Subido por joaquindios13

Dracula essay Joaquín Dios

Anuncio
Discuss the representation of the ‘masculine’ and the ‘feminine’ in
Dracula.
Bram Stoker was born in Ireland in 1847. He attended Trinity College
in Dublin to study mathematics before starting his long career as actor
Sir Henry Irving's assistant in the 1870s. In addition, Stoker started a
second career as a writer, publishing his first book, The Primrose
Path, in 1875. His most well-known work, Dracula, was published in
1897, but he passed away before the fictional vampire would become
widely known. (Bram Stoker, 2023). He lived in the Victorian Era,
which is an extremely important fact to take into consideration for
the understanding of this essay. This epoch “spans the 63 years of
Queen Victoria´s reign over Great Britain and Ireland from 1837 until
her death in 1901.” (English Heritage, n.d.). In such period of time,
the society had constructed certain conventions that influenced
people´s behaviour. The role of the man and the woman was
delimited by these conventions. Moreover, the area in which each
gender used to fulfil its role was denominated by theorists as
“sphere”; there was the “public sphere” and the “private sphere”.
Marie Bland develops this concept in her essay entitled Gender and
Gender Identity in Victorian Fiction “The idea of ‘separate spheres’
implied that men and women in Victorian England – and in the
Victorian Age in general – had different work places, skill sets and
characteristics in comparison to one another. Each gender therefore
had its own sphere: women “dominated” the private, emotional
domestic sphere, whereas men were dominant in the public sphere.”
Another concept that I regard highly important is called “the concept
of doubleness” (Bland, M. p.5). This concept states that it is possible
“to find doubles in identity: female characters with a hidden male
identity and male characters with a hidden female identity.” (p.5)
In this essay, I will analyze the portrayal of typical Victorian
conventions of masculinity and femininity in Dracula. I will use
relevant interpretations of the story to understand the representation
of these characteristics within the characters. I also will mention how
the author plays around with the standards of the epoch by using the
concept of doubleness.
Regarding Dracula´s characters, it is complex to fully identify the
Victorian conventions. From my point of view the masculine and
feminine aspects are somehow blurry in certain characters; that is
when the concept of doubleness helps us to understand its full
significance. Natalie Diane Cottrill states in her thesis the Monstrosity
of Gender Inversion in Bram stoker’s Dracula (2020) that “Many characters
take on multiple roles at once, and some exist in the space between
gender identity altogether” (p.8). In chapter 18 Mina is depicted by
Van Helsing as “that wonderful Madam Mina! She has man's brain, a
brain that a man should have were he much gifted, and a woman's
heart” (Stoker, B. p.175). This description portrays exactly what
Cottrill is commenting; the characteristics of both genders contained
in one character. Another example of this concept is portrayed in
chapter 25; this occurs after Mina´s encounter with Dracula. She
realizes that her “soul is at stake” (p.245) and mentions that “when
you shall be convinced that I am so changed that it is better that I
died that may live. When I am thus dead in the flesh, then you will,
without a moment´s delay, drive a stake through me and cut off my
head.” (p.246). The heroic stance that Mina adopts through this tough
moment is not at all aligned with the female Victorian conventions in
where a woman, facing a similar situation, would typically respond
with despair and fear.
The same happens with Jonathan who adopts the “submissive role”
as Cottrill mentions (p.14). In chapter 3, Jonathan realizes he is
trapped in Count Dracula´s castle “When I found that I was a
prisoner a sort of wild feeling came over me…I am, I know, either
being deceived, like a baby, by my own fears, or else I am in desperate
straits.” (Stoker, B. p.23). The description of his feelings clearly
portrays an inability to react when confronted with a challenging
situation. This behaviour was not in line with the societal expectations
for men during that era, given the prevailing belief in men’s
dominance in the public sphere, as discussed in Bland's previous
work. Another example of this frightening feeling and submissive
posture that Jonathan experiences is presented in the encounter with
the Count´s imprisoned vampires. In this opportunity, Jonathan
confronted a mixed sensation between fear and excitation “I lay quiet,
looking out under my eyelashes in agony of delightful anticipation…I
was afraid to raise my eyelids, but looked out and saw perfectly under
the lashes…I could feel the soft, shivering touch of the lips touching
and pausing there. I closed my eyes in a languorous ecstasy and
waited—waited with beating heart” (p.30-31). It is notably obvious
that Harker does not want to interfere in the situation, he just remains
motionless and waits for things to happen.
Another character that portrays blurry gender characteristics is Count
Dracula. When he encounters Mina in her room, he cuts himself,
creating an open wound. Subsequently, he forces Mina to draw the
blood from this wound by sucking on it. The narrative conveys this
scene by commenting that “the attitude of the two had a terrible
resemblance to a child forcing a kitten´s nose into a saucer of milk to
compel it to drink.” (210). This situation can be interpreted in several
ways. Cottrill (2020) provides a magnificent multiple interpretation
for this scene. She explains that Dracula is in midst of the binary
concept of gender because he adopts three roles at the same moment:
the phallic conqueror, the nursing mother and the menstruating maid
(p.20). This interpretation presents Dracula as a sexual figure who
obliges Mina to engage in oral acts of intimacy; as a mother who
embraces his child by giving her “milk” (as the kitten´s comparison
explains); and as a bleeding woman that through her “vagina” (open
wound) provides blood. Although I do not agree with some of the
readings, I consider that they are extremely interesting and creative
ones. The most important fact, whether you agree or not with the
interpretations, is that without doubt Dracula´s gender characteristics
are not firmly distinguishable. His gender characteristics have no
place in a binary sexual classification; his doubleness is highly visible
through the exemplifications provided.
In conclusion Bram Stoker provides characters that present blurry
characteristics regarding the social standards of the epoch. He plays
with Mina´s behaviour, highlighting her heroic willingness and her
cunning strategies; He emphasizes the trans generic role of Dracula
through his sexual encounters and the reaction of his victims; and he
sets Jonathan in a cowardice position, lacking masculinity aspects for
a man of the Victorian period.
Bibliography
Biography. (2023, March 7). Bram Stoker.
https://www.biography.com/authors-writers/bram-stoker
English Heritage. (n.d.). Victorians. https://www.englishheritage.org.uk/learn/story-ofengland/victorian/#:~:text=The%20Victorian%20era%20spans%2
0the,its%20empire%20across%20the%20globe.
Bland, M. (2019). Gender and Gender Identity in Victorian Fiction How
Mary Elizabeth Braddon’s “Lady Audley’s Secret” Challenges Victorian Social
Constructs and Beliefs Regarding Gender. Ghent University.
Cottrill, N. D. (2020). “Life Swarms with Innocent Monsters”: the Monstrosity
of Gender Inversion in Bram stoker’s Dracula. Montclair State University.
Stoker, B. (1897). Dracula. New York Grosset and Dunlap Publishers
Descargar