXdcÄgbVgZhdhhjejZhidh#:cegdbZY^d!:jgdeVXdcZmXZeX^cYZ Hj^oVnZaGZ^cdJc^Yd!fjZbVcijk^ZgdcjcVÅdiVX^ca^WgZZmeZg^bZci aVeZdg^cÅVX^cYZaVodcVYZaVDg\Vc^oVX^cYZ8ddeZgVX^cn9ZhVggdaad :Xdcb^XdhD89:#H^aVY^hX^ea^cV[jZaVbdi^kVX^c!cd[jcX^dc#Adb{h egdWVWaZZhfjZcdad[jZgV# Cuadro IV.1 AÑO DE LIBERALIZACIÓN EN EUROPA DE LA POSGUERRA Austria Bélgica Dinamarca Finlandia Francia Alemania Irlanda Italia Países Bajos Noruega Portugal España Suecia Suiza Reino Unido Interno Externo 1981 1978 1980 1970 1985 Ninguno 1969 1983 1981 1984 No disponible 1966 1983 1975 1971 No disponible 1990 1988 1989 1981 1992 1990 1986 1992 1992 1980 1979 Fuente: Controles cambiarios tomados de Bakker (1996), p. 220; topes crediticios tomados de Cottarelli y otros (1986), apéndice no publicado. 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &(. Gráfico IV.2 INFLACIÓN EN LA ZONA DE LA OCDE (En porcentajes) Fuente: FMI. Nota: Por OCDE “no europea” se entiende Australia, Canadá, Japón, Nueva Zelandia, Suiza y Reino Unido. AV ^YZV YZ fjZ adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d ejZYZc ji^a^oVghZ Xdbd VcXaV Zh WVhiVciZ gZX^ZciZ! Va bZcdh YZcigd YZ aV bZciVa^YVY dÄX^Va ZjgdeZV# Fj^ZcZh hdhi^ZcZc Za Vg\jbZcid YZ fjZ aV WhfjZYV YZ jc VcXaV ^cÅVX^dcVg^VVXijXdbdbdi^kVX^ceVgVZhiVWaZXZgZaH^hiZbVBdcZiVg^d :jgdeZdHB:Xdc[jcYZcaVhedXVh#Cd[jZh^cd]VhiVYZhejhYZaVdaV YZ Xg^h^h XVbW^Vg^Vh YZ &.-(! ajZ\d YZ fjZ ;gVcX^V VYdeiVgV aV ZhigViZ\^V YZa¹[gVcXd[jZgiZº!fjZZaHB:XdbZcoV[jcX^dcVgZc[dgbVVh^big^XV! Xdc Za bVgXd VaZb{c Xdbd VcXaV gZXdcdX^YV# 8jVcYd hZ XgZ Za HB:! hZ ]^odgZ[ZgZcX^VZmeaX^iVbZciZVaVZhiVW^a^YVYYZi^edYZXVbW^dcdb^cVa ncdVaYZhZdYZVcXaVgaV^cÅVX^cVaVhZhig^XiVhedai^XVhVaZbVcVh#Adh gZVa^cZVb^ZcidhcdhdadZgVcedh^WaZh!h^cdfjZhZegVXi^XVWVcVXi^kVbZciZ nh^ZbegZhZ_jhi^ÄXVWVcXdbd¹XdggZXX^cºYZadhY^[ZgZcX^VaZhYZ^cÅVX^c VXjbjaVYdh# 9Z ]ZX]d! Za HB: hZ XgZ ZmeaX^iVbZciZ Xdbd jc h^hiZbV h^big^Xd! h^c jcV bdcZYV XZcigVa# Hjh cdgbVh Zk^iVWVc Xj^YVYdhVbZciZ VYdeiVgaVegZhjcX^cYZah^hiZbVYZ7gZiidcLddYhYZfjZadheVhZhXdc VaiV ^cÅVX^c n bdcZYV YW^a hdedgiVgVc aV XVg\V YZa V_jhiZ! Zc XVhd YZ fjZhZegdYj_ZgVcYZh[VhZhnegZh^cYZadhbZgXVYdh#AVgZhedchVW^a^YVY &)% 8:E6A edgaVh^ciZgkZcX^dcZhZcZabZgXVYdXVbW^Vg^dZgVZhig^XiVbZciZW^aViZgVa! Xdc Vednd ^a^b^iVYd YZa eVh YZ bdcZYV [jZgiZ V VfjZa YZ bdcZYV YW^a! hZ\chZZmea^XVb{hVYZaVciZZcaVhZXX^c(#EdgbjX]dfjZaZbdaZhiVgV Va7jcYZhWVc`!3ZaHB:VejciVWVdÄX^VabZciZVjcV¹gZkZgh^cVaVbZY^Vº ncdV^bedcZgaVg^\jgdhVeg{Xi^XVYZa7jcYZhWVc`# AViZh^hYZfjZaVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V[dbZciVZaXdbZgX^dXVgZXZ YZ hjhiZcid iZg^Xd aV ^cXZgi^YjbWgZ ejZYZ VaZciVg d W^Zc YZhVaZciVg Za XdbZgX^d ^ciZgcVX^dcVa! hZ\c adh hjejZhidh n i^ZcZ jcV WVhZ Zbeg^XV a^b^iVYV# KVchZ! edg Z_Zbead! @ZcZc n GdYg^` &.-+! Xdc gZheZXid V adh Z[ZXidh YZ aV kdaVi^a^YVY YZ Xdgid eaVod Zc adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d gZVaZh Zc jcVbjZhigVYZeVhZh^cYjhig^Va^oVYdh!nYZ<gVjlZ&.--!fjZegZhZciV jc ZhijY^d hdWgZ Za ^beVXid YZ aV kdaVi^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V Zc aV Jc^c :jgdeZV0 ]Vn Zk^YZcX^Vh b{h ÄgbZh Zc GdhZ '%%%! Vh Xdbd iVbW^c Zc ejWa^XVX^dcZh VXZgXV YZa Z[ZXid ab^iZ =Zaa^lZaa! &..-0 EVghaZn n LZ^! '%%&#:cidYdXVhd!aVWhfjZYVYZZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V]Vh^YdXgjX^Va# AdhZcXVg\VYdhYZ[dgbjaVgaVedai^XVZXdcb^XVXgZVcfjZaVZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^Vcdb^cVaZh^bedgiVciZeVgVZaXdbZgX^d!nedh^WaZbZciZiZcVc WjZcVhgVodcZheVgVZaad# :cZa\g{ÄXd>K#(hZegZhZciVZk^YZcX^VYZaVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V ^ciZgcV Zc :jgdeV! V eVgi^g YZa i^ed YZ XVbW^d ZcigZ Ydh bdcZYVh XaVkZ! Za [gVcXd [gVcXh n Za bVgXd VaZb{c# :c Za \g{ÄXd hjeZg^dg ^ofj^ZgYd hZ bjZhigVZai^edYZXVbW^dgZVaZcigZZhiVhYdhbdcZYVhYjgVciZZaeZgdYd &.,&"&..-!VaXVWdYZaXjVaVbWVhYZ_VgdcYZZm^hi^g#:cZa\g{ÄXdYZVWV_d hZdWhZgkVZai^edYZXVbW^dgZVaYZa[gVcXd[gZciZVaYaVgYZadh:hiVYdh Jc^Ydh#:aXdcigVhiZZhbVgXVYdnhZkZXdcÄgbVYdedgadhYdh\g{ÄXdhYZ aVYZgZX]V!fjZYZhXg^WZcZaXdbedgiVb^ZcidYZaVa^WgVZhiZga^cV!bdcZYV cd ^cXaj^YV Zc Za HB: ZmXZeid YjgVciZ jc eZgdYd bjn WgZkZ Zc &..'# Eg{Xi^XVbZciZ Za b^hbd eVigc hZ Vea^XV V aVh digVh bdcZYVh YZa HB:# 8dc egdeh^idh XdbeVgVi^kdh! hZ bjZhigV iVbW^c Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d gZVa ZcigZ 6g\Zci^cV n 7gVh^a YjgVciZ Za eZgdYd &.-%"'%%(# 8dbd Zc Za XVhd YZ<gVc7gZiVVnhjhhdX^dhZjgdeZdh!aVkdaVi^a^YVYW^aViZgVaZcigZZhiVh YdhbdcZYVhZhYZaVb^hbVbV\c^ijYfjZhjkdaVi^a^YVY[gZciZVaYaVg# 8aVgVbZciZ! ig^jc[Vgdc adh eVhZh ZjgdeZdh fjZ YZhZVWVc ZhiVW^a^oVg hj i^edYZXVbW^dW^aViZgVa# 3 HZ\c ad YdXjbZciVc :^X]Zc\gZZc n Lneadho &..(! Za 7jcYZhWVc` ]VWV VXdgYVYd Zc [dgbV eg^kVYV Xdc Za IZhdgd 6aZb{c fjZ ZhiZ hjheZcYZgV aV Xa{jhjaV YZ ^ciZgkZcX^c h^ YZiZgb^cVWV fjZ ZhiVWV VbZcVoVcYd aV ZhiVW^a^YVY YZ egZX^dh# :hiV Xa{jhjaV hZ ^ckdX YjgVciZaVXg^h^hYZaVa^gVZchZei^ZbWgZYZ&..'# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa Gráfico IV.3 TIPOS DE CAMBIO REALES (Promedio de la muestra=100) Fuente: FMI. Nota: Para la construcción de este índice se utiliza el índice de precios al consumidor. &)& &)' 8:E6A :h ^bedgiVciZ hZVaVg fjZ cd [jZ Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d cdb^cVa! h^cd Za gZVa! Za fjZ [jZ ZhiVW^a^oVYd# :hiV dWhZgkVX^c Zh ^bedgiVciZ edg Ydh gVodcZh# Eg^bZgd! b^ZcigVh Za dW_Zi^kd ZgV Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d gZVa! Za ^chigjbZcid [jZ Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d cdb^cVa# :a egdXZY^b^Zcid Xdch^hi^ Zc gZXjgg^g Xdc [gZXjZcX^V V aVh Y^hedh^X^dcZh YZa BI8 eVgV Z[ZXijVg gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh n WVhVg Zhidh ZmeaX^iVbZciZ Zc aV eVg^YVY YZa edYZg VYfj^h^i^kd# HZ\jcYd! ZhiV dWhZgkVX^c Xdc[^gbV fjZ Za dW_Zi^kd cd ZgV ji^a^oVg Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d Xdbd VcXaV cdb^cVa eVgV ad\gVg jcV ^c[aVX^c jc^[dgbZbZciZ WV_V# 6aZbVc^V ZhiVWV ViVYV V aV ZhiVW^a^YVY YZ egZX^dh n aV ad\g YjgVciZ idYd Za eZgdYd# Digdh eVhZh! Zc ZheZX^Va ;gVcX^V Z >iVa^V! idaZgVWVc b{h aV ^c[aVX^c n gZVa^cZVWVc hjh i^edh YZ XVbW^d Zc [dgbVeZg^Y^XVeVgVgZhiVWaZXZgaVXdbeZi^i^k^YVY# 4EZgdZaYZhZbeZdYZ aV^c[aVX^cZcZaGZ^cdJc^YdZgVh^b^aVgVaYZ;gVcX^VZ>iVa^V#H^ZaGZ^cd Jc^YdcdhZjc^VaBI8cd[jZYZW^YdVaV^c[aVX^c!h^cdYZW^YdVfjZaZ VY_jY^XVWVbZcdg^bedgiVcX^VVaVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VfjZhjhkZX^cdh# H^c aj\Vg V YjYVh! adh Y^[ZgZcX^VaZh YZ ^c[aVX^c ZgVc Xdch^YZgVWaZbZciZ b{h bdYZgVYdh fjZ adh fjZ hZ dWhZgkVWVc! edg Z_Zbead! Zc 6bg^XV AVi^cV# :h bjn egdWVWaZ fjZ Za VXjZgYd cd ]jW^ZgV h^Yd edh^WaZ h^ Zhidh Y^[ZgZcX^VaZh ]jW^ZgVc h^Yd ZaZkVYdh# :c ZhZ hZci^Yd! aV ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^VZhiVWVegdbdk^ZcYdaVY^hX^ea^cV# :c gZhjbZc! Zc ZhiV hZXX^c hZ Vg\jbZciV fjZ eVgV adh eVhZh ZjgdeZdhaVZhiVW^a^YVYYZai^edYZXVbW^dgZVaZhjcdW_Zi^kdYZedai^XV XaVkZ#6Y^[ZgZcX^VYZZhiVk^h^c!ZaVg\jbZcidYZaVY^hX^ea^cVXdbdbZiV YZ aV ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V cd hZ XZcigV Zc Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d gZVa! h^cd Zc Za cdb^cVa! eZgd adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d cdb^cVaZh [jZgdc idYd bZcdh ZhiVWaZh!nZaXdbedgiVb^Zcid^cÅVX^dcVg^dYZadheVhZhZjgdeZdh]Vh^Yd eZdg fjZ Za YZ aV bVndgV YZ adh digdh eVhZh YZhVggdaaVYdh# IVbedXd Zh Xdck^cXZciZaViZh^hYZfjZadhi^edhYZXVbW^dhZbVciZcVcÄ_dhYZW^YdV fjZadhbZgXVYdhiZcVcbjnedXdYZhVggdaadeVgVhZgZÄXVXZh#:hZejZYZ ]VWZg h^Yd Za XVhd Zc adh Vdh X^cXjZciV n hZhZciV! XjVcYd aVh bdcZYVh h^beaZbZciZ cd ZgVc XdckZgi^WaZh! eZgd h^c aj\Vg V YjYVh cd ]V h^Yd Vh YZhYZZaYZXZc^dYZ&.,%# 3. Regímenes cambiarios de Europa :c ZhiV hZXX^c hZ YZhXg^WZc WgZkZbZciZ adh Y^[ZgZciZh gZ\bZcZh VYdeiVYdh Zc :jgdeV YZhYZ Za Äc YZ aV HZ\jcYV <jZggV BjcY^Va# HZ bjZhigVc Ydh VheZXidh XaVkZ YZ aV ^ciZ\gVX^c bdcZiVg^V ZjgdeZV/ jcV 4 AdhEVhZh7V_dhji^a^oVgdcVXi^kVbZciZZai^edYZXVbW^dXdbdVcXaVnhZXdbegdbZi^Zgdc VcdYZkVajVgcjcXVXdcgZheZXidVabVgXdVaZb{c# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &)( WhfjZYV XdchiVciZ YZ aV ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V ^ciZgcV n jcV hjXZh^c YZ VjYVXZh VkVcXZh n gZigdXZhdh iZbedgVaZh# AV ZhigViZ\^V YZ :jgdeV [gZciZ V aV XddgY^cVX^c YZa i^ed YZ XVbW^d ]V h^Yd \gVYjVa n egV\b{i^XV# HZ [jZ eaVhbVcYd eg^cX^eVabZciZ Xdbd gZVXX^c VciZ VXdciZX^b^Zcidh! iVcid ZmiZgcdhedgZ_Zbead!ZaÄcYZah^hiZbVYZ7gZiidcLddYhXdbd^ciZgcdh edg Z_Zbead! aV Za^b^cVX^c YZ adh XdcigdaZh YZa XVe^iVa n ]V Zk^iVYd XjVafj^Zg egdnZXid YZ \gVc bV\c^ijY# :a EaVc LZgcZg YZ &.,&! fjZ iZcV Xdbd dW_Zi^kd ^cigdYjX^g jcV bdcZYV Xdbc Zc jc eZgdYd YZ Ydh Vdh! cjcXV hZ ejhd Zc bVgX]V# :a egdnZXid hZ VYdei '% Vdh YZhejh! eZgd hdad XjVcYd nV ZgV Zk^YZciZ fjZ Za BI8 cd edYV ]VXZg [gZciZ V aV eaZcV bdk^a^YVY YZa XVe^iVa! Vjc XjVcYd adh ZcXVg\VYdh YZ [dgbjaVg aV edai^XV ZXdcb^XVfj^o{hcd]VWVcVYkZgi^YdZhiVcZXZh^YVY# a) Breve reseña histórica Bretton Woods. Adh VXjZgYdh YZ 7gZiidc LddYh Y^hejh^Zgdc ^cY^gZXiVbZciZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d Ä_dh YZcigd YZ :jgdeV! eZgd cd gZegZhZciVgdcjcXdbegdb^hdXdc_jcid!c^iVbedXdZhijk^ZgdcY^g^\^YdhV [VkdgZXZgVa\cdW_Zi^kdZjgdeZdZceVgi^XjaVg#:hidhVXjZgYdhXd^cX^Y^Zgdc Xdc adh ^ciZgZhZh ZjgdeZdh! eZgd iVbW^c Xdc adh YZ adh :hiVYdh Jc^Ydh! fjZ ZhiVWVc ^\jVabZciZ ^ciZgZhVYdh Zc aV gZhiVjgVX^c YZ adh aVodh XdbZgX^VaZh#:c[gZciVYdhVjcVegdcjcX^VYVZhXVhZoYZhVaYdhZcYaVgZh! Zcjceg^cX^e^dadheVhZhZjgdeZdhcd^bejahVgdcaVXdckZgi^W^a^YVYYZhjh bdcZYVh#6bZY^YVfjZhZXdcXZcigVWVcZcVXjZgYdhW^aViZgVaZhYZeV\d! iVcid ZcigZ Zaadh Xdbd Xdc eVhZh cd ZjgdeZdh! XdbZcoVgdc V ^YZVg hjh egde^dhbZXVc^hbdh# La Unión Europea de Pagos. AV Jc^c :jgdeZV YZ EV\dh hZ XgZ Zc &.*% Xdc Za egdeh^id YZ h^bea^ÄXVg aV Xdbea^XVYV bVgVV YZ jcdh '%% VXjZgYdh W^aViZgVaZh YZ eV\dh# ;jcX^dc Xdbd h^hiZbV XdbeZchVYdg bjai^aViZgVanhZXZcigZcaVWVaVcoVYZeV\dhidiVaYZadheVhZhb^ZbWgdh gZheZXidYZaVjc^c#<ZcZgVabZciZXdch^YZgVYVjcm^id!ZhgZXdcdX^YVedg ]VWZgXdcig^Wj^YdVaVgZVcjYVX^cYZaXdbZgX^dZcigZadheVhZhZjgdeZdh# H^cZbWVg\d!ijkdVa\jcVhYZhkZciV_Vh!ZcZheZX^VaaViZcYZcX^VVVaZciVgZa XdbZgX^dZcigZhjhb^ZbWgdh!ZcYZig^bZcidYZadheVhZhfjZcdadZgVc# Convertibilidad. :a h^\j^ZciZ eVhd ^bedgiVciZ! aV gZhiVjgVX^c YZ aV XdckZgi^W^a^YVY YZ aVh bdcZYVh Zc &.*-! hZ YZX^Y^ Zc [dgbV XdaZXi^kV! h^bjai{cZVbZciZXdcaVXZaZWgVX^cYZaIgViVYdYZGdbV!bZY^VciZZaXjVa hZ XgZ Za BZgXVYd 8dbc :jgdeZd# :c jc eg^cX^e^d! aV XdckZgi^W^a^YVY hdadhZVea^XVaVXjZciVXdgg^ZciZ#:caVbVndgVYZadheVhZh!aVhXjZciVh ÄcVcX^ZgVh eZgbVcZX^Zgdc hj_ZiVh V gZhig^XX^dcZh YgVXdc^VcVh YjgVciZ bjX]dh Vdh b{h# :a VXjZgYd egdedgX^dc jc Vaid \gVYd YZ ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V!XdcedXdhgZVa^cZVb^Zcidh#AVeg^bZgVYZegZX^VX^c^bedgiVciZ! &)) 8:E6A gZVa^oVYV edg Za GZ^cd Jc^Yd! cd dXjgg^ ]VhiV &.+,# ;jZ hjXZY^YV edg jcVYZegZX^VX^cYZa[gVcXd[gVcXhnjcVgZkVajVX^cYZabVgXdVaZb{c! VbWVhZc&.+.# La serpiente. EVgVXjVcYdhZegdYj_dZaXdaVehdYZah^hiZbVYZ7gZiidc LddYhZc&.,&"&.,(!hZ]VWVcVXjbjaVYdcjZkdhYZhZfj^a^Wg^dhZc:jgdeV# IgVh jcV hZg^Z YZ gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh! aV bVndgV YZ adh eVhZh ZjgdeZdh hZ XdbegdbZi^VbVciZcZgb{g\ZcZha^b^iVYdhYZÅjXijVX^ceVgVhjhi^edh YZ XVbW^d W^aViZgVaZh! b^ZcigVh digdh eVhZh YZhVggdaaVYdh eZgb^i^Zgdc aV a^WgZ ÅdiVX^c YZ hjh bdcZYVh# :a VXjZgYd gZhjaiVciZ! XdcdX^Yd Xdbd aV ¹hZge^ZciZ bdcZiVg^Vº ZjgdeZV! ijkd gZhjaiVYdh Y^heVgZh# AV bVndg eVgiZ YZadheVhZhad\gbVciZcZghZYZcigdYZadhb{g\ZcZhZhiVWaZX^Ydh!eZgdaV egZh^cZheZXjaVi^kVdWa^\Vdigdh!ZheZX^VabZciZ;gVcX^V!>iVa^VnHjZX^V!V gZi^gVghZYZaVXjZgYd#;jZgVYZ<gVc7gZiVV!cdhZXjZhi^dcVWVhZg^VbZciZ aVhZchViZoYZbVciZcZgi^edhYZXVbW^dÄ_dh# El Plan Werner. :a eg^cX^eVa gZkh eVgV aV ^ciZ\gVX^c bdcZiVg^V YjgVciZZhiZeZgdYdhZegdYj_dYZW^YdVaVWVcYdcdYZaEaVcLZgcZg#:cZa >c[dgbZLZgcZg!iZgb^cVYdZc&.,%nVegdWVYdedgZa8dchZ_dYZB^c^higdh Zc&.,&!hZgZXdbZcYVWVaVg{e^YVVYdeX^cYZjcVbdcZYVXdbc#:ca hZYZa^cZVWVcigZhZiVeVh!ZcigZZaaVhaV[dgbVX^cYZjc[dcYdYZgZhZgkVh YZ Y^k^hVh eVgV ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh Xdc_jciVh# AV XdcbdX^c egdkdXVYV edg aV YZh^ciZ\gVX^c YZa h^hiZbV YZ 7gZiidc LddYh aaZk V adh eVhZh b{h ^bedgiVciZhVegdedcZghZeVhdhb{hbdYZhidh!ZceVgiZedgegV\bVi^hbdn ZceVgiZXdbdegZiZmideVgVZhXVeVgVjcVYZX^h^cfjZ^WVXaVgVbZciZb{h Vaa{YZaVh^YZVhYZadhgZhedchVWaZhYZaVedai^XVZXdcb^XV#AdheVhZhb{h eZfjZdh! fjZ kZVc gZYjX^ghZ hj egde^V VjidcdbV YZ edai^XVh! ZhiVWVc YZXZeX^dcVYdhedgZa[gVXVhd!eZgdcdad\gVWVca^WgVghZYZaYdb^c^dYZadh eVhZhb{h^bedgiVciZh# El Sistema Monetario Europeo. H^cZbWVg\d!aV^ciZ\gVX^cbdcZiVg^V egdcididbdigVY^gZXX^c#:aH^hiZbVBdcZiVg^d:jgdeZdHB:hZVXdgY Zc &.,- n XdbZco V [jcX^dcVg Zc &.,.# DX]d YZ adh ZcidcXZh cjZkZ b^ZbWgdh YZ aV 8dbjc^YVY :jgdeZV hZ Xdck^gi^Zgdc Zc b^ZbWgdh VXi^kdh YZabZXVc^hbdYZi^edhYZXVbW^dBI8#8jVcYdhZaVcoZaZjgd!ZcZcZgd YZ&...!idYdhadhb^ZbWgdhYZaVJc^c:jgdeZV!XdcZmXZeX^cYZ<gZX^V! HjZX^VnZaGZ^cdJc^Yd![dgbVWVceVgiZYZabZXVc^hbd#<gZX^VhZjc^Va jcdhbZhZhYZhejh!ZhZb^hbdVd#5 La Unión Monetaria Europea. 9jgVciZ hjh eg^bZgdh &% Vdh YZ Zm^hiZcX^V!ZabZXVc^hbdYZi^edhYZXVbW^dZmeZg^bZci[gZXjZciZhXg^h^h# 5 :cigZadheVhZhZjgdeZdhfjZcdhdcb^ZbWgdhYZaVJc^c:jgdeZV!Hj^oVigVY^X^dcVabZciZ ]V bVciZc^Yd hj egde^V bdcZYV V aV eVg YZa bVgXd VaZb{c! Xj^Y{cYdhZ h^c ZbWVg\d YZ YZXaVgVgjckcXjadd[^X^Vanji^a^oVcYddXVh^dcVabZciZZai^edYZXVbW^dXdbd]ZggVb^ZciV YZedai^XVbdcZiVg^V# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &)* EVgV Xdb^Zcodh YZa YZXZc^d YZ &.-% hZ eaVciZVWVc hZg^Vh YjYVh hdWgZ hj hjWh^hiZcX^V! ZheZX^VabZciZ YZW^Yd V jcV hZg^Z YZ ViVfjZh fjZ V[ZXiVgdc Va [gVcXd [gVcXh igVh aV ZaZXX^c YZa EgZh^YZciZ B^iiZggVcY# AV gZVXX^c edai^XVgZhjaihZgjcVcjZkVbjZhigVYZVedndVai^edYZXVbW^dÄ_d#AVh Vjidg^YVYZh kdak^Zgdc V VWdXVghZ Va Y^hZd YZ jc cjZkd bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edhYZXVbW^d!ZcZafjZZabVgXdVaZb{cXjbea^gVZaeVeZaYZbdcZYV XZcigVa# :hiV ¹odcV ZmiZchV YZa bVgXd VaZb{cº VÄgb \gVYjVabZciZ hj XgZY^W^a^YVY n aaZ\ V Xdch^YZgVghZ jc m^id iVa fjZ adh gZhedchVWaZh YZ aVh edai^XVh idbVgdc [jZgoVh n YZX^Y^Zgdc VkVcoVg ]VX^V Za egm^bd eVhd a\^Xd! aV jc^c bdcZiVg^V#6 EZgd Za m^id YZa bZXVc^hbd dXjaiVWV jcV VXjbjaVX^c egd\gZh^kV YZ iZch^dcZh# AV XdbW^cVX^c YZ YZhZfj^a^Wg^dh VXjbjaVYdh n jc \gVkZ Zggdg YZ edai^XV ·aV cZ\Vi^kV V VXZeiVg fjZ aV jc^ÄXVX^cVaZbVcVgZfjZg^gVjcVgZkVajVX^cYZabVgXd·YZhViVgdcjcV hZg^ZYZk^daZcidhViVfjZhZheZXjaVi^kdh#9dheVhZh>iVa^VnZaGZ^cdJc^Yd VWVcYdcVgdcZabZXVc^hbdnbjX]dhdigdhhZk^ZgdcdWa^\VYdhVYZkVajVg! Va\jcdh YZ Zaadh kVg^Vh kZXZh# :a BI8 hZ bdY^ÄX gVY^XVabZciZ XjVcYd adh b{g\ZcZh YZ ÅjXijVX^c aaZ\Vgdc V ZchVcX]VghZ Va ejcid YZ eZgYZg hj gZaZkVcX^V# H^c ZbWVg\d! b^ZcigVh aVh bdcZYVh YZa bZXVc^hbd ZgVc dÄX^VabZciZ XjVh^ÅdiVciZh! ZmigVdÄX^VabZciZ aVh Vjidg^YVYZh bdcZiVg^Vh hZZbeZVWVcZcbVciZcZgaVhYZcigdYZb{g\ZcZhZhigZX]dh!^b^iVcYdYZ ]ZX]d!h^aZcX^dhVbZciZ!VaZmi^cidBI8# b) El mecanismo de tipos de cambio: un acuerdo complejo :abZXVc^hbdYZi^edhYZXVbW^d!fjZYjg'%VdhZchjeg^bZgV ZcXVgcVX^c! gZk^hiZ jc ^ciZgh b{h fjZ ]^hig^Xd# EVgV XdbZcoVg! h^\jZ YZhZbeZVcYdjcV[jcX^c^bedgiVciZ!nVfjZhZZheZgVfjZadhcjZkdh b^ZbWgdh YZ aV Jc^c :jgdeZV eVgi^X^eZc Zc Za bZXVc^hbd Xdbd eVhd egZk^d V hj VY]Zh^c V aV jc^c bdcZiVg^V#7 IVa kZo ad b{h ^bedgiVciZ hZV Za ]ZX]d YZ fjZ Za m^id YZa BI8 XdckZcX^ V adh gZhedchVWaZh YZ aV edai^XVZXdcb^XVVVkVcoVg]VX^VaVZiVeVh^\j^ZciZ!aVjc^cbdcZiVg^V# Edg ZhiV gVoc Zh YZ ^ciZgh \ZcZgVa Z[ZXijVg jc ZmVbZc Xgi^Xd YZ hjh eg^cX^eVaZhXVgVXiZghi^XVh# :aY^hZd^c^X^VaYZabZXVc^hbdZhijkdYZiZgb^cVYdeg^cX^eVabZciZ edg Ydh cZXZh^YVYZh# AV eg^bZgV ZgV egdedgX^dcVg jc ^chigjbZcid eVgV ZhiVW^a^oVgadhi^edhYZXVbW^d^cigVZjgdeZdh!fjZ]VWVchj[g^YdZbWViZh 6 7 @ZcZc&..*d[gZXZjcZmVbZcYZiVaaVYdYZZhiVZkdajX^c# :a cjZkd bZXVc^hbd XVbW^Vg^d BI8 >> hZ ZhiVWaZX^ Xdc aV ^cigdYjXX^c YZa Zjgd# >c^X^VabZciZ! Za c^Xd b^ZbWgd ZgV 9^cVbVgXV# :c aV VXijVa^YVY! h^ZiZ YZ adh Y^Zo cjZkdh b^ZbWgdh YZ aV Jc^c :jgdeZV hZ ]Vc hjbVYd V 9^cVbVgXV n adh igZh gZhiVciZh Zhi{c dWa^\VYdhV^ciZ\gVghZ¹egdcidºVabZXVc^hbd# &)+ 8:E6A ZcadhVdhedhiZg^dgZhVaVYZhVeVg^X^cYZah^hiZbVYZ7gZiidcLddYh#:a bZXVc^hbdYZWVhZgb{hha^YdfjZaV¹hZge^ZciZbdcZiVg^Vº#AVhZ\jcYV cZXZh^YVY ZgV YZ dgYZc edai^Xd# Adh YZb{h eVhZh ZgVc gZVX^dh V k^cXjaVg h^beaZbZciZ hjh bdcZYVh Va bVgXd VaZb{c! Vjc XjVcYd ZhiZ nV ZgV aV bdcZYVZjgdeZVb{hZhiVWaZ# AV hdajX^c YZa hZ\jcYd egdWaZbV Xdch^hi^ Zc ]VXZg YZa BI8 jc bZXVc^hbd idiVabZciZ h^big^Xd# 6 Y^[ZgZcX^V YZa bdYZad ¹gVY^Vaº (huband-spoke arrangement) YZ 7gZiidc LddYh! adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d hZ Ä_Vgdc Zc [dgbV W^aViZgVa n hZ XgZ jcV bVig^o YZ eVg^YVYZh W^aViZgVaZh! XdcdX^YV Xdbd¹aViVWaVº#8VYVi^edYZXVbW^dW^aViZgVaedYViZcZgjcVÅjXijVX^c YZ $" '!'* gZheZXid YZ aV eVg^YVY YZXaVgVYV#8 6YZb{h! XVYV eVg YZ eVhZhXdbeVgiVaVgZhedchVW^a^YVYYZbVciZcZgZai^edYZXVbW^dYZcigd YZa bVg\Zc YZ ÅjXijVX^c VXdgYVYd! h^c hjedcZg fjZ aV bdcZYV b{h YW^aijk^ZgVfjZV_jhiVghZb{hfjZaVdigV#AVh^bZigV[jZaVgZhejZhiVV YZa^XVYVhhZch^W^a^YVYZhedai^XVh# AV hdajX^c YZ aV eg^bZgV XjZhi^c [jZ Za Xdbegdb^hd h^c egZXZYZciZh YZ fjZ! Zc XVhd YZ hZg cZXZhVg^d! aVh eVg^YVYZh hZgVc YZ[ZcY^YVhXdc^ciZgkZcX^dcZh^a^b^iVYVh!YZeVgiZYZadhYdheVhZhXjnd i^ed YZ XVbW^d W^aViZgVa [jZhZ Zbej_VYd ]VX^V Za bVg\Zc YZ [ajXijVX^c YZXaVgVYd# 6h^b^hbd! edYV eZYghZaZ V digdh eVhZh b^ZbWgdh YZa bZXVc^hbd fjZ egZhiVgVc Vednd! nV [jZgV bZY^VciZ ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh d XgY^idhVXdgideaVod#AVXd]Zh^cnZaVedndbjijd[jZgdcaVgZhejZhiV VciZaV[gV\^a^YVYZXdcb^XV# EdgdigVeVgiZ!iVcidVaXdb^ZcodXdbdZcadhjXZh^kd!aVZaZXX^cYZ XVYVeVg^YVYW^aViZgVaYZWVVXdgYVghZXdaZXi^kVbZciZnXdcZaXdchZchdYZ idYdhadheVhZhb^ZbWgdh#:hiVY^hedh^X^cijkdedgdW_ZidZk^iVgXjVafj^Zg bVc^ejaVX^c YZhi^cVYV V ¹ZbedWgZXZg Va kZX^cdº edg eVgiZ YZ Va\c \gjedYZeVhZhb^ZbWgdh#IVbW^chZaVXdch^YZgXdbd_jhi^ÄXVX^cYZaV YZ[ZchVXdaZXi^kVYZaVheVg^YVYZhZm^hiZciZh# EdgZhiVhgVodcZh!ZabZXVc^hbdYZi^edhYZXVbW^d[jZbjX]db{h fjZjc¹7gZiidcLddYhZjgdeZdº#;jZjcVZbegZhVVbW^X^dhVfjZfj^iYZ aVhbVcdhYZaVhVjidg^YVYZhcVX^dcVaZhaVVYdeX^cYZYZX^h^dcZhhdWgZaV eVg^YVY XVbW^Vg^V# :ck^ aV hZVa YZ fjZ XjVafj^Zg ViVfjZ V jcV bdcZYV ZceVgi^XjaVghZgZhedcYZgVXdcjcVYZ[ZchVXdaZXi^kV#IVbW^chZegZkZV jcV \Zhi^c VXi^kV YZ aVh eVg^YVYZh! YZ bdYd fjZ adh gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh cd aaZ\VgVcVkZghZXdbdZa[gVXVhdYZah^hiZbV!h^cd!b{hW^Zc!Xdbd^cY^X^d YZÅZm^W^a^YVY# 8 6aVa^gV^iVa^VcVhZaZY^d!Zc[dgbViZbedgVg^V!jcbVg\ZcbVndgYZ $"+# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &), :c gZVa^YVY! Za bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d VigVkZh jc \gVc cbZgd YZ gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh! Xdbd hZ dWhZgkV Zc Za XjVYgd >K#'# 9ZhYZ hj ^c^X^dZcbVgodYZ&.,.]VhiVZcZgdYZ&.-,!hZXdch^YZgVgdccZXZhVg^dhcd bZcdhYZ&'V_jhiZh!jcegdbZY^dYZjcdXVYVdX]dbZhZh#Ad^ciZgZhVciZ Zh fjZ! edg ad \ZcZgVa! adh bZgXVYdh Vci^X^eVgdc Zhidh gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh fjZ! Zc XdchZXjZcX^V! [jZgdc egZXZY^Ydh edg ViVfjZh ZheZXjaVi^kdh# H^c ZbWVg\d! Zhidh ViVfjZh cd [jZgdc aZiVaZh YZW^Yd V fjZ adh XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa a^b^iVgdc Za kdajbZc YZ aVh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh gZfjZg^YVh n V fjZ adh gZVa^cZVb^ZcidhXdggZXi^kdhhZZ_ZXjiVgdcXdcgVe^YZo# Cuadro IV.2 REALINEAMIENTOS DEL MTC Fechas 24.9.79 Número de monedas involucradas 2 30.11.79 1 22.3.81 1 5.10.81 2 22.2.82 14.6.82 2 4 Fechas 21.3.83 Número de monedas involucradas 7a 18.5.83 7a 22.7.85 7a 7.4.86 5 4.8.86 12.1.87 1 3 Fechas Número de monedas involucradas 14.9.92 3b 23.11.92 2 1.2.93 1 8.1.90 1 14.5.93 2 6.3.95 2 Fuente: Elaborado por los autores. a Se realinearon todas las monedas del MTC. b Además, dos monedas (la libra esterlina y la lira) abandonaron el MTC. AVh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh YZ adh Ydh WVcXdh XZcigVaZh ^ckdajXgVYdh ZgVc dWa^\Vidg^Vh h^ hZ aaZ\VWV V XjVafj^ZgV YZ adh b{g\ZcZh W^aViZgVaZh! eZgd egdcid hZ ]^od Zk^YZciZ fjZ ZgV g^Zh\dhd ZheZgVg V fjZ Zhd hjXZY^ZgV# 6a ZhiVgegZh^dcVYdXdcigVZaab^iZ!Zai^edYZXVbW^dd[gZXZVadhZheZXjaVYdgZh jcV VejZhiV Xdc aV fjZ cd iZcYg{c egY^YVh! nV hZV fjZ hZ egdYjoXV jc gZVa^cZVb^Zcid n hZ dWiZc\Vc \gVcYZh \VcVcX^Vh! d fjZ cd hZ egdYjoXVc gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh n Za Xdhid YZ aV ZheZXjaVX^c hZV k^gijVabZciZ cjad! ad fjZ]VXZfjZadhViVfjZhZheZXjaVi^kdhhZVck^gijVabZciZ^ggZh^hi^WaZh#Edg ZhiVgVoc!Zc[dgbV\gVYjVa!aVbVndgVYZaVh^ciZgkZcX^dcZhhZidgcVgdc XVYV kZo b{h ¹^cigVbVg\^cVaZhº! Zh YZX^g! dg^ZciVYVh V bVciZcZg adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d W^aViZgVaZh W^Zc YZcigd YZ adh b{g\ZcZh YZ ÅjXijVX^c! Xdbd hZ bjZhigV Zc Za XjVYgd >K#(# :c Za XjVYgd iVbW^c hZ dWhZgkV fjZ aVh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh YZa YaVg! Y^g^\^YVh V ZhiVW^a^oVg aVh eVg^YVYZh W^aViZgVaZh YZcigdYZaBI8bZY^VciZaVZhiVW^a^oVX^cYZaVheVg^YVYZh[gZciZVaYaVg YZ adh :hiVYdh Jc^Ydh! eZgYVc ^bedgiVcX^V ·VjcfjZ cjcXV aaZ\Vgdc V hZg ^ch^\c^ÄXVciZh· V bZY^YV fjZ XdWgVWVc bVndg h^\c^ÄXVX^c aVh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZhYZaVhbdcZYVhYZaBI8# &)- 8:E6A Cuadro IV.3 INTERVENCIONES DEL MERCADO DE DIVISAS (Miles de millones de dólares de los Estados Unidos) 1979-1982 1983-1985 1986-1987 1988-1989 En el margen 20,5 Dentro de los márgenes 29,2 En dólares de los Estados Unidos 139,4 15,4 48,6 78,4 22,3 113,7 53,7 0,9 32,4 29,5 1,7 0 18,9 3,3 0 5,4 0 0 12,4 Todas las monedas Dentro del MTC Bundesbank Dentro del MTC En el margen Dentro de los márgenes En dólares de los Estados Unidos 3,1 0 25,4 Fuente: Gros y Thygesen (1998). Nota: Suma algebraica de las compras. :a XjVYgd >K#( iVbW^c gZkZaV jcV ^bedgiVciZ Vh^bZigV ZcigZ Za 7jcYZhWVc` n adh YZb{h WVcXdh XZcigVaZh# B^ZcigVh Zhidh! Zc hj bVndgV! gZXjggVc XVYV kZo b{h V aVh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh ¹^cigVbVg\^cVaZhº cd dWa^\Vidg^Vh! Za 7jcYZhWVc` a^b^iVWV hjh egde^Vh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh V Xjbea^g Xdc aV dWa^\VX^c YZ egdedgX^dcVg Vednd W^aViZgVa XjVcYd hZ aaZ\VWV Va bVg\Zc#:hiZZhjcdYZadhVheZXidhYZaegdXZhdfjZaaZkeVjaVi^cVbZciZVa bVgXdVaZb{cVh^ijVghZ!YZ]ZX]d!XdbdXZcigdYZah^hiZbV#EVgVZmea^XVgad YZbVcZgVb{hh^beaZ!Zcjceg^cX^e^dZaBI8[jcX^dcVWVXdbdjch^hiZbV h^big^Xd0idYdhadhWVcXdhXZcigVaZhZhiVW^a^oVWVchjheVg^YVYZhW^aViZgVaZh! eg^cX^eVabZciZ XdcigdaVcYd hjh gZheZXi^kVh bdcZYVh gZheZXid YZa YaVg! Xdbd Zc Za h^hiZbV YZ 7gZiidc LddYh# 8dc Za i^Zbed! idYdh adh eVhZh VWVcYdcVgdc Za YaVg Zc [Vkdg YZa bVgXd! b^ZcigVh fjZ Za 7jcYZhWVc` Vhjb^aVY^gZXX^cYZaVZkdajX^cYZaVhbdcZYVhZjgdeZVh[gZciZVaYaVg# :m^hiZ iVbW^c digV gVoc eVgV fjZ Zhid ]VnV dXjgg^Yd# IdYdh adh eVhZhXjnV^cÅVX^cZgVb{hZaZkVYVfjZaVYZ6aZbVc^VnhZ]VWVck^hid gZ^iZgVYVbZciZdWa^\VYdhVYZkVajVgVciZegZh^dcZhZheZXjaVi^kVhVXZeiVgdc edXd V edXd aV ^YZV YZ fjZ YZWVc igViVg YZ gZYjX^g hj iVhV YZ ^cÅVX^c# 9ZhYZ&.-,ZcVYZaVciZ!ZhidheVhZhVYdeiVgdcXdbdVcXaVZabVgXdVaZb{c n hZ XdbegdbZi^Zgdc V bVciZcZg ^ciVXiVh hjh eVg^YVYZh XVbW^Vg^Vh# 9Z ]ZX]d!egdXZY^ZgdcVhZ\j^gYZXZgXVaVedai^XVYZa7jcYZhWVc`#:hiZh^hiZbV Y^dWjZcdhgZhjaiVYdh!ZcZahZci^YdYZfjZ!ZcidYdhadheVhZh!aV^cÅVX^c XdbZcoVY^hb^cj^g\gVYjVabZciZ!VXZgX{cYdhZVaVYZ6aZbVc^V#:aBI8 hZ Xdch^YZg jc \gVc m^id! nV fjZ h^gk^ eVgV bVciZcZg i^edh YZ XVbW^d cdb^cVaZhZhiVWaZhYjgVciZkVg^dhVdh#AV^YZVYZÄ_Vg^ggZkdXVWaZbZciZZa i^edYZXVbW^d!bZY^VciZaVVYdeX^cYZjcVbdcZYVXdbc!hjg\^Xdbd XdchZXjZcX^VXVh^cVijgVanY^ddg^\ZcVaIgViVYdYZBVVhig^X]i# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &). B^ZcigVh iVcid! h^c ZbWVg\d! adh Y^[ZgZcX^VaZh ^c[aVX^dcVg^dh VXjbjaVYdh Zc jc Zh[jZgod edg ad\gVg aV XdckZg\ZcX^V YZ aVh iVhVh YZ ^c[aVX^c ]VWVc egdkdXVYd aV hdWgZkVajVX^c YZ Va\jcVh bdcZYVh# ;gZciZ V aV Za^b^cVX^c XdaZXi^kV YZ adh XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa Zc &..%! adh ^cZk^iVWaZh gZVa^cZVb^Zcidh hZ idgcVWVc ZheZX^VabZciZ eZa^\gdhdh# :c gZVa^YVY! XjVcYd XdbZco aV ZheZXjaVX^c! YZhViVYV edg aVh Y^[^XjaiVYZh fjZ hjg\^Zgdc eVgV gVi^[^XVg Za IgViVYd YZ BVVhig^X]i! Ydh bdcZYVh hZ k^Zgdc dWa^\VYVh V gZi^gVghZ aV a^gV ^iVa^VcV n aV a^WgV ZhiZga^cV! fjZ hZ ]VWVcjc^YdedXdhbZhZhVciZh!VjcViVhVhdWgZkVajVYVnadhb{g\ZcZh YZ [ajXijVX^c ijk^Zgdc fjZ Vbea^VghZ ZcdgbZbZciZ ]VhiV aaZ\Vg V $" &*# :a bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d ZhiVWV Zc gj^cVh! eZgd hZ ]VWV idbVYd nV aV [^gbZ YZX^h^c YZ ^cigdYjX^g Za Zjgd! ad fjZ [VX^a^i jcV Xdci^cjVYVZhiVW^a^YVYbdcZiVg^V# AVh Y^ÄXjaiVYZh fjZ Za bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d Zc[gZci Va ÄcVa^ajhigVcigZhejcidh\ZcZgVaZh#Eg^bZgd!XjVafj^Zgh^hiZbVYZeVg^YVYZh Ä_VhYZWZhZgÅZm^WaZ#JhVgZai^edYZXVbW^dXdbdVcXaVZhedh^WaZeVgVjc eVh! cd eVgV jc h^hiZbV# JcV ZhigViZ\^V hZbZ_VciZ YZWZ YZÄc^g aV edai^XV bdcZiVg^VYZaeVhfjZaVVYdeiZ0Zhjc^chigjbZcidYZY^hX^ea^cV#9Zcigd YZaBI8!YZW^YdVhjcVijgVaZoVh^big^XVnhjegdbZhVYZVedndbjijd! Za VheZXid Y^hX^ea^cVg^d hZ YZW^a^iV n XjVafj^Zg YZh[VhZ V[ZXiV V idYdh adh b^ZbWgdh#HZ\jcYd!Zh^bedh^WaZbVciZcZgeVg^YVYZhÄ_VhXjVcYdZaXVe^iVa ejZYZÅj^ga^WgZbZciZ#JcVZhig^XiVY^hX^ea^cVbdcZiVg^VZhjcVXdcY^X^c cZXZhVg^V!eZgdcdhjÄX^ZciZ!ZcjcbjcYdYdcYZhdc[gZXjZciZhaVhXg^h^h VjidXjbea^YVh# IZgXZgd! Zh WVhiVciZ hdgegZcYZciZ fjZ Za h^hiZbV ]VnV [jcX^dcVYdW^ZcXjVcYdZgVh^big^Xd!eZgd]VnV[VaaVYdXjVcYd6aZbVc^V hZXdck^gi^ZcZaXZcigdYZ[VXid#:hidcdh^\c^ÄXVfjZjch^hiZbV¹gVY^Vaº cd ejZYV [jcX^dcVg! eZgd h eVgZXZ ^cY^XVg fjZ jc h^hiZbV gZ\^dcVa ejZYZ [jcX^dcVgh^cjcXZcigd!h^idYdZagZhidZhi{W^Zc^YZVYd# c) La unión monetaria AVJc^c:Xdcb^XVnBdcZiVg^V:jgdeZVJ:BZhbZcdhdg^\^cVa fjZ Za bZXVc^hbd YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d# :c kVg^dh VheZXidh ^b^iV VXjZgYdh fjZdeZgVcZcbjX]dheVhZh[ZYZgVaZh#EdgadiVcid!ZcZhiVhZXX^ccdhZ egdXjgV egZhZciVg jcV YZhXg^eX^c YZiVaaVYV YZ aV Jc^c! h^cd! b{h W^Zc! bdhigVghjhgVh\dhdg^\^cVaZhnhZVaVgVa\jcVhYZhjhXVgVXiZghi^XVhXaVkZ# :agZideg^cX^eVaXdch^hiZZcXgZVg^chi^ijX^dcZhVYZXjVYVh#9ZhYZZa ejcidYZk^hiViXc^Xd!aVh^ijVX^cZhWVhiVciZhZcX^aaV/jcVbdcZYVc^XV gZfj^ZgZ jcV Vjidg^YVY bdcZiVg^V c^XV! n cd Zm^hiZc bjX]Vh ZhigViZ\^Vh bdcZiVg^Vh edh^WaZh# Cd ]Vn YjYV YZ fjZ adh YZWViZh VggZX^Vc XjVcYd hZ VWdgYVaVZhigViZ\^VYZa7VcXd8ZcigVa:jgdeZd!eZgdZhdhhdchdadYZiVaaZh# B{hXdbeaZ_VVcZhaVXjZhi^cYZYZaZ\VgZcjcVVjidg^YVYbjai^cVX^dcVaaV &*% 8:E6A ^bedgiVciZ[VXjaiVYYZaaZkVgVYZaVciZaVedai^XVbdcZiVg^V#H^W^ZcZaY^hZd \ZcZgVahZ^che^gV^cZk^iVWaZbZciZZcjcVdg\Vc^oVX^cYZ:hiVYdh[ZYZgVaZh! Za]ZX]dYZfjZ:jgdeVh^\Vh^ZcYdjcVjc^cYZcVX^dcZh^cYZeZcY^ZciZh Xdbea^XVZcdgbZbZciZaVhXdhVh# AV hdajX^c VYdeiVYV gZegZhZciV jcV XdbW^cVX^c YZ bZXVc^hbdh [ZYZgVaZh Z ^ciZgcVX^dcVaZh# HZ didg\V Za edYZg YZ YZX^h^c Va H^hiZbV :jgdeZd YZ 7VcXdh 8ZcigVaZh! Za :jgdh^hiZbV# :a g\Vcd YZX^hdg^d Zh Za 8dchZ_dYZ<dW^Zgcd!XdbejZhidedgadhhZ^hb^ZbWgdhYZa8db^i:_ZXji^kd YZa 78: n adh Y^gZXidgZh YZ adh WVcXdh XZcigVaZh cVX^dcVaZh YZ adh eVhZh eVgi^X^eVciZh#:a8db^i:_ZXji^kdZhYZi^ed[ZYZgVa!nVfjZhjhb^ZbWgdh VXiVc V iijad eZghdcVa# H^c ZbWVg\d! hdc YZh^\cVYdh edg adh :hiVYdh b^ZbWgdh! ad fjZ ^cZk^iVWaZbZciZ h^\c^ÄXV fjZ aV cVX^dcVa^YVY Zh YZ \gVc ^bedgiVcX^V# 8dbd ZgV YZ ZheZgVghZ! adh eVhZh b^ZbWgdh b{h \gVcYZh ;gVcX^V! 6aZbVc^V! >iVa^V n :heVV ]Vc ad\gVYd YZh^\cVg V jcd YZ hjh XdcX^jYVYVcdhnegZiZcYZcfjZZhVh^ijVX^chZbVciZc\V!nadhYdhXVg\dh gZhiVciZh Zhi{c dXjeVYdh edg X^jYVYVcdh YZ adh eVhZh b{h eZfjZdh# Edg hjejZhid! Zhid hZ dedcZ idiVabZciZ Va Zheg^ij YZa eg^cX^e^d YZ YZh^\cVg V adh b^ZbWgdh YZa 8db^i c^XVbZciZ iZc^ZcYd Zc XjZciV hj ^YdcZ^YVY n cd eVgV VXijVg Xdbd gZegZhZciVciZh YZ hjh eVhZh# 9Z bVcZgV h^b^aVg! Za ]ZX]dYZfjZadhY^gZXidgZhYZadhWVcXdhXZcigVaZhcVX^dcVaZhXjbeaVcYZ dÄX^d[jcX^dcZhZcZa8dchZ_dYZ<dW^ZgcdiVbW^cXdcigVY^XZZaeg^cX^e^d YZcdgZegZhZciVX^c# B{hegZdXjeVciZZhfjZZa8dchZ_dYZ<dW^ZgcdVjbZciVg{hjiVbVd XjVcYd hZ ^cXdgedgZc cjZkdh eVhZh V aV Jc^c :Xdcb^XV n BdcZiVg^V :jgdeZV#6XijVabZciZ!Xdc&-b^ZbWgdhXdcYZgZX]dYZkdid!nVZhWVhiVciZ ^begdWVWaZ fjZ Za egdXZhd YZ idbV YZ YZX^h^dcZh eZgb^iV ^ciZgXVbW^dh egd[jcYdhYZde^c^dcZh#:a8dchZ_dedYgVaaZ\VgV(&^ciZ\gVciZhh^idYdhadh b^ZbWgdhVXijVaZhYZaVJc^c:jgdeZVVYdeiVcZaZjgdn!Xdcb{heVhZh cdb^cVYdh eVgV ^c\gZhVg Zc aV Jc^c :jgdeZV! Za 8dchZ_d YZ <dW^Zgcd edYgVVbea^VghZVcb{h#AVY^ÄXjaiVYZhW^ZcXdcdX^YV!eZgdZhYZa^XVYV YZhYZZaejcidYZk^hiVedai^Xd#:a:jgdh^hiZbV]VegdejZhida^b^iVgV'*Za cbZgdYZb^ZbWgdhXdcYZgZX]dVkdid!Vea^XVcYdjcXdbeaZ_dh^hiZbVYZ gdiVX^cfjZidbVgVZcXjZciVZaiVbVdYZadheVhZh# B{h egZdXjeVciZ Vc Zh Za bjn Y^hXji^Yd ¹YÄX^i YZbdXg{i^Xdº# :a :jgdh^hiZbV Zh XdbeaZiVbZciZ ^cYZeZcY^ZciZ/ idYdh adh b^ZbWgdh YZa 8dchZ_d YZ <dW^Zgcd hdc YZh^\cVYdh edg eZgdYdh aVg\dh n cd ejZYZc hZg gZbdk^Ydh YZ hj XVg\d# H^c ZbWVg\d! aV ^cYZeZcYZcX^V igVZ Xdch^\d Za iZbVYZaVgZcY^X^cYZXjZciVh#AVhdajX^cZhXd\^YV]Vh^YdfjZZa7VcXd 8ZcigVa :jgdeZd egZhZciZ hjh gZhjaiVYdh VciZ Za EVgaVbZcid :jgdeZd# H^c ZbWVg\d! Za EVgaVbZcid :jgdeZd cd i^ZcZ c^c\jcV Vjidg^YVY dÄX^Va hdWgZ Za 78:! hVakd XdcÄgbVg aVh YZh^\cVX^dcZh YZ adh b^ZbWgdh YZa 8db^i :_ZXji^kd#CdejZYZ[dgbjaVggZXdbZcYVX^dcZhhdWgZedai^XVh[jijgVh0hdad 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &*& ejZYZZ[ZXijVgXdbZciVg^dhVXZgXVYZedai^XVheVhVYVh#:agZhjaiVYdZhjc YW^aegdXZhdZmedhi!h^cc^c\jcVXdchZXjZcX^V\gVkZh^ZaEVgaVbZcidZhi{ ZcYZhVXjZgYdXdcaVhbZY^YVhVYdeiVYVhedgZa:jgdh^hiZbV# :hiVh XjZhi^dcZh gZÅZ_Vc aVh Y^ÄXjaiVYZh edai^XVh Z ^chi^ijX^dcVaZh YZ jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V# H^ W^Zc :jgdeV Zh h^c\jaVg edg iZcZg jc h^hiZbV YZ \dW^Zgcd ZhigjXijgVYd Za 8dchZ_d :jgdeZd! fjZ gZcZ V adh _Z[Zh YZ :hiVYdnYZ\dW^Zgcd!nZa8dchZ_dYZB^c^higdhnjcEVgaVbZcidZaZ\^Yd!aV dg\Vc^oVX^cVXijVacdZhZciZgVbZciZhVi^h[VXidg^V#:hX^ZgidfjZaVJc^c BdcZiVg^Vn:Xdcb^XV]V[jcX^dcVYdWVhiVciZW^Zc]VhiVV]dgVnZhY^[X^a egZkZgY^ÄXjaiVYZhbVndgZh!adXjVa^cY^XVfjZadhbZXVc^hbdhcdegZhZciVc [VaaVh ZhigjXijgVaZh0 h^c ZbWVg\d! aVh Xgi^XVh hdc ZcYb^XVh n edYgVc YZW^a^iVgaV\dWZgcVW^a^YVYh^hjg\^ZgVc^cXdckZc^ZciZh\gVkZh# d) Política fiscal: coordinación y disciplina :aai^bdiZbVYZ^ciZghhZgZÄZgZVaigViVb^ZcidYZaVedai^XVÄhXVa# H^ Za XVe^iVa hZ bjZkZ a^WgZbZciZ! b^ZcigVh b{h Ä_d hZV Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d! bZcdhkVVedYZgji^a^oVghZjcVedai^XVbdcZiVg^VXdcÄcZhYZZhiVW^a^oVX^c bVXgdZXdcb^XV# :c XdchZXjZcX^V! aV edai^XV ÄhXVa hZ Xdck^ZgiZ Zc Za eg^cX^eVa! h^ cd Za c^Xd! ^chigjbZcid YZ ZhiVW^a^oVX^c bVXgdZXdcb^XV# H^c ZbWVg\d! Zc VjhZcX^V YZ jcV Y^hX^ea^cV ÄhXVa! XjVafj^Zg Xdbegdb^hd YZ edai^XV bdcZiVg^V! ^cXaj^YV aV ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V! Zhi{ YZhi^cVYd V YZW^a^iVghZ eVjaVi^cVbZciZ# 6YZb{h! Xdc [gZXjZcX^V hZ VÄgbV fjZ! YZW^Yd V fjZ V[ZXiVc adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d! aVh edai^XVh ÄhXVaZh YZWZc XddgY^cVghZ# 6h!b^ZcigVhb{hZhigZX]VhZVaVXddeZgVX^cgZheZXidYZai^edYZXVbW^d! bVndgZh hZg{c adh ab^iZh fjZ YZWVc ^bedcZghZ V aV ^beaZbZciVX^c YZ edai^XVh ÄhXVaZh cVX^dcVaZh! ad XjVa! Zc aV eg{Xi^XV! gZYjX^g{ Za VaXVcXZ YZ aVhedai^XVhcVX^dcVaZhYZZhiVW^a^oVX^cbVXgdZXdcb^XV#JcVedh^W^a^YVY Zh gZhig^c\^g aV bdk^a^YVY YZ adh XVe^iVaZh! egZ[Zg^WaZbZciZ bZY^VciZ aV ji^a^oVX^c YZ jcV kZgh^c YZa ZcXV_Z X]^aZcd#9 9^X]Vh gZhig^XX^dcZh cd didg\Vca^WZgiVYVWhdajiVeVgVaaZkVgVYZaVciZedai^XVhY^kZg\ZciZhYZaVg\d VaXVcXZ! ZheZX^VabZciZ edai^XVh fjZ YZg^kZc Zc Y^[ZgZcX^VaZh YZ ^cÅVX^c YjgVYZgdh!eZgd]VXZcbVcZ_VWaZhadhgZVa^cZVb^ZcidhXVbW^Vg^dh# EdgdigVeVgiZ!b^ZcigVhb{hZhigZX]VhZVaVjc^cXVbW^Vg^VYZcigd YZ aV gZ\^c! b{h YZeZcYZg{ XVYV eVh YZa XdbedgiVb^Zcid YZ adh YZb{h# HZhjZaZVÄgbVgfjZaVXdbW^cVX^cYZaVhedai^XVhZh^bedgiVciZeVgVaVh iVhVhYZ^ciZghnadhi^edhYZXVbW^dgZ\^dcVaZh!ZheZX^VabZciZZcjcVjc^c bdcZiVg^V#:hiVVÄgbVX^cejZYZ^cYjX^gVZggdg#H^aVgZ\^chZZcXjZcigV 9 :aZcXV_ZZhjch^hiZbVYZXdcigdaYZXVe^iVafjZ[jcX^dcVbZY^VciZaV^bedh^X^cYZXdhidh V aVh ZcigVYVh YZ XVe^iVa# :hidh Xdhidh Y^hb^cjnZc hZ\c Za kZcX^b^Zcid! h^bjaVcYd aVh XjVa^YVYZhYZhZVWaZhYZa^bejZhidIdW^c# &*' 8:E6A ZhigZX]VbZciZ ^ciZ\gVYV Zc adh bZgXVYdh ÄcVcX^Zgdh ^ciZgcVX^dcVaZh! XVYV eVh Zh YZbVh^VYd eZfjZd Xdbd eVgV ^cX^Y^g Zc aVh iVhVh YZ ^ciZgh gZ\^dcVaZh#:aadZhVh^cXajhdZcaVJc^cBdcZiVg^V:jgdeZV#AVedh^X^c XdaZXi^kV^bedgiVh^aVgZ\^cZh\gVcYZ!XdbdZhZaXVhdYZ:jgdeV!eZgdZhid h^\c^ÄXVfjZaVhedai^XVheaZcVbZciZXddgY^cVYVhedYgVcaaZ\VgVegdYjX^g hjZ[ZXid#9VYdfjZ!ZcXVYVeVh!aVedai^XVÄhXVaYZeZcYZeg^cX^eVabZciZ YZa YZWViZ edai^Xd n Zh Y^[X^a YZ Y^hZVg! Zh ZmigZbVYVbZciZ ^begdWVWaZ fjZejZYVZm^hi^gjcVXddgY^cVX^cidiVa# Ad fjZ cd YZ_V YZ hZg X^Zgid Zh fjZ Za ^cXjbea^b^Zcid YZ eV\d edg eVgiZYZjceVh!ZheZX^VabZciZh^Zh\gVcYZXdcgZaVX^cVadhYZb{hYZaV odcV!edYgViZcZgXdchZXjZcX^Vh\gVkZheVgVidYVaVgZ\^c#:hedgZaadfjZ aVY^hX^ea^cVÄhXVahZXdck^ZgiZZcjcVegZdXjeVX^cgZ\^dcVa!ZheZX^VabZciZ YZcigdYZjcVjc^cbdcZiVg^V#:jgdeV]VVYdeiVYdZaEVXidYZ:hiVW^a^YVY n 8gZX^b^Zcid! fjZ Zh jc VXjZgYd eVgV a^b^iVg adh YÄX^i egZhjejZhiVg^dh Va ( YZa E>7# :hiZ eVXid Zhi{ bVa XdcXZW^Yd edg Ydh gVodcZh# :c eg^bZg aj\Vg!adfjZhZcZXZh^iVcdZh^bedcZgab^iZhVaYÄX^iVcjVa!h^cdVhZ\jgVg aV hdhiZc^W^a^YVY YZ aV YZjYV V aVg\d eaVod# :hiVWaZXZg jc YÄX^i VcjVa Zh YZbVh^VYdgZhig^Xi^kd!njcideZg\^YdZhYZbVh^VYdZm^\ZciZ#:chZ\jcYd igb^cd!ZaEVXidYZ:hiVW^a^YVYn8gZX^b^Zcid^cXajnZjcegdXZY^b^Zcidedg ZaXjVaZa8dchZ_dYZB^c^higdhejZYZgZXdbZcYVgVadhY^hi^cidheVhZhfj YZWZc]VXZgXdchjhYÄX^iegZhjejZhiVg^dhnbjaiVgadhh^]VXZcXVhddb^hd YZZhVhgZXdbZcYVX^dcZh#:hiZh^hiZbVXdchi^ijnZjcV\gVkZ^cigdb^h^cfjZ VbZcVoVaVhdWZgVcVZcjc{bW^idbjnYZa^XVYd#:hidhYdhYZ[ZXidhhZ]Vc ^Yd]VX^ZcYdXVYVkZob{hk^h^WaZhnaaZkVgdcVaXdbeaZid[gVXVhdYZaEVXid! fjZ[jZ¹hjheZcY^YdºZccdk^ZbWgZYZ'%%(!XjVcYdZa8dchZ_dYZWV]VWZg ^c^X^VYdZaegdXZY^b^ZcidYZbjaiVhXdcigVadhYdheVhZhb{h^bedgiVciZh! ;gVcX^Vn6aZbVc^V# AV ZmeZg^ZcX^V ZjgdeZV bjZhigV iVcid aV cZXZh^YVY YZ X^Zgid Xdbegdb^hd Xdc aV Y^hX^ea^cV ÄhXVa Xdbd aV YZ jc egdXZY^b^Zcid hZchVid fjZVhZ\jgZhjXjbea^b^Zcid#HVe^gndigdh'%%(!Lneadho'%%'Vndigdh VjidgZh]VcegZhZciVYdhj\ZgZcX^VheVgV^cigdYjX^gbZ_dgVh#EgdedcZcfjZ ZadW_Zi^kdYZ_ZYZhZgZaYÄX^iÄhXVaVcjVaneVhZVhZgZac^kZaYZYZjYV# IVbW^c ^cXajnZc kVg^Vh egdejZhiVh eVgV ad\gVg jcV eVgi^X^eVX^c b{h Y^gZXiVYZadh:hiVYdhb^ZbWgdh# 4. ¿Qué nos dice la experiencia europea? :c ZhiV hZXX^c hZ VcVa^oVc aVh edh^WaZh deX^dcZh fjZ aV ZmeZg^ZcX^V ZjgdeZV gZkZaV eVgV digVh gZ\^dcZh fjZ iVbW^c h^ZciZc aV cZXZh^YVY YZ ZhiVW^a^oVghji^edYZXVbW^d# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa a) &*( Secuencia de acontecimientos: adónde ir y cómo llegar allí HZ\c hZ hZVaVgV Zc aV hZXX^c 'W! Zm^hiZc bjX]Vh [dgbVh YZ ZhiVW^a^oVg adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d YZcigd YZ jcV gZ\^c! fjZ kVc YZhYZ jc g\^bZcYZÅdiVX^ccdXdcigdaVYVZhig^XiVbZciZ]VhiVjc^dcZhbdcZiVg^Vh g\^YVh# :jgdeV ]V ^Yd eVhVcYd YZ eVg^YVYZh ÅZm^WaZh V g\^YVh n ]V VegdkZX]VYd XVYV ZiVeV eVgV XgZVg ^chi^ijX^dcZh fjZ ajZ\d aV egZeVgVgVc eVgVeVhVgVaVZiVeVh^\j^ZciZ!eZgdh^cXdbegdbZiZghZ_Vb{hV]VXZgad# :c:jgdeVZadgYZcYZadhVXdciZX^b^Zcidhh^\j^Zc\gVcbZY^YVZa Zc[dfjZigVY^X^dcVaegdejZhid^c^X^VabZciZedgBX@^ccdc&.,.#Eg^bZgd! :jgdeV a^WZgVa^o Za XdbZgX^d ^cigVggZ\^dcVa Xdc aV XgZVX^c YZa BZgXVYd 8dbcZc&.*-najZ\dhZ^ciZ\geVjaVi^cVbZciZZcZaXdbZgX^dbjcY^VaV igVkhYZjcVhZg^ZYZXdckZc^dhhjhXg^idhZcZabVgXdYZa6XjZgYd<ZcZgVa hdWgZ 6gVcXZaZh 6YjVcZgdh n 8dbZgX^d <6II# IVbW^c ZhiVWaZX^ aV XdckZgi^W^a^YVY YZ aV XjZciV Xdgg^ZciZ Va edcZg Zc bVgX]V Za BZgXVYd 8dbcnajZ\d!bjn\gVYjVabZciZ!VYdeiaVXdckZgi^W^a^YVYYZaVhXjZciVh ÄcVcX^ZgVhnad\gaVa^WZgVa^oVX^cidiVaYZaXVe^iVaZc&..%!XdbdeVgiZYZa 6XiV×c^XV:jgdeZV#:a]ZX]dYZXdchZgkVgadhXdcigdaZhYZaXVe^iVaeZgb^i^ Za bVciZc^b^Zcid YZa BI8 YjgVciZ jcV YXVYV# Adh VXjZgYdh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^dXdbZcoVgdcXdci^edhYZXVbW^dÄ_dh!eZgdV_jhiVWaZh!]VhiVfjZaV a^WZgVa^oVX^cYZaXVe^iVadWa^\VZaZ\^gZcigZadhYdhZmigZbdh!naVbVndgV YZ adh eVhZh dei edg Za ZmigZbd YZ aV jc^c bdcZiVg^V# 9Z ZhiZ bdYd! :jgdeVVea^XidYVhaVhgZXZiVhYZadha^WgdhYZiZmid!XdcWjZcdhgZhjaiVYdh# AVZmXZeX^cZhZa^ciZgkVadYZaYZXZc^dYZ&..%!XjVcYdaVbdk^a^YVYYZadh XVe^iVaZh ZgV idiVa! eZgd idYVkV cd hZ ]VWV XgZVYd aV jc^c ZjgdeZV# :aad dWa^\VhjheZcYZgYZ]ZX]dZaBI8bZY^VciZaVVYdeX^cYZb{g\ZcZhYZ ÅjXijVX^c bjn Vbea^dh! fjZ ZgV jcV bVcZgV YZ hjhiZciVg Za bZXVc^hbd! Va bZcdh iZg^XVbZciZ# H^c ZbWVg\d! ZhiZ eZgdYd hZ XVgVXiZg^o edg jcV ^c^ciZggjbe^YV ZhiVW^a^YVY XVbW^Vg^V kVhZ Za \g{ÄXd >K#( YZW^Yd V jcV gVoc^bedgiVciZ/eVgVZhZZcidcXZh!hZ]VWVidbVYdaVYZX^h^cYZ^cigdYjX^g ZaZjgdnhZ]VWVZhiVWaZX^YdjcV[ZX]VX^ZgiV#H^W^ZcZhidhai^bdh]ZX]dh hZegdYj_ZgdcZcjcdgYZcXgdcda\^XdZciZgVbZciZ[dgij^id!YZ_VcbjX]Vh ZchZVcoVhkVa^dhVh#:hiVWaZXZcZaeVeZaXgjX^VafjZXjbeaZcaVhZmeZXiVi^kVh eVgVhdhiZcZgaVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V#IVbW^cYZbjZhigVcaV^bedgiVcX^V YZ aVh ^chi^ijX^dcZh0 Za YZXZc^d YZ &..% [jZ YZY^XVYd Va Xjbea^b^Zcid YZ aVh XdcY^X^dcZh YZ ^c\gZhd Zc aV Jc^c BdcZiVg^V n :Xdcb^XV! n Zhidh Zh[jZgodh k^h^WaZh edg ad\gVg jcV XdckZg\ZcX^V egdedgX^dcVgdc jc ¹VcXaVº! hdhiZc^YVedgZaYZhVggdaad\gVYjVaYZa:jgdh^hiZbV# :aegdXZhdZjgdeZdhjb^c^higVVhjcbVeVYZgjiVfjZZh[VXi^WaZ!cd hdadedgfjZhZVaVVa\dfjZnVhZ]V]ZX]d!h^cdiVbW^cedgfjZVgbdc^oV Xdcadheg^cX^e^dhW{h^Xdh#ªH^\c^ÄXVZhidfjZaVjc^cbdcZiVg^VZhZac^Xd YZhi^cd!njcegdXZhd\gVYjVa!aVc^XV[dgbVYZaaZ\VgVa4EgdWVWaZbZciZ cd#:a6h^VhjYdg^ZciVaZhZ_ZbeadYZjcVgZ\^cfjZVaXVcoX^Zgid\gVYd &*) 8:E6A YZZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VYZhYZaVXg^h^hYZ&..,"&...!bZY^VciZjcVÅdiVX^c XdcigdaVYV ZmigVdÄX^VabZciZ# AV >c^X^Vi^kV YZ 8]^Vc\ BV^ d[gZXZ Va\jcV VnjYV!eZgdh^\jZigVi{cYdhZYZjcZh[jZgodeVgX^VanW^aViZgVa# :c Za digd ZmigZbd YZa ZheZXigd! ªejZYZc aVh gZ\^dcZh hVaiVg YZ ^cbZY^Vid V jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V h^c Za eVhd ^ciZgbZY^d YZ jc h^hiZbV YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d Ä_dh n V_jhiVWaZh! iVa Xdbd Za BI84 :c iZdgV! eVhVg Y^gZXiVbZciZ YZ jc h^hiZbV V digd Zh edh^WaZ# :a \gVYjVa^hbd ZjgdeZd cd hZ WVhV Zc eg^cX^e^dh ZXdcb^Xdh# 8dbd XVbW^d YZ g\^bZc! ejZYZ aaZ\VghZVaYZbVcZgVk^gijVabZciZ^chiVci{cZV·YZ]ZX]d!YZWZad\gVghZ ^chiVci{cZVbZciZ· n Zhid Zh ad fjZ dXjgg^ Zc :jgdeV Za &§ YZ ZcZgd YZ &...# :h X^Zgid fjZ ZhZ bdbZcid Zhijkd egZXZY^Yd edg jc aVg\d eZgdYd YZ XdckZg\ZcX^V dWa^\Vidg^V! eZgd ZhV [jZ jcV egdiZXX^c gZfjZg^YV edg 6aZbVc^V eVgV VhZ\jgVg fjZ aV ¹XjaijgV YZ aV ZhiVW^a^YVY YZ egZX^dhº Zhijk^ZhZ hjÄX^ZciZbZciZ VggV^\VYV! YZ bdYd fjZ Za Zjgd ejY^ZgV hZg iVc WjZcdXdbdZabVgXdVaZb{c#CdcZXZhVg^VbZciZi^ZcZfjZhZgVhZcdigdh XVhdh!h^ZbegZfjZadhY^[ZgZcX^VaZhYZ^cÅVX^chZVca^b^iVYdh!iZbVfjZhZ gZidbVg{b{hVYZaVciZ# Edg digd aVYd! Za eg^cX^e^d ZjgdeZd YZa \gVYjVa^hbd Zhi{ WVhVYd Zc eg^cX^e^dhedai^XdhZ^chi^ijX^dcVaZh#=Vh^YdjcegdXZhdYZXdci^cjVZgdh^c YZ aV hdWZgVcV cVX^dcVa! [dg_VYd V igVkh YZ bZY^YVh YZ XdchigjXX^c YZ XdcÄVcoV# JcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V gZfj^ZgZ YZ ^chi^ijX^dcZh! cd hdad YZ jc WVcXdXZcigVaXdbc·fjZejZYZdg\Vc^oVghZZcjci^ZbedgVodcVWaZbZciZ Xdgid·h^cdiVbW^cYZjcbZXVc^hbdYZYZh^\cVX^dcZhnXdcigdaXdbdZa fjZ hZ VcVa^o b{h Vgg^WV Zc aV hZXX^c (#W# 6YZb{h! Y^hZVg Z ^beg^b^g W^aaZiZhWVcXVg^dhejZYZaaZkVgVdh# 9ZZhiZbdYd!h^W^ZccdZm^hiZc^c\jcVgVocZXdcb^XV[jcYVbZciVa fjZ^be^YVVYdeiVgjcVbdcZYVXdbch^ceVhVgedgjcVXjZgYdhZbZ_VciZ Va BI8! aaZkV Vdh edcZg Zc [jcX^dcVb^Zcid jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V# :hiV a^b^iVX^cVWgZZa^ciZggd\VciZYZfjhjXZYZYjgVciZZaegdXZhd!iZc^ZcYd Zc XjZciV fjZ jcV XdcbdX^c ZmXZh^kV ejZYZ edcZg Zc eZa^\gd idYd Za egdnZXid# JcV hdajX^c Zh XgZVg! eVhd V eVhd! aVh ^chi^ijX^dcZh cZXZhVg^Vh! b^ZcigVh hZ eZgb^iZ aV a^WgZ ÅdiVX^c YZ aVh bdcZYVh YZ idYdh adh [jijgdh eVhZh b^ZbWgdh# H^ ZhiZ eZgdYd hZ XVgVXiZg^oV edg \gVcYZh ÅjXijVX^dcZh! ejZYZ fjZ hZV Y^[X^a YZiZgb^cVg Xdc egZX^h^c Za i^ed YZ XVbW^d Va fjZ aVh bdcZYVh fjZ YZhVeVgZXZc hZ ]Vc YZ XdckZgi^g Zc aV cjZkV bdcZYV XdaZXi^kV# :a g^Zh\d Zh fjZ Va\jcdh i^edh YZ XVbW^d ejZYZc egdkdXVg jcV hdWgZkVajVX^c# :hid VbZcVoVgV hZg^VbZciZ aV [jijgV jc^c bdcZiVg^V! nV fjZ hZ edYgVc cZXZh^iVg Vdh YZ YdadgdhV YZÅVX^c eVgV Za^b^cVg aV hdWgZkVajVX^c#DigVhdajX^cZhVea^XVgjcVÅdiVX^cXdcigdaVYVXdcXZW^YV eVgVhjeg^b^g\gVcYZhÅjXijVX^dcZh!fjZeZgb^i^gVegdWVgedh^WaZhiVhVhYZ XdckZgh^c#H^cZbWVg\d!aVÅdiVX^cXdcigdaVYVcjcXVZhjcVeVcVXZVkVhZ aV hZXX^c 'W! nV fjZ Zh egdWVWaZ fjZ adh bZgXVYdh edc\Vc V egjZWV aVh 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &** ^ciZcX^dcZhYZaVhVjidg^YVYZhbdcZiVg^Vh!fjZejZYZckZghZZcaVcZXZh^YVY YZ gZVa^oVg [jZgiZh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh# Ad bZ_dg fjZ ejZYZ ]VXZghZ! Zc iVaZh X^gXjchiVcX^Vh! Zh aaZkVg V XVWd ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh Zhig^XiVbZciZ XddgY^cVYVh! hjedc^ZcYd fjZ hZ ]jW^ZgVc VXjbjaVYd egZk^VbZciZ gZhZgkVh hjÄX^ZciZh# H^ W^Zc! edg ad \ZcZgVa! Zh ^begdWVWaZ fjZ Y^X]Vh ^ciZgkZcX^dcZh iZc\Vc m^id! ejZYZc iZcZgad h^ hZ aVh VednV bZY^VciZ Za VXjZgYd YZ VYdeiVg jcV bdcZYVXdbcZcjcV[ZX]VXaVgVbZciZZhiVWaZX^YV#H^cZbWVg\d!eVgVfjZ ZhiV deX^c Y WjZcdh gZhjaiVYdh hZ YZWZc Vea^XVg Xdc egjYZcX^V edai^XVh bdcZiVg^VhnÄhXVaZhcVX^dcVaZh!XdcZaÄcYZcdhdXVkVgZaegde^degdnZXid# 6aÄcVa!kdakZbdhVaejcidYZeVgi^YV#EVgVVkVcoVg]VX^VjcVjc^c bdcZiVg^VcdhZgZfj^ZgZccZXZhVg^VbZciZVXjZgYdhiVaZhXdbdZaBI8!c^ egd\gVbVh YZ XdckZg\ZcX^V h^b^aVgZh Va YZ BVVhig^X]i# Cd dWhiVciZ! YVYd Za i^Zbed fjZ ^cZk^iVWaZbZciZ aaZkV Za egdXZhd! Za eZgdYd YZ igVch^X^c Zhi{ aaZcd YZ eZa^\gdh ediZcX^VabZciZ aZiVaZh# JcV XjZhi^c XaVkZ Zh fjZ aV ZaZXX^c YZ i^edh YZ XVbW^d hdad ejZYZ WVhVghZ Zc Za XdbedgiVb^Zcid eVhVYd!fjZ!VhjkZo!gZfj^ZgZhjÄX^ZciZZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VYjgVciZZa eZgdYdYZigVch^X^c#6YZb{h!jcVkZofjZhZ^c^X^VaVjc^cbdcZiVg^V!aVh iVhVh^cÅVX^dcVg^VhYZWZchZg!ZcacZVh\ZcZgVaZh!h^b^aVgZh#109VYdfjZaVh iVhVh YZ ^cÅVX^c hjZaZc hZg jc iZbV Y^[X^a! aV XdckZg\ZcX^V ^cÅVX^dcVg^V YZWZg{ZhiVgW^ZcZhiVWaZX^YVVciZhYZedcZgZcbVgX]VaVjc^cbdcZiVg^V! VÄcYZZk^iVgaVhdWgZkVajVX^c#9ZV]fjZhZVcZXZhVg^djcVaid\gVYdYZ XddgY^cVX^cYjgVciZZaeZgdYdYZigVch^X^c# b) Instituciones Adh gZ\bZcZh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d cd ejZYZc [jcX^dcVg Zc Za kVXd# BZXVc^hbdh ¹hZcX^aadhº! iVaZh Xdbd aVh ÅdiVX^dcZh XdcigdaVYVh h^c XddgY^cVX^c Zhig^XiV! ejZYZc ^beaZbZciVghZ h^c ^chi^ijX^dcZh YZhi^cVYVh ZmXajh^kVbZciZ V iVa Z[ZXid! Xdbd dXjggZ Zc Za 6h^V hjYdg^ZciVa# Adh VXjZgYdh b{h VbW^X^dhdh h gZfj^ZgZc YZ ^chi^ijX^dcZh# >cXajhd adh b{h hZcX^aadhYZWZcXdciVgXdcZagZheVaYdYZ^chi^ijX^dcZhcVX^dcVaZh!XdcXZeid Vbea^VbZciZgZXdcdX^YdZcaVVXijVa^YVYZcaVhejWa^XVX^dcZhZheZX^Va^oVYVh kVchZ!edgZ_Zbead!EZghhdcnIVWZaa^c^'%%%n9gVoZc'%%%# JcV XVgVXiZghi^XV bVc^ÄZhiV YZ aVh ^chi^ijX^dcZh Zh fjZ hj XgZVX^c n Xdchda^YVX^c aaZkV i^Zbed# Edg Zaad! Zc X^Zgid bdYd hdc cZXZhVg^Vh YZhYZ VciZh YZ fjZ Zm^hiVc# AV Xdchi^ijX^c iZbegVcV YZ 10 AVh iVhVh YZ ^c[aVX^c cVX^dcVaZh Zc jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V cd cZXZhVg^VbZciZ i^ZcZc fjZ hZg^\jVaZh#EjZYZcZm^hi^g[ajXijVX^dcZhiZbedgVaZhgZaVX^dcVYVhXdcY^kZghVhXdcY^X^dcZh bVXgdZXdcb^XVh# IVbW^c ejZYZ ]VWZg iZcYZcX^Vh fjZ gZ[aZ_Zc Y^hi^cidh VjbZcidh YZ egdYjXi^k^YVY[ZcbZcd7VaVhhV"HVbjZahdc# &*+ 8:E6A aVh ^chi^ijX^dcZh W^Zc ejZYZ ]VWZg h^Yd jc [VXidg XaVkZ Zc Za m^id YZ aV ^ciZ\gVX^c ZjgdeZV# AV 8db^h^c :jgdeZV [jZ XgZVYV edg Za IgViVYd YZ GdbV Zc &.*-! [ZX]V Zc fjZ hZ ejhd Zc bVgX]V Za BZgXVYd 8dbc# Hjh [VXjaiVYZh n VbW^X^dcZh [jZgdc! Zc jc eg^cX^e^d! WVhiVciZ a^b^iVYVh# 8dc Za XdggZg YZ adh Vdh! hZ ]V XdckZgi^Yd Zc YZ[ZchdgV YZ aV ^ciZ\gVX^c! Va jc^g Ydh [jZgoVh dejZhiVh# Edg jc aVYd! ZcXVgcV Za ^ciZgh XdaZXi^kd n adh WZcZÄX^dh YZ aV XddeZgVX^c# Edg Za digd! hjh [VXjaiVYZh hZ YZg^kVc YZ adh \dW^Zgcdh! fjZ gZegZhZciVc ^ciZgZhZh cVX^dcVaZh# :hid Zmea^XV hj egdXZhd YZ idbV YZ YZX^h^dcZh! V bZcjYd b^hiZg^dhd! n bjX]dh YZ hjh YZ[ZXidh# Cd h^ZbegZ hZ VYk^ZgiZ aV XdcigVY^XX^c ^cigchZXV YZ aV 8db^h^c/ hj [jcX^c Zh Y^g^\^g VfjZaadh VheZXidh YZ aV hdWZgVcV cVX^dcVa fjZ adh :hiVYdh b^ZbWgdh ]Vc gZh^\cVYd! eZgd cZXZh^iV YZ aV VegdWVX^c YZ Zhdh b^hbdh :hiVYdh b^ZbWgdh! fjZ hdc ^chi^ci^kVbZciZ gZVX^dh V gZcjcX^Vg V hj edYZg YZ YZX^h^c VXZgXV YZ XjZhi^dcZh YZa^XVYVh YZhYZ Za ejcid YZ k^hiVedai^Xd#CdejZYZhjWZhi^bVghZZa]ZX]dYZfjZaV8db^h^cZm^hiVn fjZ!YZhYZhjXgZVX^c!hjhVig^WjX^dcZh]VnVcXgZX^YdXdch^YZgVWaZbZciZ# AV 8db^h^c cd hdad igViV YZ gZjc^g Vednd eVgV aV ^ciZ\gVX^c! h^cd fjZ iVbW^c hZ ZcXVg\V YZa igVWV_d W{h^Xd cZXZhVg^d eVgV egZeVgVg cjZkdh eVhdh# 8jVcYd Za bdbZcid edai^Xd hZV egde^X^d ·cjcXV hZ ejZYZ egZkZg Xj{cYd ad hZg{· idYd ad cZXZhVg^d eVgV fjZ Za egdnZXid VkVcXZ ZhiVg{ a^hid Zc adh XV_dcZh YZ aV 8db^h^c# 6YZb{h YZ aV 8db^h^c! :jgdeV ]V ^Yd [dg_VcYd jc kVhid Xdc_jcid YZ ^chi^ijX^dcZh! V bZY^YV fjZ Za VaXVcXZ YZ aV XddeZgVX^c igVhXZcY^ \gVYjVabZciZ aV ZXdcdbV# Edg ad \ZcZgVa! XVYVeVhdhZXVgVXiZg^oVedgaVb^hbV^cXbdYVhdajX^cYZXdbegdb^hd ZcigZaVh[jZgoVheVgi^YVg^VhYZaV^ciZ\gVX^cnYZacVX^dcVa^hbd#JcWjZc Z_ZbeadZhZaEVgaVbZcid:jgdeZd!fjZhZXdck^gi^ZcaVkVa^dhV^chiVcX^V! h^W^ZcYW^a!VciZZaXjVaZa7VcXd8ZcigVa:jgdeZdYZWZgZcY^gXjZciVh# 9ZW^Yd V fjZ adh VXjZgYdh YZ i^ed YZ XVbW^d ^bea^XVc X^Zgid YZW^a^iVb^ZcidYZaVhdWZgVcVcVX^dcVa!aVYZX^h^cYZXdcXZgiVgadhcjcXV Zh [{X^a YZ idbVg! n Zh egdWVWaZ fjZ gZfj^ZgV Zhibjad n Vednd iXc^Xd# AdheVhZhfjZZhi{cVcVa^oVcYdaVedh^W^a^YVYYZhjhXg^W^gVXjZgYdhYZ ZhiVcYdaZYZWZg{cXdciVgXdcjcV^chi^ijX^c_dkZcfjZejZYVZhijY^Vg adhXdcXZeidhnegdedcZgY^kZghVhhdajX^dcZh#IVa^chi^ijX^ccdYZWZg{ iZcZgc^c\cedYZg!eZgdhjdg^ZciVX^cYZWZg{hZgXaVgVbZciZgZ\^dcVa YZhYZ Za Xdb^Zcod# JcV kZciV_V Zh fjZ ZhiV ^chi^ijX^c ^c[dgbVgV gZ\jaVgbZciZ V adh b^c^higdh YZ [^cVcoVh n! YZ ZhiZ bdYd! VaZciVgV n ZcXjVYgVgVhjhYZa^WZgVX^dcZh# c) El papel de los mercados financieros :cgZaVX^cXdcadhgZ\bZcZhXVbW^Vg^dh!adhbZgXVYdhÄcVcX^Zgdhhdc iVcidZcZb^\dhXdbdVb^\dh#HdcZcZb^\dhedgfjZhdcegdXa^kZhVYZhVÄVg 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &*, aVh edai^XVh XjVcYd YZiZXiVc XjVafj^Zg kjacZgVW^a^YVY# 6a\jcdh ejcidh YW^aZhhdcXdchZXjZcX^VYZbVaVhedai^XVh!ZcXjndXVhdjcVVYkZgiZcX^VV i^ZbedhZg{egdYjXi^kV!VjcXjVcYdhZVYdadgdhV#EZgdZcjcbjcYdYdcYZ aVh Xg^h^h VjidXjbea^YVh hZ Va^bZciVc YZ kjacZgVW^a^YVYZh ^cigchZXVh! adh bZgXVYdhejZYZc^bedcZgeVjiVhYZWjZcXdbedgiVb^ZcidZmXZh^kVbZciZ ZaZkVYVh# Edg digV eVgiZ! XjVcYd aVh edai^XVh Zhi{c W^Zc Y^hZVYVh! adh bZgXVYdh ejZYZc egZhiVg jc [jZgiZ Vednd# Jc WjZc Z_Zbead Zh Za XVb^cd ]VX^VaVjc^cbdcZiVg^VZc:jgdeV#:cZa\g{ÄXd>K#)hZdWhZgkVciVhVhYZ ^ciZgh V Xdgid eaVod# 8jVcYd ZgV Zk^YZciZ fjZ >iVa^V hZ jc^gV V aV Jc^c :Xdcb^XV n BdcZiVg^V! hjh iVhVh YZ ^ciZgh g{e^YVbZciZ XdckZg\^Zgdc V aVhYZ6aZbVc^VnVhhZbVcijk^Zgdc#:hVXdckZg\ZcX^VcdhdadgZegZhZci jc kdid YZ XdcÄVcoV Zc aV ZbegZhV! h^cd fjZ VÄVco Za kcXjad ZcigZ aV a^gV n Za bVgXd ]VhiV aV ^cigdYjXX^c YZa Zjgd# Edg Za XdcigVg^d! aV iVhV YZ ^ciZghYZ<gVc7gZiVV]VXdchZgkVYdjcVk^YVegde^V!fjZhZgZÅZ_VZcaVh ÅjXijVX^dcZh XVbW^Vg^Vh a^WgV"Zjgd# DigV ZchZVcoV fjZ hZ ejZYZ ZmigVZg YZa\g{ÄXd>K#)ZhfjZadhbZgXVYdhYZWdcdhZjgdeZdhhZ]Vc^ciZ\gVYdn bVci^ZcZc!YZZhiZbdYd!aVegdbZhVYZjcbZgXVYdVXi^kdnZÄX^ZciZ#:hid ]VXdchi^ij^YdjcVkZciV_VeVgVadheVhZhb{heZfjZdhn]VegdedgX^dcVYd jcV_jhi^ÄXVX^cZmedhiYZaVa^WZgVa^oVX^cYZXVe^iVaZh# Gráfico IV.4 TASAS DE BONOS DE TESORERÍA EN EUROPA Fuente: FMI. &*- 8:E6A 9Z ad ZmejZhid hZ YZhegZcYZ fjZ hZ YZWZ gZXjgg^g V adh bZgXVYdh XjVcYd ejZYVc egdedgX^dcVg VnjYV n bVciZcZgadh V gVnV XjVcYd ejZYVc XVjhVg eZgijgWVX^dcZh# H^ adh gZ\bZcZh XVbW^Vg^dh hdc YZ eVg^YVY Ä_V ÅZm^WaZ! hdc VaiVbZciZ kjacZgVWaZh V aV egZh^c ZheZXjaVi^kV# :hid _jhi^ÄXV Vbea^VbZciZaVgZhig^XX^cYZadhÅj_dhYZXVe^iVa#H^aVYZX^h^cZhVkVcoVg Y^gZXiVbZciZ ]VX^V jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V! adh bZgXVYdh ejZYZc Xdcig^Wj^g VaegdXZhd!eZgdhdadh^iVajc^cZhi{W^ZcY^hZVYVnXjZciVXdc\VgVciV edai^XV#=VhiVfjZZhiZhZVZaXVhd!ZhegdWVWaZfjZadhbZgXVYdhYZhXjWgVc [VaaVh Zc Za Y^hZd n Zc aV kdajciVY edai^XV n ]V\Vc eZYVodh Za egdnZXid! digV_jhi^ÄXVX^ceVgV^bedcZggZhig^XX^dcZh# Edgai^bd!ªejZYZaV^ciZ\gVX^cgZ\^dcVaYZabZgXVYd[^cVcX^Zgd hjhi^ij^g V jc bZXVc^hbd XVbW^Vg^d4 EVgV XdbZcoVg! h^ Va\jcdh YZ adh bZgXVYdh cVX^dcVaZh nV Zhi{c ^ciZ\gVYdh Zc adh bZgXVYdh bjcY^VaZh! ^ciZ\gVX^c gZ\^dcVa h^\c^[^XV! YZ ]ZX]d! ^ciZ\gVX^c bjcY^Va# HZ\c hZ hdhi^ZcZZcaVhZXX^c'V!aV^ciZ\gVX^cYZabZgXVYd[^cVcX^ZgdedaVg^oV aV ZaZXX^c YZ jc g\^bZc XVbW^Vg^d! Xdbd ad edhijaV aV ]^eiZh^h YZa ¹bZY^dZmXaj^Ydº#:cXdchZXjZcX^V!jcXVbW^dhZbZ_VciZejZYZ^bejahVg jc g\^bZc XVbW^Vg^d g\^Yd jc^c bdcZiVg^V d W^Zc dWa^\Vg V jcV [adiVX^ca^WgZ#:h^begdWVWaZfjZ!ZcaVhgZ\^dcZhfjZXdbegZcYZceVhZh fjZ XdbZgX^Vc VXi^kVbZciZ ZcigZ h! adh i^edh YZ XVbW^d iZc\Vc jc Vaid \gVYdYZkdaVi^a^YVY# 5. Conclusiones :jgdeV ]V YVYd adh Ydh Z_Zbeadh b{h VXVWVYdh YZ gZ\bZcZh XVbW^Vg^dhgZ\^dcVaZh/eg^bZgd!ZabZXVc^hbdYZi^edhYZXVbW^dnV]dgV! aV jc^c bdcZiVg^V# ªEjZYZc n YZWZc Zhidh gZ\bZcZh ZbjaVghZ Zc digdh aj\VgZh4 :c ZhiZ igVWV_d hZ hdhi^ZcZ fjZ aVh eZfjZVh ZXdcdbVh VW^ZgiVh fjZi^ZcZckcXjadhXdbZgX^VaZhVXi^kdhdYZhZVc^ciZch^ÄXVgadhXdbeVgiZc jc^ciZghcVijgVaZcZhiVW^a^oVghji^edYZXVbW^d^ciZgcd#IVbW^chZ]V egdXjgVYdYZbdhigVgfjZZah^hiZbVZjgdeZdhZ[jcYVZceg^cX^e^dhÄgbZh n W^Zc gZXdcdX^Ydh# Edg ZhiVh gVodcZh! Xdchi^ijnZ jc egdnZXid fjZ edYgV VYdeiVghZZcdigVhgZ\^dcZh# H^cZbWVg\d!cdZhjcZ_Zbead[{X^aYZhZ\j^g#AVZhigViZ\^VYZad\gVg jc \gVYd egd[jcYd YZ ^ciZ\gVX^c ZXdcb^XV hZ WVh Zc dW_Zi^kdh bjX]d b{hVbea^dhfjZjcbZgdbZgXVYdXdbc#:acXaZdYZaegdXZhd]Vh^YdZa YZhZdYZedcZgÄcVh^\adhYZ\jZggVh#9ZW^Yd!ZceVgiZ!VfjZadhgZXjZgYdh YZ YZhigjXX^c bjijV Zhi{c Vc [gZhXdh Zc hj bZbdg^V! adh ZjgdeZdh ]Vc VXXZY^YdVYZaZ\Vgegd\gZh^kVbZciZZaZbZcidhYZhjhdWZgVcV!VeZhVgYZ jcV YZX^Y^YV dedh^X^c n YZ Y^kZg\ZcX^Vh cVX^dcVaZh egd[jcYVh# B{h Vc! cd Zh XVhjVa fjZ aV YZX^h^c YZ XdbeVgi^g jcV bdcZYV Xdbc hZ idbVgV edXdYZhejhYZjc]ZX]dZmXZeX^dcVa/aVXVYVYZaBjgdYZ7Zgac# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &*. Digd gVh\d ^bedgiVciZ YZa egdXZhd ZjgdeZd Zh fjZ cjcXV ]jWd jc eaVcbVZhigd#AV^ciZ\gVX^ch^ZbegZhZ]VXVgVXiZg^oVYdedgjcXa^bVYZ Xdc[jh^c! Zc Za fjZ hZ VkVcoVc Ydh eVhdh n hZ gZigdXZYZ jcd! Zc bZY^d YZegd[jcYVhneZgh^hiZciZhY^kZg\ZcX^VhZcXjVcidVadW_Zi^kdÄcVa#EZgd XVYVZiVeVYZaV^ciZ\gVX^c[VX^a^iVaVh^\j^ZciZ#:am^idZcjc{gZVVc^bVV adhY^g^\ZciZhedai^XdhVXdciZbeaVgaVedh^W^a^YVYYZ^c^X^VgdigdegdnZXid Vjc b{h VjYVo Zc digV Zh[ZgV# EgdWVWaZbZciZ ad b{h ^bedgiVciZ Zh fjZ XVYVeVhd]VZhiVYdVXdbeVVYdYZjcbVndgYZhVggdaad^chi^ijX^dcVa!ad fjZkVXgZVcYdaVZhigjXijgVcZXZhVg^VeVgVYVgZah^\j^ZciZeVhd#:cZhiZ hZci^Yd! Zh Y^[X^a hdWgZhi^bVg aV ^bedgiVcX^V YZ XgZVg ^chi^ijX^dcZh! edg ^beZg[ZXiVhfjZhZVc!YZhYZaVheg^bZgVhZiVeVhXdcZaÄcYZgZheVaYVgZa egdXZhdYZ^ciZ\gVX^c# IVbW^cZh^bedgiVciZXdch^YZgVgfjZ!YjgVciZaVg\di^Zbed!bjX]dh eVhZhZjgdeZdh]VcbVciZc^YdXdcigdaZhYZXVe^iVa!ZcjcbjcYdYdcYZ aV eaZcV bdk^a^YVY YZ XVe^iVaZh ZgV aV ZmXZeX^c n cd aV gZ\aV# 8jVcYd Za egdXZhd bjcY^Va YZ a^WZgVa^oVX^c hZ VXZaZg! :jgdeV nV ]VWV VkVcoVYd WVhiVciZedgZaXVb^cdYZaVZhiVW^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VgZ\^dcVa#:ck^hiVYZhj VeZ\dViVaZhiVW^a^YVYnYZam^iddWiZc^Yd!XjVcYdhZaVdWa^\VZhXd\Zg ZcigZ jcV ÅdiVX^c a^WgZ n jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V Xdbd gZhjaiVYd YZ hj egde^Va^WZgVa^oVX^cÄcVcX^ZgV!aVZaZXX^c[jZgZaVi^kVbZciZhZcX^aaV# AV hdajX^c ZjgdeZV YZ deZgVg eVg^YVYZh [^_Vh [aZm^WaZh YjgVciZ jceZgdYdegdadc\VYdncdZheZX^[^XVgZadW_Zi^kdai^bdYZjcVjc^c bdcZiVg^V gZfj^ZgZ bVciZcZg adh XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa d! Zc Va\jcdh XVhdh! gZhiVWaZXZgadh# :hid Y^d WjZcdh gZhjaiVYdh Zc :jgdeV n iVbW^c ejZYZYVgadhZcdigdhaj\VgZh#EdgdigVeVgiZ!h^hZZa^b^cVcadhXdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa! aV a^hiV YZ deX^dcZh edh^WaZh hZ gZYjXZ n hZ edaVg^oV# :h ^begdWVWaZfjZaVheVg^YVYZh[aZm^WaZhYjgZcbjX]di^Zbed!adfjZYZ_V Ydh VaiZgcVi^kVh/ [adiVX^c gZ\^dcVa d jc VkVcXZ gVodcVWaZbZciZ g{e^Yd ]VX^V jcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V# JcV jc^c bdcZiVg^V gZfj^ZgZ jcV [jZgiZ kdajciVYedai^XV!ZheZX^VabZciZZcgZ\^dcZhfjZ!]VhiVZabdbZcid!]Vc kVX^aVYdZcZhijY^VgaVedh^W^a^YVYYZYZaZ\VghdWZgVcVncd]VcXgZVYd aVh^chi^ijX^dcZhfjZhZgZfjZg^g{ceVgVegZeVgVgnZ_ZXjiVgaVhbZY^YVh cZXZhVg^Vh# :hiVh ^cXajnZc aV XgZVX^c YZ jc WVcXd XZcigVa gZ\^dcVa! aV ^chiVjgVX^c YZ Va\jcV [dgbV YZbdXg{i^XV YZ gZcY^X^c YZ XjZciVh n aV VYdeX^c YZ bZY^YVh fjZ \VgVci^XZc Y^hX^ea^cV [^hXVa# H^c ZbWVg\d! Va eVgZXZg YZWZg{c YVghZ X^gXjchiVcX^Vh ZmXZeX^dcVaZh eVgV bVgX]Vg Z[ZXi^kVbZciZZcZhiVY^gZXX^c# :hedgZhiVhgVodcZhfjZ!YZhejhYZidYd!jcegdXZhdaZcidejZYZ hZg b{h gZVa^hiV! Vjc XjVcYd hj ZkdajX^c YZWV bZY^ghZ Zc cbZgd YZ \ZcZgVX^dcZh n cd Zc Vdh# :a eg^bZg eVhd Zc jc egdXZhd hZbZ_VciZ Zh aV \Zhi^cXdc_jciVYZi^edhYZXVbW^d!nVhZVcÄ_dhdV_jhiVWaZh!gZheVaYVYdh &+% 8:E6A edg XdcigdaZh YZ XVe^iVa Xdbd Zc Za BI8! d Za bVcZ_d Xdc_jcid YZ ÅdiVX^dcZh a^WgZh# Edg ZhiZ bdi^kd Za g\^bZc YZ bdk^a^YVY YZ XVe^iVaZh Zh jcV YZX^h^c egZa^b^cVg XaVkZ# :a eVeZa fjZ YZhZbeZVc adh XdcigdaZh YZa XVe^iVa h^\jZ h^ZcYd jc iZbV VW^Zgid n XdcigdkZgi^Yd# 6 kZXZh hZ VÄgbV fjZ nV cd hdc [VXi^WaZh Zc Za bjcYd \adWVa^oVYd YZ ]dn# :hiV VÄgbVX^c cdZhi{XdcÄgbVYV#CddWhiVciZ!Zh^begdWVWaZfjZadheVhZhfjZnV]Vc a^WZgVa^oVYdhjhbdk^b^ZcidhYZXVe^iVa!ZcbjX]dhXVhdheV\VcYdjcVaid egZX^dedgZaad!11gZk^ZgiVcaVh^ijVX^c#:cidYdXVhd!h^aVa^WZgVa^oVX^cYZ adhÅj_dhYZXVe^iVaZhhZXdch^YZgVXdckZc^ZciZ!hj^beaZbZciVX^cYZWZg{ ^gVXdbeVVYVYZjcVcdiVWaZÅZm^W^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^V#:cXjVafj^ZgVYZadh XVhdh!aVhgZ\^dcZhfjZYZhZZca^b^iVgaVkdaVi^a^YVYXVbW^Vg^VW^aViZgVacd i^ZcZc digV hdajX^c fjZ XgZVg Va\jcV ^chi^ijX^c YZY^XVYV V iVa Z[ZXid n XZaZWgVgVXjZgYdhbjai^aViZgVaZhYZVedndbjijd!h^b^aVgZhVabZXVc^hbd YZi^edhYZXVbW^d# 11 :m^hiZZk^YZcX^VXdch^YZgVWaZYZfjZaVVeZgijgV[^cVcX^ZgVZhi{hZ\j^YVYZXg^h^hbdcZiVg^Vh# KVchZ!edgZ_Zbead!@Vb^h`nnGZ^c]Vgi&...nLneadho'%%'W# 8ddeZgVX^cÄcVcX^ZgVgZ\^dcVa &+& Bibliografía 7V``Zg! 6\Z ;#E# &..+! The Liberalization of Capital Movements in Europe, @ajlZg 6XVYZb^XEjWa^h]Zgh# 7VaYl^c!G#&..,!¹I]ZXVjhZhd[GZ\^dcVa^hbº!The World Economy'%,# 8Vakd! <# n 8# GZ^c]Vgi '%%%! ¹;ZVg d[ ÅdVi^c\º! Quarterly Journal of Economics &&,'# 8diiVgZaa^!8#!<#<Vaa^!E#BVgjaadGZZYion<#E^iiVaj\V&.-+!¹BdcZiVgneda^Xni]gdj\] XZ^a^c\hdcWVc`aZcY^c\º!Economic Policy (# 9Z <gVjlZ! E# &.--! ¹:mX]Vc\Z gViZ kdaVi^a^in VcY i]Z hadlYdlc ^c \gdli] ^c ^ciZgcVi^dcVaigVYZº!IMF Staff Papers (*# 9gVoZc!6#'%%%!Political Economy in Macroeconomics, Eg^cXZidcJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# :^X]Zc\gZZc! 7# n 8]# Lneadho &..(! ¹I]Z jchiVWaZ :BHº! Brookings Papers on Economic Activity &# ;ZaYhiZ^c! B# &..,! ¹I]Z eda^i^XVa ZXdcdbn d[ :jgdeZVc BdcZiVgn Jc^dc/ eda^i^XVa gZVhdch[dgVcZXdcdb^Xa^VW^a^inº!Journal of Economic Perspectives&&)# <gdh! 9# n C# I]n\ZhZc &..-! European Monetary Integration, HZ\jcYV ZY^X^c! =Vgadl!6YY^hdcLZhaZnAdc\bVc# =Zaa^lZaa! ?# ;# &..-! How Much Do National Borders Matter?, LVh]^c\idc! 9#8#! 7gdd`^c\h>chi^iji^dc# @Vb^ch`n!<#n8#GZ^c]Vgi&...!¹I]ZIl^c8g^hZh/i]ZXVjhZhd[WVc`^c\VcYWVaVcXZ" d["eVnbZcihegdWaZbhº!American Economic Review -.(# @ZcZc! E# 7# &..*! Economic and Monetary Union in Europe: Moving Beyond Maastricht,8VbWg^Y\ZJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# @ZcZc! E# 7# n 9# GdYg^` &.-+! ¹BZVhjg^c\ VcY VcVano^c\ i]Z Z[[ZXih d[ h]dgi"iZgb kdaVi^a^in^cgZVaZmX]Vc\ZgViZhº!Review of Economics and Statistics+-# AZkn"NZnVi^! :# n ;# HijgoZcZ\\Zg '%%'! ¹8aVhh^[n^c\ ZmX]Vc\Z gViZ gZ\^bZh/ YZZYh kZghjhldgYhº!Jc^kZgh^YVYIdgXjVidY^IZaaV# BX@^ccdc! G# &.,.! Money in International Exchange, The Convertible Currency System, Dm[dgYJc^kZgh^inEgZhh# EVghaZn!9#nH#"?#LZ^'%%&!¹A^b^i^c\XjggZcXnkdaVi^a^inidhi^bjaViZ\ddYhbVg`Zi ^ciZ\gVi^dc/Veg^XZWVhZYVeegdVX]!ºC7:GLdg`^c\EVeZgC§-)+-# EZghhdc! I# n <# IVWZaa^c^ '%%%! Political Economics, Explaining Economic Policy, B>IEgZhh# GZ^c]Vgi!8#n@#Gd\d[['%%)!¹I]ZbdYZgc]^hidgnd[ZmX]Vc\ZgViZVggVc\ZbZcih/V gZ^ciZgegZiVi^dcº!Quarterly Journal of Economics &&.&# Gd\d[[!@#'%%'!¹GZi]^c`^c\XVe^iVaXdcigdah/L]Zch]djaYlZ`ZZeVcdeZcb^cY4º! Finance and Development(.)# GdhZ!6#'%%%!¹DcZbdcZn!dcZbVg`Zi/Zhi^bVi^c\i]ZZ[[ZXid[XdbbdcXjggZcX^Zh dcigVYZº!Economic Policy (%# HVe^g!6#! E#6\]^dc! <# 7ZgidaV! B# =Zaal^\! ?# E^hVc^";Zggn! 9# GdhVi^! ?# K^Vah n =# LVaaVXZ'%%(!Agenda de una Europa en crecimiento para que el sistema económico de la UE funcione, 8db^h^c:jgdeZV# Lneadho!8]#'%%'V!¹=dlg^h`n^hÄcVcX^Vaa^WZgVa^oVi^dc^ci]ZYZkZade^c\Xdjcig^Zh4º! Comparative Economic Studies ))'"(# '%%'W! ¹;^hXVa Y^hX^ea^cZ ^c :BJ/ gjaZh dg ^chi^iji^dch4º! YdXjbZcid egZeVgVYd eVgVZa<gjedYZ6c{a^h^h:Xdcb^XdYZaV8db^h^c:jgdeZV#