rtículo - Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos
Anuncio
A rtículo
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional
al artículo 29. Perspectiva del estado de excepción
en México
Carlos Brokmann Haro*
5ESUMEN/DVUHFLHQWHVUHIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVPRGL
¿FDURQHOWH[WRGHODUWtFXORGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
0H[LFDQRV&3(80TXHKDEtDSHUVLVWLGRYLUWXDOPHQWHLQDOWHUDGRGHVGH/DV
UHIRUPDVSUHFLVDQ\GHOLPLWDQHODOFDQFHGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQ0p[LFR
DEULHQGRXQGHEDWHDFHUFDGHODFUHDFLyQGHXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ6HGLVFXWHOD
H[SHULHQFLDKLVWyULFD\ODVSRVLEOHVLPSOLFDFLRQHVTXHWLHQHHVWHKHFKRSDUDORVGH
UHFKRVKXPDQRV
ABSTRACT7KHUHFHQWFRQVWLWXWLRQDOUHIRUPVRQKXPDQULJKWVPRGL¿HGDUWLFOHRI
the CPEUM, which subsisted virtually unaltered since 1857. This reform limits and
describes with precision a possible suspension of guarantees in Mexico, opening up
a debate about the creation of a state of exception. The article discusses past historical experiences and the implications that this would have on human rights.
6UMARIO,6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ,,$QWHFHGHQWHV
KLVWyULFRVGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQ0p[LFR,,,/DVUHIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV
HQGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV,95HWRV\EDODQFHGHODUHIRUPDDODUWtFXOR9&RQ
FOXVLRQHV9,$QH[RV
I. Suspensión de garantías y estado de excepción
(OWpUPLQR³HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ´IXHXQFRQFHSWRSURSXHVWRSRU&DUO6FKPLWW\
GHQWURGHVXWHRUtDMXUtGLFDUHVXOWDVHPHMDQWHDOHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDGHOD
WUDGLFLyQDQJORVDMRQD/DGLIHUHQFLDSULQFLSDOUDGLFDHQODKDELOLGDGGHOVREHUDQR
SDUDLUPiVDOOiGHOHVWDGRGHGHUHFKRrule of lawHQLQJOpVHQQRPEUHGHOELHQ
FRP~QRGHOLQWHUpVS~EOLFR(OHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDSXHGHGH¿QLUVHFRPR
XQDGHFODUDFLyQR¿FLDOGHOJRELHUQRTXHVXVSHQGHROLPLWDFLHUWDVIXQFLRQHVGH
ORVWUHVSRGHUHVGHXQJRELHUQRGHPRFUiWLFROLEHUDOREOLJDRFRQPLQDDODFLX
GDGDQtDDDGHFXDUVXFRQGXFWDDXQSDWUyQDOWHUQRRELHQLPSOHPHQWDSODQHV
GHHPHUJHQFLDSRUSDUWHGHFLHUWDVLQVWLWXFLRQHV(OFRP~QGHQRPLQDGRUHVTXH
ODGHFODUDFLyQLPSOLFDODVXVSHQVLyQGHFLHUWDVJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVRGHDOJX
,QYHVWLJDGRUGHO&HQWUR1DFLRQDOGH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRVGHOD&1'+
&DUO6FKPLWWLa dictadura. Desde los comienzos del pensamiento moderno de la soberanía hasta
la lucha de clases proletaria0DGULG(GLFLRQHVGHOD5HYLVWDGH2FFLGHQWHSS%LEOLRWHFD
GH3ROtWLFD\6RFLRORJtD6HULH0LQRU
[ 71 ]
Carlos Brokmann Haro
72
QRVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVDXQFXDQGRHVWpQSURWHJLGRVSRUHORUGHQFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
(VWHWLSRGHGHFODUDFLRQHVWLHQHQOXJDUJHQHUDOPHQWHHQSHULRGRVGHGHFODUDFLyQ
GHJXHUUDFRQÀLFWRVVRFLDOHVRGHVDVWUHVQDWXUDOHV(VXQKHFKRSDUDGyMLFR
TXHPLHQWUDVTXHKDFH\DPXFKRVDxRV&DUO6FKPLWWGH¿QLyDOVREHUDQRFRPR
³TXLHQGHFLGHDFHUFDGHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ´WRGDYtDQRVHGHVDUUROOHXQDWHRUtD
DFHUFDGHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQGHQWURGHOGHUHFKRS~EOLFR/DRPLVLyQSXGLHUD
GHEHUVHDOSULQFLSLRGHOnecessitas non habetODQHFHVLGDGQRWLHQHOH\SHUR
SDUD$JDPEHQSDUHFHWHQHUPD\RUUHODFLyQFRQHOKHFKRGHTXHHOIHQyPHQRVH
HQFXHQWUDDPHGLRFDPLQRHQWUHODSROtWLFD\HOGHUHFKR
(OSRGHUGHOVREHUDQRGHUHGXFLUDVXVV~EGLWRVRFLXGDGDQRVDOQLYHOGHhomo
sacerDOGHVSRMDUORVGHWRGRVVXVGHUHFKRVSROtWLFRV\DVtSRGHURUGHQDUVX
PXHUWHLPSXQHPHQWHHVHOSULQFLSDOHOHPHQWRTXHVXEUD\DHOFDUiFWHUYLROHQWR
GHOOLEHUDOLVPR$OGHVWDFDUHVWHFDUiFWHU\VDFDUDUHOXFLUODYLROHQFLDFRPRPD
WHULDGHDQiOLVLV*LRUJLR$JDPEHQUHVDOWDODLPSRUWDQFLDGHHVWXGLDUORVHVSDFLRV
³GHH[FHSFLyQ´HQORVFXDOHVORVFLXGDGDQRVVRQUHGXFLGRVDODQXGDYLGD/RV
FDPSRVGHFRQFHQWUDFLyQQD]LVKDQVLGRFRQVLGHUDGRVODH[SUHVLyQSRUDQWR
QRPDVLDGHHVWDV]RQDVGHH[FHSFLyQSHURHQHOPXQGRFRQWHPSRUiQHRH[LV
WHQPXFKRVRWURVHMHPSORVDQiORJRV(O¿OyVRIRLWDOLDQROOHYDHVWDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQ
PiVDOOiGHORVHVSDFLRV\WLHPSRVHVSHFt¿FRVSURSRQLHQGRTXHHVSUHFLVD
PHQWHHQODH[FHSFLyQTXHVHFRQVWLWX\HQHOGHUHFKR\ODVOH\HV/DSUHPLVDOL
EHUDODFHUFDGHO(VWDGRQHXWUDOVHGHELOLWDWRGDYtDPiVVLFRQVLGHUDPRVTXHOD
SROtWLFDODYLROHQFLD\HOGHUHFKRQRVRQUHLQRVVHSDUDGRVVLQRFRQWLQXRV
$JDPEHQFLWDD)RQWDQDFXDQGRGH¿QHDOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQFRPR³XQSXQWR
GHGHVHTXLOLEULRHQWUHHOGHUHFKRS~EOLFR\HOKHFKRSROtWLFR´6LWXDGRHQXQD
IURQWHUDGHFDUiFWHUQHFHVDULDPHQWHDPELJXRHO¿OyVRIRLWDOLDQRFRQVLGHUDVX
DQiOLVLVWRGDYtDPiVSHUWLQHQWH\REYLRTXHQLQJXQDSRVLFLyQSXHGHSRUVtVROD
GDUFXHQWDGHWRGDVXFRPSOHMLGDG(QSRFDVSDODEUDVVHWUDWDGHXQDVHULHGH
PHGLGDVMXUtGLFDVTXHQRSXHGHQVHUHQWHQGLGDVHQWpUPLQRVHVWULFWDPHQWHOH
JDOHV3DUD$JDPEHQ³HOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQDSDUHFHFRPRODIRUPDMXUtGLFD
GHDTXHOORTXHQRSXHGHWHQHUIRUPDMXUtGLFD´\TXHSRUWUDWDUVHGHODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHODOH\HQVtPLVPDHVXQDWHRUtDTXHGHEHH[SOLFDUFyPRVHDEDQGRQDDORV
VHUHVYLYRVDODOH\/DLQGDJDFLyQDFHUFDGHOSUREOHPDGHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ
\VXFRUUHODFLyQFRQHOOLEHUDOLVPRFRPRIRUPDGHJRELHUQRWLHQHTXHKDFHUUH
IHUHQFLDQHFHVDULDPHQWHD0LFKHO)RXFDXOW3ODQWHDQGRODVSUHJXQWDVGHOFyPR
\SRUTXpVHJRELHUQDQODVSHUVRQDVDVtPLVPDV\DODVGHPiVGH¿QLyODJREHU
QDELOLGDGFRPR³ODFRQGXFWDGHODFRQGXFWD´)RXFDXOWIXHTXL]iVHOSULPHURHQ
GLVWLQJXLUHQHOOLEHUDOLVPRXQVHVJRGHOLQWHUpVSRUODVREHUDQtDWHUULWRULDOKDFLD
ORTXHGHQRPLQyHOELRSRGHUHQODSREODFLyQ\VXJRELHUQR(QRWUDVSDODEUDV
HQHOFyPRUHJODPHQWDUODYLGDFRPRREMHWLYRGHO(VWDGROLEHUDOPRGHUQR\\D
QRHQODDPHQD]DGHODPXHUWHFRPRPHFDQLVPRGHFRQWURO$WUDYpVGHORVVHU
YLFLRVGHO(VWDGRVHSUHWHQGHORJUDUODIHOLFLGDGGHODFLXGDGDQtDORTXHLPSOLFD
HOVXUJLPLHQWRGHXQDUDFLRQDOLGDGGLIHUHQWHHQODFXDOODOLEHUWDGDGTXLHUHGRV
6HDQ.$QGHUVRQ\6WHSKHQ6ORDQHistorical Dictionary of Terrorism/DQKDP7KH6FDUHFURZ
3UHVVSS+LVWRULFDO'LFWLRQDULHVRI:DU5HYROXWLRQDQG&LYLO8QUHVW
*LRUJLR$JDPEHQState of Exception&KLFDJR8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR3UHVVSS
(PLO\*LOEHUW³/LEHUDOLVP´HQInternational Encyclopedia of Human GeographyÈPVWHUGDP(OVH
YLHU6FLHQFHYROS
*$JDPEHQop. cit.supraQRWDSS
(*LOEHUWop. citsupraQRWDS
:LOOLDP:%XUNH:KLWH³+XPDQ5LJKWVDQG1DWLRQDO6HFXULW\7KH6WUDWHJLF&RUUHODWLRQ´HQHarvard Human Rights Journal&DPEULGJH0DVVYROSULPDYHUDGHSS
73
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
GLPHQVLRQHVFRPRFRQGLFLyQ\UHVXOWDGRGHODUHVSRQVDELOLGDGPXWXDGHO(V
WDGR\GHOLQGLYLGXR)RXFDXOWLGHQWL¿FyGRVHVWUDWHJLDVSDUDODPRYLOL]DFLyQGH
ODVWHFQRORJtDVOLEHUDOHV/DSULPHUD\DPHQFLRQDGDHVODSURWHFFLyQGHODFLX
GDGDQtD/DVHJXQGDVHUH¿HUHGLUHFWDPHQWHDOWHPDGHQXHVWURDUWtFXOR\WUDWD
GHOD³KLJLHQHUDFLDO´PHGLDQWHODFXDOODSREODFLyQHVHYDOXDGD\JREHUQDGDGH
DFXHUGRFRQODFDSDFLGDGTXHSHUFLEHHO(VWDGRSDUDSRGHUVHUDXWyQRPD
GHPDQHUDUHVSRQVDEOH(OSRGHUGLVFLSOLQDULRVHHMHUFHWDQWRSDUDUHIRUPDUD
TXLHQHVQRVHDMXVWDQDODQRUPDFRPRSDUDQHXWUDOL]DUDDTXHOORVTXHVHFRQ
VLGHUDTXHQRSXHGHQVHULQFRUSRUDGRV/DVPDQHUDVSDUDFRQVHJXLUHVWDKLJLHQH
VRFLDOLQFOX\HQORVFHUFRVORVWRTXHVGHTXHGD\ORVSXHVWRVGHUHYLVLyQFRQVL
JXLHQGRODHUHFFLyQGHEDUUHUDVItVLFDV\FXOWXUDOHVTXHGLYLGHQDODSREODFLyQ\
WLHQGHQDODIRUPDFLyQGHghettos/DOXFKDFRQWUDHOWHUURULVPRODGHOLQFXHQFLD
RUJDQL]DGDRHOQDUFRWUi¿FRVHSXHGHQFRQYHUWLUGHHVWDIRUPDHQXQDPDQLIHV
WDFLyQGHODELRSROtWLFD\GHOFRQWURODXWRULWDULRGHO(VWDGRHQRSLQLyQGH)RXFDXOW
(QHOVLVWHPDMXUtGLFRHVWDGRXQLGHQVHVHKDSURSXHVWRODWHRUtDGHTXHHO3UH
VLGHQWHFRQWURODHOUDPR(MHFXWLYRSRUFRPSOHWR(VWDSRVLFLyQVHFRQRFHFRPR
ODWHRUtDXQLWDULDGHO(MHFXWLYR\VHEDVDMXUtGLFDPHQWHHQODLQWHUSUHWDFLyQGHO
DUWtFXORVHJXQGRGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRVGH$PpULFDTXHOH
FRQFHGHHO³3RGHU(MHFXWLYR´DHVWHIXQFLRQDULR(OSULQFLSLRJHQHUDOHVDFHSWD
GRSRUORVMXULVWDVSHURVXVDOFDQFHV\IXHU]DHVPDWHULDGHGHEDWHGRFWULQDULR
H[LVWLHQGRSRVLFLRQHVTXHGH¿HQGHQXQFDUiFWHUXQLWDULRIXHUWH\RWURVPiVGL
IXVR\GpELO(QODSUiFWLFDTXLHQHVSRVWXODQXQXQLWDULVPRIXHUWHFRQVLGHUDQTXH
HOFRQWUROGHO&RQJUHVRVLJQL¿FDXQDFODUDLQWHUIHUHQFLD\TXHHO(MHFXWLYRSXHGH
\HQFLHUWDVRFDVLRQHVGHEHJREHUQDUPHGLDQWHGHFUHWRVTXHVDOWHQHVWDVOLPL
WDFLRQHV(QODSRVWXUDFRQWUDULDVHHQFXHQWUDQHVWDGRVFRPR7H[DVHQORV
FXDOHVFLHUWRVFDUJRVGHO(MHFXWLYRVRQQRPEUDGRVVLQFRQWURODOJXQRSRUSDUWH
GHODFDEH]DGHO(MHFXWLYRORFDO
(QODLQWURGXFFLyQDVXFRQIHUHQFLDGHDFHUFDGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJD
UDQWtDVHQ0p[LFR0DULRGHOD&XHYDFRQVLGHUyXQDDXWpQWLFDWUDJHGLDMXUtGLFD
ODJUDGXDOFRPSOLFDFLyQGHXQWHPDTXHFRQVLGHUDVHQFLOORHQRULJHQSHURDIHF
WDGRSURIXQGDPHQWHSRUORVDFRQWHFLPLHQWRVKLVWyULFRV6LJXLHQGRHOUD]RQD
PLHQWRGH7HQD5DPtUH]RSLQDTXHODVFRQWUDGLFFLRQHVGHODUWtFXORHPDQDURQ
GHVGHHQODFRQWUDSRVLFLyQHQWUHORVLGHDOHVGHOLEHUWDGSROtWLFDUHSUHVHQ
WDGRVSRUODGLYLVLyQGHSRGHUHV\HOELQRPLRIRUPDGRSRUODUHDOLGDG\ODQHFH
VLGDG(VFULELHQGRMXVWRDQWHVGHO¿QGHOD6HJXQGD*XHUUD0XQGLDO'HOD&XHYD
DUJXPHQWyTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVTXHD~QQRHUDOHYDQWDGDUHSUHVHQ
WyHODSODVWDPLHQWRGHORVLGHDOHVSRUODVQHFHVLGDGHVGLFWDGDVSRUODUHDOLGDG
(QODSXEOLFDFLyQTXHFRPSLODWDQWRODLQWHUYHQFLyQDQWHVPHQFLRQDGDFRPROD
VX\DSURSLD-RVp$JXLODU\0D\DDSXQWDTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHVXQD
JDUDQWtDTXHVXUJHHQHOGHUHFKRURPDQRTXHLQWHUUXPSHODYLJHQFLDGHODVJD
UDQWtDVSDUDTXHXQVXMHWR²HO(MHFXWLYR²KDJDIUHQWHDHVDDQRPDOtD\DTXH
LPSOLFDQXQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ+D\DXWRUHVTXHSLHQVDQ
TXHQRVHLQWHUUXPSHODYLJHQFLDVLQRTXHVyORVHGHMDQGHDSOLFDU(OSURFHGL
PLHQWRRSHUDSDUDTXHHO/HJLVODWLYRGHOHJXHIDFXOWDGHVDO(MHFXWLYRSDUDKDFHU
Carlos Brokmann Haro
74
IUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSRUORTXHVHVXVSHQGHQVyORODVTXHREVWDFXOLFHQODVROX
FLyQGHOFRQÀLFWR(QVXRSLQLyQOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHHQIDWL]DEDTXHVHSR
GtDQVXVSHQGHUWRGDVH[FHSWRHOGHUHFKRDODYLGD(QHVWHVHQWLGRHV~WLOUH
FRUGDUTXHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRVGH¿QHTXHORV
GHUHFKRVTXHSURWHJHQODLQWHJULGDGSHUVRQDOHOQRPEUHODYLGDODQDFLRQDOLGDG
\ODSURKLELFLyQGHODHVFODYLWXGQRSXHGHQVHUVXVSHQGLGDV2WURVRUJDQLVPRV
LQWHUQDFLRQDOHVGLFHQTXHWDPSRFRHOHabeas CorpusHVVXVFHSWLEOHGHVXVSHQ
VLyQSHURHVWHDVXQWRQRIXHGLVFXWLGRHQODREUDTXHUHFRSLOyODVSRVLFLRQHVGH
DPERVMXULVWDV\HVXQWHPDGHiOJLGRVGHEDWHV/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
SXHGHOLPLWDUVHDXQDSDUWHGHOWHUULWRULRSHURQRSXHGHGHVWLQDUVHDSHUVRQDR
SHUVRQDVHQORSDUWLFXODU$VLPLVPR$JXLODU\0D\DVHxDODTXHSDUDODVXVSHQ
VLyQGHEHKDEHUXQDUHODFLyQGHPHGLRDItQTXHVHGHEHUHVSHWDUODDIHFWDFLyQ
GHOLQGLYLGXR\HOELHQS~EOLFRVRSHVDQGRDPERVREMHWLYRV\SRU~OWLPRGHEH
VHUSURSRUFLRQDODORV¿QHVTXHVHSHUVLJXHQ
&RQEDVHHQVXUHFRUULGRSRUODKLVWRULDGHOGHUHFKR*XUUtD/DFURL[D¿UPD
TXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQWHQGLGDJHQpULFDPHQWHKDH[LVWLGR³HQFDVL
WRGRVORVSXHEORV\FDVLWRGDVODVpSRFDVGHODKXPDQLGDG´3DUDpOVHWUDWDGH
ORTXH6FKPLWW\$JDPEHQGHVFULEHQFRPRXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQODVXVSHQ
VLyQWHPSRUDOGHFLHUWRVGHUHFKRVFRQHO¿QGHSHUPLWLUDO(VWDGRRODDXWRULGDG
HQIUHQWDUXQDVLWXDFLyQGHHPHUJHQFLDTXHUHTXLHUDGHPHGLGDVH[WUDRUGLQDULDV
$SDUWLUGHOGHUHFKRURPDQRVHIXHURQFRQVLGHUDQGRGLYHUVDVPHGLGDVSDUDDSOL
FDUHVWDPHGLGDVLHQGRFODURTXHVyORSXHGHFRQVLGHUDUVHFRPRWDOXQDYH]
TXHH[LVWDXQDVLWXDFLyQGH³LPSHULRGHODOH\´³rule of law´R³(VWDGRGHGHUH
FKR´PLVPRTXHTXHGDHQVXVSHQVR'HHVWDIRUPDHQODWUDGLFLyQDQJORVDMRQD
VHGH¿QHTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVDIHFWDGLUHFWDPHQWHDOHabeas Corpus
/RVGHEDWHVUHFLHQWHVDFHUFDGHODDIHFWDFLyQGHHVWHSULQFLSLRGHELGRDODVPH
GLGDVH[WUDRUGLQDULDVTXHVHKDQFRQYHUWLGRHQSHUPDQHQWHVDOSDUHFHUWUDV
ORVDWHQWDGRVGHOGHVHSWLHPEUHUHVDOWDQODLPSRUWDQFLDGHOFRQWURO\ORVFRQ
WUDSHVRVSDUDHMHUFHUHVWH3RGHU(MHFXWLYR/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVTXH
FUHDXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQKDVLGRUDVWUHDGDSRU$JDPEHQKDVWDHOFRQFHSWR
MXUtGLFRURPDQRGHOjustitium(UDLQYRFDGRHQFDVRVGHSHOLJURSDUDHO(VWDGR
JHQHUDOPHQWHDUDt]GHODPXHUWHGHOVREHUDQRRELHQGHELGRDSRVLEOHVDWDTXHV
PLOLWDUHVHLQYDVLRQHV(QHOSULPHUFDVRXQLQWHUUHJQRinterregnumHUDFRQ
VLGHUDGRXQSHULRGRGLItFLOHQHOFXDOORVGHUHFKRVFLXGDGDQRVGHEtDQVHUVXV
SHQGLGRVWHPSRUDOPHQWHKDVWDTXHXQVXFHVRUFODURDOFDQ]DUDHOSRGHU\SRU
FRQVLJXLHQWHSXGLHUDHVWDEOHFHUXQDQXHYD³QRUPDOLGDG´DWUDYpVGHORUGHQ
S~EOLFR(QHOFDVRGHDWDTXHVD5RPDSDUD$JDPEHQDOSDUHFHUQRIXHODDPH
(QHVWHDVSHFWRORVKLVWRULDGRUHVGHOGHUHFKROLEUDURQXQDIHUR]EDWDOODDOGLVFXWLUORVDOFDQFHVGH
OD/H\GHSURPXOJDGDSRUHOSUHVLGHQWH%HQLWR-XiUH]\TXHIXHXWLOL]DGDFRPREDVHMXUtGLFDSDUD
HOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQTXHLPSHUyGXUDQWHODUJRVDxRV%DVDGDHQODHPHUJHQFLDTXHKDEtDQSURYRFD
GROD*XHUUDGH5HIRUPD\SRVWHULRUPHQWHOD,QWHUYHQFLyQ)UDQFHVDDOJXQRVGHORVGHFUHWRVSURPXOJD
GRVSRUHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOHQHVWHSHULRGRIXHURQFRQVLGHUDGRVGLFWDWRULDOHVLQFOXVRSRUORVMXULVWDVPiV
EHQLJQRVFRQHVHUpJLPHQ'HOD&XHYD\*XUUtD/DFURL[FULWLFDQiFLGDPHQWHHOKHFKRGHTXHVHKD\D
ERUUDGRYLUWXDOPHQWHODVHSDUDFLyQGHSRGHUHV\VHxDODQTXHODVDWULEXFLRQHVTXHVHDUURJyODSUHVLGHQ
FLDVXSHUDEDQSRUPXFKRORVOtPLWHVGHOiustitiumURPDQR
-RVp$JXLODU\0D\D³/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV´HQ0DULRGHOD&XHYD\-RVp$JXLODU\0D\DLa
suspensión de garantías y la vuelta a la normalidad0p[LFR81$0)DFXOWDGGH'HUHFKRSS
6HULH(VWXGLRV-XUtGLFRV
-RUJH*XUUtD/DFURL[³$QWHFHGHQWHVGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV´HQBoletín Mexicano de Derecho Comparado0p[LFRDxR;,Q~PVHQHURDJRVWRGHSS
²(VWDGRGHDODUPD
²(VWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ
²(VWDGRGHVLWLR
²(VWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLD
²(VWDGRGHJXHUUDROH\PDUFLDO
'HVGHXQSXQWRGHYLVWDFRQWHPSRUiQHRHQHOQLYHOLQWHUQDFLRQDO'HUHN*UH
JRU\KDSURSXHVWRTXHHOFDPSRGHFRQFHQWUDFLyQGHOD%DKtDGH*XDQWiQDPR
FRQVWLWX\HXQHMHPSORGHHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQGHQWURGHODGH¿QLFLyQGH$JDP
EHQ$UJXPHQWDTXH*XDQWiQDPRGHEHVHUYLVWRGHVGHXQDSHUVSHFWLYDLQWHU
QDFLRQDO\TXHQRVHWUDWDGHXQDVLWXDFLyQHQODFXDOHOGHUHFKRQRH[LVWDVLQR
TXHORTXHHVWiDXVHQWHHVODDSOLFDFLyQGHXQUpJLPHQGHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV
/DLPSOLFDFLyQGLUHFWDHVTXHVHWUDWDGHXQDDFWXDOL]DFLyQGHORVSULQFLSLRVFR
ORQLDOLVWDVTXHOOHYDQDOD³KLJLHQHUDFLDO´DWUDYpVGHSUiFWLFDVFRPRORVSHU¿OHV
UDFLDOHVUDFLDOSUR¿OLQJ9ROYLHQGRDOFDVRGH0p[LFRHODUWtFXORSXHGHVHU
DSOLFDGRHQFDVRGHH[WUHPRSHOLJURRQHFHVLGDGXQDVLWXDFLyQTXHSDUD%D]
GUHFKVHMXVWL¿FDGHHVWDPDQHUD³ODVXVSHQVLyQGHODVJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHV
VHMXVWL¿FDSRUODQHFHVLGDGSROtWLFDGHTXHORVyUJDQRVJXEHUQDWLYRVWHQJDQOL
EHUWDGGHDFFLyQSDUDSURFHGHUFRQUDSLGH]\HQHUJtDDPDQWHQHUHORUGHQS~
EOLFRPHGLDQWHODHOLPLQDFLyQUDGLFDOGHODVVLWXDFLRQHV\FLUFXQVWDQFLDVGHKHFKR
TXHDJUHGHQORVLQWHUHVHVVRFLDOHV´
II. Antecedentes históricos de la suspensión de garantías en México
*XUUtD/DFURL[UHDOL]yXQVHJXLPLHQWRGHORVGHFUHWRVTXHKDQDSOLFDGRODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVRVXHTXLYDOHQWHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQODKLVWRULDGH0p[LFR
1XHVWURSURSyVLWRQRHVUHDOL]DUXQDQiOLVLVKLVWyULFRSRUPHQRUL]DGRSRUORFXDO
GHVWDFDPRV~QLFDPHQWHVXVSULQFLSDOHVFRQFOXVLRQHV$SDUWLUGHVHVX
FHGLHURQXQDVHULHGHGHFUHWRVTXHSXHGHQVHUFRQVLGHUDGRVDQWHFHGHQWHVGL
UHFWRVGHODOHJLVODFLyQFRQWHPSRUiQHD\FX\RDEXVRSXHGHLOXVWUDUORVSHOLJURV
GHSURSRQHUORVDODOLJHUD$OJXQRVGHORVPiVFXHVWLRQDEOHV\SRUORPLVPRGH
*$JDPEHQop. cit.supraQRWDSS
Vid6.$QGHUVRQ\66ORDQop. citsupraQRWD
(*LOEHUWop. citsupraQRWDS
/XLV%D]GUHVFKGarantías constitucionales0p[LFR7ULOODVS
75
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
QD]DGLUHFWDVREUHHOWHUULWRULRVLQRORVHIHFWRVGHWDOHVQRWLFLDVVREUHHOSXHEOR
ORTXHOOHYDEDDOHVWDEOHFLPLHQWRGHOjustitium8QHMHPSORIXHODLQYDVLyQGH
$QtEDOTXHSURYRFyXQDDODUPD\GHVFRQFLHUWRWDOHVTXHIXHQHFHVDULRGDUD
4XLQWR)DELR0i[LPRSRGHUHVGLFWDWRULDOHVSDUDHQIUHQWDUODFULVLV$JDPEHQ
H[SOLFDTXHHOFRQFHSWRIXHDGTXLULHQGRJUDGXDOPHQWHHOVLJQL¿FDGRGHTXHVH
WUDWDEDGHXQDGHFLVLyQGHOVREHUDQRTXLHQPHGLDQWHHODVXPLUXQDDXWRULGDG
autoritasFRPSOHWDSURWHJtDDOSXHEORVLQQHFHVLGDGGHFRQVXOWDURDSR\DUVH
HQQLQJXQDRWUDLQVWLWXFLyQ'HHVWDIRUPDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVLPSOLFD
HOHVWDEOHFLPLHQWRGHXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQRHPHUJHQFLDGHSHQGLHQGRGH
ODWHUPLQRORJtDMXUtGLFDTXHSXHGHFODVL¿FDUVHHQGLYHUVRVHVWDGRV
Carlos Brokmann Haro
76
PD\RUUHOHYDQFLDSDUDSUHFLVDUVXVOtPLWHVFRQEDVHHQODSUy[LPDOH\UHJODPHQ
WDULDLQFOX\HQ
²'HFUHWRVH[WUDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV
²6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVSDUDFLHUWRWLSRGHGHOLQFXHQWHV
²3URVFULSFLyQGHXQLQGLYLGXRHQHOFDVRGH$JXVWtQGH,WXUELGH
²6XVSHQVLyQGHODJDUDQWtDGHOLEUHWUiQVLWR\UHVLGHQFLD(O(VWDGRSRGtDWUDV
ODGDUDFXDOTXLHULQGLYLGXRHQFDVRGHHPHUJHQFLD
²6XVSHQVLyQGHODOLEHUWDGGHLPSUHQWDRH[SUHVLyQ
²&RQILVFDFLyQGHELHQHVGHLQGLYLGXRVGXUDQWHODJXHUUDFRQ(VWDGRV8QLGRV
GRVHQ
(VWRVGHFUHWRVPXHVWUDQFODUDPHQWHORVSHOLJURVGHSHUPLWLUDO(MHFXWLYR)H
GHUDOXQDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQDPSOLDGHODSUHUURJDWLYDGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
$PSDUDGRHQHOODHO(VWDGRGHFLPRQyQLFRHMHUFLyYHUGDGHUDVGLFWDGXUDVTXH
H[FHGtDQFRQPXFKRORVOtPLWHVSODQWHDGRVRULJLQDOPHQWHSDUDHVWHDFWRSRUORV
URPDQRV1RVHUtDVLQRKDVWDOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHVLQHPEDUJRTXHODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVFRPHQ]DUDDVHUDFRWDGD\FRQWDUFRQXQDREOLJDFLyQOH
JLVODWLYD9DULRVDXWRUHVKDQWUD]DGRHOUHFRUULGRGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
HQODKLVWRULDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGH0p[LFRFX\DVHWDSDVFHQWUDOHVUHVXPLPRVGH
HVWDPDQHUDSDUDGHVSXpVDQDOL]DUDOJXQRVSRUPHQRUHVGHFDGDXQD
/H\GH&RQVSLUDGRUHVTXHIDFXOWyDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOSDUDOHJLVODUHQ
GLYHUVDVPDWHULDV5HDQXGDGDSRUHO&RQJUHVRWXYRYLJHQFLDKDVWD
&RQVWLWXFLyQGH6HHVWDEOHFLyTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVSR
GtDDSOLFDUVHH[FHSWRODVTXH³DVHJXUDQODYLGDGHOKRPEUH´3DUD&DVWDxHGD
ODVDOYHGDGVHUHILHUHDODURWXQGDRSRVLFLyQDODSHQDGHPXHUWH
6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQUHODFLyQFRQODOLEHUWDGGHWUDEDMR
'HFUHWRGH6XVSHQVLyQGH*DUDQWtDV,QGLYLGXDOHVGHMXQLRGHVGHHO
PHVGHPD\RGHELGRDODGHFODUDFLyQGHJXHUUDD$OHPDQLD,WDOLD\-DSyQ0D
QXHOÈYLOD&DPDFKRODVROLFLWySDUDTXH³HO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO>WXYLHUD@IDFXOWD
GHVH[WUDRUGLQDULDVFRQREMHWRGHOHJLVODU´DO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ(OGHFUH
WRHVWDEOHFLyODVXVSHQVLyQGHODVJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVTXHDSDUHFHQHQORV
DUWtFXORV\DOJXQRVVyORHQFLHUWRVSiUUDIRV
HQWRGRHOWHUULWRULR
/RVDQWHFHGHQWHVKLVWyULFRVGHODUWtFXORVHHQFXHQWUDQGHLQPHGLDWRHQ
ORVGHEDWHVSROtWLFRV\OHJLVODWLYRVGHOVLJOR;,;1RWHQHPRVODLQWHQFLyQGHGLV
FXWLUORVDTXtSXHVWRTXHGLVWLQJXLGRVMXULVWDVORKDQKHFKRGHPDQHUDHMHPSODU
SHURFRQVLGHUDPRV~WLOWRPDUDOJXQDVGHVXVSULQFLSDOHVFRQFOXVLRQHVSDUDHQ
WHQGHUODUHIRUPDDFWXDODOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO3DUD'HOD&XHYDXQPRPHQWR
GHHVSHFLDOLQWHUpVIXHODGHFLVLyQGHOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDHQDFHU
FDGHHOLPLQDUODVIDFXOWDGHVOHJLVODWLYDVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO%DViQGRVHHQ
ODVSURSXHVWDVGH(]HTXLHO0RQWHVYDULRVGHORVFpOHEUHVPDJLVWUDGRVGHOD
-*XUUtD/DFURL[op. cit.supraQRWD SS
+pFWRU)&DVWDxHGD-LPpQH]³/DLQGHIHQVLyQGHORVJREHUQDGRVDQWHHOULHVJRGHVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDV´HQPodium Notarial*XDGDODMDUDQ~PMXQLRGHS
²5HVWDEOHFLPLHQWRGHORUGHQS~EOLFR\GHIHQVDGHODVLQVWLWXFLRQHVTXH
VXVSHQGLyDUWtFXORVHVSHFtILFRVHQWRGRHOSDtV
²$PSOLDFLyQGHOGHFUHWRDQWHULRUIDFXOWDQGRDOIXVLODPLHQWRVLQMXLFLRGH
FLHUWRWLSRGHGHOLQFXHQWHV
²GHMXQLR\GHRFWXEUH'HFUHWRDPSOLRSDUDUHVWDEOHFHUHORUGHQ
S~EOLFRGLULJLGRFRQWUDORVFRQVHUYDGRUHV'RWyD-XiUH]GHIDFXOWDGHVH[WUDRU
GLQDULDV\IXH³PiVGLFWDWRULDOD~QTXHORVH[SHGLGRVHQORVSDtVHVWRWDOLWDULRV´
VHJ~Q*XUUtD/DFURL[TXLHQORFRQVLGHUyFRPSOHWDPHQWHLQFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
²GHGLFLHPEUH+L]RPiVJHQHUDOODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
²GHDEULO5HQRYyHOGHFUHWRGHOGHMXQLRGH
²GHPD\R5HQRYyHOGHFUHWRGHOGHGLFLHPEUHGHSHURHQ
FXDGUiQGRORGHQWURGHOPDUFRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
²8QDVHULHGHGHFUHWRVHQWUH\DFWXDOL]DURQ\SURUURJDURQGLYHUVDV
PHGLGDVDQWHULRUHV
0DULRGHOD&XHYD³/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\ODYXHOWDDODQRUPDOLGDG´op. citsupraQRWD
SS
0DULRGHOD&XHYDIXHXQLPSRUWDQWHDERJDGR\MXULVWDPH[LFDQRFX\RHVER]RELR
JUi¿FRQRVSDUHFHIXQGDPHQWDOSRUWUDWDUVHGHXQRGHORVHMHVPHGXODUHVGHQXHVWUDGLVFXVLyQDFHUFD
GHODUWtFXOR6HWUDWyGHXQRGHORVSULQFLSDOHVDERJDGRVDFDGpPLFRVGHVXpSRFDGHSHU¿OOLEHUDO
LQYHVWLJDGRU\GRFHQWHPX\UHFRQRFLGRWXYRXQJUDQpQIDVLVHQODGLJQLGDGKXPDQD\ODLGHDGHTXHHO
GHUHFKRGHEtDVHUYLVWRFRPRXQLQVWUXPHQWR\DQDOL]DGRHQVXFRQWH[WR
&RQRFHGRUGHGLYHUVRVLGLRPDVWUDGXMRLPSRUWDQWHVREUDVGHODOHPiQ+HOOHU9HUGURVV0HQ]HO
.UJHU\IXHTXL]iHOMXULVWDPH[LFDQRGHPD\RUUHQRPEUHLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQWRUQRDOGH
UHFKRODERUDO3URDFWLYRHQHOFDPSRSROtWLFRDGHPiVGHVHUUHFWRUGHOD0i[LPD&DVDGH(VWXGLRVIXH
TXLHQSURSXVRTXHORVWUDEDMDGRUHVSDUWLFLSDUDQHQHOUHSDUWRGHXWLOLGDGHV+DVLGRFRQVLGHUDGRXQPDU
[LVWDHQFXDQWRDODSRVLFLyQFUtWLFDGHOGHUHFKRWRPDQGRHQFXHQWDTXHODEDVHGHO(VWDGRHUD³XQDHV
WUXFWXUDGHSRGHUGHVWLQDGDDDVHJXUDUHOHMHUFLFLROLEUHGHOGHUHFKRGHSURSLHGDG´&ULWLFyD.HOVHQSRU
GHVOLJDUHOHVWXGLRGHOGHUHFKRGHODMXVWL¿FDFLyQVRFLDO\ODpWLFDGHOSRGHU/X]0DUtD=DU]D'HOJDGR
³0DULRGHOD&XHYDDQWHODFRQGLFLyQKXPDQD´HQ$OEHUWR6DODGLQR*DUFtDFRPSHumanismo mexicano del siglo XX7ROXFD8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGHO(VWDGRGH0p[LFRW,SSHQKWWSZZZ
HQVD\LVWDVRUJFULWLFDJHQHUDOHV&+PH[LFRFXHYDKWPUHYLVDGRHQMXQLRGH
77
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
pSRFDVXVFULELHURQVXVWHVLVOLPLWDQGRORVSRGHUHVFRQIHULGRVGXUDQWHORVSH
ULRGRVGHSHOLJURSDUDODQDFLyQ1RREVWDQWH\DUDt]GHOMXLFLRGHDPSDURHQWD
EODGRSRUODYLXGDGH1HSRPXFHQR$OPRQWHVHGHVHFKyHVWHSULQFLSLRFRQVL
GHUDGR³GHPRFUiWLFR\OLEHUDO´SRU'HOD&XHYD&RQHOORVHDEULyHOFDPLQRDOD
SRVLEOHGLFWDGXUD\FDSDFLGDGOHJLVODWLYDHQPDUFDGRVHQHODUWtFXORVHJ~QHO
PLVPRMXULVWD+D\TXHUHFRUGDUQRREVWDQWHTXH0DULRGHOD&XHYDIXHXQR
GHORVDERJDGRVPiVLQÀX\HQWHV\FUtWLFRVGHOVLVWHPDMXUtGLFRPH[LFDQR7XYR
IXHUWHVSRVLFLRQHVSROtWLFDVFRPRFXDQGRVHUH¿HUHDOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFD
GHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV&3(80³(VOOHJDGRHOWLHPSRGHD¿UPDU
TXHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQODSULPHUD\PiVDGHODQWDGDGHODVHJXQGDGpFDGDGHOVLJOR
VHKDFRQYHUWLGRHQHOFRUUHUGHORVDxRVHQHOEDOXDUWHGHODEXUJXHVtD\ORTXH
HVD~QPiVJUDYHKDGHYHQLGRHQODELRVGHORVSRVHHGRUHVGHOSRGHUHQHVWD
WXWRLQPXWDEOHFHUUDGRDODKLVWRULD\DODVQXHYDVH[LJHQFLDVGHORVSXHEORV´
(QUHODWLYDFRQWUDSRVLFLyQFRQHVWDSRVLFLyQFUtWLFDGHODLPSOHPHQWDFLyQGH
ODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHVGHODKLVWRULDGHOGHUHFKR-RUJH*XUUtD/DFURL[
UHFDOFyODHYLGHQWHGLVFUHFLRQDOLGDG\HVSHFLDOPHQWHHOULHVJRGHDSOLFDUHVWRV
GHFUHWRVGHPDQHUDDXWRULWDULDFRQWUDORVHQHPLJRVSROtWLFRVDWUDYpVGHPHGLGDV
GUDFRQLDQDV$SDUWLUGHODSURPXOJDFLyQGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHVHQRWDXQ
JLURHQHOWLSRHLQWHQFLyQGHORVGHFUHWRVUHODWLYRVDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
Carlos Brokmann Haro
78
²GHPD\R&LUFXODUTXHUHFKD]DHOGHUHFKRGHTXHHOHVWDGRGH-DOLV
FRGHFUHWHXQDVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
²GHHQHUR6XVSHQVLyQQDFLRQDOGHGLYHUVRVDUWtFXORVGHPDQHUD
PX\DPSOLD
²GHHQHUR6HGHFODUyDOHVWDGRGH4XHUpWDURHQHVWDGRGHVLWLR
²GHDEULO6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVSDUDSODJLDULRV\VDOWHDGRUHV9LU
WXDODXWRUL]DFLyQGHIXVLODPLHQWRVLQSUHYLRMXLFLR
²GHPD\R1XHYDVXVSHQVLyQUHIHUHQWHDOPLVPRWLSRGHJDUDQWtDV\
GHOLWRV
²GHPD\R/H\UHJODPHQWDULDUHODWLYDDODVGRVVXVSHQVLRQHVPHQ
FLRQDGDV,QFOXVRSHUPLWtDDORVFLXGDGDQRVWHQHUODVPLVPDVFDSDFLGDGHVHQ
ODSHUVHFXFLyQGHEDQGROHURVTXHDODVDXWRULGDGHV
(ODQiOLVLVGHORVGHFUHWRVGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVDSOLFDGRVGXUDQWHOD
YLJHQFLDGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHHVPX\DOHFFLRQDGRU%DVDGRHQXQFULWHULR
IRUPDOLVWD*XUUtD/DFURL[HYDOXyVXJUDGRGHOHJDOLGDGFRQEDVHHQHODSHJRD
ODVSDXWDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV'HVGHHVWDSHUVSHFWLYDFULWLFyDTXHOORVFDVRVHQ
ORVFXDOHVQRVHREHGHFLyHOPDQGDWRH[SUHVRPLHQWUDVTXHHQORVGHPiVFRQ
VLGHUyYiOLGDVXDSOLFDFLyQ6XGLYHUJHQFLDUHVSHFWRGHODFRUULHQWHGH'HOD
&XHYDQRSRGUtDVHUPD\RU$OQRWRPDUHQFXHQWDORVIDFWRUHVSROtWLFRVRORV
HIHFWRVGHORVGHFUHWRVGHMyGHODGRXQDHYDOXDFLyQPiVDPSOLD0XHVWUDGH
HVWDOLPLWDFLyQIXHVXUHVSDOGRDORVGHFUHWRVGHSRUDSHJDUVHHVWULFWD
PHQWHDODUWtFXOR\VLQGHWHQHUVHDGHEDWLUODVLPSOLFDFLRQHVWHyULFDV\SUiF
WLFDVTXHHOVHJXQGRUHYLVyGHPDQHUDGHVFDUQDGD(QHVWHVHQWLGR'HOD&XH
YD6FKPLWW\$JDPEHQQRVSDUHFHQPiV~WLOHVSDUDODGHIHQVDGHORVGHUHFKRV
KXPDQRV(ODSHJRIRUPDODODQRUPDQRDVHJXUDHIHFWRVSRVLWLYRVVREUHHO
FRQMXQWRVRFLDO\FRPRVHxDODUDHOWDPELpQUHFWRU'HOD&XHYDHOXVRGLVFUH
FLRQDO\DXWRULWDULRGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHGHUHFKRVFRPRLQVWUXPHQWRGHOSRGHU
SROtWLFR
(QVXDQiOLVLVGHODUWtFXOR'HOD&XHYDFRQVLGHUDTXHH[LVWHXQVHVJR
HTXLYRFDGRHQVXLQWHUSUHWDFLyQ6HVXHOHHQIDWL]DUVXFDUiFWHUGHFUHDGRUGH
XQUpJLPHQGHH[FHSFLyQGHQWURGHORUGHQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOVLQWRPDUHQFXHQWD
TXHVHWUDWDGHTXH³IRUPDSDUWHGHORVGHUHFKRVGHOKRPEUHRPiVFRUUHFWDPHQ
WHHVODD¿UPDFLyQ\ODGHIHQVDGHORVGHUHFKRVGHOKRPEUH´(QOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ
GHOHOPLVPRDUWtFXORDOKDFHUUHIHUHQFLDDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
UHFDOFyTXHpVWDQRSRGtDVXVSHQGHUHOUHVSHWRDORVGHUHFKRVGHOKRPEUHHV
SHFLDOPHQWHHQORTXHVHUH¿HUHDOGHUHFKRDODYLGD(VWRSXHGHH[SOLFDUVHIi
FLOPHQWH\DTXHGDGRORLUUHPHGLDEOHGHOGDxRQRVHWUDWDUtDGHODVXVSHQVLyQ
VLQRGHODVXSUHVLyQGHOGHUHFKRPLVPR3RUHVWDVUD]RQHVGHVGHOD&RQVWLWX
FLyQGHO\PiVD~QHQODGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVQRSXHGHVHU
YLVWDFRPRXQDHOLPLQDFLyQGHOHTXLOLEULRGHSRGHUHVTXHGRWDDO(MHFXWLYR)H
GHUDOGHFDSDFLGDGHVLOLPLWDGDVVLQRFRPRXQDPHGLGDSDUDGHFUHWDUHOHVWDGR
GHH[FHSFLyQGHQWURGHOtPLWHVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV8QDUWtFXORTXHFRQFHGLHUDDO
(VWDGRHVWDFDSDFLGDGVLQSRQHUOHOtPLWHVVyORVLJQL¿FDUtDODDQXODFLyQGHODOy
JLFDFRQVWLWXFLRQDODOJRTXHHQIiWLFDPHQWHKDVLGRUHIXWDGRGHVGHHOVLJOR;,;
-*XUUtD/DFURL[op. citsupraQRWDSS
0GHOD&XHYDop. citsupraQRWDSS
²/DVFDXVDVTXHMXVWLILFDQODDSOLFDFLyQGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVRQLGpQ
WLFDV³FDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFDRFXDOHVTXLHUD
RWURVTXHSRQJDQDODVRFLHGDGHQJUDYHSHOLJURRFRQIOLFWR´
²(QDPERVFDVRVVHUHVWULQJHDO3UHVLGHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFDODSRVLELOLGDGGH
DSOLFDUORVLHPSUHGHDFXHUGRFRQVXJDELQHWH\FRQODDSUREDFLyQGHO&RQJUH
VRGHOD8QLyQRGHVXVPLHPEURVUHXQLGRVGHIRUPDSHUPDQHQWH(QHVWH
LQFLVRORVFDPELRVKDQVLGR~QLFDPHQWHGHQRPEUHVvr. grHO&RQVHMRGH0L
QLVWURVRODH[LVWHQFLDGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQWH
²(QVHJXLGDRFXUUHODSULPHUDGLIHUHQFLDLPSRUWDQWHHQWUHORVGRVWH[WRVFRQV
WLWXFLRQDOHVRULJLQDOHV0LHQWUDVTXHODGHPHQFLRQDTXHVHSXHGHVXV
SHQGHUODVJDUDQWtDVGHPDQHUDJHQHUDOODGHH[SOLFLWDTXHpVWDSXHGH
OOHYDUVHGHPDQHUDQDFLRQDOR³HQOXJDUGHWHUPLQDGR´
²2WUDGLYHUJHQFLDIXQGDPHQWDOHQHOPLVPRHVTXHODGHDSXQWDTXHOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHVJHQHUDO³FRQH[FHSFLyQGHODVTXHDVHJXUDQODYL
GDGHOKRPEUH´PLHQWUDVTXHODGHHOLPLQyHVWDEDUUHUDRULJLQDOPHQWH
(OFDVRKLVWyULFRPiVLPSRUWDQWHGHDSOLFDFLyQGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
HQQXHVWURSDtVIXHHO'HFUHWRGH6XVSHQVLyQGH*DUDQWtDV,QGLYLGXDOHVGH
/DVXVSHQVLyQDEVROXWDVRODPHQWHGXUyGHVGHHODOGHMXQLRGH\WHU
PLQyFRQODH[SHGLFLyQGHXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULD/RVGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDV
VXVSHQGLGRVLQFOX\HURQODDQXODFLyQGHODPSDURFRQWUDVXVYLRODFLRQHVGHELGR
DTXHKDEtDQVLGR³GHVSRMDGDVGHVXYLJHQFLD´/DLPSOHPHQWDFLyQGHODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVUHYHOyTXHOOHYDUODDFDERVLQFRUWDSLVDVSHUPLWtDDO(MHFX
WLYR)HGHUDOXQDGLVFUHFLRQDOLGDGDEVROXWD(QHVHEUHYHODSVRTXHGDURQVLQ
HIHFWRODPD\RUtDGHODVJDUDQWtDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVODSRVLEOHGHIHQVDFRQWUDHO
DEXVRGHO(VWDGR\QRH[LVWLHURQOLPLWDFLRQHVMXUtGLFDVDVXSUyUURJDGHPDQHUD
DXWRULWDULD'HOD&XHYDFRQVLGHUDTXHXQRGHORVHIHFWRVPiVQRFLYRVGHOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQ0p[LFRFRQPRWLYRGHODFRQÀDJUDFLyQPXQGLDOGH
IXHHOKHFKRGHTXHVHFRQYLUWLHVHUiSLGDPHQWHHQXQDQRUPDOLGDG
DFHSWDGD'HVGHODIDFXOWDGGHOHJLVODFLyQH[WUDRUGLQDULDKDVWDODUHSUHVLyQGH
ORVPRYLPLHQWRVVRFLDOHVGLYHUVRVDFWRUHVDSODXGtDQODVIDFXOWDGHVTXHIRUWD
OHFLHURQGHPDQHUDDXWRULWDULDDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOHQHOSHULRGR([SUHVDGRHQ
VXPtQLPDH[SUHVLyQMXUtGLFD'HOD&XHYDDUJXPHQWyTXHHODUWtFXORHUDFR
P~QPHQWHLQWHUSUHWDGRHQHOVHQWLGRGHTXH³HVHOSUHFHSWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXH
SHUPLWHHQODVVLWXDFLRQHVGHHPHUJHQFLDHULJLUDOSUHVLGHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFD
HQXQGLFWDGRURSDUDHPSOHDUODVSDODEUDVGHODIDPRVD/H\GHGHGLFLHPEUH
GHGRWDUDOSUHVLGHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFDGHIDFXOWDGHVRPQtPRGDV´
+)&DVWDxHGD-LPpQH]op. citsupraQRWDS
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDS
79
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
'HVGHQXHVWUDSHUVSHFWLYDDQWURSROyJLFDODHVWUXFWXUDRUJDQL]DWLYDGHODV
JDUDQWtDVIXQGDPHQWDOHVHVVLPLODUHQWUHORVWH[WRVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVGH\
HOGH(QDPERVFDVRVHODUWtFXORUHIHUHQWHDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
RFXSDHOPLVPRVLWLRMXVWRDO¿QDOGHODGHOLPLWDFLyQGHODVPLVPDV\FRQHOPLV
PRQXPHUDOHODUWtFXOR(QWUHDPERVVHUHJLVWUDXQDVHULHGHSHTXHxDVGLIH
UHQFLDVTXHIXHURQDQDOL]DGDVSRUGLYHUVRVMXULVWDVSHURTXHFUHHPRVFRQYH
QLHQWHUHFDSLWXODUYHU(VTXHPD
Carlos Brokmann Haro
80
/DVXVSHQVLyQGHFUHWDGDSRUHOSUHVLGHQWHGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV
0DQXHOÈYLOD&DPDFKRIXHODPiVDPSOLDHQODKLVWRULDQDFLRQDOHQORTXHVH
UH¿HUHDORH[SOtFLWRGHVXFREHUWXUD&RQYRFyDO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQDVHVLR
QDUDHIHFWRVGHHODERUDUODGHFODUDFLyQGHKRVWLOLGDGHVFRQWUDORVSDtVHVGHO(MH
$OHPDQLD-DSyQH,WDOLDDVtFRPRSDUDVROLFLWDUOHIDFXOWDGHVH[WUDRUGLQDULDV
HQWDOHPHUJHQFLDQDFLRQDO(OGHMXQLRGHVHGHFUHWyODVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDVDODPSDURGHODUWtFXORGHOD&3(80FRQORFXDOVHVXVSHQGLHURQ
ORVVLJXLHQWHVDUWtFXORVRSiUUDIRSULPHURGHORRR
\SiUUDIRWHUFHURGHO\/DVXVSHQVLyQIXHXQDGHORVWHPDVMXUtGLFRV
GHPD\RUSROpPLFDHQODpSRFDFRPRYHUHPRVHQVHJXLGD\¿QDOL]yFRQXQ
QXHYRGHFUHWRHOGHDJRVWRGH
0DULRGHOD&XHYDDQDOL]yODVFRQGLFLRQHVSDUDFRQVLGHUDUODVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDV\GHFUHWDUHOHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLD(VWiGH¿QLGRHQHOPLVPRDUWtFX
ORSHURFLWDD-RVp&DPSLOORFRQHO¿QGHHVFODUHFHUSRUFRPSOHWRHVWHSXQWR
³6HFRQVLGHUDSRUODGRFWULQDTXHH[LVWHXQHVWDGRGHQHFHVLGDGFXDQGRODLQWH
JULGDGODVREHUDQtDODVLQVWLWXFLRQHVIXQGDPHQWDOHVODGLJQLGDGGHXQSDtVRHO
ELHQFRP~QVHHQFXHQWUHQVHULDPHQWHDIHFWDGRVRJUDYHPHQWHDPHQD]DGRV´
/DVDXWRULGDGHVUHVSRQVDEOHVGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVRQHOSUHVL
GHQWH\HO&RQJUHVR\HODUWtFXORHVWLSXODODVFRQGLFLRQHV\IRUPDVHQTXH
DPEDVDXWRULGDGHVGHEHQDMXVWDUVXDSOLFDFLyQ/DVXVSHQVLyQVRODPHQWHSXH
GHDIHFWDUDTXHOODVJDUDQWtDV³TXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\
IiFLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ´'HVGHHODQiOLVLVGH'HOD&XHYDHVWRVLJQL¿FDTXH
GHEHVHUPX\SUHFLVRHOGHFUHWR\ODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHHQFXDQ
WRDQRDIHFWDUQLQJXQDRWUDJDUDQWtDRGHUHFKRKXPDQR/DUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLR
QDOUHFLHQWHUHWRPDHQHVWHVHQWLGRODOLPLWDFLyQTXHRULJLQDOPHQWHSURSXVROD
&RQVWLWXFLyQGHHQORTXHVHUH¿HUHDODV³JDUDQWtDVGHODYLGDGHOKRPEUH´
H[WHQGLpQGRODVDKRUDDOQ~FOHRTXHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV
+XPDQRV&$'+FRQVLGHUDIXQGDPHQWDOHVSDUDSUHVHUYDUORVGHUHFKRVKX
PDQRV8QDVHJXQGDOLPLWDFLyQGHOLQHDGDSRUHOSURSLRDUWtFXORHVHOKHFKR
GHTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHEHOLPLWDUVHDODUHJLyQTXHVHHQFXHQWUH
DIHFWDGDSRUHOHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDRQHFHVLGDG(QFDVRGHKRVWLOLGDGHVLQ
WHUQDFLRQDOHVFRPRRFXUULyGXUDQWHOD6HJXQGD*XHUUD0XQGLDOHVWDFREHUWX
UDSXHGHDOFDQ]DUWRGRHOWHUULWRULRQDFLRQDO(QFDPELRORVGHVDVWUHVQDWXUDOHV
RODLQJREHUQDELOLGDGTXHDFWXDOPHQWHVHDVRFLDFRQODOXFKDFRQWUDHOFULPHQ
RUJDQL]DGRVHUHVWULQJHQDHVSDFLRVORFDOL]DGRVSRUORTXHHOGHFUHWRSXHGH
WHQHUUHVWULFFLRQHVJHRJUi¿FDVFODUDV/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHEHWHQHU
XQDYLJHQFLDWHPSRUDOFODUDPHQWHGH¿QLGDGHPDQHUDSUHYLDDVXGHFUHWR3DUD
'HOD&XHYDHVWDOLPLWDFLyQHVWiLPSOtFLWDHQHOKHFKRGHTXHHODUWtFXORIRUPD
SDUWHGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ\SRUORWDQWRQRSXHGHPRGL¿FDUODGHPDQHUDGH¿QLWLYD
(OPLVPRMXULVWDLGHQWL¿FyGRVIRUPDVGHGHWHUPLQDUHVWHSHULRGRHQODKLVWRULD
PH[LFDQDSRUHOWLHPSRHQTXHGXUDVHODHPHUJHQFLDHVSHFLDOPHQWHHQWLHP
SRVGHJXHUUDRUHEHOLyQLQWHUQDRELHQSRUORTXHGXUDVHHOSHULRGRGHVHVLRQHV
GHO&RQJUHVR(QHVWH~OWLPRFDVRHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOGHEHUtDVRPHWHUDFRQ
VLGHUDFLyQGHO/HJLVODWLYRODFRQYHQLHQFLDGHSURUURJDUHOSHULRGRGHVXVSHQVLyQ
9,,,3HULRGRGHOSUHVLGHQWH0DQXHOÈYLOD&DPDFKRHQKWWSZZZSJUJREP[TXHHVSJU
'RFXPHQWRVFRQPHPRUDFLRQSHSUPDDFKWPFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
&LWDGRSRU0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDS
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDSS
9,,,3HULRGRGHOSUHVLGHQWH0DQXHOÈYLOD&DPDFKRHQKWWSZZZSJUJREP[TXHHVSJU
'RFXPHQWRVFRQPHPRUDFLRQSHSUPDDFKWPFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
81
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
GHJDUDQWtDV/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHVXQDPHGLGDJHQHUDO\QRSXHGH
DSOLFDUVHVRODPHQWHDXQLQGLYLGXR(QQXHVWUDOHFWXUDHVWRSXHGHH[WHQGHUVHDO
FDVRGHFRPXQLGDGHVRJUXSRVGDGRTXHODPHGLGDWLHQHFRPROLPLWDQWHVOD
DSOLFDFLyQHVSDFLDO\WHPSRUDO3RUORWDQWRQRVHUiSRVLEOHLQWHUSUHWDUODGHPD
QHUDTXHSXHGDUHIHULUVHDQLQJ~QVHFWRUVRFLDOSROtWLFRUHOLJLRVRRFXOWXUDOHV
SHFt¿FR(OUHVXOWDGRGHOFXPSOLPLHQWRGHHVWRVSULQFLSLRVIXHODDSOLFDFLyQGHO
DUWtFXORHQODIHFKDDQWHVUHIHULGD&RPRLQVWUXPHQWRIXQGDPHQWDOSDUDDSOL
FDUORGHPDQHUDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOIXHQHFHVDULRHODERUDU\DSUREDUXQDOH\UHJOD
PHQWDULDPLVPDTXHIXHDQDOL]DGDSRU$JXLODU\0D\D\TXHUHFLELyHOWtWXORGH
/H\GH3UHYHQFLRQHV*HQHUDOHVHQWUHFX\RVDVSHFWRVFHQWUDOHVVHHQFXHQWUD
TXHHV³UHODWLYDDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVHQGRQGHSDUDJDUDQ
WL]DUHVWHSURSyVLWRVHVHxDODEDTXHHOSURSLR(MHFXWLYRHUDODDXWRULGDG~QLFD
TXHSRGUtDGLFWDUGLVSRVLFLRQHVHQHVWDPDWHULD\VyORDWUDYpVGHVXVLQPHGLD
WRVFRODERUDGRUHVORV6HFUHWDULRVGH(VWDGRORV-HIHVGH'HSDUWDPHQWRV\HO
3URFXUDGRU*HQHUDOGHOD5HS~EOLFD´
+HPRVYLVWRTXHORVGHEDWHVHQWRUQRDORVDOFDQFHV\OLPLWDFLRQHVGHODUWtFX
ORKDQVLGRODUJRV\HQRFDVLRQHVGHMDQJUDQGHVODJXQDVSDUDODLQWHUSUHWD
FLyQ3RUHVWDVUD]RQHVHVFRQYHQLHQWHUHSDVDUGHPDQHUDSXQWXDOORVHIHFWRV
TXHWLHQHVXLPSOHPHQWDFLyQFRQEDVHHQODVSURSXHVWDVWHyULFDVORVDVSHFWRV
MXUtGLFRV\DOJXQRVHOHPHQWRVGHULYDGRVGHODH[SHULHQFLDSUiFWLFD1RVSDUHFH
TXHODH[SRVLFLyQGH0DULRGHOD&XHYDHVPX\FODUDSRUORTXHKHPRVVHJXLGR
VXRUGHQDxDGLHQGRFRPHQWDULRV\FRQVLGHUDFLRQHVGHtQGROHSROtWLFD\DQWUR
SROyJLFD3DUDHOMXULVWDHODQiOLVLVGHORVHIHFWRVGHOGHFUHWRGHODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDVUHVXOWDLPSUHVFLQGLEOHSDUDDTXLODWDUODFRQYHQLHQFLDGHXWLOL]DUOD
FRPRLQVWUXPHQWRMXUtGLFRSROtWLFR(VFRQYHQLHQWHVXEUD\DUGHQXHYDFXHQWD
HVWDLQWHUDFFLyQIXQGDPHQWDOHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQFUHDGRSRUODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDVVHHQFXHQWUDDPHGLRFDPLQRHQWUHODHVIHUDGHORMXUtGLFR\DTXH
OODGHODSROtWLFD3DUD6FKPLWW$JDPEHQ'HOD&XHYD&DVWDxHGD*DOODUGR\
ODPD\RUSDUWHGHORVDXWRUHVTXHKHPRVFLWDGR\FRQVXOWDGRHVWHFDUiFWHUGXDO
H[SOLFD\DODYH]GL¿FXOWDODFRPSUHQVLyQGHXQGHFUHWRGHHVWDQDWXUDOH]D3RU
HVWRVPRWLYRV\FRQVLGHUDQGRQXHVWUDIRUPDFLyQFUHHPRV~WLOFRPELQDUDPERV
SXQWRVGHYLVWDDOUHSDVDUORVHIHFWRVGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
/RVSULPHURVDUWtFXORVGHQXHVWUD&RQVWLWXFLyQVHUH¿HUHQDODVJDUDQWtDV
IXQGDPHQWDOHVGHVFULWDVSRU'HOD&XHYDFRPRORVGHUHFKRVGHOKRPEUH\HQ
ODDFWXDOLGDGSDUWLFXODUPHQWHFRPRUHVXOWDGRGHODUHFLHQWHUHIRUPDLGHQWL¿FD
GDVGLUHFWDPHQWHFRQORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV3RUHVWDUD]yQHODUWtFXORHV
HO~OWLPRGHHOORVVHWUDWDGHDTXHOTXHXQDYH]GHVFULWRVORVGHFDUiFWHUIXQGD
PHQWDOFUHDGHPDQHUDH[SOtFLWDHOLQVWUXPHQWRSDUDVXVSHQGHUORVGHPDQHUD
WHPSRUDOFXDQGRVHDQHFHVDULRKDFHUOR/DPD\RUtDGHORVDXWRUHVFRQVXOWDGRV
FRQFXHUGDTXHODWUDGLFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOQRVOOHYDDGHWHUPLQDUTXHODVXVSHQ
VLyQWHQGUtDXQDSULPHUDOLPLWDQWHQRSXHGHLUPiVDOOiGHVHUXQDUHVWULFFLyQ
WHPSRUDO\GHQLQJXQDPDQHUDSXHGHLQIULQJLUORVGHPDQHUDOHJLVODWLYD9DULRV
KDQFLWDGRODWHVLVGH&DUULOOR)ORUHVTXLHQDUJXPHQWyTXHHOHVWDGRGHH[FHS
FLyQOLPLWDGRSRUHODUWtFXORQRVLJQL¿FDXQDGHVDSDULFLyQGHORUGHQMXUtGLFR\
Carlos Brokmann Haro
82
SRUORWDQWRGHOSULQFLSLRGHOHJDOLGDG'HVGHXQDSHUVSHFWLYDPiVWHyULFDOD
D¿UPDFLyQGHORVMXULVWDVSDUHFHXQWDQWRHQGHEOHVLQHPEDUJRHOHVWDGRGH
H[FHSFLyQLQVWDXUDGROHJDOPHQWHSXHGHWDQWRSURORQJDUVHGHPDQHUDLQGH¿QLGD
WDO\FRPRKDVXFHGLGRFRQHOPatriot Act\GLYHUVRVUHJtPHQHVDXWRULWDULRVRELHQ
JREHUQDUSRUGHFUHWRGHPDQHUDTXHVHYLROHQWHSRUFRPSOHWRHORUGHQFRQVWL
WXFLRQDORMXUtGLFRHVWDEOHFLGRVLQDOWHUDUORde jureFRPRHQHOFDVRGHOQD]LVPR
HOHVWDEOHFLPLHQWRGHOJRELHUQRGHORVVRYLHWVROD5HYROXFLyQ&XOWXUDOFKLQD
8QVHJXQGRHIHFWRGHODDSOLFDFLyQGHODUWtFXORHQODDSUHFLDFLyQGH'H
OD&XHYD&DVWDxHGD\*XUUtD/DFURL[HVODDPSOLDFLyQGHODDFFLyQDGPLQLVWUD
WLYDGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO(VWD³PD\RUDPSOLWXG´GHULYDGHORULJLQDOSiUUDIRVH
JXQGRGHODUWtFXORTXHDSDUWLUGHODVUHIRUPDVGHTXHGyXQLGRHQXQVROR
SiUUDIR\FRQVWLWX\yHOPHROORGHODGLVFXVLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLVWDGXUDQWHODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGH+DELHQGRTXLHQHVLQWHUSUHWDEDQHOOLQHDPLHQWR
FRPRXQDYLUWXDOFRQGLFLyQSDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOHMHUFLHUDXQPDQGDWR
GLFWDWRULDORWURVDO]DURQVXVFUtWLFDVDUJXPHQWDQGRTXHODDXWRUL]DFLyQGHO&RQ
JUHVRHTXLOLEUDEDHVWRVSRGHUHV-XQWRFRQHVWRV~OWLPRVFRQVLGHUDPRVTXHQR
SXHGHLQWHUSUHWDUVHFRPRXQD³FDUWDHQEODQFR´HQODIUDVHGH'HOD&XHYD\
TXHTXHGDUtDOLPLWDGDSRUODVFRQVLGHUDFLRQHVSUHYLDVGHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
/DPD\RUtDGHORVMXULVWDVRSLQDURQGXUDQWHHVWRVGHEDWHVHQIDYRUGHXQD³LQ
WHUSUHWDFLyQUHVWULQJLGD´GHOPDQGDWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOOLPLWDUHQODPHGLGDGHOR
SRVLEOHODDPSOLDFLyQGHIDFXOWDGHVDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO\DXPHQWDUODYLJLODQFLD
GHOSURFHVR\VXGHVDUUROORSUiFWLFRSRUSDUWHGHO&RQJUHVR(OSULQFLSLRQRVyOR
SDUHFH~WLOVLQRTXHSRGUtDVHULQFOXLGRH[SUHVDPHQWHHQODOH\UHJODPHQWDULD
TXHHVWiSUHYLVWRSURPXOJDU$ODVUHVWULFFLRQHVGHOHMHUFLFLRDXWRULWDULRRULJLQDO
PHQWHSUHYLVWDVHQHODUWtFXORTXHQRIXHURQPRGL¿FDGDVHQVXVSULPHUDV
GRVUHIRUPDVODDFWXDOUHIRUPDDxDGHRWUDVTXHWRGDYtDSXHGHQVHUSXQWXDOL]D
GDVDWUDYpVGHODFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHOH\GHIRUPDTXHVHOLPLWHHQODPHGLGDGHOR
SRVLEOHHVWHSHOLJUR
(ODUWtFXORIXHDSOLFDGRWDO\FRPRIXHUHGDFWDGRRULJLQDOPHQWHGXUDQWHOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVTXHWXYROXJDUFRQPRWLYRGHOD6HJXQGD*XHUUD0XQ
GLDOYHU(VTXHPD(OWH[WRGHODUWtFXORVXIULyDOJXQDVPRGL¿FDFLRQHVHQHO
³'HFUHWRSRUHOTXHVHUHIRUPDQORVDUWtFXORV\GHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3R
OtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRVGH´(OSULPHURGHHOORVIXHFDPELDU
ODGHQRPLQDFLyQ³3UHVLGHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFD0H[LFDQD´SRUHOGH³3UHVLGHQWH
GHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV´DFRUGHFRQODWHUPLQRORJtDR¿FLDODVHQWDGD
HQHODUWtFXORGHODPLVPD&3(80/DVHJXQGDPRGL¿FDFLyQLQWURGXFLGDSRU
HVWHGHFUHWRGXUDQWHODSUHVLGHQFLDGH0LJXHOGHOD0DGULGIXHVXVWLWXLUODDQWLJXD
IyUPXODGH³&RQVHMRGH0LQLVWURV´SRUODYLJHQWHGHORV³7LWXODUHVGHODV6HFUH
WDUtDVGH(VWDGRORV'HSDUWDPHQWRV$GPLQLVWUDWLYRV\OD3URFXUDGXUtD*HQHUDO
GHOD5HS~EOLFD´UDWL¿FDQGRVXIXQFLyQDOLQGLFDUTXHHOWLWXODUGHO(MHFXWLYR)H
GHUDOGHEHUtDDFRUGDUFRQHOORVODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV8QDWHUFHUDPRGL¿
FDFLyQSDUHFHKDEHUVLGRXQHUURUVLQWiFWLFRSXHVWRTXHIXHQXHYDPHQWHFRUUH
JLGRHQODVLJXLHQWHUHIRUPDOOHYDGDDFDERHQDOKDEODUGHODVJDUDQWtDV
TXHSRGtDQLPSHGLURGL¿FXOWDUODVDFFLRQHVGXUDQWHXQSHULRGRGHHPHUJHQFLD
VHVXVWLWX\y³REVWiFXOR´SRU³REVWiFXORV´3RU~OWLPRFRQHOSURSyVLWRGHGHMDU
HQFODURODUHGDFFLyQGHOD~OWLPDIUDVHGHODUWtFXORVHVXVWLWX\yHOSXQWR\VHJXL
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDSS
/DVHJXQGDHVWRGDYtDXQDLQLFLDWLYD6XVDXWRUHVVRQHOVHQDGRUSHUUHGLVWDSRUHO
HVWDGRGH&KLDSDV5XWLOLR&UX](VFDQGyQ&DGHQDVTXHSURSRQHXQDPRGL¿FD
FLyQDODUWtFXORFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHOTXHSUHYpODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV/DSUR
SXHVWDDJUHJDXQVHJXQGRSiUUDIRDODUWtFXORTXHVHOHHDVt³/RVWUDWDGRV\OD
OH\GHWHUPLQDUiQTXpJDUDQWtDV\GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVQRSRGUiQVXVSHQGHUVHHQ
QLQJ~QFDVR´(VWDUHGDFFLyQGHDSDULHQFLDSURWHFFLRQLVWDORTXHKDFHHQUHDOLGDG
HVDEULUODSRVLELOLGDGGHTXHVHOHJLVOHDOUHVSHFWR8QDYH]TXHH[LVWDXQDOH\UH
JODPHQWDULDVHSRGUiDFXGLUDOH[SHGLHQWHGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHPD
QHUDH[SHGLWD<HQHIHFWR\DH[LVWHHOWH[WRGHXQDLQLFLDWLYDFRQSUR\HFWRGHGH
FUHWRSRUHOTXHVHFUHDOD/H\)HGHUDOGH(VWDGRVGH([FHSFLyQ6HWUDWDGHXQD
SURSXHVWDGHOVHQDGRUSDQLVWD&DUORV0DGUD]R/LPyQTXHIXHSUHVHQWDGDHOPDU
WHVGHGLFLHPEUHGH\IXHWXUQDGDDODV&RPLVLRQHVGH(VWXGLRV/HJLVOD
WLYRV*REHUQDFLyQ\-XVWLFLD
6HJ~QH[SRQHHOVHQDGRU0DGUD]RHOJRELHUQRGH0p[LFRKDUHFXUULGRDODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHQDOJXQDVRFDVLRQHVGXUDQWHHOVLJOR;,;\HQGRVGXUDQWH
HOVLJOR;;ODSULPHUDPRWLYDGDSRUOD³SHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFD´TXH
VLJQL¿FyODUHYROXFLyQPDGHULVWD\ODVHJXQGDIXHFRQVHFXHQFLDGHODGHFODUDFLyQ
GHHVWDGRGHJXHUUDFRQODVSRWHQFLDVGHOHMH%HUOtQ5RPD7RNLR
1LQJ~QRWURPRPHQWRGHOVLJORSDVDGRUHTXLULyODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV1L
ODUHSUHVLyQDORVPRYLPLHQWRVDUPDGRVQLODVFDODPLGDGHVGHODQDWXUDOH]DOOHYD
URQDOJRELHUQRDVXVSHQGHUODVJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHV1RKD\SXHVHQHOKRUL
]RQWHXQDUD]yQHVSHFLDOTXHKDJDUHFRPHQGDEOHODFUHDFLyQGHXQDOH\SDUD
UHJXODUODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
(O³'HFUHWRSRUHOTXHVHUHIRUPDQORVDUWtFXORV\
GHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV´GHOMXHYHV
GHDJRVWRGHVLJQL¿FyXQDDOWHUDFLyQPHQRUYHU(VTXHPD/OHYDGDD
FDERGXUDQWHODSUHVLGHQFLDGH)HOLSH&DOGHUyQ+LQRMRVDODVPRGL¿FDFLRQHV
~QLFDPHQWHFRUULJLHURQDVSHFWRVGHVLQWD[LVFRQHO¿QGHSXQWXDOL]DUXQSDUGH
DVSHFWRVGHOWH[WRGHODUWtFXOR(OSULPHURTXH\DPHQFLRQDPRVDOFRPHQWDU
HOGHFUHWRGHTXHKDEtDFRUUHJLGRHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHDOWUDWDU
DTXHOODVJDUDQWtDVTXHSXGLHVHQVLJQL¿FDUXQSUREOHPDSDUDODVPHGLGDVGH
HPHUJHQFLDGHFUHWDGDVSRUHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOVLJQL¿FyUHJUHVDUDODUHGDF
FLyQRULJLQDO6HWUDWDGHODYXHOWDDOWpUPLQRGH³ODVJDUDQWtDVTXHIXHVHQ´VXV
'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQPDUWHVGHDEULOGHHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQIMXU
OHJFRQVWPH[SGIUFSGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
*XVWDYR,UXHJDV³$OJRKXHOHDSRGULGR´HQLa JornadaGHIHEUHURGH
83
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
GRGH³6LODVXVSHQVLyQVHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVR´SRUXQDFRPDVHJXL
GDGH³SHURVLVHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVR´ORFXDOUHIRU]yHOVHQWLGRGH
LQPHGLDWH]GHODPHGLGD'HPDQHUDTXHHOVHQWLGRJHQHUDOGHODVPRGL¿FD
FLRQHVLQWURGXFLGDVSRUHVWHGHFUHWRIXHHOGHDFWXDOL]DUODWHUPLQRORJtD\HOVHQ
WLGRGHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
*XVWDYR,UXHJDVGHVFULEHXQDLQLFLDWLYDGHSDUDUHIRUPDU\FUHDUXQDOH\
UHJODPHQWDULDSDUDHODUWtFXORGHOD&3(80TXHFRQVLGHUDSDUWHGHXQDVH
ULHTXHREHGHFtDQDSUHVLRQHVGH(VWDGRV8QLGRVSDUDDMXVWDUODOHJLVODFLyQGH
VHJXULGDGQDFLRQDODQWHODDPHQD]DWHUURULVWDDSDUWLUGHO
Carlos Brokmann Haro
84
WLWX\HQGR³REVWiFXORV´SRU³REVWiFXOR´XQDREYLHGDGVLQWiFWLFD(OVHJXQGRFDP
ELyHQOD~OWLPDIUDVHODFRPD¿QDOSRUXQSXQWR\FRPDUHVXOWDGRPiVFODUDOD
UHGDFFLyQFRQHVWDDOWHUDFLyQ/DIUDVHTXHGyDVt³6LODVXVSHQVLyQWXYLHVHOXJDU
KDOOiQGRVHHO&RQJUHVRUHXQLGRpVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]DFLRQHVTXHHVWLPH
QHFHVDULDVSDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJDIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURVLVHYHUL¿FDVH
HQWLHPSRGHUHFHVRVHFRQYRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQJUHVRSDUDTXHODV
DFXHUGH´&RQHVWDVPRGL¿FDFLRQHVHODUWtFXORSUHFLVyVXWHUPLQRORJtD\
SXQWXDOL]yVXVDOFDQFHV3HURHVODDFWXDOUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQPDWHULDGH
GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVODTXHORWUDQVIRUPDGHPDQHUDSXQWXDOFRPRYHUHPRVPiV
DGHODQWH
III. Las reformas constitucionales en derechos humanos
(ODUJXPHQWRIXQGDPHQWDOGH0DULRGHOD&XHYDDODQDOL]DUODVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDVFRQPRWLYRGHOD6HJXQGD*XHUUD0XQGLDO\HQUHIHUHQFLDDOPDUFR
GHLQWHUSUHWDFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHODUWtFXORIXHTXHVHWUDWDGHXQWH[WRHQ
DEVROXWDFRQFRUGDQFLDFRQORVSULQFLSLRV\JDUDQWtDVIXQGDPHQWDOHV&RQVLGH
UDQGRTXHODVOLPLWDFLRQHVDOHMHUFLFLRDXWRULWDULRGHOSRGHUSRUSDUWHGHOSUHVL
GHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFDVRQH[SOtFLWDV\FODUDVHO/HJLVODWLYRGHEHIXQFLRQDUFRPR
FRQWUDSHVRDO(MHFXWLYR1RHVSUHUURJDWLYDQLSRWHVWDGGHHVWH~OWLPRGHWHUPLQDU
ODH[LVWHQFLDGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVXVOtPLWHVQLVXYLJHQFLD(OSUHVL
GHQWHWDPSRFRSXHGHDUURJDUVHIDFXOWDGHVH[WUDRUGLQDULDVTXHFRQWUDYHQJDQ
HOPDQGDWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOFRPRVHUtDHOOHJLVODURJREHUQDUSRUGHFUHWR(QHO
HMHPSORGHVHH[WUDOLPLWyDOPRGL¿FDUOD/H\GH3UHYHQFLRQHV*HQH
UDOHV\GHELyVHUPiVFDXWHORVRHQVXLPSOHPHQWDFLyQSRUTXH³WDPSRFRHVDG
PLVLEOHTXHSXHGDVXUWLUHIHFWRVODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVDQWHVGHTXHVH
GLFWHQODVSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV´
7RPDQGRHQFRQVLGHUDFLyQORVPDQGDWRVH[SOtFLWRVGHODUWtFXORDVtFRPR
HOF~PXORGHLPSOtFLWRVLGHQWL¿FDGRVSRUORVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLVWDVTXHORDQDOL]DURQ
GHVGHHOVLJOR;,;HVREYLRTXHODDFWXDOUHIRUPDHQPDWHULDGHGHUHFKRVKX
PDQRVVyORSXHGHUHIRU]DUHVWDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQ&RPRKDQHVFULWRGLYHUVRVMXULV
WDVQRSXHGHH[LVWLUXQDUWtFXORGHQWURGHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXHSUHYHDVX
DEURJDFLyQ\SURYHDORVHOHPHQWRVSDUDKDFHUOR3HURHOODUJRGHEDWHKLVWyULFR
DFHUFDGHHVWHSHOLJURQRVOOHYDDVXSRQHUTXHSXQWXDOL]DUODVOLPLWDFLRQHVGHO
HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ\ODWXWHODGHORVGHPiV3RGHUHVGHOD8QLyQVREUHODDF
WXDFLyQGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOUHSUHVHQWDXQSDVRHQODGLUHFFLyQFRUUHFWD
8QDVSHFWRIXQGDPHQWDOGHODVUHIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQPDWHULDGHGH
UHFKRVKXPDQRVHVHOUHJUHVRDODLGHDGHTXHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ³UHFRQRFH´ORV
GHUHFKRVGHORVSHUVRQDV/DSURSXHVWDRULJLQDODSDUHFLyHQOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGH
HLQFOXVLYHHQODGH$SDW]LQJiQIXHUHWRPDGDSRUHOFRQVWLWX\HQWH
GH\GHVHFKDGDSRUODYHUVLyQRULJLQDOGHODGH(QHVWD~OWLPDSURGXF
WRGHHQFRQDGRVGHEDWHVOLEHUDOHV\GHtQGROHPiVUDGLFDOVHSUH¿ULyODLGHDGH
TXHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ³RWRUJXH´ORVGHUHFKRVXQSULQFLSLRTXHFODUDPHQWHHQWUDUtD
'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQMXHYHVGHDJRVWRGHHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQ
IMXUOHJFRQVWPH[SGISGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDS
6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
2WRUJDDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO³XQDPD\RUDPSOLWXGGHDFFLyQDGPLQLVWUDWLYD´
)DFXOWDGHVOHJLVODWLYDVH[WUDRUGLQDULDV'HEDWHFRQVWLWXFLRQDORULJLQDGRSRU
9DOODUWDFRQSXQWRVGHYLVWDGLYHUJHQWHV
/DVWUHVPHGLGDVUHVXOWDQDXWyQRPDVDOJUDGRTXHHQYDULRVHMHPSORVKLVWy
ULFRVDSDUHFHQVHSDUDGDVHQGLVWLQWRVGHFUHWRVGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
/DSURPXOJDFLyQGHOD/H\GH6HJXULGDG1DFLRQDOGHIXHFRQVLGHUDGD
XQPRPHQWRIXQGDPHQWDOSDUDUHFRQVLGHUDUODQRUPDWLYDUHIHUHQWHDODVXVSHQ
VLyQGHJDUDQWtDV&DVWDxHGDSURSXVRHVHPLVPRDxRHODERUDUXQDOH\UHJOD
PHQWDULDTXHGHPDQHUDFRPSOHPHQWDULDDpVWDVLUYLHUDFRPRDFRWDPLHQWRD
ODVIDFXOWDGHVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOSXHVRSLQDEDTXHODGLVFUHFLRQDOLGDGHQOD
DSOLFDFLyQGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVFRQVWLWXtDXQVHULRSHOLJURSDUDODVR
FLHGDG(QVXRSLQLyQXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDSRGUtDHVWDEOHFHU
>@ODSUHFLVLyQGHH[SUHVLRQHVTXHIUHFXHQWHPHQWHSURSLFLDQXQDDUELWUDULDLQWHU
SUHWDFLyQGHFRQVHFXHQFLDVFRQWUDULDVDOHVStULWXPLVPRGHODGLVSRVLFLyQ\DUHIH
ULGDWDOHVFRPR³LQYDVLyQ´³SHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFD´³JUDYHSHOLJUR
RFRQÀLFWR´³REVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\IiFLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ´FRPR
6HUJLR*DUFtD5DPtUH]³5HIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQHOiPELWRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV´&RQ
IHUHQFLD0DJLVWUDO)RUR,QWHUQDFLRQDO'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV7UDQVSDUHQFLD\(GXFDFLyQ&RPSOHMR&XO
WXUDO8QLYHUVLWDULRGHOD%HQHPpULWD8QLYHUVLGDG$XWyQRPDGH3XHEOD3XHEODGHMXQLRGH
+)&DVWDxHGD-LPpQH]op. citsupraQRWDS
0GHOD&XHYDop. citsupraQRWDSS
85
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
DxRVGHVSXpVHQFRQWUDGLFFLyQFRQODYRFDFLyQLXVQDWXUDOLVWDGHORVGHUHFKRV
KXPDQRVWDO\FRPRVHWHRUL]DQHQ0p[LFR(QVXDUWtFXOR³/DLQGHIHQVLyQGH
ORVJREHUQDGRVDQWHHOULHVJRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV´+pFWRU&DVWDxHGD
-LPpQH]VHxDODTXHGXUDQWHODUJRWLHPSRGHVGHODSURPXOJDFLyQGHOD&RQVWL
WXFLyQGHHODUWtFXORFRQVWLWXFLRQDOKDEtDSDUHFLGR³LQRFXR´GHELGRDOD
HVWDELOLGDGQDFLRQDO\ODSURJUHVLYDFRQVROLGDFLyQGHODVLQVWLWXFLRQHV(VFULELHQ
GRHQDSXQWDTXHXQDVHULHGHULHVJRVLQWHUQRVFRQÀLFWRVHQWUHORV3RGH
UHVGHOD8QLyQPHVLDQLVPRLUUHVSRQVDELOLGDGGHORVDFWRUHVSROtWLFRVDVtFRPR
H[WHUQRVPD\RULQWHUYHQFLRQLVPRGHELGRDODJOREDOL]DFLyQLQVWUXPHQWRVLQWHU
QDFLRQDOHVDSOLFDEOHVHQHOFRQWH[WRKDFtDQQHFHVDULRUHFRQVLGHUDUHVWDLQD
PRYLOLGDGGHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO3DUDpOODFDUHQFLDSULQFLSDOHVODPLVPDTXH
DKRUDUHFRQRFHPRVDUDt]GHODUHFLHQWHUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQPDWHULDGH
'HUHFKRV+XPDQRVODSHOLJURVDDXVHQFLDGHXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDTXHVLUYD
FRPR³LQVWUXPHQWRDGHFXDGRSDUDGDUUHVSXHVWDRSRUWXQD\HILFD]DOD
VRFLHGDG´
/DH[SHULHQFLDKLVWyULFDPXHVWUDTXHHQORVDUWtFXORVGHODFRQVWLWXFLRQHV
GH\VHWUDWyGHOLPLWDUODVIDFXOWDGHVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDODOGHFUHWDU
ODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV'HOD&XHYDDUJXPHQWDTXHFRQVLGHUDQGRTXHOD
GRFWULQDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOPH[LFDQDSDUWHGHODEDVHGHTXHWRGRDFWRGHDXWRULGDG
TXHYLROHODQRUPDPi[LPDHVQXORHQWLHPSRVQRUPDOHVDXQHQXQHVWDGRGH
H[FHSFLyQQRVHSRGUtDHPLWLUOH\DOJXQDHQHVWHVHQWLGRGHFRQWUDYHQFLyQ'HV
GHHVWHSXQWRGHYLVWDHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQSUHYLVWRHQDPERVDUWtFXORVLPSOL
FDWUHVPHGLGDV
SXHGHREVHUYDUVHODVXEMHWLYLGDGGHGLFKDVH[SUHVLRQHVSHUPLWHP~OWLSOHVLQWHU
SUHWDFLRQHVDOFDSULFKRGHORVJREHUQDQWHVHQWXUQR
Carlos Brokmann Haro
86
(QEmpire+DUW\1HJULKDQSURSXHVWRTXHHOPRPHQWRGHODVGHPRFUDFLDV
OLEHUDOHVKDWHUPLQDGRGHELGRDODFULVLVGHOHJLWLPLGDGTXHVXIUHQDUDt]GHOD
VREUHUUHDFFLyQPLOLWDUGH(VWDGRV8QLGRVDXQDQWHVGHORVDWHQWDGRVGHO
$OLGHQWL¿FDUQXHYDVIRUPDVGHOLPSHULDOLVPRDSOLFDGRFRPR³VROXFLyQ´GHORV
FRQÀLFWRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVORGXGRVRGHOPpWRGRSXHGHYHUVHHQORV³FDVRVH[L
WRVRV´FRPROD³GHPRFUDFLDSDUODPHQWDULD´HQ,UDNROD³SDFL¿FDFLyQ´DFWXDOGH
$IJDQLVWiQ3RRWUDSDUWHODFUHDFLyQGHXQGLVFXUVRTXHSURPXHYHHOOLEHUDOLV
PRFRPRXQDIRUPDPRUDOPHQWHVXSHULRUDWUDYpVGHODREUDGH5DZOVR)XNX
\DPDVHSHUSHW~DQODVGHVLJXDOGDGHV\GHVWUX\HODSRVLELOLGDGGHXQGLiORJR
HQWUHVHFWRUHV\FXOWXUDV
8QPDUFRIXQGDPHQWDOSDUDHQWHQGHUODVUHIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQGHUH
FKRVKXPDQRVGHHVODLQFRUSRUDFLyQGHFULWHULRVGHULYDGRVGHOGHUHFKR
LQWHUQDFLRQDOGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVYHU(VTXHPD(QODRSLQLyQGHGLYHU
VRVMXULVWDVUHFRQRFLGRVODLQÀXHQFLDSULQFLSDOTXHWXYLHURQORVOHJLVODGRUHV
HVSHFLDOPHQWHOD&iPDUDGH'LSXWDGRVDOHQYLDUSRUVHJXQGDRFDVLyQODLQLFLD
WLYDDORVVHQDGRUHVIXHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV
(VWDSHUFHSFLyQODFRPSDUWLPRVSRUFRPSOHWR8QEUHYHDQiOLVLVGHODUWtFXOR
GHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRVTXHVHUH¿HUHDORVHV
WDGRVGHH[FHSFLyQDWUDYpVGHODFWRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVQRVPXHVWUD
HVWRVSDUDOHOLVPRV$XWRUHVFRPR&DVWDxHGDUHVDOWDQHOKHFKRGHTXHGDGR
TXHHVWHDUWtFXORQRVHUH¿HUHRFRUUHODFLRQDFRQRWURVGHQWURGHODPLVPD&RQ
YHQFLyQHVQHFHVDULRFRQVLGHUDUTXHODVOLPLWDFLRQHVSDUDVXLPSOHPHQWDFLyQ
GHEHQWHQHUSRUIXHU]DFDUiFWHULQWHUQRHQFDGDSDtV3RUHVWHPRWLYRHVIXQ
GDPHQWDOFRQWDUFRQXQDSDUDWRMXUtGLFRTXHSURYHDHVWHPDUFRGHSURWHFFLyQGH
PDQHUDQDFLRQDO(ODUWtFXORGHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV
+XPDQRVVHxDODSXQWXDOPHQWH
$UWtFXOR6XVSHQVLyQGH*DUDQWtDV
(QFDVRGHJXHUUDGHSHOLJURS~EOLFRRGHRWUDHPHUJHQFLDTXHDPHQDFHOD
LQGHSHQGHQFLDRVHJXULGDGGHO(VWDGRSDUWHpVWHSRGUiDGRSWDUGLVSRVLFLRQHV
TXHHQODPHGLGD\SRUHOWLHPSRHVWULFWDPHQWHOLPLWDGRVDODVH[LJHQFLDVGHOD
VLWXDFLyQVXVSHQGDQODVREOLJDFLRQHVFRQWUDtGDVHQYLUWXGGHHVWD&RQYHQFLyQ
VLHPSUHTXHWDOHVGLVSRVLFLRQHVQRVHDQLQFRPSDWLEOHVFRQODVGHPiVREOLJDFLR
QHVTXHOHVLPSRQHHOGHUHFKRLQWHUQDFLRQDO\QRHQWUDxHQGLVFULPLQDFLyQDOJXQD
IXQGDGDHQPRWLYRVGHUD]DFRORUVH[RLGLRPDUHOLJLyQXRULJHQVRFLDO
/DGLVSRVLFLyQSUHFHGHQWHQRDXWRUL]DODVXVSHQVLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVGHWHU
PLQDGRVHQORVVLJXLHQWHVDUWtFXORV'HUHFKRDO5HFRQRFLPLHQWRGHOD3HUVRQD
OLGDG-XUtGLFD'HUHFKRDOD9LGD'HUHFKRDOD,QWHJULGDG3HUVRQDO3UR
KLELFLyQGHOD(VFODYLWXG\6HUYLGXPEUH3ULQFLSLRGH/HJDOLGDG\GH
5HWURDFWLYLGDG/LEHUWDGGH&RQFLHQFLD\GH5HOLJLyQ3URWHFFLyQDOD
)DPLOLD'HUHFKRDO1RPEUH'HUHFKRVGHO1LxR'HUHFKRDOD1D
+)&DVWDxHGD-LPpQH]op. citsupraQRWDSS
(*LOEHUWop. citsupraQRWDS
&DVWDxHGD\RWURVHVSHFLDOLVWDVHQHO6LVWHPD,QWHUDPHULFDQRKDQDSXQWDGR
DOJXQDVREVHUYDFLRQHVDODQRUPDWLYDUHODWLYDDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHQ
WURGHOD&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV(OSDFWRGH6DQ-RVp
HVHOSULPHULQVWUXPHQWRLQWHUQDFLRQDOHQSURKLELUH[SUHVDPHQWHODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHODV³JDUDQWtDVMXGLFLDOHVLQGLVSHQVDEOHV´'HHVWDPDQHUDVHFRQVWUX\HXQ
PDUFRPtQLPRGHSURWHFFLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVH[SUHVDGRV\DVHDD
WUDYpVGHJDUDQWtDVRGHGHUHFKRV(ODFWRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHEH
WHQHUFRPROLPLWDQWHHOQRH[FHGHUORHVWULFWDPHQWHQHFHVDULRSDUDHQIUHQWDUHO
HVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDSRUHOFXDOIXHLQYRFDGR(VIXQGDPHQWDOTXHODVXVSHQ
VLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVHLQYRTXHGHPDQHUDFODUDFRQPRWLYRVELHQIXQGDPHQWDGRV
\FRQJUDQSUHFLVLyQHQVXVDOFDQFHVHQORTXHVHUH¿HUHDODVXVSHQVLyQSDUFLDO
RWRWDOGHORVGHUHFKRVDVtFRPRDVXGXUDFLyQ/DDFWXDFLyQGHODDXWRULGDGQR
GHEHUiVREUHSDVDUSRUQLQJ~QPRWLYRORVOtPLWHVTXHpVWDPLVPDWUD]yHQHOGH
FUHWRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV(VWHSULQFLSLRGHMDLPSOtFLWDODQHFHVLGDGGH
FRQWDUFRQXQPHFDQLVPRRDXWRULGDGTXHWXWHOH\FRQWUROHDODSULPHUDGXUDQWH
HOSHULRGR
/DIDOWDGHSUHFLVLyQ\GHOLPLWDFLyQGHORVDOFDQFHVGHODUWtFXORKDEtDVLGR
VXEUD\DGD\QRWDGDSRUGLVWLQWRVLQYHVWLJDGRUHVDWUDYpVGHVXKLVWRULD/DVUH
IRUPDVDOWH[WRGHOOHYDGDVDFDERHQ\QRFXEUtDQXQDPtQLPD
SURSRUFLyQGHODVGXGDV\REMHFLRQHVMXUtGLFDV3DUD6LOYDHOSUREOHPDVHFRQ
YHUWtDHQXQRGHPD\RUHVSURSRUFLRQHVDOFRQVLGHUDUOD³HVFDVDLQWHUSUHWDFLyQ
GHOPLVPRSRUORVyUJDQRVGHLQWHUSUHWDFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDO´WRGDYtDHQSRU
ORFXDOXQDUHIRUPDGHPD\RUHVDOFDQFHVHUDIXQGDPHQWDOSDUDIRUWDOHFHUODFHU
WH]D(OPLVPRDXWRUSURSRQtD\DFRPRVHKL]RHQODUHIRUPDDFWXDOTXHKDEtD
TXHLQFRUSRUDUODVFRQVLGHUDFLRQHVGHORVLQVWUXPHQWRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVUDWL¿FD
GRVSRU0p[LFRFRPRPDUFRQHFHVDULRSDUDD¿QDUVXSRVLEOHDSOLFDFLyQ
/DUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQPDWHULDGHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVSXEOLFDGDHQHO
'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQHOYLHUQHVGHGHMXQLRGHIXHSURGXFWRGH
XQULFRGHEDWHHLQWHUFDPELRGHLGHDVGHVGHYDULRVDxRVDWUiV9LVWRGHPDQH
UDLQWHJUDOVHRULJLQyDWUDYpVGHODFRQÀXHQFLDGHLQLFLDWLYDVGLYHUVDVTXHFXO
PLQDURQFRQXQGLFWDPHQGHOD&iPDUDGH'LSXWDGRVHQ$OHQYLDUORDOD
&iPDUDGH6HQDGRUHVpVWDORUHWRPyHQULTXHFLyODGLVFXVLyQ\WHUPLQySRU
DPSOLDUODKDVWDDOFDQ]DUHOQLYHOGHXQDDXWpQWLFDUHIRUPDHQGHUHFKRVKXPD
QRV(OQ~PHURGHDUWtFXORVDPRGL¿FDUVDOWyGHFLQFRDHQHOGLFWDPHQGHORV
VHQDGRUHVDSUREDGRHOGHDEULOGHO/DWUDQVIRUPDFLyQUHVXOWyGHDOFDQ
FHVVXSHULRUHVDORRULJLQDOPHQWHSUHYLVWRSRUORTXHOD&iPDUDGH'LSXWDGRV
QRVHFLxy~QLFDPHQWHDYRWDUODVLQRTXHDVXYH]ODUHYLVySRUFRPSOHWR\SUR
&RQYHQFLyQ$PHULFDQDVREUH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV³3DFWRGH6DQ-RVpGH&RVWD5LFD´HQKWWS
ZZZFRPLVLRQYDOHFKJRYFO¿FKDV&RQYHQFLRQ$PHULFDQDGH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRVSGI
FRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
*XVWDYRGH6LOYD*XWLpUUH]³6XVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV$QiOLVLVGHODUWtFXORFRQVWLWXFLRQDO´HQ
Cuestiones Constitucionales. Revista Mexicana de Derecho Constitucional0p[LFRQ~PMXOLRGL
FLHPEUHGHS
³'HFUHWRSRUHOTXHVHPRGL¿FDODGHQRPLQDFLyQGHO&DStWXOR,GHO7tWXOR3ULPHUR\UHIRUPDGLYHUVRV
DUWtFXORVGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV´'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQ
W'&;&,,,Q~PYLHUQHVGHMXQLRGH
87
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
FLRQDOLGDG\'HUHFKRV3ROtWLFRVQLGHODVJDUDQWtDVMXGLFLDOHVLQGLVSHQVDEOHV
SDUDODSURWHFFLyQGHWDOHVGHUHFKRV
Carlos Brokmann Haro
88
SXVRQXHYDVPRGL¿FDFLRQHV/DPLQXWDGHORVGLSXWDGRVIXHHQYLDGDGHUHJUHVR
DOD&iPDUDGH6HQDGRUHVHQGLFLHPEUHGHGLVFXWLGDDSUREDGD\SXEOL
FDGDHQODIHFKDTXH\DPHQFLRQDPRV
/DSULPHUDGHODVUHVROXFLRQHVFRQHIHFWRVHQHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDOIXHVRV
WHQHUHQHOSULPHUSiUUDIRODWUDGLFLRQDOGLVWLQFLyQHQWUHXQDVXVSHQVLyQGHJD
UDQWtDVJHQHUDOHQHOQLYHOQDFLRQDO\XQDORFDO3HURHOSULQFLSLRIXHFRPSOH
PHQWDGRFRQGRVQXHYDVIyUPXODVGHODVFXDOHVODPiVPHQFLRQDGDVHUH¿HUHD
TXHDKRUDVHKDEODGH³JDUDQWtDV´\GH³GHUHFKRV´VLQGLVWLQJXLUHQHVWHWH[WRHV
SHFt¿FRVXVGH¿QLFLRQHVSXQWXDOHV&RPRVHDHVWRDEUHODSXHUWDDODTXHFRQ
VLGHUDPRVXQDPRGL¿FDFLyQGHPD\RUHVDOFDQFHVHQODFXDOVHGLVWLQJXHHQWUH
OD³VXVSHQVLyQ´\OD³UHVWULFFLyQ´GHORVGHUHFKRV\ODVJDUDQWtDVORTXHSHUPLWH
DYL]RUDUTXHODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDTXHWHQGUiTXHSURPXOJDUVHHQHOSOD]RGHXQ
DxRDFRUGHFRQHODUWtFXORWUDQVLWRULRFXDUWRGHHVWDUHIRUPDGHEHUiFRQVLGHUDU
\GH¿QLUFRQFODULGDGHVWDVGRVFDWHJRUtDV1RROYLGHPRVTXHODH[SHULHQFLD
KLVWyULFDFRQHVWDVODJXQDVMXUtGLFDVVHKDSUHVWDGRDORVH[FHVRVGHO(MHFXWLYR
)HGHUDOSRUORTXHHVWHWLSRGHSUHFLVLRQHVGHEHUiVHUPX\SXQWXDO
/DSURWHFFLyQDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVIXQGDPHQWDOHVRHO³Q~FOHRGXUR´
FRPRORVOODPDQDOJXQRVHVSHFLDOLVWDVGHULYDGLUHFWDPHQWHGHOD&$'+FRPR
KHPRVYLVWR'HQWURGHHVWHPDUFRODOLPLWDFLyQDVXDIHFWDFLyQGLUHFWDQRVH
UH¿HUHVRODPHQWHDODVUHIRUPDVLQWURGXFLGDVHQHODUWtFXORVLQRTXHFRPLHQ
]DQGHVGHHO3ULPHUR/DQHFHVLGDGGHSXQWXDOL]DUORVDOFDQFHVGHXQDVXVSHQ
VLyQGHJDUDQWtDVHUDWDQHYLGHQWHTXH*DUFtD5DPtUH]DSXQWD
&RPRVHDUHVXOWDLQDGPLVLEOHTXHHO&RQVWLWX\HQWHGHVFRQR]FDORVGHUHFKRVIXQ
GDPHQWDOHVDGXFLHQGRODVSRWHVWDGHVTXHOHWUDQVPLWHODVREHUDQtDGHOSXHEOR
,QFOXVRpVWDWLHQHIURQWHUDVODGLJQLGDGKXPDQD(OGLFWDPHQGHORVGLSXWDGRVGH
GLFLHPEUHGHHVHQIiWLFRXWLOL]DWpUPLQRVLPSHQVDEOHVKDFHSRFRVDxRV+H
PRVDYDQ]DGRXQODUJRWUHFKRDODFHSWDUTXHHOSRGHUUHYLVRUGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ
6HUJLR*DUFtD5DPtUH]³+DFLDXQDQXHYDUHJXODFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV
´HQBoletín Mexicano de Derecho Comparado0p[LFRDxR;/,9Q~PPD\RDJRVWR
GHS
/DVGLVFXVLRQHVDFHUFDGHODVGLIHUHQFLDVHQWUHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\JDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVHV
DxHMD\FRQVLGHUDPRVTXHQRWHQHPRVDEVROXWDPHQWHQDGDTXHDSRUWDUGHELGRDVXHVSHFLDOL]DFLyQ
3HURUHWRPDPRVODLGHDGH*DUFtD5DPtUH]DFHUFDGHTXHHQUHDOLGDGQRHVGHJUDQLPSRUWDQFLDVLDWHQ
GHPRVDORVUHVXOWDGRVSUiFWLFRV\GHSURWHFFLyQGHODOHJLVODFLyQ\QRWDQWRDVXVDVSHFWRVQRPLQDOLVWDV
6*DUFtD5DPtUH]³5HIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQHOiPELWRGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV´FLWsupraQRWD
6HUJLR*DUFtD5DPtUH]DSXQWDTXHODGLVWLQFLyQHQWUH³VXVSHQVLyQ´\³UHVWULFFLyQ´SRGUtDIXQGD
PHQWDUVHHQODSURSLD&$'+SHURTXHVXLPSOHPHQWDFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLPSOLFDVHJXLUXQGREOHGHUUR
WHUR(QVtQWHVLVVHWUDWDUtDGHXQDDSOLFDFLyQGHODUWtFXORSDUDFDVRV³PiVJUDYHV´VXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDV\XQDSDUDFDVRV³QRWDQJUDYHV´UHVWULFFLyQGHJDUDQWtDV3URSRQHTXH³3DUDUHVROYHUHVWH
SUREOHPDHQIRUPDUD]RQDEOH\FRQVWUXFWLYDVHSRGUtDHQWHQGHUTXHHOQXHYRVLVWHPDGHDIHFWDFLyQ
²JpQHURDOTXHFRUUHVSRQGHQODVXVSHQVLyQ\ODUHVWULFFLyQ²VHSUR\HFWDHQGRVGLUHFFLRQHVRYHUWLHQ
WHVORFXDOVLJQL¿FDUtDODDGPLVLyQGHXQDQRYHGRVDKLSyWHVLVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOTXHWHQGUtDHQVXIDYRU
EXHQDVUD]RQHVGHOHJLWLPLGDG\XWLOLGDG(QXQFDVRTXHGDUtDFRPSUHQGLGDODVXVSHQVLyQGHGHUHFKRV
\JDUDQWtDVTXHLPSOLFDODDOWHUDFLyQFRPSOHWDGHOHMHUFLFLRGHDTXpOORV(QHORWURTXHGDUtDQLQFOXLGDV
FLHUWDVUHVWULFFLRQHVGLIHUHQWHVGHODVTXHQDWXUDOPHQWHSXGLHUDQJUDYLWDUVREUHGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDVSRU
ODYtDGHODOHJLVODFLyQRUGLQDULDGHULYDGDGHDXWRUL]DFLRQHVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVRLQWHUQDFLRQDOHV\DH[LV
WHQWHV(QRWURVWpUPLQRVODVUHVWULFFLRQHVDFRJLGDVHQpVWHVHUtDQDIHFWDFLRQHVHVSHFt¿FDV\H[FHSFLR
QDOHVGHWHUPLQDGDVSRUODVJUDYHVFLUFXQVWDQFLDVTXHLQYRFDHOSULPHUSiUUDIRGHOSUHFHSWR´6*DUFtD
5DPtUH]op. citsupraQRWDSS
&RQHVWDVFRQVLGHUDFLRQHVODDOWHUDFLyQGHOWH[WRGHODUWtFXORUHVXOWDED
YLUWXDOPHQWHXQDREOLJDFLyQSDUDORVOHJLVODGRUHV+HPRVYLVWRTXHODVGRVUH
IRUPDVDQWHULRUHVVyORVLJQL¿FDURQDFWXDOL]DFLRQHVGHQRPHQFODWXUDHQXQFDVR
\VHPiQWLFDVHQHORWUR3HURHOGHVDUUROORGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVHQQXHVWUR
SDtVGHMyPX\DWUiVODOyJLFDVRFLDO\SROtWLFDTXHVHHQFRQWUDEDHQHOVHQRGHO
WH[WRRULJLQDOVXUJLGRGLUHFWDPHQWHGHOD&3(80GH'HPDQHUDTXHOD
&iPDUDGH6HQDGRUHVSURSXVRXQDVHULHGHPRGL¿FDFLRQHVGHODUJRDOFDQFH
TXHHQFRQMXQWRVLJQL¿FDQODPD\RUUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQHVWHVHQWLGRGHVGH
ODIXQGDFLyQGHODVLQVWLWXFLRQHVVREHUDQDVHQQXHVWUDQDFLyQ(OSULPHUREMHWLYR
FRPRUHVDOWDURQ&DVWDxHGD'HOD&XHYD*DOODUGR\RWURVHVSHFLDOLVWDVIXHOD
DGHFXDFLyQGHODOHJLVODFLyQQDFLRQDODFRUGHFRQORVLQVWUXPHQWRVLQWHUQDFLR
QDOHVHQGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVGHORVTXHVRPRVSDUWH /DSULQFLSDOGHHVWDV
DSRUWDFLRQHVGHODOHJLVODFLyQLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVVLQOXJDUDGXGDVHO³Q~FOHRGXUR´
TXHVHxDODPRVHQUHODFLyQFRQHODUWtFXORGHOD&$'+6XFRQFRUGDQFLD
FRQORVSULQFLSLRVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVVHDSUHFLDHQHOVHJXQGRSiUUDIRGHOQXHYR
DUWtFXORTXHGLFH
(QORVGHFUHWRVTXHVHH[SLGDQQRSRGUiUHVWULQJLUVHQLVXVSHQGHUVHHOHMHUFLFLR
GHORVGHUHFKRVDODQRGLVFULPLQDFLyQDOUHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODSHUVRQDOLGDGMXUt
GLFDDODYLGDDODLQWHJULGDGSHUVRQDODODSURWHFFLyQDODIDPLOLDDOQRPEUHD
ODQDFLRQDOLGDGORVGHUHFKRVGHODQLxH]ORVGHUHFKRVSROtWLFRVODVOLEHUWDGHV
GHSHQVDPLHQWRFRQFLHQFLD\GHSURIHVDUFUHHQFLDUHOLJLRVDDOJXQDHOSULQFLSLRGH
OHJDOLGDG\UHWURDFWLYLGDGODSURKLELFLyQGHODSHQDGHPXHUWHODSURKLELFLyQGHOD
HVFODYLWXG\ODVHUYLGXPEUHODSURKLELFLyQGHODGHVDSDULFLyQIRU]DGD\ODWRUWXUD
QLODVJDUDQWtDVMXGLFLDOHVLQGLVSHQVDEOHVSDUDODSURWHFFLyQGHWDOHVGHUHFKRV
(VWHSiUUDIRUH~QHORVGHUHFKRVFHQWUDOHVGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\UH
SUHVHQWDVLQOXJDUDGXGDVXQRGHORVORJURVSULQFLSDOHVGHODUHIRUPD$OSUR
WHJHUGHPDQHUDLQHTXtYRFDXQDVHULHGHSULQFLSLRVOLPLWDGHPDQHUDGHFLVLYDOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\HYLWDDOJXQRVGHORVSULQFLSDOHVSHOLJURVTXHMXULVWDV
FRPR'HOD&XHYDGHQXQFLDURQ1RREVWDQWHWHQHPRVWRGDYtDDOJXQDVGXGDV
HVSHFt¿FDVHQFXDQWRDODUHGDFFLyQGHOWH[WR3RUHMHPSORDOPHQFLRQDUTXH
QRVHSXHGHQDIHFWDU³ODVJDUDQWtDVMXGLFLDOHVLQGLVSHQVDEOHVSDUDODSURWHFFLyQ
GHWDOHVGHUHFKRV´QRVSDUHFHTXHVHWUDWDGHXQDFREHUWXUDUHVWULQJLGD1RVH
SUHVHUYDHOSULQFLSLRJHQHUDOGHPDQHUDTXHSRGUtDLQWHUSUHWDUVHFRPRVXFHGLy
HQ(VWDGRV8QLGRVFRQHOPatriot ActGHXQDSRVLEOHYLRODFLyQGHODVJDUDQWtDV
MXGLFLDOHVQRSUHYLVWDVHQHOSiUUDIR3RURWUDSDUWHHQODDFWXDOLGDGVHYLYHHQ
DOJXQDVUHJLRQHVGH0p[LFRXQDVLWXDFLyQDQiORJDDORTXH$JDPEHQGHQRPLQD
Ibid.SS
9pDQVHSRUHMHPSORODVSURSXHVWDVHQPDWHULDGHFRQFRUGDQFLDGHODOHJLVODFLyQQDFLRQDOHQPD
WHULDGH)XHUR0LOLWDUFRQORVSULQFLSLRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVHQ-RVp)UDQFLVFR*DOODUGR5RGUtJXH]Ejército
y sociedad en México: reforma de las fuerzas armadas7HVLVGRFWRUDO0p[LFR81$0)&36
³'(&5(72SRUHOTXHVHPRGL¿FDODGHQRPLQDFLyQGHO&DStWXOR,GHO7tWXOR3ULPHUR\UHIRUPDGL
YHUVRVDUWtFXORVGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV´'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGH
UDFLyQW'&;&,,,Q~PYLHUQHVGHMXQLRGH
89
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
QRSXHGHDUUROODUODGLJQLGDGKXPDQDQLGHVFRQRFHUORVGHUHFKRVTXHGHULYDQGH
HOOD
Carlos Brokmann Haro
90
³HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ¿FWLFLR´HOHPSRGHUDPLHQWR\DPSOLDFLyQGHODVFDSDFL
GDGHVGHODVIXHU]DVSROLFLDOHV\DUPDGDVPiVDOOiGHVXPDQGDWRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
HQXQDVLWXDFLyQ³QRUPDO´3HURLPSOLFDTXHQRHVQHFHVDULRLPSOHPHQWDUXQ
HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ³UHDO´TXHUHTXLHUHXQDVHULHGHSDVRVMXUtGLFRVTXHOHGHQ
OHJLWLPLGDGVRFLDO6HJHQHUDSRUORWDQWRXQDLQGH¿QLFLyQMXUtGLFDTXHGHVHP
ERFDHQODLQFHUWLGXPEUHSROtWLFD\VRFLDO([WHQGHUHVWDVLWXDFLyQDOIXWXURUH
SUHVHQWDUtDXQDJUDYHIDOODGHODVLQVWLWXFLRQHVTXHGHEHQDSURYHFKDUODVUHIRU
PDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQPDWHULDGHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVSDUDDPSOLDUVX
SURWHFFLyQQRSDUDFRQWLQXDUYLROiQGRORVVRWHUUDGDPHQWH
(OWHUFHUSiUUDIRGHODUWtFXORHVFRPSOHWDPHQWHQXHYR\VHUH¿HUHDORV
SULQFLSLRVTXHQRUPDQWDQWRODUHVWULFFLyQFRPRODVXVSHQVLyQGHORVGHUHFKRV
\ODVJDUDQWtDV³/DUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQGHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRV\JD
UDQWtDVGHEHHVWDUIXQGDGD\PRWLYDGDHQORVWpUPLQRVHVWDEOHFLGRVSRUHVWD
&RQVWLWXFLyQ\VHUSURSRUFLRQDODOSHOLJURDTXHVHKDFHIUHQWHREVHUYDQGRHQ
WRGRPRPHQWRORVSULQFLSLRVGHOHJDOLGDGUDFLRQDOLGDGSURFODPDFLyQSXEOLFLGDG
\QRGLVFULPLQDFLyQ´
(VWHSiUUDIRFRQVWLWX\HWDPELpQXQDDSRUWDFLyQGHSULPHUDLPSRUWDQFLDGDGR
TXHHQVXDQiOLVLVKLVWyULFR'HOD&XHYDVXEUD\DEDHQYDULDVRFDVLRQHVORVSUR
EOHPDVRFDVLRQDGRVSRUQRFRQWDUFRQQLQJXQDOLPLWDFLyQH[SOtFLWDSDUDODDP
SOLDFLyQGHSRGHUHVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOQLPXFKRPHQRVFRQXQDEDVHSDUD
FRQWURODUORGXUDQWHHVWHSHULRGR5HFRUGHPRVTXHHQHOSUHVLGHQWHÈYLOD
&DPDFKRHPLWLyXQDVHULHGHGHFUHWRVTXHQRVRODPHQWHH[FHGtDQODVIURQWHUDV
TXHWHyULFDPHQWHOHKDEtDQPDUFDGROD&RQVWLWXFLyQ\HO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ
VLQRTXHHQXQPRPHQWRGDGRSDUHFLHURQVXSHUDUODVFDSDFLGDGHVMXUtGLFDVGH
XQGLFWDGRUURPDQR3RUHVWDUD]yQ*DUFtD5DPtUH]DSXQWDTXHHQHOWHUFHU
SiUUDIRSXHGHFRQVLGHUDUVHTXH³6HWUDWDGHSULQFLSLRVFOiVLFRVUHFRJLGRVHQOD
MXULVSUXGHQFLDGHOD&RUWH,QWHUDPHULFDQDOHJDOLGDGSURSRUFLRQDOLGDGSURFOD
PDFLyQSXEOLFLGDGQRGLVFULPLQDFLyQ6HSXGRDJUHJDUWHPSRUDOLGDGUHWRPDQ
GRHOFRQFHSWRGHOSULPHUSiUUDIRGHODUWtFXOR\QHFHVLGDGRPHMRUWRGDYtDLQ
GLVSHQVDELOLGDGGHODPHGLGD´
/RVGRV~OWLPRVSiUUDIRVDxDGLGRVDODUWtFXORVLJQL¿FDQFUHDUXQPDUFRGH
PD\RUFHUWLGXPEUH\FRQ¿DELOLGDGDOFRQVWUXLUHOSXHQWHGHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ
DOD³QRUPDOLGDG´\¿QDOPHQWHFRORFDUDOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDGHOD1D
FLyQFRPRXQFRQWUDSHVRDODFDSDFLGDGDXWRULWDULDGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO(VWRV
GRVSiUUDIRV¿QDOHVGHODUWtFXORUHIRUPDGRVHxDODQTXH
&XDQGRVHSRQJD¿QDODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQGHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRV\
JDUDQWtDVELHQVHDSRUFXPSOLUVHHOSOD]RRSRUTXHDVtORGHFUHWHHO&RQJUHVRWR
GDVODVPHGLGDVOHJDOHV\DGPLQLVWUDWLYDVDGRSWDGDVGXUDQWHVXYLJHQFLDTXHGDUiQ
VLQHIHFWRGHIRUPDLQPHGLDWD(O(MHFXWLYRQRSRGUiKDFHUREVHUYDFLRQHVDOGH
FUHWRPHGLDQWHHOFXDOHO&RQJUHVRUHYRTXHODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQ
/RVGHFUHWRVH[SHGLGRVSRUHO(MHFXWLYRGXUDQWHODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQVH
UiQUHYLVDGRVGHR¿FLRHLQPHGLDWDPHQWHSRUOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDGHOD
*$JDPEHQop. citsupraQRWDSS
³'(&5(72«´FLWsupraQRWD
6*DUFtD5DPtUH]op. citsupraQRWDS
*DUFtD5DPtUH]LGHQWL¿FDXQSUREOHPDSUDJPiWLFRHQHOSULPHURGHHVWRV
SiUUDIRV¿QDOHV(QSULQFLSLRVLJQL¿FDTXHODODERUOHJLVODWLYDSDUDODLPSOHPHQ
WDFLyQGHODUWtFXORVHGLYLGLUtDHQXQDIDVHGH³DSUREDFLyQ´TXHFRUUHUtDDFDU
JRGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQWH\HQXQDVHJXQGDVHWUDWDUtDGHOPRPHQWRGH
³DXWRUL]DFLyQ´GHODVPHGLGDVLPSOtFLWDVHQHOGHFUHWRGHVXVSHQVLyQRUHVWULFFLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDV7RGRHVWRDEULUtDXQDVHULHGHFXHVWLRQDPLHQWRVHQVXRSLQLyQ
³¢&XiOHVHODOFDQFHGHVXDSUREDFLyQHQODSULPHUDHWDSD"¢6HWUDWDUtDGHDSUR
EDUXQDVXVSHQVLyQHQVtPLVPDVLQHVWDEOHFHUVXFRQWHQLGR"(VWDSRVLELOLGDG
UHVXOWDLQDFHSWDEOH´
(OSHOLJURQRHVQXHYR<D'HOD&XHYDDGYHUWtDGHOKLDWRTXHH[LVWLyHQOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVGHHQWUHHOGHFUHWRTXHOHGLRSULQFLSLR\ODSUR
PXOJDFLyQGHODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHeO\RWURVFRQQRWDGRVDER
JDGRVDOHUWDURQGHOULHVJRDXWRULWDULR\GHOKHFKRLQFRQWURYHUWLEOHGHTXHHQHVH
ODSVRGHMyGHVHUYLJHQWHFXDOTXLHUJDUDQWtDLQGLYLGXDOLQFOX\HQGRHOGHUHFKRGH
DPSDUR(VHYLGHQWHTXHODIXWXUDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDGHEHUiWRPDUHQFRQVLGH
UDFLyQHVWDVREMHFLRQHVMXUtGLFDVTXHHQXQDVLWXDFLyQGHHPHUJHQFLDQDFLRQDO
SRGUtDQFRQYHUWLUVHHQFRQÀLFWRVSROtWLFRV\VRFLDOHVFRQJUDQIDFLOLGDG
(OSiUUDIR¿QDOGHOQXHYRDUWtFXORVHUH¿HUHDOQXHYRSDSHOTXHOD6XSUHPD
&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDGHOD1DFLyQGHEHUiFXPSOLUHQUHODFLyQFRQVXDSOLFDFLyQ7R
GRVORVGHFUHWRVTXHHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOH[SLGDHQHOPDUFRGHODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDV\GHUHFKRVVHUtDQUHYLVDGRVGHR¿FLRHLQPHGLDWDPHQWHSRUHOWUL
EXQDOORFXDOSURYHHGHXQSULQFLSLRGHFHUWH]DMXUtGLFDDXVHQWHHQODVYHUVLRQHV
DQWHULRUHVGHOWH[WR(OSULQFLSLRKDVLGRDODEDGRSRUQXPHURVRVFRPHQWDULVWDV
HQFROXPQDVSHULRGtVWLFDVSHUR*DUFtD5DPtUH]OHHQFXHQWUDXQVHULRGHIHFWR
6HGHVFULEHXQDYDOLGDFLyQa posterioriORFXDOUHVWDWUDQVSDUHQFLD\SRGUtDSUHV
WDUVHDPDQLREUDVSROtWLFDVHQWUHDPERVSRGHUHV3RUHVWDUD]yQ\DSHVDUGH
VXJUDGRGHGL¿FXOWDGHVWHMXULVWDSURSRQHUHIRUPDUHOWH[WRSDUDTXHSXGLHVH
KDFHUVHGHPRGRTXHOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDGHOD1DFLyQUHYLVDUDORV
SUR\HFWRVRLQLFLDWLYDVSDUDHQFXDGUDUODVHQHORUGHQFRQVWLWXFLRQDO(VWD
PHGLGDQRVSDUHFHLGyQHDSHURHQODSUiFWLFDVLJQL¿FDUtDXQDUHVSXHVWDPiV
OHQWDHQHOPDUFRGHXQDHPHUJHQFLDQDFLRQDOORFXDOSRGUtDUHVXOWDUFRQWUDSUR
GXFHQWH
)LQDOPHQWHQRSRGHPRVGHMDUGHODGRTXHVHGHFUHWyHQORVWUDQVLWRULRVOD
QHFHVLGDGGHSURPXOJDUXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDSDUDDSOLFDUHODUWtFXORUHIRU
PDGRHQHVWRVWpUPLQRV³&XDUWR(O&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQH[SHGLUiOD/H\5H
JODPHQWDULDGHODUWtFXORFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQPDWHULDGHVXVSHQVLyQGHOHMHUFLFLR
³'(&5(72«´FLWsupraQRWD
6*DUFtD5DPtUH]op. citsupraQRWDS
/RVSUREOHPDVSRGUtDQHVWDOODUSRUFXDOTXLHUODGR(QOD/H\GH3UHYLVLRQHV*HQHUDOHVVH
FRQFHGLHURQSRGHUHVWDQDPSOLRVDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOTXHPXFKRVYLHURQHQHOODXQLQVWUXPHQWRGHJR
ELHUQRDXWRULWDULR/RPLVPRVLUYLySDUDUHSULPLUKXHOJDV\PDQLIHVWDFLRQHVTXHSDUDFRQ¿VFDUELHQHVGH
H[WUDQMHURV³VRVSHFKRVRV´(OXVRGLVFUHFLRQDOGHOSRGHUKDVLGRXQDFRQVWDQWHHQQXHVWURSDtVHQWRGRV
ORVHVWUDWRVUHJLRQHV\QLYHOHV/DH[SHULHQFLDGHEHVHUYLUSDUDH[LJLUWUDQVSDUHQFLD\FRQWUDSHVRVSDUD
HYLWDUODVWHQWDFLRQHVDXWRULWDULDVTXHDÀRUDQHQODSROtWLFDHLQVWLWXFLRQHVHQFDGDPRPHQWR
6*DUFtD5DPtUH]op. citsupraQRWDS
91
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
1DFLyQODTXHGHEHUiSURQXQFLDUVHFRQODPD\RUSURQWLWXGVREUHVXFRQVWLWXFLR
QDOLGDG\YDOLGH]
Carlos Brokmann Haro
92
GHORVGHUHFKRV\ODVJDUDQWtDVHQXQSOD]RPi[LPRGHXQDxRFRQWDGRDSDUWLU
GHOLQLFLRGHODYLJHQFLDGHHVWHGHFUHWR´
(QUHIHUHQFLDDODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDUHVHUYDPRVQXHVWURVFRPHQWDULRV¿QDOHV
SDUDFHUUDUHVWHWH[WR1RSRGHPRVGHMDUGHKDFHUKLQFDSLpVLQHPEDUJRHQ
TXHFXDQGRPHQRVGRVGHORVGHFUHWRVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOUHIHUHQWHVDGLIH
UHQWHVPRPHQWRVGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVUHVXOWDURQDFUHPHQWHFULWLFDGRV
HQHVWHVHQWLGR/D/H\GH\OD/H\GH3UHYLVLRQHV*HQHUDOHVIXHURQ
FRQVLGHUDGDVLQVWUXPHQWRVGHODXWRULWDULVPR\VLUYLHURQHQPXFKRVFDVRVSDUD
DFWXDUGHPDQHUDGLVFUHFLRQDOSRUHQFLPDGHORVSULQFLSLRVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV/D
HODERUDFLyQGHHVWDOH\GHEHUiFRQWDUFRQWRGRVORVHOHPHQWRVSDUDDVHJXUDU
ODSURWHFFLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\ODVJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVDOWLHPSRTXH
SHUPLWDDODQDFLyQHQIUHQWDUXQDHPHUJHQFLDGHODPDQHUDPiVH¿FD]SRVLEOH
IV. Retos y balance de la reforma al artículo 29
/DUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVKDVLGRYLVWDGHVGHGLVWLQWDV
SHUVSHFWLYDV3DUDDOJXQRVDQDOLVWDVVHWUDWDGHXQJUDQORJURHQPDWHULDGHDU
PRQL]DFLyQGHORVWUDWDGRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVFRQODOHJLVODFLyQQDFLRQDO3DUD
RWURVODVSULQFLSDOHVYDULDEOHVTXHIXHURQSODVPDGDVHQGH¿QLWLYDVHSXHGHQ
UHIHULUDSUiFWLFDVTXHGHVGHKDFHDxRVLQFOXVLYHGpFDGDVHQFLHUWRVFDVRVVH
YHQtDQSUHVHQWDQGRGHPDQHUDFRWLGLDQDHQHOHVSHFWURSROtWLFR\MXUtGLFRQDFLRQDO
'HODVHYDOXDFLRQHVTXHKHPRVWHQLGRRSRUWXQLGDGGHFRQVXOWDUFRQVLGHUDQGR
TXHODVUHIRUPDVIXHURQSURPXOJDGDVDSHQDVKDFHXQDVSRFDVVHPDQDVQRV
SDUHFHTXHODVGHOGRFWRU6HUJLR*DUFtD5DPtUH]SRQGHUDQFRQJUDQHTXLOLEULR
ORVSURV\FRQWUDVGHDOJXQRVGHORVDVSHFWRVPHGXODUHVGHODVUHIRUPDV(QVX
WH[WR³+DFLDXQDQXHYDUHJXODFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOVREUHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV´\
HQODFRQIHUHQFLDPDJLVWUDO³5HIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQHOiPELWRGHORVGH
UHFKRVKXPDQRV´DGYLHUWHXQDVHULHGHYHQWDMDVLQQHJDEOHVDVtFRPRGHDOJX
QRVSHOLJURVTXHDFHFKDQODDGHFXDGDLPSOHPHQWDFLyQGHODVPLVPDV\VX
WUDQVIRUPDFLyQHQXQPDUFRGH¿QLWLYR3RUSULQFLSLRGHFXHQWDV\FRPRYHUHPRV
DORODUJRGHOWH[WRODUHIRUPDIXHUHVXOWDGRGHXQDVHULHGHSURSXHVWDVGLVtPLOHV
TXHVHRULJLQDURQHQOD&iPDUDGH'LSXWDGRV\SDVDURQGHDOOtDOD&iPDUDGH
6HQDGRUHV(QHOSURFHVRODLQLFLDWLYDVHIXHHQULTXHFLHQGRGHPDQHUDJUDGXDO
HVSHFLDOPHQWHFRQODGHFLVLyQGHDxDGLUPiVDUWtFXORVHQODUHIRUPD$OSDVDU
GHFLQFRDHOQ~PHURGHDUWtFXORVVLJQL¿FyXQUHSODQWHDPLHQWRJHQHUDOGHO
SUR\HFWRSHURDOPLVPRWLHPSRQRVHXWLOL]yHOWLHPSRQLORVIRURVGLVSRQLEOHV
SDUDOOHYDUDFDERXQDFRQVXOWDDPSOLDTXHGHWHFWDUDODVQHFHVLGDGHV\DQKHORV
VRFLDOHV'HPDQHUDTXHODUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOQRIXHSHQVDGDGHPDQHUD
LQWHJUDOVLQRTXHUHVXOWDGHXQDVHULHGHPRGL¿FDFLRQHVODPiVGHODVYHFHV
DFHUWDGDV\SUREDEOHPHQWHH¿FDFHVSHURQRHQIRUPDGHXQSODQWHDPLHQWRGH
QDWXUDOH]DKROtVWLFDRJOREDO3DUD*DUFtD5DPtUH]HVWHFDUiFWHUGHVWDFDHQ
FXDQWRDTXHQRVHWUDWDGHXQSUR\HFWRUHGRQGHDGRHQVtPLVPR\PHQRVD~Q
GHXQDSDUWHPHGXODUGHOSUR\HFWRSROtWLFR$OFRQWUDULR&RPRKDQGHVWDFDGR
YDULRVGHVXVFUtWLFRVLQFOX\HQGRDOPLVPR*DUFtD5DPtUH]ODSRVLEOHDSURED
FLyQGHOD/H\GH6HJXULGDG1DFLRQDOHQWUDUtDHQIUDQFDFRQWUDGLFFLyQFRQVWLWX
³'(&5(72«´FLWsupraQRWD
(QFRQFOXVLyQVHKDSURSXHVWROOHYDUDGHODQWHXQDEXHQDUHIRUPD²TXHSXGRVHU
PHMRU²HQPDWHULDGH'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV(VDUHYLVLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOGHODTXH
KDEUiTXHH[WUDHUORVPHMRUHVIUXWRV²HQORVKHFKRVQR~QLFDPHQWHHQORVGL
FKRV²VHIXQGDHQXQFRPSURPLVRSROtWLFRpWLFR\MXUtGLFRFRQDTXHOORVGHUHFKRV
HVGHFLUFRQHOVXMHWRFHQWUDOGHODRUJDQL]DFLyQVRFLDO\MXUtGLFDHOVHUKXPDQR\
FRQVXVELHQHVPiVLPSRUWDQWHV\WUDVFHQGHQWHV(VHFRPSURPLVRTXHGDUDWL¿FD
GRQRUPDWLYD\SUiFWLFDPHQWHDWUDYpVGHGHUHFKRVJDUDQWtDV\GHEHUHVGHO(V
WDGR/DUHIRUPDVHLQVHUWDHQODPHMRUFRUULHQWHFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHLQWHUQDFLRQDO
FRQWHPSRUiQHD
/DYLROHQFLD\ODLQVHJXULGDGVLHPSUHKDQIRUPDGRSDUWHGHODH[SHULHQFLDGH
JRELHUQR&XDOTXLHUDQiOLVLVKLVWyULFRGHEHUHVDOWDUHVWHKHFKR\VHxDODUTXHIRU
PDQSDUWHGHORVHOHPHQWRVFRQVWLWXWLYRVGHOOLEHUDOLVPRQRGHXQDDOWHUDFLyQGH
VXH[LVWHQFLDEiVLFD'H¿QLUFXDOTXLHUVLWXDFLyQKLVWyULFDFRPRSUHGRPLQDQWH
PHQWHSDFt¿FD\DMHQDDOFRQÀLFWRHVSRUORWDQWRIDOD]\WLHQGHDVHVJDUHOHVWX
GLR\ODVLQWHUSUHWDFLRQHV3DUDDOJXQRVDXWRUHVHOHOHPHQWRTXHGDFRKHUHQFLD
DOOLEHUDOLVPRHVSUHFLVDPHQWHODPDUFDGDWHQGHQFLDKDFLDODLPSRVLFLyQYLROHQ
WDGHXQDVXHUWHGHDQWLOLEHUDOLVPRiliberalismVLHPSUHHQQRPEUHGHODOLEHU
WDG3DUD&DVWDxHGDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVWDO\FRPRTXHGDGHOLQHDGD
HQOD&RQVWLWXFLyQUHSUHVHQWDXQDXWpQWLFRHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ1RREVWDQWH\
GHELGRDTXHODVPHGLGDVUHVWULFWLYDVQRDIHFWDQQHFHVDULDPHQWHWRGDVODVJD
UDQWtDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVOHSDUHFHTXHQRUHSUHVHQWDHQVtPLVPDXQDVXVSHQVLyQ
GHO(VWDGRGH'HUHFKR(VWRREHGHFHDTXHODVDXWRULGDGHVQRGHEHUtDQH[FHGHU
ORVOtPLWHVOHJDOHVHQVXDFWXDFLyQSUHPLVDTXHHOPLVPR&DVWDxHGDFRQVLGHUD
EDVDGDPiVHQODEXHQDIHTXHHQXQDUHVWULFFLyQHIHFWLYD(QHVWHSXQWRHVFRQ
YHQLHQWHUHFRUGDUODVLGHDVGH6FKPLWW\$JDPEHQDFHUFDGHOSUREOHPD(OSHOLJUR
GHFRQYHUWLUHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHQODQRUPDOLGDGQRHVXQYXHORGHLPDJLQD
FLyQ(QOD$OHPDQLDGHHQWUHJXHUUDVODVXVSHQVLyQGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGH:HLPDU
SRU³QHFHVLGDGHVGH(VWDGR´GHVHPERFyGLUHFWDPHQWHHQODGLFWDGXUDGH+LWOHU
0iVGHOGHORVDOHPDQHVUDWL¿FDURQODVLWXDFLyQDWUDYpVGHXQUHIHUpQGXP
KiELOPHQWHFRQGXFLGR/DGHFLVLyQSROtWLFDKDEtDOOHYDGRDXQQXHYRHVWDGRGH
FRVDVHQHOFXDOODH[FHSFLyQVHWUDQVIRUPyHQXQDQXHYDQRUPDOLGDG(OH¿FD]
DSDUDWRMXUtGLFRDOHPiQVLUYLySDUDOHJLWLPDUHORUGHQTXHHQRULJHQVyORWHQtD
FDUiFWHUSROtWLFR\ORHULJLyHQXQQXHYR(VWDGRGH'HUHFKREDVDGRHQODDQXOD
FLyQGHJUDQSDUWHGHORVSULQFLSLRVOLEHUDOHV\GHPRFUiWLFRV
6*DUFtD5DPtUH]op. cit supraQRWDS
(*LOEHUWop. citsupraQRWDS
+)&DVWDxHGD-LPpQH]op. citsupraQRWDSS
93
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
FLRQDOFRQORVSUHFHSWRVUHIRUPDGRVHQORTXHVHUH¿HUHDODSURWHFFLyQGHORV
GHUHFKRVKXPDQRV$VXYH]HVWDUHIRUPDSDUHFHHQWUDUHQFRQÀLFWRFRQODV
SURSXHVWDVGHODUHFLHQWHUHIRUPDSHQDO³UHVXOWDGRGHFRQFLOLDFLRQHVHQWUHH[
WUHPRVLQFRQFLOLDEOHVGHPRFUDFLD\DXWRULWDULVPR´(VGHFLUQRSRGHPRVYHUOD
FRPRXQFRQMXQWRDFDEDGR\DUPyQLFRSHURVtFRPRXQDVHULHGHLPSRUWDQWHV
DYDQFHVHQWHPDVHVSHFt¿FRV(QWUHHOORVKHPRVGHVWDFDGRHOFDVRGHODUWtFX
ORGHGLFDGRDODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\TXHFRQVWLWX\HXQRGHORVLQVWUX
PHQWRVIXQGDPHQWDOHVGHQXHVWUD&RQVWLWXFLyQ&RPRVHxDODHOMXULVWD
Carlos Brokmann Haro
94
$OJXQDVSUHPLVDVDQDOtWLFDVGH*XUUtD/DFURL[\'HOD&XHYDWLHQHQUHOHYDQ
FLDGLUHFWDVREUHODSRVLEOHLPSOHPHQWDFLyQGHXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHQHO
PDUFRGHODVUHFLHQWHVUHIRUPDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVHQPDWHULDGHGHUHFKRVKX
PDQRV(QWUHHOODVTXHUHPRVGHVWDFDUVXGLYLVLyQSRUWLSRVGHVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDVPLVPDTXHKHPRVVLVWHPDWL]DGRGHHVWDPDQHUD
3RUiPELWRGHDIHFWDFLyQFRQVWLWXFLRQDORGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV
6XVSHQVLyQJHQHUDOGHODPD\RUSDUWHGHODVJDUDQWtDV
6XVSHQVLyQSDUFLDOROLPLWDGDGHODVJDUDQWtDV
&REHUWXUDHVSDFLDOGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
1LYHOQDFLRQDOHQFDVRVGHDPHQD]DRSHOLJURDOSDtV
1LYHOUHJLRQDOTXHSXHGHWUDWDUVHGHXQiPELWRPXQLFLSLRFLXGDGHVWDGR
(QHVWHVHQWLGRHOHVTXHPDTXHGHULYDPRVGH*XUUtD/DFURL[WLHQHLPSOLFD
FLRQHVGHJUDQDFWXDOLGDG/DUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLQGLFDSRUSULPHUDRFDVLyQ
XQQ~PHUR\WLSRGHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVTXHQRSXHGHQVHUVXVSHQGLGRVVDOYR
SRUODUHIHUHQFLDHQOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHDFHUFDGHQRDIHFWDUHOGHUHFKRDOD
YLGD&RQHOORVHDVHJXUDXQDSULPHUDOLPLWDQWHDODFDSDFLGDGGHDXWRULGDGGHO
(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOGXUDQWHXQSHULRGRGHHPHUJHQFLDSXHVWRTXHQRSRGUtDH[
WHQGHUVHKDVWDORVGHUHFKRVTXHTXHGDQH[SUHVDPHQWHSURWHJLGRV/DVHJXQGD
RSFLyQHVXQFDVRLQWHUHVDQWH\DTXHHQJHQHUDOVHSLHQVDVyORHQHOFDVRGH
DSOLFDUODVXVSHQVLyQGHPDQHUDWRWDO\QRFRPRODOLPLWDFLyQGHFLHUWRVGHUHFKRV
~QLFDPHQWHeVWHVHUtDHOFDVRGHORTXHKHPRVUHIHULGRFRPRHOHVWDGR¿FWLFLR
RSROtWLFRGHH[FHSFLyQHQHOFXDOHO(VWDGRLPSOHPHQWDPHGLGDVH[WUDRUGLQDULDV
SHURVLQFXEULUORVUHTXLVLWRVSDUDKDFHUOROHJDOPHQWHDOQRFRQYRFDUDO&RQJUH
VRSDUDKDFHUOR8QHMHPSORHYLGHQWHHVODXWLOL]DFLyQGHODVIXHU]DVDUPDGDV
HQODOXFKDFRQWUDHOQDUFRWUi¿FRPLVPRTXHKDVLGRFRQVLGHUDGRMXUtGLFDPHQ
WHLQDSURSLDGRSRUOD&RPLVLyQ1DFLRQDOGHORV'HUHFKRV+XPDQRV&RQODV
UHIRUPDVDFWXDOHVHOULHVJRGHPDQWHQHUXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQSROtWLFRVHUtD
D~QPD\RU\DTXHVHUHTXLHUHHOFRQFXUVRGHOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLD(Q
QXHVWUDRSLQLyQODSRVLELOLGDGGHTXHVHQRUPDOL]DUDODVLWXDFLyQWHQGUtDYHQWD
MDVSDUDFDVLWRGDVODVSDUWHVLQYROXFUDGDVSXHVWRTXHGDUtDXQSULQFLSLRGH
FHUWH]DDORTXHSXHGHVHUYLVWRFRPRXQiUHDGHSHOLJURVDLQGH¿QLFLyQ(QOR
TXHVHUH¿HUHDODFREHUWXUDJHRJUi¿FDGHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQSRGHPRVFRQ
VLGHUDUTXHHOLPSDFWRGHOFDPELRHVPHQRU\DTXHGHVGHHOWH[WRFRQVWLWXFLRQDO
GHTXHGDEDDELHUWDODSRVLELOLGDGGHVXVSHQGHUODVJDUDQWtDVHQODHVFDOD
QDFLRQDORELHQGHPDQHUDOLPLWDGDDXQ³OXJDUGHWHUPLQDGR´(VWDIUDVHTXH
UHSUHVHQWDXQDLQQRYDFLyQFRQUHVSHFWRGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHSXHGHVHU
DSOLFDGDHQFLUFXQVWDQFLDVP~OWLSOHVLQFOX\HQGRODVVXVSHQVLRQHVLPSOtFLWDVHQ
HO3ODQ'1,,,('HPDQHUDTXHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVSXHGHVHUYLVWD
FRPRXQLQVWUXPHQWRFRQDOFDQFHVGLYHUVRVTXHGHEHQDGHFXDUVHDFDVRVHV
SHFt¿FRVEDMRHOSULQFLSLRGHODYXOQHUDFLyQPtQLPDDORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\
ODVJDUDQWtDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHV/DH[SHULHQFLDGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
GHDOOHYyD'HOD&XHYDDUHÀH[LRQDUDFHUFDGHODQDWXUDOH]DGHOD
&RQVWLWXFLyQFRPRQRUPDMXUtGLFDGHODQRUPDOLGDGGHFRUWHOLEHUDO\GHPRFUi
Vid-)*DOODUGR5RGUtJXH]op. citsupraQRWD
-*XUUtD/DFURL[op. cit.supraQRWDS
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDS
(*LOEHUWop. citsupraQRWDS
0GHOD&XHYD op. citsupraQRWDS
95
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
WLFDSRGUtDPRVDxDGLU3HURHOHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDQRHVODQRUPDOLGDGVLQR
WRGRORFRQWUDULRXQDFRQGLFLyQHQODFXDOODVXVSHQVLyQGHFLHUWDVJDUDQWtDV
URPSHSRUQHFHVLGDGHORUGHQDQWHULRUSRUTXHOD³UD]yQH[LJHTXHVLWXDFLRQHV
GLVWLQWDVVHDQJREHUQDGDVSRUQRUPDVGLYHUVDV´3DUDKDFHUIUHQWHDHVWDVFRQ
WLQJHQFLDVOD&RQVWLWXFLyQGHLQFRUSRUDDODUWtFXORH[SOLFDGRGHHVWD
PDQHUDSRUHOMXULVWD³HVHOFRQMXQWRGHPHGLGDVGHQDWXUDOH]DMXUtGLFRSROtWLFD
SHUPLWLGDVSRUOD&RQVWLWXFLyQSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHDOHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDPRWL
YDGRSRUODUXSWXUDGHODDUPRQtDGHOVHUSROtWLFRPH[LFDQR´
(QHOPDUFRJOREDOL]DGRGHODSROtWLFD\ORVLQVWUXPHQWRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVFRQ
WHPSRUiQHRVODguerra contra el terror KDSURYRFDGRXQVLQQ~PHURGHSUHJXQ
WDV\FXHVWLRQDPLHQWRVDFHUFDGHODVHJXULGDG\ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV(Q
P~OWLSOHVHVSDFLRV\UHJLRQHVH[LVWHXQHVWDGRGHJXHUUDQRGHFODUDGDHQHOFXDO
QRH[LVWHHOPDUFRMXUtGLFRGHSURWHFFLyQFRQWHPSODGRSRUODVKRVWLOLGDGHVIRU
PDOHVSHURVtODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHV\ORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV
(VWHIHQyPHQRHQHOFXDOPLOORQHVGHSHUVRQDVFDHQHQOD³QXGDYLGD´GH$JDP
EHQVHSXHGHFRQVWDWDUHQWHPDVWDQGLVSDUHVFRPRHOWUDWDPLHQWRFDGDYH]
PiVVHYHURDORVPLJUDQWHVLQYRFDGRFRPRHOSDUDGLJPDGHODOLPLWDFLyQGHORV
GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVSRU+DQQDK$UHQGWGHVGHHVFULWRVDxHMRVKDVWDODFRVL¿FD
FLyQGHODVPXMHUHVTXHQRHQFXHQWUDQDVLGHURDOJXQRKDFLDORVGHUHFKRVPiV
HOHPHQWDOHVHQHOHPSOHRGRPpVWLFRRHQODSURVWLWXFLyQ8QDREVHUYDFLyQGH
0DULRGHOD&XHYDTXHQRVSDUHFHSHUWLQHQWHUHWRPDUHQHOFRQWH[WRGHODUHIRU
PDFRQVWLWXFLRQDODFWXDOHVORTXHGHVFULELyFRPRODQHFHVLGDGGHTXHODDSOLFD
FLyQGHODUWtFXORGHEHWHQHUXQFDUiFWHU³DUPyQLFR´³TXLHUHGHFLUORVGLVWLQWRV
HIHFWRVTXHVHSURGXFHQGHEHQHVWDUUHODFLRQDGRVORVXQRVFRQORVRWURV<D
LQGLFDPRVTXHODPHGLGDSULQFLSDOHVODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\TXHODVRWUDV
DXWRUL]DFLRQHVDGPLQLVWUDWLYDV\OHJLVODWLYDVOHHVWiQVXERUGLQDGDV´
6LHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQVLJQL¿FDHOFUXFHGHFDPLQRVGHODSROtWLFD\ORMX
UtGLFRGHEHPRVEXVFDUORVPHFDQLVPRVSDUDHYLWDUTXHVHWUDWHGHODMXGLFLDOL
]DFLyQGHODSROtWLFD/DWHRUtDSROtWLFDLQGLFDTXHHOSHOLJURH[LVWHVLHPSUHSHUR
FRQODVPRGL¿FDFLRQHVLQWURGXFLGDVSRUODUHFLHQWHUHIRUPDFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQ
PDWHULDGHGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVVXPDGDVDXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDH¿FD]pVWRV
SRGUtDQDPLQRUDUVH
(OHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHVUHVXOWDGRGLUHFWRGHODFWRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJD
UDQWtDVFRQWHPSODGRHQHODUWtFXORGHOD&3(80+HPRVUHJLVWUDGRGLYHUVDV
SRVLFLRQHV\DQiOLVLVHQWRUQRDODIRUPDGHOOHYDUDFDERODVXVSHQVLyQGHOD
PDQHUDPiVDGHFXDGDSRVLEOHSDUDODSURWHFFLyQGHORVGHUHFKRV\ODVJDUDQ
WtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVSHURHVHYLGHQWHTXHSHVHDWRGDVODVOLPLWDQWHVSHVRV\FRQ
WUDSHVRVTXHVHSXHGDQSURSRQHUVLJXHWUDWiQGRVHGHXQDVLWXDFLyQDQyPLFD
$FRWDUHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQYLJLODUHOFXPSOLPLHQWRGHVXVSULQFLSLRV\H[LJLU
ODSUHVHQFLDGHXQDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDQREDVWDUtDSDUDQHJDUTXHVHWUDWDGHOD
VXVSHQVLyQWHPSRUDOGHO(VWDGRGH'HUHFKR8QDOH\UHJODPHQWDULDDSOLFDGD
GXUDQWHXQSHULRGRSURORQJDGRVHFRLQYHUWLUtDHQODQXHYDQRUPDOLGDGGHQWURGH
ODUHJLyQRODQDFLyQXQDVLWXDFLyQFHUFDQDDOD³JXHUUDQRGHFODUDGD´R³JXHUUD
QRJXHUUD´TXHKDQLGHQWL¿FDGRGLYHUVRVDQDOLVWDVSROtWLFRVHQODDFWXDOLGDG/D
Carlos Brokmann Haro
96
SURWHFFLyQHIHFWLYDGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVUHTXLHUHWDQWRTXHHOHVWDGRGH
H[FHSFLyQFUHDGRSRUODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVHDORPiVEUHYHSRVLEOHFRPR
TXHVHWUDWHGHXQDPHGLGDH¿FD]SDUDHQIUHQWDUORVSUREOHPDVSRUORVFXDOHV
HVLQYRFDGR3DUD6FKPLWW\$JDPEHQHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQGH¿QHORVDOFDQ
FHVGHOSRGHUGHOVREHUDQR(QpOVHVXVSHQGHHO(VWDGRGH'HUHFKRDXQFXDQ
GRVHDGHPDQHUDDFRWDGD\VHLQVWDXUDXQUpJLPHQGHH[FHSFLyQTXHSXHGH
WUDQVIRUPDUVHHQXQDQXHYDQRUPDOLGDGIiFLOPHQWH(OHMHPSORPiVXWLOL]DGR
GHHVWHSURFHVRHVODDSOLFDFLyQGHO$FWD3DWULRWDHQ(VWDGRV8QLGRVGHVSXpVGH
ORVDWHQWDGRVWHUURULVWDVGHOGHVHSWLHPEUH$UJXPHQWDQGRODH[LVWHQFLDGHXQ
SHOLJURJUDYHHLQPLQHQWHORFXDOIXHGH¿QLGRHQODGRFWULQDMXUtGLFDHVWDGRXQLGHQ
se como clear and present dangerSRUHOPDJLVWUDGR2OLYHU:HQGHOO+ROPHV-U
ODDGPLQLVWUDFLyQGH*HRUJH:%XVKGHFUHWyXQHVWDGRGHHPHUJHQFLDDFRWDGR/D
VXVSHQVLyQGHOHabeas CorpusSDUDFXDOTXLHUVRVSHFKRVRHOHVWDEOHFLPLHQWR
GHGHFHQDVGHFDPSRVGHFRQFHQWUDFLyQIXHUDGHFXDOTXLHUQRUPDWLYDLQWHUQD
FLRQDODOUHVSHFWR\ODVSUiFWLFDVTXHKDQOOHJDGRDODFRQGHQDDPXHUWHin absentiaKDQVLGRVyORDOJXQDVGHVXVPHGLGDVPiVFULWLFDGDV$PiVGHDxRV
GHORVDFRQWHFLPLHQWRVFRQODGHUURWDYLUWXDOGHOHQHPLJRDOPHQRVGHO³SHOLJUR
FODURHLQPLQHQWH´\DXQFXDQGRHOSDUWLGRRSRVLWRUDKRUDVHHQFXHQWUDHQHO
SRGHUHOPatriot ActVHKDFRQYHUWLGRHQODQXHYDQRUPDOLGDG(OHVWDGRGHH[
FHSFLyQLQWHUQRHLQWHUQDFLRQDOFUHDGRSRUGHFUHWRHVHOHVFHQDULRGRQGHVH
GHEHQGHVDUUROODUODVUHODFLRQHVHQWUHODVQDFLRQHV\HOPDUFRGHUHIHUHQFLDREOL
JDGRSDUDFXDOTXLHUFRQÀLFWRTXHGHULYHGHHOOD$ODQDOL]DUHOHVWDGRGHH[FHS
FLyQFRPRIHQyPHQRGHOGHUHFKR\GHODSROtWLFD6FKPLWWPXHVWUDTXHORVGRV
VRQLQGLVRFLDEOHV3DUDpOOD¿FFLyQGHVHSDUDUORVUHVXOWDHVSHFLDOPHQWHIDOD]
VLVHFRQVLGHUDTXHHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHVUHVXOWDGRGHXQDFRQVLGHUDFLyQ
RFiOFXORSROtWLFRTXHGHVSXpVHVMXVWL¿FDGR\OHJLWLPDGRMXUtGLFDPHQWH<HVWH
FDUiFWHUGHH[FHSFLRQDOHVGH¿QLWRULRSRUPiVTXHVHHVWDEOH]FDQFRQWUROHV
SDUDVXLPSOHPHQWDFLyQ\DSOLFDFLyQQRGHMDUiGHWUDWDUVHGHXQDVLWXDFLyQTXH
GHVSOD]DDO(VWDGRGH'HUHFKR/DVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVLQLPSRUWDUORELHQ
MXVWL¿FDGDTXHVHDORVFRQWUROHVTXHSXHGDQSRQHUVHDVXHMHFXFLyQ\ORVSHVRV
\FRQWUDSHVRVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVTXHVHSURSRQJDQVLJQL¿FDSRUQHFHVLGDGTXH
FLHUWRVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\JDUDQWtDVLQGLYLGXDOHVVRQSXHVWRVHQUHFHVRRHOL
PLQDGRVDOPHQRVGHIRUPDWHPSRUDO6FKPLWWGHMDFODURTXHODFDSDFLGDGGHO
VREHUDQRSDUDLQYRFDU\DSOLFDUXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHVODYHUGDGHUDPHGLGD
GHVXSRGHU\DXWRULGDG(OSHULRGRGXUDQWHHOFXDOH[LVWDHOHVWDGRGHH[FHS
FLyQVHFRQYLHUWHHQHOWLHPSRGHOVREHUDQRHQHOFXDOSXHGHOHJLVODUDFHUFDGH
FLHUWDVPDWHULDVHMHFXWDUDFWRVGHDXWRULGDGRLQFOXVLYHSURORQJDUORVOtPLWHVHQ
WLHPSRHVSDFLR\iPELWRGHODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV
(ODUWtFXORGHMDHQFODURGHVGHVXSULPHUDUHGDFFLyQTXHODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDVWLHQHFRPRSURSyVLWRSURWHJHUDODQDFLyQPHGLDQWHHOHVWDEOHFL
PLHQWRGHXQHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQWHPSRUDO/DPHGLGDHVWiFRQWHPSODGD~QL
FDPHQWHHQFDVRVGHSHOLJURRDPHQD]DJUDYHVFRPRIXHVX~QLFDDSOLFDFLyQ
GXUDQWHOD6HJXQGD*XHUUD0XQGLDO'HQWURGHQXHVWURRUGHQFRQVWLWXFLRQDOOD
VXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVLPSOLFDODGHOHJDFLyQDO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOGHIDFXOWDGHV
H[WUDRUGLQDULDVFRPRVRQODSURPXOJDFLyQGHQRUPDVVLQUHTXHULUGHO/HJLVODWL
YR(QHOFDVRKLVWyULFRDQDOL]DGROD/H\GH3UHYHQFLRQHV*HQHUDOHVGH
&6FKPLWWop. cit.supraQRWDSS
V. Conclusiones
)LOyVRIRVSROLWyORJRVWHyULFRVGHOGHUHFKR\RWURVHVSHFLDOLVWDVVHxDODQODUH
OHYDQFLDFRQFHSWXDO\SUiFWLFDTXHWLHQHHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ3DUDGH¿QLUOR
HQSRFDVSDODEUDVVHWUDWDGHXQDVLWXDFLyQSUHYLVWDMXUtGLFDPHQWHHQODFXDO
VHVXVSHQGHHORUGHQMXUtGLFR/DFRQWUDGLFFLyQHVHYLGHQWH\KHPRVUHYLVDGR
DOJXQDVLGHDVHQWRUQRDHVWHFRPSOHMRFDUiFWHU(OHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQHVWi
PRQWDGRDKRUFDMDGDVHQWUHHOGHUHFKR\ODSROtWLFD6HWUDWDGHXQDYLUWXDOWLHUUD
GHQDGLHHQODFXDOORVHVSHFLDOLVWDVGHFDGDFDPSRWHPHQDGHQWUDUVHSRUWUD
WDUVHGHXQDPDWHULDLJQRWD3HURHOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQVHKDFRQYHUWLGRHQ
XQDUHDOLGDGSUHVHQWHFDGDYH]PiVSHUPDQHQWH/RVJRELHUQRVOLEHUDOHVOR
XWLOL]DQSDUDVDOYDUODVOLPLWDFLRQHVMXUtGLFDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVRGHRWURWLSRTXH
HQIUHQWDQHQODOXFKDFRQWUDODVDPHQD]DVH[WHUQDVHLQWHUQDV/RVUHJtPHQHV
DXWRULWDULRVORKDQLPSODQWDGRGHPDQHUDJHQHUDOL]DGD<HOUHVXOWDGRHVXQD
VLWXDFLyQFDGDYH]PiVFRQWUDGLFWRULDHQODFXDOORVSULQFLSLRVVHVXEVXPHQHQ
ODVQHFHVLGDGHVSROtWLFDV<ODMXVWL¿FDFLyQ\OHJLWLPDFLyQGHHVWDVGHFLVLRQHV
WLHQHQXQWLQWHFDGDYH]PiVLGHROyJLFR
'HVGHHOVLJOR;,;ODV&RQVWLWXFLRQHVQDFLRQDOHVKDQFRQWHPSODGRODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVFRPRLQVWUXPHQWRSDUDHQIUHQWDUORVHVWDGRVGHHPHUJHQ
FLD/DH[SHULHQFLDKLVWyULFDGHODDSOLFDFLyQGHODPHGLGDSXHGHUHIHULUVHHQGRV
VHQWLGRV(OSULPHURHVWULFWDPHQWHIRUPDO\MXUtGLFRHVTXHHQODPD\RUtDGHORV
FDVRVODVXVSHQVLyQIXHOOHYDGDDFDERFRQDSHJRDODQRUPDWLYD1RREVWDQWH
97
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
IXHURQYDULDVODVOH\HVUHJODPHQWRV\GHFUHWRVLPSOHPHQWDGRVEDMRHVWDOyJLFD
6LDHVWDSUHUURJDWLYDMXUtGLFDOHVXPDPRVTXHHQHVWHPLVPRHMHPSORH[LVWLy
XQEUHYHSHULRGRGXUDQWHHOFXDOQLVLTXLHUDHODPSDURWXYRYLJHQFLDHVHYLGHQ
WHHOSHOLJURGHFDHUHQXQUpJLPHQDXWRULWDULRDWUDYpVGHXQGHFUHWRPDOIXQGD
PHQWDGRRDFRWDGRGHVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVeVWDHVXQDUD]yQIXQGDPHQWDO
SDUDFRQVLGHUDULPSUHVFLQGLEOHLQFRUSRUDUHQODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDTXHVHUiH[
SHGLGDFRQVLGHUDFLRQHVTXHSURWHMDQHOSULQFLSLRGHODGLYLVLyQGHSRGHUHV\HO
HTXLOLEULRGHODVIXHU]DVSROtWLFDV8QDVSHFWRTXHQRVHFRQWHPSODHQJHQHUDO
HVHOKHFKRGHTXHH[LVWHQQXPHURVRVLQVWUXPHQWRVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHVTXHSXHGHQ
VHUYLUSDUDSURWHJHUORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVHQSHULRGRVGHHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ
0p[LFRQRKD¿UPDGRHO3URWRFROR,,GHOD&RQYHQFLyQGH*LQHEUDTXHKHPRV
YLVWRTXHSDUDDOJXQRVDXWRUHVHVHOPiVLPSRUWDQWHGHHVWRVLQVWUXPHQWRV
$GRSWDUORRDOPHQRVLQFRUSRUDUVXVSULQFLSDOHVDVSHFWRVHQODHODERUDFLyQGH
ODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDFRUUHVSRQGLHQWHSRGUtDFRDG\XYDUHQODHIHFWLYDSURWHFFLyQ
GHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV\ODVJDUDQWtDVFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHVDWUDYpVGHpVWD/DV
UHIRUPDVDOWH[WRGHODUWtFXORFRQVWLWX\HQXQDDSRUWDFLyQGHHQRUPHLPSRU
WDQFLD3XQWXDOL]DQXQDVHULHGHSUHUURJDWLYDV\IDFXOWDGHVTXHHUDQDPELJXDV
\TXHSRUWDOPRWLYRVHSUHVWDEDQDODLPSOHPHQWDFLyQGLVFUHFLRQDOGHODVXV
SHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV$OH[WHQGHUHOWH[WR\FRQWHPSODUFRQPD\RUSUHFLVLyQORV
OtPLWHVGHODFWRUHVXOWDQGHJUDQYDORUHQODSURWHFFLyQGHORVGHUHFKRVIXQGD
PHQWDOHV$VLPLVPRHOKHFKRGHLQFRUSRUDUDO3RGHU-XGLFLDOGHQWURGHOSURFHVR
\VXWXWHODFUHDORVSHVRV\FRQWUDSHVRVQHFHVDULRVSDUDFRQYHUWLUODVXVSHQVLyQ
GHJDUDQWtDVHQXQDPHGLGDGHJRELHUQR~WLOHQFRQGLFLRQHVWHPSRUDOHV\HVSD
FLDOHVHVSHFt¿FDV
Carlos Brokmann Haro
98
H[LVWHQFDVRVGHFLPRQyQLFRVHQORVFXDOHVODLPSOHPHQWDFLyQIXHGLVFUHFLRQDO
\GHPDQHUDSUHRFXSDQWHQRVHUHVSHWDURQODVOLPLWDFLRQHVTXHVHVHxDODEDQ
HVSHFt¿FDPHQWH3XHGHFRQVLGHUDUVHTXHLQFOXVLYHH[LVWLHURQSUHVLGHQWHVTXH
HMHUFLHURQXQDDXWRULGDGFDVLLOLPLWDGDDOEDVDUVHHQHOJRELHUQRSRUGHFUHWR'H
PDQHUDSDUDOHODUHDOL]DPRVXQUHFXHQWRGHORVGHEDWHV\GLVFXVLRQHVGHWLSR
PHQRVIRUPDO\FX\RFDUiFWHUSROtWLFRHFRQyPLFRVRFLDO\FXOWXUDOQRVSDUHFH
UHOHYDQWH(QHVWHUHQJOyQODH[SHULHQFLDPH[LFDQDSXHGHFRQVLGHUDUVHIXQGD
PHQWDOPHQWHSUHRFXSDQWH(QFDVLWRGDVODVFR\XQWXUDVGHHPHUJHQFLDHQODV
FXDOHVVHDSOLFyODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDVVHSXHGHLGHQWL¿FDUXQSDWUyQGH
DEXVRGHOSRGHUGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDO/DPHGLGDIXHGLULJLGDFRQWUDLQGLYLGXRV
JUXSRVRVHFWRUHVGHPDQHUDFRP~Q\VHFRQYLUWLyHQXQDSHOLJURVDKHUUDPLHQ
WDDOSHUPLWLUDFWRVTXHH[WUDOLPLWDEDQHOPDQGDWRRULJLQDO(OKHFKRQRGHEHVyOR
VRUSUHQGHUVLQRVHUYLUFRPRSODWDIRUPDGHGLVFXVLyQDFHUFDGHODVSRVLELOLGDGHV
GHDSOLFDUODPHGLGDHQODDFWXDOLGDG
(ODFWXDODUWtFXORGHULYDGLUHFWDPHQWHGHOPLVPRWtWXORGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ
GHIRUPDQGRSDUWHLQWHJUDOGHOFDStWXORGHGLFDGRDODVJDUDQWtDVIXQGDPHQ
WDOHV\DSDUWLUGHODVUHFLHQWHVUHIRUPDVGHORVGHUHFKRVKXPDQRV0HGLDQWH
ODVXVSHQVLyQGHJDUDQWtDV\GHUHFKRVHODUWtFXORQRUPDODDSOLFDFLyQGHXQ
HVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQFRPRUHVXOWDGRGHXQDVLWXDFLyQGHHPHUJHQFLD$OGHMDU
HQPDQRVGHO(MHFXWLYR)HGHUDOODSURPXOJDFLyQGHOGHFUHWRGHVXVSHQVLyQGH
JDUDQWtDV\DO/HJLVODWLYRXQSDSHOVHFXQGDULRFRORFyDOSULPHURHQODSRVLFLyQ
GHO³VREHUDQR´HQWpUPLQRVGH&DUO6FKPLWW/DVDFWXDOHVUHIRUPDVHQPDWHULDGH
GHUHFKRVKXPDQRVKDQHQIUHQWDGRHQSULPHUWpUPLQRHVWHSUREOHPD3HUROR
KDQKHFKRGHXQDPDQHUDTXHSDUHFHGLItFLODSOLFDUHQFDVRVGHHPHUJHQFLD
FUHDQGRSURFHVRVTXHUHTXLHUHQODSDUWLFLSDFLyQGHORVWUHVSRGHUHV(OWH[WR
RULJLQDODUWtFXORGHOD&3(80VLJQL¿FyXQUHWURFHVRHQWpUPLQRVGHODSURWHF
FLyQGHORVGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDV0LHQWUDVTXHVXDQWHFHVRUGHFRQWHP
SODEDODLQYLRODELOLGDGGHOGHUHFKRDODYLGDHQVHHOLPLQyHVWD~QLFDVDO
YHGDG$KRUDODVUHIRUPDVKDQDOWHUDGRHVWHSDQRUDPDDODGRSWDUODTXHSXHGH
VHUFRQVLGHUDGDODOHJLVODFLyQLQWHUQDFLRQDOPiVDYDQ]DGDHQODPDWHULD(OUH
WRPDUGHPDQHUDLQWHJUDOHODUWtFXORGHOD&$'+VLJQL¿FDSRQHUOtPLWHVFODURV
DOHVWDGRGHH[FHSFLyQ(VWDEDUUHUDLQFOX\HXQDSURWHFFLyQMXUtGLFDTXHQR
H[LVWtDSHURDEUHXQDVHULHGHFXHVWLRQDPLHQWRVTXHKHPRVPHQFLRQDGR\TXH
GHEHUiQVHUHQIUHQWDGRVHQHOWH[WRGHODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDSUHYLVWDHQHODUWtFX
ORFXDUWRWUDQVLWRULR
(QODFR\XQWXUDDFWXDOTXHDWUDYLHVDHOSDtVVHHVFXFKDQYRFHVTXHSLGHQ
KHUUDPLHQWDVSDUDHQIUHQWDUODVDPHQD]DVDODVHJXULGDGQDFLRQDO(OVLJXLHQWH
SDVRHVODHODERUDFLyQGHODOH\UHJODPHQWDULDTXHQRUPDUiODSRVLEOHDSOLFDFLyQ
GHODUWtFXOR+HPRVVHxDODGRGLYHUVRVSXQWRVTXHVHUiQHFHVDULRFRQVLGHUDU
HQHVWHWH[WRTXHSRUGH¿QLFLyQGHEHUiDFRWDUWRGDYtDPiVXQDSRVLEOHVXVSHQ
VLyQGHGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDV/DUHIRUPDHQGHUHFKRVKXPDQRVHVHOPDUFR
GHQWURGHOFXDOVHGHEHOOHYDUDFDERHVWDWDUHDSRUORTXHVHGHEHJDUDQWL]DUOD
SURWHFFLyQHIHFWLYDGHORVGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDVUHIRUPDGRV
VI. Anexos
(648(0$7(;726&2167,78&,21$/(625,*,1$/(6
&203$5$&,Ï1'(/$&3(80'(</$&3(80'(
&RQVWLWXFLyQGH
$UWtFXOR
(QORVFDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYH
GHGHODSD]S~EOLFDRFXDOHVTXLHUDRWURVTXHSRQ
JDQDODVRFLHGDGHQJUDYHSHOLJURRFRQÀLFWR
VRODPHQWHHO3UHVLGHQWHGHOD5HS~EOLFDGH
DFXHUGRFRQHOFRQVHMRGHPLQLVWURV\FRQDSUR
EDFLyQGHO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ\HQORVUHFHVRV
GHpVWHGHODGLSXWDFLyQSHUPDQHQWHSXHGHVXV
SHQGHUODVJDUDQWtDVRWRUJDGDVHQHVWD&RQVWLWX
FLyQFRQH[FHSFLyQGHODVTXHDVHJXUDQODYLGD
GHOKRPEUHSHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRUXQWLHPSR
OLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGHSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV\
VLQTXHODVXVSHQVLyQSXHGDFRQWUDHUVHDGHWHU
PLQDGRLQGLYLGXR
6LODVXVSHQVLyQWXYLHUHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVHHO
&RQJUHVRUHXQLGRHVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]D
FLRQHVTXHHVWLPHQHFHVDULDVSDUDTXHHO(MHFX
WLYRKDJDIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ6LODVXVSHQVLyQVH
YHUL¿FDUHHQWLHPSRVGHUHFHVRODGLSXWDFLyQSHU
PDQHQWHFRQYRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQJUHVRSDUD
TXHODVDFXHUGH
&RQVWLWXFLyQGH2ULJLQDO
$UWtFXOR
(QORVFDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]
S~EOLFDRGHFXDOTXLHUDRWURTXHSRQJDDODVRFLHGDGHQ
JUDQGHSHOLJURRFRQÀLFWRVRODPHQWHHO3UHVLGHQWHGHOD
5HS~EOLFD0H[LFDQDGHDFXHUGRFRQHO&RQVHMRGH0L
QLVWURV\FRQDSUREDFLyQGHO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ\HQ
ORVUHFHVRVGHpVWHGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQWHSRGUi
VXVSHQGHUHQWRGRHOSDtVRHQOXJDUGHWHUPLQDGRODV
JDUDQWtDVTXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD
\IiFLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRUXQ
WLHPSROLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGHSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV\
VLQTXHODVXVSHQVLyQVHFRQWUDLJDDGHWHUPLQDGRLQGLYL
GXR6LODVXVSHQVLyQWXYLHVHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVHHO&RQJUH
VRUHXQLGRpVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]DFLRQHVTXHHVWLPH
QHFHVDULDVSDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJDIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ
6LODVXVSHQVLyQVHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVRVH
FRQYRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQJUHVRSDUDTXHODVDFXHUGH
)XHQWHConstitución de 1857. Constituciones de los estados0p[LFR&RPLVLyQ1DFLRQDO(GLWRULDOGHO3DUWLGR
5HYROXFLRQDULR,QVWLWXFLRQDOConstitución Política de los EUMWH[WRFRQIRUPHDO'LDULR2¿FLDOWRPR9
DpSRFDQ~POXQHVGHIHEUHURGHSSHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQIMXUOHJ
FRQVKLVWSGISGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
99
Carlos Brokmann Haro
100
(648(0$5()250$6$/$57Ë&8/2'(/$&3(80
7(;7225,*,1$/'(/$&3(80'(<'(&5(72648(/25()250$521
&3(80GH
7H[WRRULJLQDO
'HFUHWRSRUHOTXHVHUHIRUPDQORV
DUWtFXORV\GHOD&RQVWL
WXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV8QL
GRV0H[LFDQRVPDUWHVGHDEULO
GH
'(&5(72SRUHOTXHVHUHIRUPDQ
ORVDUWtFXORV
\GHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWL
FDGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFD
QRVMXHYHVGHDJRVWRGH
$UWtFXOR
(QORVFDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXU
EDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFDR
GHFXDOTXLHUDRWURTXHSRQJDDOD
VRFLHGDGHQJUDQGHSHOLJURRFRQ
ÀLFWRVRODPHQWHHO3UHVLGHQWHGH
OD5HS~EOLFD0H[LFDQDGHDFXHUGR
FRQHO&RQVHMRGH0LQLVWURV\FRQ
DSUREDFLyQGHO&RQJUHVRGHOD
8QLyQ\HQORVUHFHVRVGHpVWHGH
OD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQWHSRGUi
VXVSHQGHUHQWRGRHOSDtVRHQOX
JDUGHWHUPLQDGRODVJDUDQWtDVTXH
IXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWH
UiSLGD\IiFLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQ
SHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRUXQWLHPSR
OLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGHSUHYHQFLR
QHVJHQHUDOHV\VLQTXHODVXVSHQ
VLyQVHFRQWUDLJDDGHWHUPLQDGR
LQGLYLGXR6LODVXVSHQVLyQWXYLHVH
OXJDUKDOOiQGRVHHO&RQJUHVRUHX
QLGRpVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]D
FLRQHVTXHHVWLPHQHFHVDULDVSDUD
TXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJDIUHQWHDOD
VLWXDFLyQ6LODVXVSHQVLyQVHYHUL
¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVRVHFRQ
YRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQJUHVR
SDUDTXHODVDFXHUGH
³$UWtFXOR(QORVFDVRVGHLQYD
VLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]
S~EOLFDRGHFXDOTXLHUDRWURTXH
SRQJDDODVRFLHGDGHQJUDQGHSH
OLJURRFRQÀLFWRVRODPHQWHHO3UH
VLGHQWHGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV
0H[LFDQRVGHDFXHUGRFRQORV7L
WXODUHVGHODV6HFUHWDUtDVGH(VWD
GRORV'HSDUWDPHQWRV$GPLQLVWUD
WLYRV\OD3URFXUDGXUtD*HQHUDOGH
OD5HS~EOLFD\FRQDSUREDFLyQGHO
&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ\HQORVUH
FHVRVGHpVWHGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HU
PDQHQWHSRGUiVXVSHQGHUHQWRGR
HOSDtVRHQOXJDUGHWHUPLQDGRODV
JDUDQWtDVTXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORV
SDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\IiFLO
PHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURGHEHUi
KDFHUORSRUXQWLHPSROLPLWDGRSRU
PHGLRGHSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV
\VLQTXHODVXVSHQVLyQVHFRQWUDL
JDDGHWHUPLQDGRLQGLYLGXR6LODVXV
SHQVLyQWXYLHVHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVH
HO&RQJUHVRUHXQLGRpVWHFRQFH
GHUiODVDXWRUL]DFLRQHVTXHHVWLPH
QHFHVDULDVSDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYR
KDJDIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURVL
VHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVR
VHFRQYRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQ
JUHVRSDUDTXHODVDFXHUGH´
$UWtFXOR(QORVFDVRVGHLQYD
VLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQJUDYHGHODSD]
S~EOLFDRGHFXDOTXLHURWURTXH
SRQJDDODVRFLHGDGHQJUDYHSHOL
JURRFRQÀLFWRVRODPHQWHHO3UHVL
GHQWHGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[L
FDQRVGHDFXHUGRFRQORV7LWXODUHV
GHODV6HFUHWDUtDVGH(VWDGR\OD
3URFXUDGXUtD*HQHUDOGHOD5HS~
EOLFD\FRQODDSUREDFLyQGHO&RQ
JUHVRGHOD8QLyQ\HQORVUHFHVRV
GHpVWHGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQ
WHSRGUiVXVSHQGHUHQWRGRHOSDtV
RHQOXJDUGHWHUPLQDGRODVJDUDQ
WtDVTXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKD
FHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\IiFLOPHQWHDOD
VLWXDFLyQSHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRU
XQWLHPSROLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGH
SUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV\VLQTXH
ODVXVSHQVLyQVHFRQWUDLJDDGHWHU
PLQDGRLQGLYLGXR6LODVXVSHQVLyQ
WXYLHVHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVHHO&RQJUH
VRUHXQLGRpVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDX
WRUL]DFLRQHVTXHHVWLPHQHFHVDULDV
SDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJDIUHQWHD
ODVLWXDFLyQSHURVLVHYHUL¿FDVHHQ
WLHPSRGHUHFHVRVHFRQYRFDUiVLQ
GHPRUDDO&RQJUHVRSDUDTXHODV
DFXHUGH
)XHQWHConstitución Política de los EUMWH[WRFRQIRUPHDO'LDULR2¿FLDOWRPR9DpSRFDQ~POXQHV
GHIHEUHURGHSSHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQIMXUOHJFRQVKLVWSGISGIFRQVXO
WDGRHQMXQLRGH'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQPDUWHVGHDEULOGHHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDP
P[LQIMXUOHJFRQVWPH[SGIUFSGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQMXHYHVGH
DJRVWRGHHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQIMXUOHJFRQVWPH[SGISGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLR
GH
7(;72'(/$&3(80
02',),&$'2325Ò/7,0$9(=
(/'($*2672'(
'(&5(72SRUHOTXHVHPRGL¿FDODGHQRPLQDFLyQ
GHO&DStWXOR,GHO7tWXOR3ULPHUR\UHIRUPDGLYHUVRV
DUWtFXORVGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV
8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV
$UWtFXOR(QORVFDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQ
JUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFDRGHFXDOTXLHURWURTXHSRQJD
DODVRFLHGDGHQJUDYHSHOLJURRFRQÀLFWRVRODPHQWH
HO3UHVLGHQWHGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRVGH
DFXHUGRFRQORV7LWXODUHVGHODV6HFUHWDUtDVGH(VWD
GR\OD3URFXUDGXUtD*HQHUDOGHOD5HS~EOLFD\FRQOD
DSUREDFLyQGHO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQ\HQORVUHFHVRV
GHpVWHGHOD&RPLVLyQ3HUPDQHQWHSRGUiVXVSHQGHU
HQWRGRHOSDtVRHQOXJDUGHWHUPLQDGRODVJDUDQWtDV
TXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\Ii
FLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRUXQ
WLHPSROLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGHSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV
\VLQTXHODVXVSHQVLyQVHFRQWUDLJDDGHWHUPLQDGR
LQGLYLGXR6LODVXVSHQVLyQWXYLHVHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVH
HO&RQJUHVRUHXQLGRpVWHFRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]DFLR
QHVTXHHVWLPHQHFHVDULDVSDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJD
IUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURVLVHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSR
GHUHFHVRVHFRQYRFDUiVLQGHPRUDDO&RQJUHVRSDUD
TXHODVDFXHUGH
$UWtFXOR(QORVFDVRVGHLQYDVLyQSHUWXUEDFLyQ
JUDYHGHODSD]S~EOLFDRGHFXDOTXLHURWURTXHSRQJD
DODVRFLHGDGHQJUDYHSHOLJURRFRQÀLFWRVRODPHQWH
HO3UHVLGHQWHGHORV(VWDGRV8QLGRV0H[LFDQRVGH
DFXHUGRFRQORVWLWXODUHVGHODV6HFUHWDUtDVGH(VWDGR
\OD3URFXUDGXUtD*HQHUDOGHOD5HS~EOLFD\FRQOD
DSUREDFLyQGHO&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQRGHOD&RPLVLyQ
3HUPDQHQWHFXDQGRDTXHOQRHVWXYLHUHUHXQLGRSRGUi
UHVWULQJLURVXVSHQGHUHQWRGRHOSDtVRHQOXJDUGH
WHUPLQDGRHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRV\ODVJDUDQWtDV
TXHIXHVHQREVWiFXORSDUDKDFHUIUHQWHUiSLGD\Ii
FLOPHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHURGHEHUiKDFHUORSRUXQ
WLHPSROLPLWDGRSRUPHGLRGHSUHYHQFLRQHVJHQHUDOHV
\VLQTXHODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQVHFRQWUDLJDD
GHWHUPLQDGDSHUVRQD6LODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQ
WXYLHVHOXJDUKDOOiQGRVHHO&RQJUHVRUHXQLGRpVWH
FRQFHGHUiODVDXWRUL]DFLRQHVTXHHVWLPHQHFHVDULDV
SDUDTXHHO(MHFXWLYRKDJDIUHQWHDODVLWXDFLyQSHUR
VLVHYHUL¿FDVHHQWLHPSRGHUHFHVRVHFRQYRFDUiGH
LQPHGLDWRDO&RQJUHVRSDUDTXHODVDFXHUGH
(QORVGHFUHWRVTXHVHH[SLGDQQRSRGUiUHVWULQJLUVH
QLVXVSHQGHUVHHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRVDODQR
GLVFULPLQDFLyQDOUHFRQRFLPLHQWRGHODSHUVRQDOLGDG
MXUtGLFDDODYLGDDODLQWHJULGDGSHUVRQDODODSURWHF
FLyQDODIDPLOLDDOQRPEUHDODQDFLRQDOLGDGORVGH
UHFKRVGHODQLxH]ORVGHUHFKRVSROtWLFRVODVOLEHUWD
GHV GH SHQVDPLHQWR FRQFLHQFLD \ GH SURIHVDU
FUHHQFLDUHOLJLRVDDOJXQDHOSULQFLSLRGHOHJDOLGDG\
UHWURDFWLYLGDGODSURKLELFLyQGHODSHQDGHPXHUWHOD
SURKLELFLyQGHODHVFODYLWXG\ODVHUYLGXPEUHODSUR
KLELFLyQGHODGHVDSDULFLyQIRU]DGD\ODWRUWXUDQLODV
JDUDQWtDVMXGLFLDOHVLQGLVSHQVDEOHVSDUDODSURWHFFLyQ
GHWDOHVGHUHFKRV
/DUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQGHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUH
FKRV\JDUDQWtDVGHEHHVWDUIXQGDGD\PRWLYDGDHQ
ORVWpUPLQRVHVWDEOHFLGRVSRUHVWD&RQVWLWXFLyQ\VHU
SURSRUFLRQDODOSHOLJURDTXHVHKDFHIUHQWHREVHU
YDQGRHQWRGRPRPHQWRORVSULQFLSLRVGHOHJDOLGDG
UDFLRQDOLGDGSURFODPDFLyQSXEOLFLGDG\QRGLVFULPL
QDFLyQ
&XDQGRVHSRQJD¿QDODUHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQGHO
HMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRV\JDUDQWtDVELHQVHDSRU
FXPSOLUVHHOSOD]RRSRUTXHDVtORGHFUHWHHO&RQJUHVR
WRGDVODVPHGLGDVOHJDOHV\DGPLQLVWUDWLYDVDGRSWDGDV
GXUDQWHVXYLJHQFLDTXHGDUiQVLQHIHFWRGHIRUPDLQ
PHGLDWD(O(MHFXWLYRQRSRGUiKDFHUREVHUYDFLRQHV
DOGHFUHWRPHGLDQWHHOFXDOHO&RQJUHVRUHYRTXHOD
UHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQ
/RVGHFUHWRVH[SHGLGRVSRUHO(MHFXWLYRGXUDQWHOD
UHVWULFFLyQRVXVSHQVLyQVHUiQUHYLVDGRVGHR¿FLRH
LQPHGLDWDPHQWHSRUOD6XSUHPD&RUWHGH-XVWLFLDGH
OD1DFLyQODTXHGHEHUiSURQXQFLDUVHFRQODPD\RU
SURQWLWXGVREUHVXFRQVWLWXFLRQDOLGDG\YDOLGH]
101
Suspensión de garantías y reforma constitucional al artículo 29.
Perspectiva del estado de excepción en México
(648(0$5()250$(1'(5(&+26+80$126
&$0%,26$/$57Ë&8/2'(/$&3(80
&203$5$&,Ï1(175((/7(;72$17(5,25<(/5()250$'2
'(&5(72'(/'(-81,2'(
Carlos Brokmann Haro
102
75$16,725,26
&XDUWR(O&RQJUHVRGHOD8QLyQH[SHGLUiOD/H\5H
JODPHQWDULDGHODUWtFXORFRQVWLWXFLRQDOHQPDWHULD
GHVXVSHQVLyQGHOHMHUFLFLRGHORVGHUHFKRV\ODVJD
UDQWtDVHQXQSOD]RPi[LPRGHXQDxRFRQWDGRD
SDUWLUGHOLQLFLRGHODYLJHQFLDGHHVWHGHFUHWR
)XHQWH'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQMXHYHVGHDJRVWRGHHQKWWSZZZMXULGLFDVXQDPP[LQIMXU
OHJFRQVWPH[SGISGIFRQVXOWDGRHQMXQLRGH³'(&5(72SRUHOTXHVHPRGL¿FDODGHQRPLQD
FLyQGHO&DStWXOR,GHO7tWXOR3ULPHUR\UHIRUPDGLYHUVRVDUWtFXORVGHOD&RQVWLWXFLyQ3ROtWLFDGHORV(VWDGRV
8QLGRV0H[LFDQRV´'LDULR2¿FLDOGHOD)HGHUDFLyQWRPR'&;&,,,Q~PYLHUQHVGHMXQLRGH
