Posterior Cortical Atrophy D. Frank Benson, MD; R. Jeffrey Davis, DO; Bruce D. Snyder, MD \s=b\ Five patients had progressive dementia heralded by disorders of higher visual function. All eventually developed alexia, agraphia, visual agnosia, and components of Balint's, Gerstmann's, and transcortical sensory aphasia syndromes. Memory, insight, and judgment were relatively preserved until late in the course. Predominant parieto-occipital atrophy was demonstrated on both computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging in two of the patients; posterior circulation was normal by angiography in the three studied. To date, no pathologic specimen is available for study; speculations on the underlying pathologic condition include an atypical clinical variant of Alzheimer's disease, a lobar atrophy analogous to Pick's disease, or some previ- ously unrecognized entity. (Arch Neurol 1988;45:789-793) evaluation of large popula¬ Pouring tion of patients with dementia, a a few individuals with slowly progres¬ sive deterioration stood out because of early visual dysfunction. Despite dis¬ abling visual problems, both visual acuity and visual fields remained intact until late when unilateral qua¬ drante visual extinction could be demonstrated. Agnosia, alexia, anom¬ ia, Balint's syndrome (sticky fixation, ocular dysmetria, and simultanagnosia), Gerstmann's syndrome (rightleft disorientation, finger agnosia, acalculia, and agraphia), and transcortical sensory aphasia eventually developed. Memory, insight into their problems, and motivation to improve themselves were preserved until late in the course. PATIENT SELECTION AND EVALUATION Four patients from neurologic and psy¬ chiatric clinics at UCLA were noted to have a history of slowly progressive dementing illness, with the most promi¬ nent cognitive and functional deficits referable to visual processing. A similar Accepted for publication Feb 15, 1988. From the Department of Neurology, UCLA School of Medicine; and the Neurobehavior Unit, West Los Angeles Veterans Administration Medical Center (Brentwood Division) (Drs Benson and Davis); and the Department of Neurology, St Paul-Ramsey Medical Center, St Paul, Minn (Dr Snyder). Reprint requests to UCLA Department of Neurology, 710 Westwood Plaza, Los Angeles, CA 90024-1769 (Dr Benson). by one of us (B.D.S.). None had hypertension, diabetes, hyperlip¬ idemia, clinical encephalitis, heavy metal exposure, or known medical cause. Prima¬ ry motor and sensory modalities, including visual fields, were intact. Causes other than a primary degenerative process were sought. All patients underwent a routine complete blood cell count; thyroid, liver, and renal function tests; glucose, serum calcium, and phosphorus determinations; and determinations of sedimentation rate and folate and vitamin B12 levels. Twentyfour-hour urine samples were collected to determine the levels of heavy metals and other toxic substances. All patients under¬ went lumbar punctures. No abnormalities were demonstrated. Computed tomography (CT) and mag¬ netic resonance imaging (MRI) were per¬ formed in all patients, and three under¬ went angiography of the carotid and verte¬ brobasilar systems (Table 1). An electroen¬ cephalogram (EEG) was performed on all patients and a full battery of neuropsycho¬ logical tests supplemented clinical exami¬ nation in the three patients who were testable. REPORT OF CASES case was discovered Case 1.—A 64-year-old former bank executive presented with episodes of anxi¬ ety that complicated a slowly progressive disturbance of vision and language. About eight years earlier, he had noted difficulty reading; he remained at his job, but his secretary had to read for him. Although still able to write, he could not read what he produced. Eventually, he also lost the ability to write and had difficulty finding his way in familiar areas (environmental agnosia) and in performing visually medi¬ ated tasks. The problems slowly pro¬ gressed; he stated that what he saw disap¬ peared before he could sense what it was. Progressive worsening of his expressive ability was observed, though his family remained convinced that he understood what was said. On examination, he was alert, oriented, attentive, and in reasonably good physical health. His manner was gracious and his insight was painfully apparent. Conversa¬ tional speech was hesitant, with wordfinding pauses and occasional semantic and verbal paraphasic substitutions. Artic¬ ulation and prosody were intact and he readily repeated and comprehended simple sentences; with complex or abstract descriptions of objects or actions, however, comprehension became faulty. Confronta¬ tion naming was markedly impaired but improved with palpation of the object. When offered multiple choices, he selected the names of colors better than objects or simple shapes. He could not read words, letters, or numbers. He wrote his name and three-word sentence to dictation, but paraphasic substitutions intruded into other attempts. Simple calculations were poor and not aided by paper and pencil. Right-left orientation was almost perfect for his own body but was otherwise ran¬ dom. His ability to name and recognize fingers was severely impaired. Registra¬ one tion of new information could not be strin¬ gently assessed because of word-finding impairment and visual problems, but recall of verbal material was nearly per¬ fect if multiple choice responses were pro¬ vided. Behaviorally, a considerable degree of preserved memory function was indi¬ cated by the content of his continued attempts at interpersonal discourse. Despite language problems, he correctly interpreted similarities, differences, and proverbs. He easily performed verbally commanded praxis tasks unless visual mediation to an outside object was required. For instance, he easily oriented the telephone receiver to his ear but could not replace the receiver on the hook. He could not copy, trace, or perform line orien¬ tation tasks. He drew a circle, square, and triangle on command, but the productions were poor and he failed more complex figures, su&h as a bicycle. He competently tapped out rhythms and performed recip¬ rocal rhythm tasks. The only problem noted on basic neuro¬ logic examination was an inconsistent and questionable diminution of visual acuity in the right lower quadrant, best demon¬ strated by double-simultaneous stimula¬ tion. He accurately counted fingers at 45 cm, but was slow and uncertain. There was neither paresis nor alteration of sensation. He walked as though blind but could navi¬ gate the room without colliding into any¬ thing. When offered a chair, he had diffi¬ culty finding it and when he did, sat on the arm before correctly seating himself. A strong tendency to fix his gaze on a single object (sticky fixation) was present. Full lateral and vertical gaze were possible if he followed a moving object, but jerky, hypometric saccades and tendency to over¬ shoot were noted. When asked to touch a stationary object held in front of him, he initially missed by 7.5 or 10 cm (ocular dysmetria). With repeated attempts, his performance improved but remained uncertain. He routinely failed to find all objects in an array (simultanagnosia). Meaningful neuropsychological testing performed because of the severe impairment present at the time of the initial visit. Computed tomography and MRI of the head revealed bilaterally symmetrical atrophy, most prominent in the parieto-occipital region, with enlarge¬ could not be ment of both the ventricles and the cortical sulci (Fig 1). An EEG showed a generalized 6- to 7-Hz pattern without evidence of focal Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY-DAL-11762 User on 05/18/2015 dysfunction. Case 2.—A 59-year-old bookkeeper sought help for "increasing memory diffi¬ culty" but presented his own history with only minimal additions from family mem¬ bers. His problem had surfaced the previ¬ ous year with progressive difficulty in fol¬ lowing a line of print. Problems in calcula¬ tion, even in keeping the family checkbook, developed and he became lost while driving in his community. He was unable to main¬ tain his job. Mental status examination demon¬ strated an alert man with a digit span of six and an intact memory for the chronolo¬ gy of his symptoms and for general infor¬ mation concerning both remote and cur¬ rent events. Comprehension and repetition of spoken language were normal. Confron¬ tation naming of high-frequency items was intact, but less common items were missed. Both reading and writing were limited to simple statements (eg, "The weather is nice"). Calculations were totally failed. Right-left orientation was poor, but finger identification was adequate. Neurologic examination revealed no focal abnormali¬ ty; visual acuity was normal, visual fields were full to confrontation, and the extra¬ ocular movements were intact. Over the next three years, his mental state progressively deteriorated. Although able to feed himself, he could not identify the food until it was in his mouth. Similar¬ ly, although able to dress himself, he needed guidance and encouragement. Sim¬ ple tasks, such as opening a jar or using a tool such as a hammer or screwdriver, became impossible. He developed total alexia, agraphia, and acalculia plus com¬ plete right-left disorientation and finger agnosia (Gerstmann's syndrome). The aphasia worsened considerably, particu¬ larly naming, which was almost totally failed. Some difficulty with language com¬ prehension developed, but he still repeated well. A full Balint's syndrome could be demonstrated. Neuropsychological testing on two occa¬ sions early in the course demonstrated a depressed full scale IQ, with a significant difference between verbal (VIQ) and per¬ formance (PIQ) subscores (VIQ 91; PIQ 63). Serial EEGs consistently dem¬ onstrated slow (6- to 7-Hz) background without focal abnormalities. Repeated CT scans and a single MRI scan showed only a = = mild, progressive atrophy. Case 3.—A 57-year-old woman com¬ plained of slowly progressive difficulty with vision. Three changes of glasses over 2!/2-year period had not helped. She could not drive, had difficulty reading, and com¬ Fig 1.—Magnetic resonance imaging scan (case 1) demonstrating ventricular enlargement, particularly of occipital horns, and cortical atrophy, most pronounced in parieto-occipital areas. Table 1.—Patient Data* Patients Approximate age of onset, y 56 54 67 53 RLQ RHH LLQ LLQ NT 83 44 79 Duration of disorder, y Anomia Alexia Memory impairment Gerstmann's syndrome Agraphia_ Acalculia Finger agnosia R-L disorientation Balint's syndrome Sticky fixation Ocular dysmetria Simultanagnosia Visual field extinction Environmental agnosia Emotional symptoms Full scale IQ Verbal IQ Performance IQ Wechsler memory quotient NT NT NT PA PA 91 85 63 63 NT NT Impairedt 59 NT NEG GA PA Computed tomography NEG PA PA scan resonance GA imaging Magnetic NL NL NL Angiography SL SL SL SL SL Electroencephalography SL, slow; NL, normal: ?, not not atrophy: testable; GA, generalized atrophy: PA, posterior *NT indicates reported; +, present; ±, mild; —, absent; RLQ, right lower quadrant; RHH, right homonymous hemianopsia; LLQ, left lower quadrant; NEG, negative. tNumbers not given in report and raw data subsequently lost. a plained of forgetting where she had placed her belongings. Examination revealed a healthy individ¬ ual without basic medical or neurologic difficulty. There was no paresis, sensory loss, or visual field disturbance, and extraocular movements were intact. She alert but not fully oriented. Verbal output was fluent but empty, with circum¬ locutions and occasional paraphasic sub¬ stitutions. Comprehension and repetition were normal. On confrontation naming, she had difficulty with low-frequency words (eg, the "bridge" of her glasses, the was "thread" used to sew a button). She could comprehend written material only at the level of a three- or four-word sentence. Writing was severely impaired; only her own name was correctly spelled. She easily learned and retained new verbal informa¬ tion and retrieved information from the past. She was almost totally unable to calculate. Right and left were discrimi¬ nated with fair accuracy, but mistakes of finger identification were consistently not¬ ed. She could not copy drawings, except for a circle. A complete battery of neuropsychologi- cal tests was most remarkable for its dem¬ onstration of visually oriented impair¬ ments reflected in a 22-point difference in the VIQ and PIQ subscores. A CT scan was read as normal, but EEGs were abnormal, with generalized slowing and disorganized background frequencies. Evaluation at several additional diag¬ nostic centers with repeated laboratory tests produced similar results. Five and one-half years following the original examination, she was reevaluated. She now acted as though blind and had to be led. Visual acuity was normal, however, and Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY-DAL-11762 User on 05/18/2015 visual fields were full to confrontation testing although an inconsistent right visual extinction was noted. Her eyes moved in all directions when following a finger, but hypometric saccades were prominent. Neither paresis nor primary sensory loss was evident. She was now severely aphasie with a fluent, anomic output, significantly disturbed comprehen¬ sion, almost total inability to name on confrontation, and total alexia and agraphia but intact repetition of spoken language (transcortical sensory aphasia). The severity of the mental deterioration made neuropsychological testing impossi¬ ble. Gerstmann's syndrome and a full Bal¬ int's syndrome were present. Repeated CT and MRI scans demonstrated atrophy, greatest in the occipital and parietal regions bilaterally, without evidence of a mass lesion or focal lucency (Fig 2). Angi¬ ography showed normal vessels in both anterior and posterior vascular systems. The EEG remained generally slow. Despite marked disability, she retained consider¬ able insight, frequently manifested by cry¬ ing and despondency concerning her fear of progressive disability. Case 4.—A 75-year-old, college-educated author was evaluated for progressive intel¬ lectual impairment of seven years' dura¬ tion. She first noted that her typing slowed and typographical errors increased. Her handwriting deteriorated, eventually be¬ coming illegible. She continued typing a novel, which was published, and then wrote another. Grammatical structure and the general content were satisfactory, but the more recent work was not accepted for publication. By then, she also noted diffi¬ culty with many daily tasks but remained independent. On examination, she was alert and expressed herself clearly, although some word-finding pauses and circumlocution were present. Comprehension, though gen¬ erally intact, broke down with complex grammatical constructions. Repetition was intact to an extended span length. She exhibited a profound confrontation anom¬ ia, failing even the first few items on the Boston Naming Test. She appeared unable to recognize objects visually but also had difficulty providing a name when the item's function was described. Phonemic cues did not help. When an object was placed in her hand, she could pick its function from multiple-choice offerings but could not select the name from several choices. Her only writing was a barely legible signature. Memory testing was complicated by the severe anomia, but when offered multiple-choice responses concerning current news, she was fully correct, even for obscure details. Calcula¬ tion was profoundly impaired, right-left orientation was totally disturbed, and she could not differentiate fingers. She failed to copy even the simplest geometric draw¬ ing and even had difficulty finding the model on the page. She distinguished between a thick and a thin line but could not name or choose a color from multiple choice. Ocular fixation was intense; visual recognition was so limited that simultanagnosia could not be tested. No visual field defect could be demonstrated Fig 2.—Computed tomographic scan (case 4) demonstrating striking enlargement of occipital horns bilaterally. although extinction in the left lower quad¬ rant with double simultaneous stimulation was noted late in the course. The advanced state of deterioration at the time she was first seen in our clinic precluded meaning¬ ful neuropsychological testing. A CT scan was considered normal for her age, but an EEG showed diffuse slowing. Case 5.—A 54-year-old housewife com¬ plained that "my vision is hazy and fades in and out." Ophthalmologic examination demonstrated normal visual acuity, but she noted increasing difficulty in sewing, playing cards, and in playing the piano. She found herself uncertain about which direction to take in her own home and became lost in previously familiar sur¬ roundings. She could no longer perform the simple arithmetic required to balance her checkbook. Despite these difficulties, she held telephone conversations, entertained guests, performed most household chores, planned meals, and attended a dance class. On mental status examination, she was alert and oriented, articulated clearly, and showed good verbal reasoning. She was fluent and repeated and comprehended well. She read aloud, but with difficulty. Knowledge of current events was mildly impaired and both registration and retrieval of verbal and nonverbal material was imperfect. The line bisection task was performed slowly but correctly and with¬ out omission. She drew a clock but could not set the specified time. Her copy of a cube lacked three-dimensional quality. Neurological examination revealed no abnormalities of the cranial nerves, motor strength, sensation, or coordination. Visual acuity was normal, eye movements full, optokinetic nystagmus was equal, and no visual neglect was demon¬ were strated with double simultaneous visual stimulation. An EEG demonstrated theta activity. Computed tomography without and with contrast showed only mild sulcal Neuropsychological testing showed a clear discrepancy between VlQ and PIQ scores (Table 1). Two years later, she could still articulate widening. description of her problems with only an occasional paraphasic substitution. Despite intact functional speech, she could write nothing but her name. All visual tasks were severely impaired, particularly attempts to integrate a complex visual picture into a meaningful whole (simultanagnosia). Spelling aloud was severely impaired. New learning was limited and she could perform only the simplest arith¬ a detailed metic. After three years, her speech became increasingly circumstantial. She no longer handled money and could not perform seri¬ al threes. Her neighborhood was now unfa¬ miliar and she became lost if unaccompa¬ nied. New learning was profoundly impaired. Although she experienced diffi¬ culty getting clothing on correctly, she still attended ballet class for exercise, applied her own makeup, and managed some household duties. She remained socially appropriate and retained insight into the nature of her problems with no change in personality or mood. On examination three years after initial examination, calculations and right-left discrimination were clearly impaired and her ability to find objects in space was poor. Visual fields were intact to confron¬ tation, but she showed greater difficulty localizing objects in the left visual field, and fairly consistent extinction to double simultaneous stimulation could be demon¬ strated in the left inferior quadrant. Cra¬ nial nerves were otherwise intact, there was no dysarthria or motor impairment, reflexes were brisk and symmetrical, and toes were downgoing. Sensation, balance, and coordination testing were unreveal- ing. Neuropsychological testing was per¬ formed on several occasions, providing supportive data for the observations of far greater visual than verbal disorder. Com¬ puted tomographic scanning showed ven¬ tricular size to be somewhat larger than average for age, particularly in the posteri¬ or-superior parietal regions bilaterally. An MR scan demonstrated atrophy that was most pronounced posteriorly. Brain-stem, Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY-DAL-11762 User on 05/18/2015 Table 2.—Posterior Cortical Atrophy* Course Slowly progressive Not stepwise Initial symptoms visual Clinical findings Visual agnosia, constructional disturbance, environmental agnosia Transcortical sensory aphasia (alexia, agraphia, anomia, and decreased comprehension but normal repetition) Gerstmann's syndrome (acalculia, agraphia, R-L disorientation, and finger agnosia) Balint's syndrome (ocular dysmetria, sticky fixation, and simultanagnosia) Decreased verbal learning (late) Normal primary visual, motor, and sensory systems Retention of insight, appropriate affect EEG: diffuse slowing in mid to late stages Laboratory findings WAIS: PIQ 25-30 points lower than VIQ CT: posterior > anterior atrophy MRI scan: posterior > anterior atrophy *EEG indicates electroencephalogram; WAIS, Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale; CT, computed tomogra¬ phy; PIQ, performance IQ; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; and VIQ, verbal IQ. _ in these patients deserves comment. Although first described in 1909,2 the syndrome was rarely reported until recent years. While still considered rare, reviews by Hécaen and Albert3 and Damasio4 document a number of examples and present pertinent theo¬ ries concerning the underlying mech¬ anism. Damasio4 stressed obligatory bilateral parieto-occipital abnormali¬ ty, usually with accompanying inferi¬ quadrantanopia, and suggested two cortical areas of greatest importance: (1) Brodmann area 7 of the parietal cortex appeared essential for direct¬ ing gaze to novel stimuli; (2) the supe¬ rior occipital cortex was thought nec¬ essary to structure the full visual field. Hécaen and Albert3 agree with the observation of a mandatory bilat¬ or eral, parieto-occipital pathologic con¬ dition but note the presence of frontal Table 3.—Differential Diagnosis of Cortical Dementia cortex Features Amnesia Alzheimer's Disease Agraphia Early Early Early Early Early Moderately late Moderately late Gerstmann's syndrome Balint's syndrome Absent Constructional disturbance Environmental agnosia Acalculia Anomia Alexia Moderately late Klüver-Bucy syndrome Loss of insight Absent or late Behavioral response Posterior Pick's Disease Late Late Cortical Atrophy Late Late Early Moderately late Moderately late Late Absent Early Early Early Early Early Early Relatively early Present Absent Early Early Early Unconcerned Disinhibited Appropriately concerned visual, and somatosensory evoked re¬ sponses were normal. An EEG showed intermittent (4- to 6-Hz) slowing superim¬ posed on a 6- to 8-Hz background. COMMENT Each of the patients showed a pro¬ gressive mental deterioration without evidence of basic motor or sensory dysfunction. The earliest clinical find¬ ings (eg, alexia or visual agnosia) implied visual-association malfunc¬ tion. Despite the early presence of visual disturbances that progressed to severe disability, visual acuity re¬ mained intact and the only visualfield discrepancies were extinction to double-simultaneous stimulation and hemineglect noted late in the course of the illness, long after severe visual disability was evident. Two showed right- and two left-sided extinction and in none was it a consistent find¬ ing. An early complaint of each patient was a tendency to get lost in familiar areas, such as an inability to find their way in their neighborhood or difficulty finding their way from room to room in their own home. Environmental agnosia is a term used Late for this dramatic disorder.1 Four patients developed a full Balint's syn¬ drome (sticky fixation, ocular dysme¬ tria, and simultanagnosia) and the fifth showed optic ataxia and ocular dysmetria. All eventually developed all four components of Gerstmann's syndrome (finger agnosia, right-left disorientation, agraphia, and acalcu¬ lia) and also developed the findings of transcortical sensory aphasia (anom¬ ia, comprehension disorder, alexia and agraphia, and good repetition). As an early finding, all had severe impairment of the ability to copy drawings. Memory function was abnormal but only to a limited degree until late in the course. Each could present his or her own history, was aware of current events, and showed considerable insight into his or her predicament. While use of specific names was difficult, true abnormality in memory function was mild until late in the course. No patient devel¬ oped a primary motor, auditory, or somatesthetic disturbance. Table 1 outlines the more important clinical findings of the cases presented. The presence of Balint's syndrome or occipital-frontal pathway lesions in some cases. It has been posited that a combined parieto-occipitofrontal dysfunction underlies the full syndrome.5 All of the neuroanatomical areas said to be associated with Balint's syndrome are either association cortex or cortical-cortical connections, not primary visual cortex or its efferent connections, a feature consistent with the lack of visual field defect in our cases. The three compo¬ nents essential for the diagnosissticky fixation (also called optic apraxia, oculomotor apraxia, ocular apraxia, psychic paralysis of gaze, or spasm of fixation), ocular dysmetria (optic ataxia or misreaching), and simultanagnosia (visual disorienta¬ tion)—were fully present in four cases and only partially present in one (naming and pointing were too severe¬ ly disordered to prove simultanagno¬ sia). The syndrome was incomplete in the early stages (cases 2, 3, and 5) but developed into the complete clinical picture over a course of several years. When features of Balint's syndrome are present, a bilateral parieto-occipi¬ tal pathological condition is implied; the progression into a full syndrome may indicate additional involvement of frontal connections. Computed tomography and MRI revealed a degenerative process that appeared more prominent in the pos¬ terior cerebral hemispheres in three of the patients. There was no evidence of vascular, neoplastic, or inflamma¬ tory disease. The EEGs of all patients showed diffuse theta activity without focal slowing or epileptiform dis¬ charge, patterns that resemble those reported in the midstages of both Pick's and Alzheimer's disease.6·7 The neuropsychological test results of all patients who could be tested showed a Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY-DAL-11762 User on 05/18/2015 marked discrepancy between PIQ and VIQ scales, probably reflecting the sensitivity of the PIQ subtests to visual dysfunction. The findings in these patients fit current definitions of dementia.8·9 The constellation of findings suggests dis¬ turbance of association cortex or con¬ nections, with sparing of the primary sensory and motor pathways. The ear¬ ly clinical picture suggests that the disorder initially involved occipital and parietal association cortices, par¬ ticularly Brodmann areas 18 and 19. Later findings suggest anterior spread to involve the angular gyrus or its connections bilaterally. Table 2 lists the major clinical features noted in these patients. The possibility that the visual symptoms presented by these patients could be the result of a disconnection disorder deserves consideration. Most reports of alexia,10 visual agnosia,11 prosopagnosia,4 environmental agno¬ sia,1 and Balint's syndrome2'4 describe structural defects that effectively dis¬ connect the intact primary visual cor¬ tical areas from various association cortices. Numerous brain-imaging studies in these patients revealed no such structural defects. Demyeiin¬ ating disorders, such as multiple scle¬ rosis or Schilder's disease, can produce visual symptoms; again, MRI scans in these patients revealed no evidence of demyelination. On the basis of these observations, degenera¬ tion primarily affecting posterior association cortex appears most prob¬ able. In the proposed division between cortical and subcortical dementia syn¬ dromes,9 this disorder presents with predominantly higher-function ab¬ normalities that appear to originate almost exclusively from the posterior association cortex. A descriptive term, posterior cortical atrophy, is suggest¬ ed to identify the disorder until more definitive causative data become available. Several causative considerations can be suggested. In that the disorder begins as a progressive derangement of the association cortex, it resembles Alzheimer's disease. Differences from the typical clinical features of Alz¬ heimer's disease12 are obvious, howev¬ er. Memory and personal insight are relatively well retained in these patients until late in the course, while visual agnosia, alexia, and acalculia are severe at early stages. Even if the neuropathologic features of Alzheim¬ er's disease are eventually demon¬ strated, the early clinical findings are strikingly atypical. Nonetheless, Alz¬ heimer's disease is said to show con¬ siderable variation in the initial pre¬ sentation and these cases may well represent an atypical Alzheimer dis¬ ease clinical pattern.13 A degenerative disorder with lobar predilection, such as Pick's disease, offers a tempting alternative origin. Pick's disease has long been described as primarily affecting anterior struc¬ tures, particularly frontal and anteri¬ or temporal cortex.9·1415 The patients in this report also appear to show a lobar dysfunction, but one that pri¬ marily affects occipital and posterior parietal cortex. Could these cases rep¬ resent a posteriorly localized variant of Pick's disease? The answer must await neuropathologic studies. The recent reports of progressive aphasia1618 deserve note. These cases are also awaiting histological verifica¬ tion but are suspected to represent variations in the onset of traditional dementing disorders. Alterations in the early clinical picture of degenera¬ tive dementia are well recognized, apparently dependent on the site of the initial cerebral involvement.19 The syndrome described here may well represent an aberrant onset of a more common disorder. Table 3 lists clinical findings that appear to distinguish the syndrome reported here from the two currently recognized types of cor¬ tical dementia. Among other causative possibilities considered in these cases, focal vascu¬ lar disease deserves strong consider¬ ation. Most reported cases of Balint's syndrome have been based on multi¬ ple vascular infarcts and the promi¬ nence of transcortical sensory apha¬ sia, and the Gerstmann syndrome in these cases suggests a posterior bor¬ der-zone abnormality. However, no evidence of a cerebrovascular disorder was uncovered by CT, MRI, or angio¬ graphie studies. One remote causative possibility was suggested by the history that two of these patients had received exten¬ sive (seven to eight years) tetracycline therapy and a third had bronchial problems treated with a variety of antibiotics over a period of years. The other two did not receive such drugs, however, and, at most, any relation¬ ship between antibiotic therapy and this syndrome must be considered tenuous. The possibility that each of these individuals suffers from the same dis¬ order appears high. The findings and course, particularly the presence of a combination of rare clinical disorders such as Balint's, Gerstmann's, and transcortical sensory aphasia syn¬ dromes, appear unique. These cases are sufficiently similar to each other and the findings are sufficiently dif¬ ferent from those typical for either Alzheimer's or Pick's disease to war¬ rant classing them separately until definitive pathologic information be¬ comes available. References 1. Landis T, Cummings JL, Benson DF, et al: Loss of topographic familiarity: An encironmental agnosia. Arch Neurol 1986;43:132-136. 2. Balint R: Die seelenlahmung des 'Schauens.' Monatschr Psychiatr Neurol 1909;1:25-51. 3. H\l=e'\caenH, Albert ML: Human Neuropsychology. New York, John Wiley & Sons Inc, 1978. 4. Damasio A: Disorders of complex visual processing: Agnosias, achromatopsia, Balint's syndrome and related difficulties of orientation and construction, in Mesulam M-M (ed): Principles of Behavioral Neurology. Philadelphia, FA Davis Co Publishers, 1985, pp 259-288. 5. H\l=e'\caenH, de Ajuriaguerra J, David M, et al: Paralysie psychique du regard de Balint au cours de l'evolution d'une leuco-encephalite type Balo. Rev Neurol 1950;83:81-104. 6. Gordon EB, Sim M: The EEG in presenile dementia. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1967; 30:285-291. 7. Harner RN: EEG evaluation in the patient with dementia, in Benson DF, Blumer D (eds): Psychiatric Aspects of Neurologic Disease. New York, Grune & Stratton, 1975, pp 63-82. 8. American Psychiatric Association: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, ed 3. Washington, DC, American Psychiatric Association, 1980, pp 205-224. 9. Cummings JL, Benson DF: Dementia: A Clinical Approach. Stoneham, Mass, Butterworth Publishers Inc, 1983. 10. Benson DF: Alexia, in Frederiks JAM (ed): Handbook of Clinical Neurology, ed 2. Amsterdam, Elsevier Science Publishers, 1985, vol 45: Clinical Neuropsychology, pp 433-455. 11. Rubens AB: Agnosia, in Heilman KM, Valenstein E (eds): Clinical Neuropsychology. New York, Oxford University Press Inc, 1979, pp 233-267. 12. McKhann G, Drachman D, Folstein M, et al: Clinical diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease: Report of the NINCDS-ADRDA Work Group under the auspices of Department of Health and Human Services Task Force on Alzheimer's Dis- Neurology 1984;34:939-944. 13. Mayer-Gross W: Posterior involvement by ease. 14. Corsellis JAN: Aging and the dementias, in Blackwood W, Corsellis JAN (eds): Greenfield's Neuropathology. Chicago, Year Book Medical Publishers Inc, 1976, pp 796-848. 15. Malamud N, Hirano A: Atlas ofNeuropathology, ed 2. Berkeley, Calif, University of California Press, 1974. 16. Chawluk JB, Mesulam M-M, Hurtig H, et al: Slowly progressive aphasia without generalized dementia: Studies with positron emission tomography. Ann Neurol 1986;19:68-74. 17. Kirshner HS, Webb WG, Kelly MP, et al: Language disturbance: An initial symptom of cortical degenerations and dementia. Arch Neurol 1984;41:491-496. 18. Mesulam M-M: Slowly progressive aphasia without generalized dementia. Ann Neurol 1982;11:592-598. 19. Morris JC, Monroe C, Banker BQ, et al: Hereditary dysphasic dementia in the Pick- Alzheimer spectrum. Ann Neurol 1984;16:455\x=req-\ 466. DAT. Proc R Soc Med 1937;38:1443-1454. Downloaded From: http://archneur.jamanetwork.com/ by a DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY-DAL-11762 User on 05/18/2015
0
Puede agregar este documento a su colección de estudio (s)
Iniciar sesión Disponible sólo para usuarios autorizadosPuede agregar este documento a su lista guardada
Iniciar sesión Disponible sólo para usuarios autorizados(Para quejas, use otra forma )