La unidad del pensamiento

La unidad del pensamiento The Unity of Thought Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio En-claves del Pensamiento, vol. VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre, 2014, pp. 79-97.
Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey Campus Ciudad de
México Distrito Federal, México
En-claves del Pensamiento,
ISSN (Versión impresa): 1870-879X
[email protected]
[email protected]
Instituto Tecnológico y de Estudios Superiores de
Monterrey Campus Ciudad de México
México
LA UNIDAD DEL PENSAMIENTO
ALDO GUARNEROS MONTERRUBIO*
Resumen
!
"#$% $&"'()% #*'#'% ")+*$% ,'% -&.$"#-/'0-1&% 2$,% 3*-&0-3-)% 2$% 4&-2'25% 6'*'% $,,)%
$7'8-&)%,'%4&-2'2%$&%*$,'0-1&%0)&%$,%3$&"'8-$&#)5%!,%3$&"'8-$&#)%$"%0)89
3*$&2-2)%$&%#*$"%"$&#-2)":%0)8)%,'%4&-2'2%2$,%)+;$#)%2$%-&.$"#-/'0-1&<%0)8)%,'%
4&-2'2% 2$,% 2$"'**),,)% =-"#1*-0)% (% 0)8)% 3*-&0-3-)% !"#$%% 2$,% >4$='0$*% ?-,)"1?-0)5%
!"#)"%"$&#-2)"%84$"#*'&%,'%3)"-+-,-2'2%2$%0)&#-&4'*%0)&%,'%-&.$"#-/'0-1&%2$%,'%
.$*2'25%!,%2-@,)/)%0)&%,'%#*'2-0-1&%(%,)"%"$&#-2)"%>4$%A"#'%2)&'%',%0)&0$3#)%2$%
3$&"'8-$&#)%&)"%3$*8-#$&%0)83*$&2$*%,'%2-?-04,#'2%2$%2-0='%-&.$"#-/'0-1&<%&)%
0)&%,'%?-&',-2'2%2$%0$2$*%'&#$%$,,'<%"-&)%3'*'%0)&#*-+4-*%$&%,'%+B">4$2'5%!,%3*)9
31"-#)%$"%'+*-*"$%3'")%$&%,)%3*$.-'8$&#$%3$&"'2)%3'*'%*$3$&"'*,)%(%$&*->4$9
0$*,)%2$"2$%,'%A3)0'%'0#4',5
&$%$'($)*+%$!,:%4&-2'2<%3$&"'8-$&#)<%=-"#)*-'<%3*-&0-3-)<%.-2'<%,C8-#$5
Abstract
D
=-"%$""'(%-&>4-*$"%'+)4#%#=$%*$"$'*0=%)&%#=$%3*-&0-3,$%)?%4&-#(5%E)*%#=-"%34*9
!"#$% &% $'()*+$% ,-$% .+*,/% *+% 0"++$0,*"+% 1*,-% ,-$% ,-*+2*+34% 5-$% ,-*+2*+3% *#%
4&2$*"#))2%-&%#=*$$%"$&"$":%'"%#=$%4&-#(%)?%-&>4-*(F"%"4+;$0#<%'"%#=$%4&-#(%)?%#=$%
=-"#)*-0',%2$.$,)38$&#%'&2%'"%!"#$%%!6*+0*!7$%"8%!-*7"#"!-*0(7%1"624%5-$#$%#$+#$#%
2-"3,'(%#=$%3)""-+-,-#(%#)%0)&#-&4$%#=$%*$"$'*0=%)&%#=$%#*4#=5%D=$%2-',)/4$%G-#=%
,-$%,6(9*,*"+%(+9%,-$%#$+#$#%3*:$+%;/%*,%,"%,-*+2*+3<#%0"+0$!,%7$,%.#%.+9$6#,(+9%
H% I)0$&#$%$&%,'%E'04,#'2%2$%E-,)")?C'%(%J$#*'"<%K&-.$*"-2'2%L'0-)&',%M4#1&)8'%2$%NA7-0)<%
NA7-0)<%',2)/4'*&$*)"O('=))50)8
79
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
80
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#!$%&'&#%(")'$*+,,+(-.!/0$12!$+1$2%*&%$!2$/+&.*$!2$+!0$3-!$!2$(21!%+3-!&$+1$!"&$'&#%("4$
!"#$%&'%()#$*)$+($,-.#$(/#0)$1-2$3#+1##/$+"#$%'#4*(&)52$%(/6#'#67$*/$('6#'$
+($'#+"*/.$*+$-/6$#/'*8"$*+$9'(,$+"#$8&''#/+$#%(8":
!"#$%&'()5$-1+!/0$!"2-6"!0$"+'!2%/0$7%+1(+7.&0$.+,&0$.+8+!4
La unidad del pensamiento
9#$#(!+:+*#*$,+.2';,+(#$&'$7&1'#%4$<'!#$:2(#(+;1$&'$*+$!+72$*&$7&1'#8+&1!24$
=+'!+16-+82'$'-$7&(-.+#%+*#*$*&$(-#.>-+&%$2!%#$!&2%?#4$<1$&'!&$7&1'#8+&1!2$(21@
:&%6&0$#*&8A'0$!2*2$7&1'#8+&1!25$,-1*#8&1!#$.2'$*&8A'$'#3&%&'0$#'?$(282$
.#$27+1+;14$B+1#.8&1!&0$&'!#$!&2%?#$&'$7%#C+'D$12$';.2$&'$-1#$,2%8#$*&$:+:+%0$'+12$
>-&$&1$'&1!+*2$%#*+(#.$&.$7&1'#8+&1!2$&'$:+*#4
<.$7&1'#8+&1!2$&'$(21(%&!2$/$&'7&(?,+(24$E2$23'!#1!&0$.#$&'7&(+,+(+*#*$*&.$
(21(&7!2$*&$7&1'#8+&1!2$&'$!#1$#83+6-#$(282$.#$&'7&(+,+(+*#*$*&$.#$,+.2'2,?#4$
F$!#.$6%#*2$'21$+1*+'!+16-+3.&'$.2'$.?8+!&'$*&$'-$(21(&7!2$>-&$+1(.-'2$'-$'&1!+*2$
7-&*&$&C!%#:+#%4$=&'*&$.#$82*&%1+*#*$*+'721&82'$*&$*+:&%'2'$&G&87.2'$*&$.#$
&'7&(+,+(+*#*$/$#83+6H&*#*$*&.$7&1'#8+&1!24$
<1$.#$'&6-1*#$*&$'-'$,"(-./0-&+")$1"./23)-0/)$=&'(#%!&'$#,+%8#0$72%$-1#$
7#%!&0$>-&$.#$(2'#$7&1'#1!&$&'$(287%&1*+*#$!#83+I1$(282$8&1!&0$&1!&1*+8+&1@
!20$#.8#$2$%#J;1$/0$72%$2!%#$7#%!&0$'&K#.#$>-&$&'$+1"&%&1!&$#$'-$&'&1(+#$&.$*-*#%0$
&1!&1*&%0$#,+%8#%0$1&6#%0$>-&%&%0$12$>-&%&%0$+8#6+1#%$/$'&1!+%4$=&'(#%!&'$!28#$
'&8&G#1!&$:#%+&*#*$(21(&7!-#.$(282$.#$7%+8&%#$&:+*&1(+#$(.#%#$/$*+'!+1!#0$(%+@
!&%+2$*&$.#$(&%!&J#4$9#$*&!&%8+1#(+;1$7%+8#%+#$*&.$7&1'#%$&1$=&'(#%!&'$12$&'$
*&.$!2*2$&:+*&1!&D$'+1$&83#%620$(21G-6#$!2*#'$#>-&..#'$12(+21&'$8&*+#1!&$.2'$
(21(&7!2'$+1!-+%$/$7&%(+3+%0$*A1*2.&'$&.$'&1!+*2$*&$4'-+0-4-&4$<1$&.$7%+1(+7+2$&'!A$
.#$-1+*#*4$9#$7%&6-1!#$&'0$&1!21(&'0$(;82$(287%&1*&%$&.$7%+1(+7+24
<1$ .#'$ 5"67/)$ 4/'/$ 7/$ (-'"00-8+$ ("7$ ")43'-.*$ L02'40$ %&6.#$ !"M$ '&K#.#$ >-&$ &.$
7%+1(+7+2$&'$.2$/9)&7*.&4$<'!2$>-+&%&$*&(+%0$#$'-$:&J0$>-&$&'$.2$)-147"4$F832'$
#!%+3-!2'$.2'$*&'(-3%&$&.$+1!-+%$&1$'-$7%27+2$'&%$#.$#-!2&C#8+1#%'&4$B%&1!&$#$&'!&$
,(6($6#$)#'$6#$5-$*/+&*8*;/$#)+<$5-$6#6&88*;/7$6#$+-5$)&#'+#$=&#$>?$-=&#55-)$
7%272'+(+21&'$>-&$'&$'+6-&1$+18&*+#!#8&1!&$*&$.2'$7%+8&%2'$7%+1(+7+2'0$3#G2$
*+:&%'#$(21'+*&%#(+;10$'21$(212(+*#'$!#1!2$72%$+1!-+(+;1$(282$72%$*&*-((+;10$
7&%2$.2'$7%+8&%2'$7%+1(+7+2'$8+'82'$';.2$72%$+1!-+(+;10$8+&1!%#'$>-&$.#'$(21(.-@
'+21&'$%&82!#'$12$.2$'21$'+12$72%$*&*-((+;1N4O$=&*-(+%$&'$(28721&%$#$7#%!+%$*&$
#.62$7%&:+24$P1!-+%0$&1$(#83+20$&'$.#$(287%&1'+;1$)-147"$&$+18&*+#!#$>-&$(#7!#$
O$ Q&1I$=&'(#%!&'0$5"67/)$4/'/$7/$(-'"00-8+$("7$")43'-.*0$F.+#1J#0$R#*%+*0$STTU0$"""0$74$VO4
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
81
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$"%&'"()"*+#"#,*-(&."&#"/&0,1."#$"-1)-,)"#&1"0)*)"!"#$%&'$."()"!2#$&(3)"&4"
&("#&43,/)"/&"()",4/&-&4/,&43&5
6)"*,#*)"#$0&/&"0)4"(!"4)0,74"/&("()*+,()*)"&4"(!#"-).,'!+,$/)#5"8#01,2&"
!"#$%&'"#()*+),-#)$."&/-#)0-)#-0)/"&$1213-#)/&-/1%4"0'")/-&),-#)#"0'13-#)-)
/-&),%)5%$.,'%3)3")14%610%&7)#10-)#8,-)/-&)",)"0'"03141"0'-7)9+:)0-)#")/"&$12"0)
!(" 3)0!1()#" )" !(" %&1()#." #,4)" #7()" -)19$&" #&" &43,&4/&4." 0)4)'0)" 0(!1!*&43&"
:0)40($;&"&43)40&#"<&#0!13&#:"9$&"4)"-$&/)"-&10,2,1"4!/!"*+#"=+0,(";"&%,>
/&43&*&43&"9$&"*,"-1)-,!"*&43&?5@"6!"-&10&-0,74"4)"#&"!A)3!"&4"()"*!3&1,!(5"
8("+$0,'!*)"&#"&("-$1)"-&10,2,1#&"!"#B"*,#*)"0)*)"-&10&-0,745"C#B."-)/&*)#"
$-4/&"03"&)",)-2;"'1<-)3")!"#$%&'"#)10$,.#-)#10),%)3.3%)4"'831$%=)>%#'%)51;%&#")
&4" 9$&" 4,4A$4!" -&10&-0,74" 0)1-)1!(" !/9$,&1&" #&43,/)" -)1" #B" #)(!5" <&#0!13&#"
-,&4#!"&4"&("*,#*)"#&43,/)"9$&"()#"A1,&A)#D"!9$&(()"0!-!'"/&"-&10,2,1."&4"E(3,*!"
,4#3!40,!."4)"#)4"4,"()#")F)#"4,"()#")B/)#"-)1"#B"*,#*)#."#,4)"&("!(*!5"G$!(9$,&1"
3,-)"/&"-&10&-0,74",40,/&"&4"(!"0)#!"-&4#!43&H"#,4"I#3!"(!"-&10&-0,74"#&4#,2(&"
4)"&#"-)#,2(&5
6)"&#-&0B=,0)"/&("+$0,'!*)"&#"#$"#,*-(&'!";"#$"0!1+03&1"!2#)($3)5"J,4"&*>
2!1A)."-$&#3)"9$&"&("-&4#!1"4)"#&"/,#)0,!"/&("*$4/)."3!*-)0)"#&"/,#)0,!"/&"()"
)31)."&#"/&0,1."/&"!9$&(()"9$&"4)"&#"-&4#!*,&43)5"6)"#,*-(&";"!2#)($3)"!/9$,&>
1&"#&43,/)"-)1"#$"1&(!0,74"0)4"&("3)/)."0)4"()"0)*-$&#3)";"()"-!13,0$(!15"<&2,/)"
!"&#3!"1&(!0,74"1&#$(3!"0)*-(&F)"&K-1&#!1"&("0!1+03&1"-!13,0$(!1"/&("-1,40,-,)5"<&"
!LB"&("-(&K)"/&"0)40&-3)#"0)4"()#"9$&"<&#0!13&#"&K-1&#!"(!"&#&40,!"/&"(!"*)#1
+$0,'!/#5" 6!" !*2,AM&/!/" /&(" -1,40,-,)" &#" ,4L&1&43&" !" #$" #$#3!40,!(,/!/" ;" #$"
0!1+03&1"=$4/!43&5"8#3!"!*2,AM&/!/"4)"#&"/&2&"!"$4!"=!(3!"/&"/,#0&14,*,&43)"
)"!"$4!"%,#,2,(,/!/"=!((,/!"#)21&"&("-1,40,-,)."#,4)"!"(!#"/,=,0$(3!/&#"/&"(!"-!(!21!"
-!1!"&K-1&#!1()"&4"#$"-$1&'!5"G,&13!*&43&."&("-&4#!1"&431!N!"0,&13!",4/&-&4>
/&40,!."-&1)"I#3!"4)"#,A4,=,0!"!$#&40,!"/&"1&(!0,745"8("O&4"#B?";"O-)1"#B?"9$&"(!"
=,()#)=B!"!31,2$;&"0)4#3!43&*&43&"!("-1,40,-,)"F!*+#"#&"1&=,&1&"!"$4!"&*!40,-!>
0,74" 1!/,0!(" ;" -$1!5" P)/)" =,(7#)=)" L!" 4)3!/)" 9$&" $4" -1,40,-,)" 9$&" 4)" A$!1/!"
1&(!0,74"0)4"&("3)/)"&#"3!4"&#3I1,("0)*)"$4!"*&1!")-,4,745"Q4"-1,40,-,)"/&#-1&4>
/,/)"/&"()#"&43&#"4)"3,&4&"0!2,/!"&4"=,()#)=B!5
8("-1)2(&*!"9$&"/&"0)43,4$)"#&"-1&#&43!"&4"(!"=,()#)=B!"0)4#,#3&"&4"L!0&1"
%&1"9$&"&("-1,40,-,)."#,&4/)"!(A)"23#"9$&"$4"&43&"-!13,0$(!1."4)"&#"!F&4)"!"3)/)"
()"-!13,0$(!15"8#3)"&#"()"9$&"&4"3,&*-)#"1&0,&43&#"R&,/&AA&1"/&4)*,4!"/,=&1&4>
0,!")43)(7A,0!."#,"2,&4"L!"#,/)";!"-&4#!/)";"4)*21!/)"/&"*$0L!#"=)1*!#"!"()"
(!1A)"/&"(!"L,#3)1,!"/&"(!"=,()#)=B!5"6!"/,=&1&40,!":((+*&#&")43)(7A,0!")"/&"0$!(>
9$,&1")31)"*)/):"4)"&#3!2(&0&"$4"/$!(,#*)."#,4)"(!"1&(!0,74";"(!"$4,/!/5
J,"%)(%&*)#"!"<&#0!13&#."%&*)#"07*)"()#"/$!(,#*)#"9$&"#&"/&#-1&4/&4"
/&" #$" ,4%&#3,A!0,74" #&" 0,*&43!4" &4" #$" 2E#9$&/!" &K-1&#!" -)1" (!" $4,/!/5" 6!"
@" S&4I"<&#0!13&#."-).,'!+,$/)#12)'!45#,+!#161$'*$#1')7'$#."T1&/)#."U!/1,/."@VVW."-5"WV5
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
82
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%$&$'(&)'"*%+#'",-&'*&!"%&.-"/#..#0"&$'&(%&1!'&2(&)%3,'&%(&#"/'*,#4%3&(%&/'35
$%$6&7-&'*&43%,!#,-&1!'&$#4%8&.-+-&)3#+'3&)3'.'),-&$'&*!*&!"#$%&8&(-&*#4!#'",'9
:&;'+-*&$'&)'"*%3&1!'&'*,<"&'"(%=%$%*&$'&,%(&+-$-&'",3'&*>&,-$%*&(%*&.#'".#%*8&
1!'&'*&+!.;-&+<*&?<.#(&%)3'"$'3(%*&,-$%*&@!",%*&%&(%&/'=8&1!'&*')%3%3&!"%&*-(%&$'&
'((%*& $'& (%*& $'+<*6& A*>& )!'*8& *#& %(4!#'"& 1!#'3'& #"/'*,#4%3& *'3#%+'",'& (%& /'3$%$&
$'& (%*&.-*%*8&"-&$'B'&'('4#3&!"%&.#'".#%&$','3+#"%$%8&)!'*&,-$%*&'*,<"&'",3'&*>&
'"(%=%$%*&C&$')'"$#'"$-&!"%*&$'&-,3%*&3'.>)3-.%+'",'D&*#"-&1!'&)#'"*'&,%"&*0(-&
!"#$%&!%!"'$&#($#()*#"$')&$(#+!#($#&$*,"-E
F%&'%()"&*&+!"#/'3*%(&G.-+-&H'*.%3,'*&((%+%&%&(%&?#(-*-?>%G&'*&(%&#"/'*5
,#4%.#0"&$'(&-3$'"&C&(%&!"#$%$&$'(&,-$-6&I-3&'((-&#"*#*,'&'"&1!'&.-+)3'"$'3&(%&
!"#$%$& $#*'..#-"<"$-(%& '*& !"& 1!';%.'3& +%(-43%$-6& I%3%?3%*'%"$-& %& I(%,0"&
;'+-*& $'& %?#3+%3& 1!'& $'*,%=%3& (-& .-+J"8& %(& +-$-& $'& !"& +%(& .%3"#.'3-8& '*&
$'*)3-)-3.#-"%$-&C&%@'"-&%&(%&?#(-*-?>%6&A*#+#*+-8&.!%"$-&%*'/'3%&H'*.%3,'*&
1!'&)%3%&.-+)3'"$'3&'(&+!"$-&*'&3'1!#'3'&$'&!"%&)3'/#%&#",3-*)'..#0"&$'&(%*&
?%.!(,%$'*&$'(&;-+B3'8&"-&$'B'+-*&.3''3&1!'&*0(-&'*,'&'K%+'"&)3'/#-&.-"*,#5
,!C'&,-$-&'(&1!';%.'3&?#(-*0?#.-6&L(&$'*%33-((-&$'(&)'"*%+#'",-8&1!'&*'&*#4!'&$'(&
.&/"%/./01#2$#%0"3'/')4!"+0#($#)"/+$+5#6)/*7#!"#!(#%$30#+!#8!3%$&'!3#!(#%$9/"0#
1!'&*#4!'&'"&*!*&,"-*(%.*/0"&&"-&'*&%?-3,!"%$%8&C%&1!'8&)-3&*!&.%3<.,'3&$#$<.5
,#.-8&)3'*'",%&'"&)3#+'3&(!4%3&!"&$!%(#*+-6&M%C&1!'&"-,%38&"-&-B*,%",'8&.!<(&'*&
3'%(+'",'&'(&-3$'"&"%,!3%(&$'&*!&#"/'*,#4%.#0"D&%*>&*'&'*.(%3'.'&'"&1!2&.-"*#*5
,'&(%&!"#$%$&$'(&)'"*%+#'",-&1!'&('&#",'3'*%6
I-$3>%+-*&$'.#3&1!'&'"&'*%&-B3%&$'&+%$!3'=&H'*.%3,'*&.-+#'"=%&(%&'K)-5
*#.#0"&"-&)-3&'(&)3#".#)#-8&*#"-&)-3&'(&3'*!(,%$-8&%&*%B'38&'"&(%&#"/'*,#4%.#0"&)-3&
(%&/'3$%$&*'&;%"&$'&.-"*#$'3%3&$-*&)%3,'*&1!'&%.,!%(+'",'&((%+%+-*&*!@',-&C&
-B@',-6&L(&'K%+'"&'*&B#)%3,#,-&)-31!'&#"/'*,#4%&(-*&(>+#,'*&,%",-&$'(&1!'&.-"-.'8&
%090#+!#(0#:)!#.)!+!#%0"0%!&#+!#($3#%03$35#;)3%$#($#+/&!%%/,"#+!(#!3.<&/')#
N%.3'.'",%3&(%&(!=&"%,!3%(O8&$'(&+#*+-&+-$-&1!'&1!#'3'&$','3+#"%3&1!2&'*&.-45
"-*.#B('& $'(& -B@',-& C& 1!2& "-& (-& '*6& A!"1!'& *!& -B@',#/-& '*& !"#,%3#-8& '"& '*,'&
)3-.'$'3&*'&;%&.-+)3'"$#$-&'(&P$-+#"#-Q&$'(&*!@',-&*-B3'&'(&-B@',-9&(%&*'1/&*2
.*30&$'(&)'"*%+#'",-&*-B3'&(%&3'%(#$%$6
H'&%;>&*'&$'*)3'"$'&'(&$!%(#*+-6&I-3&!"&(%$-8&'(&*!@',-&*'3>%&(-&%B*-(!,-8&'*&
+!%/&1#=-$:)!((0#:)!#%0"'/!"!#!"#3<#($#"$')&$(!*$#.)&$#4#3/9.(!#>-?#(0#:)!#3!#
.-"*#$'3%&.-+-&#"$')'"$#'",'8&.%!*%8&*#+)('8&!"#/'3*%(8&!"-8&#4!%(8&*'+'@%"5
'!-@AR#!(#0BC!'01#!"#%$9B/01#3!&<$#(0#&!($'/201#=-#(0#:)!#.$&'/%/.$#!"#($#9/39$#
"$')&$(!*$#0#$(#9!"03#!"#$(D0#+!#!(($#>-?#(0#:)!#3!#(($9$#+!.!"+/!"'!1#!E!%'01#
E& H'*.%3,'*8&!"#$%&-1#/14+.*(48&S8&)6&TU6
R& 56*-68&)6&VT6
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
83
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&'(")*$+,(-!%.+,)*#/.(-$.&)*0&'-1%+.234!"#$%"$&"'()('*&)+,("'-./0.&0*&"1("
2+3&)&0'+("+))&'-0'+1+(41&"&0*)&"2-$"5-1-$6"5&0$(.+&0*-7&8*&0$+90:"&$5%)+*;70(*;7
)(1&,(:"(1.(7';&)5-<
=+0" &.4()>-:" $+" 0-$" 2&?(.-$" >;+()" 5-)" &$*(" 1&'*;)(" '1@$+'(:" 1(" !"#$%&'&"
;0+A&)$(1"$&".(17'-.5)&02&)%("'-.-"!"#$%&'&";0+1(*&)(1:"&0"';B-"'($-"2&?()%("
2&"$&)"3+1-$-3%(<"C("+0A&$*+>('+90"2&"1(";0+2(2"2&1"5&0$(.+&0*-:"&.5&)-:"0-"&$"
&8'1;B&0*&<" C(" ;0+2(2" 2&1" 5&0$(.+&0*-" 0-" 5&)*&0&'&" $91-" (" 1(" )('+-0(1+2(2"
D;.(0(<"E0")+>-)"$91-"2&$2&"1(";0+2(2"$&"'-.5)&02&0"1-$"2;(1+$.-$6"1-"(4$-7
1;*-"B"1-")&1(*+A-:"1-"$;4?&*+A-"B"1-"-4?&*+A-:"($%"'-.-"*-2("$;5;&$*("(0*+0-.+(:"
+.51+'(0"F&85)&$(.&0*&"-"0-F"1("(%)"*'+,"2&"1-$"*G).+0-$<
=(4&.-$"H;&"("5()*+)"2&"I&$'()*&$"F(;0H;&"0-"$+&.5)&"$&>/0"$;"'-0A+'7
'+90F"$&"2("5($-"("1("+0A&$*+>('+90"5-)"1-$"1%.+*&$"2&1"5&0$()"D;.(0-:"B("$&("
5()("(?;$*()1-$"D($*("($3+8+()"$;"*&02&0'+(-0(*;)(1:"B("5()("(.51+()1-$:"B("5()("
2+3;.+0()1-$<"J&)-"1("5)&>;0*("5-)"&1"1%.+*&"&$";0("'-0$*(0*&"&0"1("3+1-$-3%("2&$7
2&"$;$"'-.+&0,-$<"C-"H;&"'()('*&)+,("&$*("5)&>;0*("&0"1(".-2&)0+2(2"&$"1("
+0*&0'+90"H;&"*+&0&0"(1>;0-$"5&0$(2-)&$"2&"2&*&).+0()"1-$"1%.+*&$"/0+'(.&0*&2&$2&"1(")(,90"$;4?&*+A(<"K(4&"5)&>;0*()0-$:"5-)"1-"*(0*-:"$+"0-"&$".@$"4+&0"&1"
L-4?&*-M"1-"H;&"'-0$*+*;B&"0&'&$()+(.&0*&"&1"1%.+*&"2&1"5&0$(.+&0*-<
E3&'*+A(.&0*&"0;0'("0-$"2&$5)&02&.-$")(2+'(1.&0*&"2&1"-4?&*-<"N(.4+G0"
&0"1("+0A&$*+>('+90"2&"O(0*:"H;&"5)&>;0*("5-)"1-$"1%.+*&$"2&"1("3(';1*(2")('+-0(1"
5-)"$%".+$.(:"D(B"B("("1("4($&";0("'-0A+''+90"$-4)&"&1".-2-"2&"$&)"2&1"-4?&*-<"
I&"(';&)2-"'-0"O(0*"1("')%*+'("2&"1(")(,90"0-")&H;+&)&"&03)&0*()$&"("1-$"-4?&*-$"
&.5%)+'-$:"B("H;&"1("3+1-$-3%("*)($'&02&0*(1"0-"&8(.+0("5)+.&)(.&0*&"1-$"&0*&$<"
5.*+67.-'-'*(,+'!&60&6(+.)*0-!&*8+6()*&'*92*':."*+;%&.*$",*&.*!%+.*!"6"!&#"'*
;%&*<=*!:#">*!-&,(+'*,&$,&'&6(+!-"6&'*?2@*':."*"-.('/('*'"6*$"'-A.&'234P"=+&02-"
1-""-.('/('"(H;&1"'()@'*&)"0&'&$()+-"&"%0$+*-"&0"1(")(,90"5;)(:"1("+0A&$*+>('+90"
*&02)%("H;&")&'(&)"$+.51&.&0*&"&0"&1".-2-"2&"-5&)()"2&"1(")(,90"D;.(0(<"=+0"
&.4()>-:"5&$&"("1("(;*-0-.%("*)($'&02&0*(1"2&1"')+*+'+$.-:"O(0*"5()*&"2&"1("+2&("
2&" H;&" &1" /01%*#2!" 5-$&&" ;0(" $;$*(0'+(1+2(2" +0*;+41&" &0" $%:" (;0H;&" 0-" $&("
5&)'+4+2("5-)"&1"D-.4)&<
C1(.("1("(*&0'+90"H;&"O(0*"0+&>;&:"5-)";0("5()*&:"1("5-$+4+1+2(2"2&"$(4&)"
H;G"$-0"1($"'-$($"&0"$%".+$.($"B:"5-)"-*)(:"(3+).&"H;&"1($"'-$($"0-"$-0"&0"$%"
.+$.($"'-.-"$-0"5()("0-$-*)-$<"QK9.-"$(4&)"H;&"D(B"2-$".-2-$"2&"$&)"2&"
.+'*!"'+'*!%+60"*%6"*0&*&'("'*#"0"'*6"'*&'*-6+!!&'-A.&B*C&#"'*0&*6"(+,*;%&)*
$+"&1"2;(1+$.-"$;?&*-7-4?&*-"2+3+';1*("1("'-.5)&0$+90"2&"1(";0+2(2:"&$*-"0-"$&"
2&4&"("1("&8+$*&0'+("2&"&$-$"2-$"&1&.&0*-$"2&1"'-0-'+.+&0*-<"C-"5)-41&.@*+'-"
&$"3)('*;)()"1(")&1('+90"&0*)&"&11-$:"&$"2&'+):"5)&$;5-0&)";0"'()@'*&)"+0*;+41&"2&"
!" 34%!5
P" R..(0;&1"O(0*:"6(7#'*"-4%-)"-("8+,-.2(":" SKE7T#U7TV#U)*DEF-!")*GHHI)*J*KL)*M*NH4
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
84
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%&#"#$'()$)#*+$!"#$%&&"$,)!$!-./*)$,)!$#)0$1(."2&3$4"0$5)$"$#).)6"2*)$70)8
#(7&#/%/92$ #)0-"$ %&.&$ '()0)0$ ,)#"*"0$ )!$ 2(,&$ :&0,/"2&$ )#*"2,&$ (2&$ ./#.&$
"."00",&3
;$%"(#"$,)$)#*"#$%&2*0"0/),",)#$2&$)#$,)$)<*0"="0$'()$#)$/2*)2*)$#(7)0"0$
)!$,("!/#.&$.),/"2*)$!"$2):"%/92$,)!$>/2&./&$#(6)*&8&>6)*&3$?/2$).>"0:&@$#($
#&!(%/92$2&$%&2#/#*)$2)%)#"0/".)2*)$)2$)<*/07"0$,)$!"$/2A)#*/:"%/92$5/!&#95/%"$"!$
#(6)*&3$B"$#(>6)*/A/,",$2&$*/)2)$7&0$'(+$#)0$2):","@$2/$1"$,)$)#*"0$0)!):","$"$
(2$#):(2,&$7!"2&3$C!$#(6)*&$)#$&'$#()*+'$"!$&>6)*&3$B"$#(>6)*/A/,",$)#$70&>!).D8
*/%"$%("2,&$2&$#)$!"$%&.70)2,)$)2$)!$%&26(2*&$,)$)#"$0)!"%/923$B"$/.7)05)%%/92$
E%&.&$,/%)$4)#%"0*)#E$#9!&$#)$7)0%/>)$%("2,&$)!$*&,&$#)$A)$7"0%/"!/F",&$G$
2&$#)$70)#*"$"*)2%/92$"$!"$0)!"%/923$B"$#(>6)*/A/,",$#9!&$%&.7&0*"$0/)#:&#$#/$#)$
!"$%&2%/>)$%&.&$#(#*"2%/"$1)0.+*/%"3
C!$70&7/&$H"2*$)#$%&2#%/)2*)$,)$)#)$0/)#:&3$I)"!/F"$(2"$%0-*/%"$,)$!"$0"F92$
7(0"$G$)#*&$'(/)0)$,)%/0$(2"$,/#)%%/92$,-*./%$,)$!"#$5"%(!*",)#$1(."2"#3$C#$
(2"$,/#)%%/92$70)A/"$7&0'()$%&./)2F"$7&0$#)7"0"0$!"$0"F92$,)$%("!'(/)0$."*)8
0/"$,)$%&2&%/./)2*&3$J&$&>#*"2*)@$+!$2&$>(#%"$E%&.&$*".7&%&$!&$1/F&$4)#%"08
*)#E$#)!!"0$!"$0"F92$)2$(2"$.)0"$#(>6)*/A/,",3$;!$%&2*0"0/&@$H"2*$#)$%(/,"$,)$
'()$!"$0"F92$2&$'(),)$%&25/2","$)2$#-$G$7&0$#-@$"!!)2,)$!&$)<*)02&3
K"0"$)#*&$,/#*/2:()$)2*0)$)!$%"0D%*)0$"2"!-*/%&$G$)!$,/"!+%*/%&$,)$!"$0"F923$B"$
"2"!-*/%"$.()#*0"$!"$/2*)00)!"%/92$)2*0)$)!$7)2#"./)2*&$G$!&#$&>6)*&#$L"!$.)2&#$
)2$ *"2*&$ 5)29.)2&#M3$ B"$ ,/"!+%*/%"@$ )2$ %".>/&@$ )#$ )2:"=&#"$ 7&0'()$ '(),"$
!"#$%&'(#)*+ !"+ %",*-(./+ *,01/*+ -&/+ ,*+ "2$"%("/-(*3+ 45+ ",+ "/)"/!(6("/)&+ 758+
%&00)$7)!/:0&$,)$1"%)0@$.),/"2*)$#&5/#*)0-"#$A"%-"#@$(2$(#&$."*)0/"!$,)$!&#$70/28
%/7/&#$.)0".)2*)$5&0."!)#$,)!$)2*)2,/./)2*&$7(0&@$6(F:"2,&$/2,/#*/2*".)2*)$
"%)0%"$,)$&>6)*&#$'()$2&$2&#$#&2$,",&#@$G$'()$'(/FD$2&$7(),"2$#)02&#$,",&#$
,)$ 2/2:(2"$ ."2)0"N3O$ P&2$ )!$ 5/2$ ,)$ )A/*"0$ !&#$ )<*0"A-&#$ ,)$ !"$ 0"F92$ 1"G$ '()$
.&#*0"0$!"$%&25&0./,",$)2*0)$!&$Q/2*)0/&0N$G$!&$Q)<*)0/&0N3$C#*&$'(/)0)$,)%/0@$7"0"$
H"2*@$.&#*0"0$!"$#-2*)#/#$,)!$)2*)2,/./)2*&$%&2$!"$#)2#/>/!/,",$G@$7&0$)2,)@$!"$
0)!"%/92$,)$!&#$%&2%)7*&#$%&2$!&#$5)29.)2&#3$;(2'()$)#*"$%&25&0./,",$*".>/+2$
,)>)$)2*)2,)0#)@$.D#$"!!D$,)$H"2*@$%&.&$!"$#-2*)#/#$)2*0)$)!$5)29.)2&$G$!"$%&#"$
)2$#-3
B"$(2/,",$,)!$7)2#"./)2*&$)2$4)#%"0*)#$G$H"2*@$7)#)$"$#(#$."*/%)#$7)%(8
!/"0)#@$"7(2*"$"$(2$/2*)0+#$%&.R2S$.&#*0"0$,)$!"$."2)0"$.D#$%0*1(%0%$7&#/>!)$
!"$0)!"%/92$,)!$7)2#"0$%&2$"'()!!&$'()$#)$7/)2#"3$K&0$)!!&$7&,).&#$"5/0."0$'()$
)#*&#$.&,)02&#$/2A)#*/:"0&2$%&2$./0"#$"$!"$%&.7)2)*0"%/92$)2*0)$!"$(2/,",$G$
!"$,/A)0#/,",@$!"$7)0."2)2%/"$G$)!$%".>/&@$)!$70/2%/7/&$G$)!$*&,&3$T@$#/2$).>"0:&@$
)#*)$70&79#/*&$5()$"#(./,&$%&.&$!"$>R#'(),"$70/A/!):/","$,)$(2$70/2%/7/&$)#*"8
>!)@$)<%!(G)2*)$,)!$,)A)2/03
O$ 23/09:+;+<=:+>+??9
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
85
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&'%"()")*$"*+,-'.,"()%'/."+,$"()"0$*"-%1&'-$*"()"2')&3*-4)"$"0$"56()%7
,'($(8"9'"0$"+,'($("()0"#),*$5'),&6"%)#%)*),&$"+,$"*+*&$,-'$"'5#$*':0)")"',$07
&)%$:0);" )0" #),*$%" )*&<" 5)%5$(6" =" )*" %)(+-&'/68" >," 0$" !"#"$ %&'(%&"" )*-%':)"
2')&3*-4)?"@)'(*"+&'(,-*8"AB6*"#),*$5'),&6*"*6,"0$*"*65:%$*"()",+)*&%$*"
*),*$-'6,)*A" *')5#%)" 5<*" 6*-+%6*;" 5<*" /$-16*;" 5<*" *'5#0)*" C+)" D*&$*E8F"
G$%$"2')&3*-4)")0"-6,&),'(6"()0"#),*$%")*"+,"-6,*&%+-&6")*-',('(6"()"0$"*),7
*$-'.,8"B$"*'5#0)3$"()0"#),*$%")*")0"/$-168
H65#0)5),&$")*&$"-%1&'-$"-6,"0$*"*'I+'),&)*"#$0$:%$*?"@./$0'(*"1-28"A>*"
+,"#),*$(6%?"C+')%)"()-'%;"*$:)"&65$%"0$*"-6*$*"5<*"*'5#0)*"C+)"-656"06"*6,E8J"
2')&3*-4)"-6,*'()%$"0$"*'5#0)3$"()0"#),*$%;"C+)"#$%$"K)*-$%&)*")%$"-0$%'($("="
('*&',-'.,;"-656"+,$"L$0&$"()"/'*'.,8"K'-46"()"6&%6"56(6;"0$"-%1&'-$"()"2')&3*-4)"
)*"0$"$-+*$-'.,"()0"@()*#%)-'6"5)&$L1*'-6E"$"06*"*),&'(6*;"$0"()/),'%"="$"0$"/'($;"
$*1"-656")0"$L<,"()"5$I,'L'-$%"0$"%$-'6,$0'($("),"0$":M*C+)($"()"+,"5+,(6"
/)%($()%68"!*1;"0$"0)-&+%$"()"2')&3*-4)"*6:%)"0$"4'*&6%'$"()"0$"L'06*6L1$"('-)"06"
*'I+'),&)?
N6(6" 06" C+)" 06*" L'0.*6L6*" 4$," /),'(6" 5$,)O$,(6" ()*()" 4$-)" 5'0),'6*" L+)%6,"
565'$*" -6,-)#&+$0)*P" 1'$ *3*$ +"(-*$ (-$ *"/&4$ 5&5-$ ("1"$ 2'"/! "#$! %&! '()! )*! +&!
1'5&'('P"06"C+)"()/'),)",6"'*#!,-&./!01)+2!3&4&*!)55&*!6.))+2!1+65(*&!6&+!4)*)*7
#)%$-'.,;"),"06"C+)")*8"Q$*"-656",6"#+)(),"$#6()%$%*)"()")006;":+*-$,"%$36,)*"
()"#6%"C+D"*)"0)*"%)&'),)8"@N'),)"C+)"4$:)%"+,$"'0+*'.,;"+,"),I$R6"),")0"4)-46"()"
'()!+&!7).610/8&*!5&!'()!)*9!:4;+4)!*)!)*6&+4)!)5!)+</=/4&.>?!@A%&!3)+)8&*2!
<.13/+! 416-&*&*2! B)*! 5/! *)+*101514/4C! D*3&*! *)+314&*! "#$! +&*! )+</=/+! /6).6/! 4)5!
5+,(6"5'21"1'2-E8"Q6%$0)O$?"()*4$-)%*)"()0"),I$R6"()"06*"*),&'(6*;"()0"()/),'%;"
()"0$"4'*&6%'$;"()"0$"5),&'%$8"B$"4'*&6%'$",6")*"5<*"C+)"L)"),"06*"*),&'(6*;"L)"),"0$"
5),&'%$8ST
B$"%$3.,;"*)IM,"2')&3*-4);")*&)%'0'3$"0$"/'($"#6%C+)",')I$"&$,&6")0"-$5:'6;"
-656"0$"5+0&'#0'-'($("()"06*"),&)*8"B$"@*$0/$I+$%($E"()"0$"/)%($(;"()0"#%',-'#'6"
="()"0$"+,'($("%)C+')%)"()"*+"()'L'-$-'.,;"-+=$"-6,*)-+),-'$")*"0$"+3'2,'"()"
E1&*F! G).&2! :6;8&! 5/! (+14/4! 4)5! 7)+*/.! 8&81H16/! 5/! .)/514/4! '()! 4)I1)+)>!
:J;8&!7()4)!)5!7)+*/.!.)-(*/.!)5!6/801&!K!5/!8(531751614/4>!D+!7.18).!5(</.2!
4$="C+)"*)R$0$%"C+)"565'L'-$%")0"()/),'%")*&<"0)O6*"()0"6:O)&'/6"()"K)*-$%&)*"
="U$,&8"G6%"6&%6"0$(6;"$+,C+)"*)"4+:')*),"#%6#+)*&6"*)5)O$,&)"&$%)$;"-$:%1$"
7.)<(+3/.9!:6;8&!-/0.L/+!5&<./4&!4)*/.316(5/.!)5!3&4&>!:J;8&!7&4.L/!/5<(1)+!
+)</.!5&!75)+/8)+3)!7&*131I&>
F" V%')(%'-4"2')&3*-4);"6"$7"#"$%&'(%&"2!,M/52!N/4.142!OPPQ2!R!QST!K!QUVF
J" 89&1F2!R!QUT!K!QUWF
ST" V%')(%'-4" 2')&3*-4);" ./$ %2'0:*%3/-$ 1'$ /-*$ ;1-/-*;" !0'$,3$;" Q$(%'(;" WTTX;" ##8" YS7YW8" B$*"
#%'5)%$*"-+%*'/$*"*6,"51$*8
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
86
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%&'"'#'()#*(%+",&(%-.#(/-0"12"#3$"%'.#+$#",4&5$"#(+*(3&6&3&'"'#+(#
*"03&")&7"#(#&%'&1&'$")&7"8#3$"%'.#'(5(%(0"#(%#(+-"#&%-(0*0(-"3&9%#'()#*(%+":
,&(%-.#3.,.#"%-2*.'"#'()#'(1(%&08#'()#3",4&.8#'(#)"#'&1(0+&'"'8#'()#-&(,*.8#'(#
)"#;&+-.0&"8#'(#)"#,$)-&*)&3&'"'8#'()#3$(0*.<#=&(-7+3;(#;"4)"#'(#).+#'(+*0(3&"'.0(+#
'()#3$(0*.#3.,.#">$()).+#(%.?"'.+#3.%#)"#1&'"<#@$0&.+",(%-(#(+#)"#1&-")&'"'#'()#
*(%+",&(%-.#)"#>$(#+(#.*.%(#?$+-",(%-(#")#"5.-",&(%-.#'(#)"#,(-"62+&3"#'()#>$(#
;"4)"#=&(-7+3;(<#A"'"#)"#1&-")&'"'#-"%#*"-(%-(#(#&%+&+-(%-(#"#).#)"05.#'(#)"#;&+-.0&"8#
;"402",.+#'(#*0(5$%-"0%.+#+&#)"#$%&'"'#'()#*(%+",&(%-.#*$('(#"5.-"0+(#3.,.#
+(#"5.-"%#).+#0(3$0+.+#%"-$0")(+#B#)"+#(+*(3&(+#"%&,")(+<
C.'"12"#D(&'(55(0#*0(5$%-"#'(#%$(1.8#(%#()#+&5).#EE8#>$F#+&5%&6&3"#*(%+"0<#
@.,*"0-(#3.%#=&(-7+3;(#)"#3.%1&33&9%#'(#$%#"5.-",&(%-.#'(#)"#,(-"62+&3"8#"+2#
!"#"$%&$'()&$()$*+)$&*+)%%"$*+)$,)$&-".&$),$)%$/01234$5),()$%+)-"$6&7$+8&$
('9):)8!'&$)8.:)$&#;",<$=+),$>').?,!6)$!"#=:)8()$)%$/0123$("#'8&8.)$)8$%&$
;&+-.0&"#3.,.#0"79%8#,&(%-0"+#>$(#D(&'(55(0#).#(%-&(%'(#3.,.#*")"40"<#G(5H%#
D(&'(55(0#)"#,(-"62+&3"#+&(,*0(#;"#*0(5$%-"'.#*.0#()#*(%+"0#'(+'(#()#I,4&-.#
'(#)"#(%$%3&"3&9%#B#)"#'(6&%&3&9%<#J+-(#I,4&-.#(+8#(%-.%3(+8#)"#!"#$%&#(%#()#+(%:
-&'.#'(#$%"#'&+3&*)&%"#'(#)"+#6.0,"+#'()#(%-(%'&,&(%-.<#!"#)95&3"8#"+2#3.,*0(%:
'&'"8#5$2"#)"#&%1(+-&5"3&9%#'(#)"+#3&(%3&"+#B#'(#)"+#.%-.).52"+#0(5&.%")(+<#K"0"#
()).#+(#+&01(#'()#*0&%3&*&.#'(#%.#3.%-0"'&33&9%<
L;.0"#4&(%8#"#*"0-&0#'(#(+-(#'(+"00.)).#'(#)"#;&+-.0&"#'(#)"#,(-"62+&3"#D(&'(:
55(0#4$+3"#'()&#3.,*0(%+&9%#'()#*(%+"0<#J+(#.-0.#+(%-&'.#(+#()#'()#0(3$(0'.8#
*.0>$(#0(3.0'"0#(+#*(%(-0"0#(%#).#%.#;.B"'.#*.0#)"#,(-"62+&3"M#N!"#,(,.0&"#(%#
()#+(%-&'.#'()#0(3$(0'.#;$,"%.#;"4&-"#(%#).#>$(#3$+-.'&"#-.'.#).#>$(#'"#>$(#
*(%+"0<# !.# ))",",.+# )"# 3$+-.'&"<# J))"# (+3.%'(# B# ")4(05"# ).# >$(# %.+# '"# >$(#
*(%+"0<#G.)",(%-(#)"#3$+-.'&"#"40(#%'*'+,'-#).#>$(#;"#'(#*(%+"0+(8#).#,I+#
,(0(3('.0#'(#*(%+"0+(O<PP#K(%+"08#*$(+8#%.#(+#$%"#6"3$)-"'#;$,"%"<#G9).#+(#
*$('(#'(3&0#>$(#N*(0-(%(3(O#")#;.,40(#*.0>$(#()#*(%+"0#*(0-(%(3(#*0&,"0&":
,(%-(# "# ">$()).# >$(# +(# '.%"# ")# ;.,40(<# !.# .3$)-.# $# .)1&'"'.# '(-0I+# '(# )"+#
'(-(0,&%"3&.%(+#)95&3"+#>$(#;"%#&,*(0"'.#(%#)"#,(-"62+&3"#(+#">$()).#"#).#>$(#
+(#0(6&(0(#D(&'(55(0#")#;"4)"0#'(#).#>$(#3$+-.'&"8#(+3.%'(#B#")4(05"<#G(#-0"-"#
'(#)"#3.%'&3&9%#'(#*.+&4&)&'"'#'(#)"#$%&'"'#'()#*(%+",&(%-.#,(-"62+&3.M#()#+(0<#
J)#+(%-&'.#>$(#'"#D(&'(55(0#")#*(%+"08#3.,.#3$")>$&(0#.-0.#'"'.#*.0#)"#;&+-.0&"#
'(#)"#,(-"62+&3"8#(+#0(%.1"'.0#B8#(%#(+(#+(%-&'.8#0(1&-")&7"#).#B"#'&3;.<
C"%-.#=&(-7+3;(#3.,.#D(&'(55(0#"6&0,"%#>$(#)"#6&).+.62"#Q)"#,(-"62+&3"Q#
;"#'"'.#'(#+2<#G&%#(,4"05.8#)"#*0(+(%3&"#B#3.%-&%$&'"'#'(#(+-"#1.3"3&9%#(+#
,"%&6&(+-"#(%#()).+M#3.,*0(%'(%+)"#$%&'"'#'()#*(%+"0#B#)"#'.-"%#%$(1",(%-(#
'(#+&5%&6&3"'.8#B"#+("#3.,.#;&+-.0&"#'(#$%#(00.0#B#'()#'(+*0(3&.#*.0#()#3$(0*.#B#
)"#1&'"8#B"#3.,.#)"#;&+-.0&"#'()#.3$)-",&(%-.#.#0(;H+.#'(#).#>$(#+(#'.%"<#!"#
PP# R"0-&%#D(&'(55(08#./01+2$#-$3$%&+45-2&)68#C0.--"8#R"'0&'8#STTU8#*<#PVW<
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
La unidad del pensamiento
87
!"#$%&'()#*+,"*"--$.*--"%&#*&*'&/$*0,".1!&*+,"*"-*&2$1&0("#1$*#$*3,"4"*."!*
3-"#$5*6("03!"*7&8*'!"&'()#*8*!"'!"&'()#*4"*-$.*0(.0$.*3!$/-"0&.*8*.$-,'($#".*
"#*9(-$.$9:&5
;#*-&*7(.1$!(&<*+,"*".*,#(4&4*"#*4"%"#(!<*="2"-*'$03!"#4"*-&*,#(4&4*4"-*
3"#.&0("#1$*9(-$.)9('$*'$0$*,#&*0(.0&*1&!"&<*+,"*#$*3$!*"--$*."*-(0(1&*&*'&-'&!*
!"#$%#&'()"*#+,#-.#/%./"#01-#!%#2'!"3"24%#3-#"(15%#('-6/%7-./-#&-#!%#!"#$%$*"#*
2"#"!&-<*3"!$*#$*4"*-&*0"!&*(4"#1(4&4*&/.1!&'1&*#(*4"*-$*&/.$-,1$*%&':$<*.(#$*4"*
-&*,#(4&4*&'"&()*%*>4"-*'$#'"31$?*@8*-&*9(-$.$9:&*&*-$*-&!2$*4"*1$4&*"--&*#$*7&'"*
$1!&*'$.&@*'&4&*"1&3&*4"-*3!$'".$*".*,#&*$)*)(+#"%&#,"-.)&!/#%(-0-.('.#%*4"*
".1&*!"#$%$#(".(6-/%,89AB*C&*,#(4&4*".*"-*$/D"1$*4"-*3"#.&0("#1$*8*"--&*.)-$*
".*,#(4&4*4"*4(.1(#1$.*0$0"#1$.*3&!1(',-&!".5
E9(!0&*="2"-*"#*.,*1"&#&/'.)$#%*>&2(9:#;#<=>#01-#5-.3%6#-3#!"#7'37"#01-#
'!""!<*.&/"!*"*(#1,(!5*;.1$.*1F!0(#$.*4('"#*-$*0(.0$*3$!+,"*."G&-&#*"-*0$4$*3$!*
"H'"-"#'(&*4"-*3"#.&0("#1$I*-&*".3"',-&'()#<*".*4"'(!<*"-*'$#'"/(!*(#0"4(&1$*
+,"*"#1!&G&*-&*0"4(&'()#*>-$*4(%"!.$?5*J$#*"-*'$#'"31$*4"*".3"',-&'()#*="2"-*
3!$',!&*0$.1!&!*-&*'$03-"0"#1&!("4&4*4"-*1$4$*4".4"*.,.*4(.1(#1&.*3"!.3"'1(K
%&.5*;#*".$*'$#.(.1"*"-*3.)&!/!+I*,#*0$%(0("#1$*"#*"-*+,"*-$*+#3+'*."*!"9-"D&*
"#*-$*$#2)()"*)*8*-$*$#2)()"*)*"#*-$*+#3+'5*;#*"-*L%&(%F#M*4"-*!"9-"D$*".3"',-&1(%$*
/,.')*="2"-*-&*"H3!".()#*0N.*&4"',&4&*&*-&.*'$.&.*0(.0&.*3&!&*0$.1!&!*.,*
!"-&'()#*(#1!:#."'&<*-&*',&-*."*4&*(#'-,.$*"#1!"*&+,"--$.*'$#'"31$.*+,"*3&!"'("K
."#*'$03-"1&0"#1"*(!!"4,'1(/-".5*
;-*0&-*--&0&4$*3!$/-"0&*4"*-$*,#$*8*-$*0O-1(3-"<*3$!*"D"03-$<*#$*".*3&!&*
="2"-*@'$0$*1&03$'$*-$*".*3&!&*$1!$.*9(-).$9$.@*,#&*4(9(',-1&4*,*$/.1N',-$*3&!&*
"-*3"#.&!5*E*-$*0N.<*'$#.1(1,8"*,#&*4(9(',-1&4*"#'$#1!&!*-&*9$!0&*&4"',&4&*4"*.,*
"H3!".()#5*;#*-&*4#)"&#%-$)-/%-/,5#&%*".'!(/"*="2"-*-$*.(2,("#1"I*L;.*,#&*&#1(2,&*
3!$3$.('()#*+,"*-$*!"'*".*+6/*#./)*8*".3"'(&-0"#1"*+,"*-$*+6/*#./)*".*!"'M5AP*
J&4&*,#&*4"*".&.*3!$3$.('($#".*3&!"'"*4"'(!*-$*0(.0$*+,"*-&*$1!&Q*.(#*"0/&!K
?":#+,#!%#@-6&%&#&-#!"#1."#$#!"#7A!/'5!-:#-B56-3%&%#-.#56"5"3'('".-3:#%5%6-(-#
-.#1.%#2"67%#'.%&-(1%&%,8:AR*".1$*3$!+,"*-&.*3!$3$.('($#".*3&!1(',-&!".*.$#*
1.'!%/-6%!-3:#7'-./6%3#01-#+,#-3/%#@-6&%&#/'-.-#01-#(".(-C'63-#$#-B56-3%63-#
3D!"#("7"#1.#&-@-.'6:#("7"#1.#56"(-3":#1.%#6-51!3'D.#$#%/6%(('D.,89AS*E.:<*
3,".<*"#*"-*4(#&0(.0$*4"-*3"#.&!*."*"#',"#1!&*-&*,#(4&4<*".*4"'(!<*-&*%"!4&45
AB* T"$!2*U(-7"-0*V!("4!('7*="2"-<*1"&#&/'.)$#%-$)-/%3-&#)"&#%3-2#/'3,2#&%3<*E-(&#W&<*X&4!(4<*
EFFG:#;#GH=#$#<FF9
AP* T"$!2*U(-7"-0*V!("4!('7*="2"-<*4#)"&#%-$)-/%-/,5#&%#I:#J"!%6KL%()-//-:#M1-."3#N'6-3:#OPP=:#
35*BBY5
AR* 7$)+8
AS* 7$)+8
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
88
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%&#'("#)"*"+#,"-$+".#$#/010#2+$345670.#'("#%$7"#8$+3$#+$#"9":763$7645#
"5#"+#2"5,$/6"530#16$+;73670#2$:$#70/2:"51":#'("#+0#(50#<#+0#/=+362+"#0#+$#(56>
1$1#<#+$#16?":,61$1#,"#70/2"5"3:$5#651"8"736@+"/"53"A#B8"736?$/"53".#9$/C,#%$#
,610#"D3:&5,"70#$#+$#(561$1#1"+#2"5,$/6"530#+$#5"7",61$1#1"#2:"2$:$:,".#"9":>
763$:,"#<#1"2(:$:,"A#E"#:"'(6":"#$865$:#+$#2:026$#?6,645#2$:$#70/2:"51":#+0#70>
/=5#<#:"865$:#+$#"D2:",645#2$:$#2":/636:#,(#7057"27645A#B,30#'(6":"#1"76:.#"5#"+#
7$,0#1"#)"*"+.#/0,3:$:#/"16$53"#"+#2"5,$/6"530#1"+#",2&:63(#+0#'("#"5#"+#2"5>
,$/6"530#+4*670#<#$@,0+(30#<$#,"#2:","53$A
F$#(561$1#<#+$#16?":,61$1#%$5#1"#,":#"D2(",3$,#$+#(5&,050#2$:$#+0*:$:#+$#
/$<0:#7057:"7645#20,6@+"A#G05#",3$#10@+"#3$:"$#"53:"#/$50,#)"*"+#H5$1$#$#705>
3:$70::6"53"IA# B,30# 20:'("# "5# ,(# ;207$.# 2","# $# +$# ,(2(",3$# "D$+3$7645# 1"# +$#
:$J45.#)"*"+#0@,":?$#"+#10/6560#1"+#,"53610#70/=5#'("#,4+0#$7"23$#+$#16?":,61$1#
<#56"*$#+$#(561$1A#F0#'("#%$#1"#%$7":#)"*"+#",.#"53057",.#:",$+3$:#+$#(561$1.#
,65#5"*$:#+$#16?":,61$1A#B+#2"5,$/6"530#'("#+0*:"#/0,3:$:#$:/4567$/"53"#",3$#
6/@:67$7645#",#",2"7(+$36?0#<#1$#:$J45.#20:#+0#3$530.#1"#+$#653"::"+$7645#16$+;736>
7$A# B,30# +0# 0@,":?$/0,# 5("?$/"53"# "5# "+# 7$,0# 1"# +0# (50# <# +0# /=+362+"A# F0#
/=+362+"#K$#+0#'("#)"*"+#1"50/65$#"5#"+#,6*(6"53"#2$,$9"#+0,#/(7%0,L#/(",3:$#
,(#:"+$7645#(563$:6$#/"16$53"#"+#7057"230#1"#"D7+(,645M
!"#$%"&'()"*+'%,#(*-&$(&".&(&/-0$*.%"1%-%"&,"%(/%2"1*.*"#$%"&'"#$%3"1*.*"#$%"
",#(50#"53:"#/(7%0,N#<#"D7+(<"#$#+0,#03:0,N#1"#/010#'("#3010,#,05#$@,0+(3$/"5>
3"#+0#/6,/0#<#",3C#2:","53"#"5#$@,0+(30#,4+0#(5$#=567$#1"3":/65$7645A#B,3"#",#"+#
%"7%0.#<#",#,4+0#7(",3645.#20:#"51".#1"#+0*:$:#+$#70/2:"5,645#1"#",3"#,6/2+"#%"7%0A#
F$#0@,365$7645#1"+#653"+"730#,"#:"%=,$#$#",3"#"53"51":#,4+0#20:#"+#/036?0#1"#'("#
&'()"4/&'&$(&"(*-+05$",*".06&/&$10*"7!8"9&/%"&'(*".06&/&$10*"$%"'&"%-0(&".&+0.%"*"
$'("+#%"7%0.#3$+#70/0#$'("+#%"7%0#"D6,3"#$#2",$:#1"#+$#168":"576$AOP
Q:"53"#$#+$#/":$#0265645#R$#+$#'("#)"*"+#++$/$#653"+"730R#'("#",#657$2$J#
1"#2:07"1":#"5#+$#65?",36*$7645#<#,"#2$:$+6J$#$#7$(,$#1"+#/C,#/&56/0#0@,3C7(>
+0.#+$#86+0,08&$#@(,7$#705365($/"53"#"+#$?$57"#?63$+A#B5#",0#705,6,364#"+#/0?6>
/6"530#1"#+$#1"1(77645#1"#!",7$:3",.#+$#,&53",6,#1"#+$#6/$*65$7645#1"#S$53.#+$#
16$+;7367$#7057"23($+#1"#)"*"+A#T01$,#",3$,#3",6,#%$7"5#:"8":"576$.#"5#2:6/":#
+(*$:.#$#+$#70/2:"5,645#1"+#3010#/"16$53"#"+#2"5,$/6"530A#U0#,05#$@,3:$77605",#
65168":"53",#<#/(":3$,#1"+#2"5,$:.#2(",#50#$1'(6":"5#,"53610#56#+$#2":7"27645#
,65#+$#1"1(77645.#56#"+#2"5,$/6"530#7$3"*0:6$+#,65#+$#,&53",6,#1"#+$#6/$*65$7645.#
56#+$#",2"7(+$7645!$@,0+(3$#,65#+$#16$+;7367$#1"+#7057"230A#V0:#03:$#2$:3".#"+#1",$>
::0++0#%6,34:670#",#+$#(561$1#1"+#2"5,$/6"530A#V"5,C510,"#$#,&#/6,/0.#"+#2"5>
,$/6"530#70/2:"51"#'("#3010#2"5,$:#70580:/$#(5$#(561$1A#B,3$#$86:/$7645#
OP# "#$%A.#2A#WWOA
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
89
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&'(%$%#)%#'!#*%+%,#"#)%#'!#*%()%++%$#-.$.#.)&'($($#/%!0()"1#2/#3'45"#
36/#.!0(+'.#&'%#%,,"/1#7"/#3")%$!"/#8#4"!0%3-"$6!%"/#!"#,.#(!9%!0.$"!:#,.#
$%/(+!(;(4.$"!1
7.#5(/0"$(.#)%#,.#;(,"/";<.#8#,.#;(,"/";<.#)%#,.#5(/0"$(.#.;($3.!#&'%#%/#-"/(=,%#
%!4"!0$.$#'!#5(,"#4"!)'40"$#%!#,.#0$.)(4(>!#+$.4(./#.,#)(6,"+"#4"!#,"/#-%!/.)"$%/#
.!0(+'"/1#?%$"#%/0.#()%.#&'%#/'$+%#.#-.$0($#)%#,"/#/(+,"/#@ABBB#8#@B@#!"#;'%#.C%!.#
.#,.#;(,"/";<.#%!#/'/#"$<+%!%/#+$(%+"/#8#.'!#)%/)%#.!0%/1#D(%3-$%#/%#5.#4"3E
-$%!)()"#%,#-%!/.$#4"3"#)(6,"+":#4"3"#.40(9().)#4"3F!1#2/#?,.0>!#&'(%!#$%3(E
0%#%/0.#0%/(/#.,#3.%/0$"#*"3%$":#%,#4'.,#%/4$(=%G
D(%!)"#)"/#,"/#&'%#9.!:#/(#!"#%/#'!"#%/#"0$"#&'(%!#9%#.!0%/#4>3"#/.4.$#+.!.!4(.H#
-%$"#'!"#/",":#.'!&'%#.4.=%#9(I!)",":#%/#36/#$"3"#-.$.#!"0.$,"#8#0(%!%#3%!"/#
/'0(,#%,#(!+%!("1JK
!"#$%&'(%)#*(#(+,)+#-(%+)+#./.*(#0".,12#")#+&34&(2,(5#67#%(42&*)+#+)')+#
,"/#5"3=$%/#)%#.,+F!#3")"#36/#56=(,%/#-.$.#4'.,&'(%$#!"#$%&'!()*&$&+,*-!.
/0,*#$1#D(#'!"#-(%!/.#.,+"#I,#/",":#%!#/%+'().:#3.$45.!)"#-"$#/'#.,$%)%)"$:#
='/4.#.#&'(I!#)%3"/0$6$/%,"#8#4"!#&'(I!#./%+'$.$/%:#5./0.#&'%#,"#%!4'%!0$.L1JM#
7.#!.0'$.,%N.#5'3.!.#%/#)(.,>+(4.1
7.# '!().)# )%,# -%!/.3(%!0"# %/# .3=(+'.# !"# />,"# -"$# %,# )%/.$$",,"# )%# /'#
4"!4%-0"#%!#,.#3")%$!().):#/(!"#0.3=(I!#-"$&'%#%!#/'#4"3(%!N"#+$(%+"#0'9"#
"0$"# /%!0()"# %3(!%!0%1# O(;<4(,3%!0%# -'%)%# 5"3","+.$/%# 4"!# .,+F!# 4"!4%-0"#
3")%$!"#,./#!"4("!%/#&'%#'/.$"!#,"/#+$(%+"/#-.$.#5.=,.$#)%#,.#'!().)#)%,#-%!E
/.3(%!0"H#/(!#%3=.$+":#-")%3"/#.-$"P(3.$!"/#.#%,,"/#-$%/0.!)"#.0%!4(>!#.#/'#
4"3-$%!/(>!#)%,#-$(!4(-("#)%#'!().)1
2!#9.$("/#;$.+3%!0"/#5.=,.#*%$64,(0"#)%,#0")":#)%#,.#'!().)#8#)%#,"#4"3F!1#
0.%.#%(8(%&%+(#.#(+,)#9)':2#;.<".#$%&29&$."'(2,(#*(#=>?@A#BC#(2#)9.+&)2(+C#
,.'<&D2#*(#EFGHA#B#I>GJ@AK#L+949;.%#("#,)*)#+&32&8&9.#9)'$%(2*(%")K#0.%.#;.E
=,.$#)%#"$/+',*-0)*#*%$64,(0"#5.4%#'/"#)%#)(9%$/"/#0I$3(!"/1#Q!"#)%#%,,"/#%/#
EM>NOGHAK#P(%Q9"&,)#(+9%&<&1#R(2#")#S4(#$%(+4'&<"('(2,(#84(#("#9)'&(2T)#*(#
+4#"&<%)R#")#+&34&(2,(5#67#(+#2(9(+.%&)#+(34&%#.#")#9)':2C#$(%)#.42S4(#("#=>?@A#
(+#9)':2C#".#'.B)%U.#-&-(2#9)')#+&#,4-&(%.2#42.#EM>NOGHA#$.%,&94".%VKJR
JK# *"3%$":#123!4!:#S$%)"/:#T.)$():#UVVM:#4.!0"#@:#991#UUWEUUX1
JM# ?,.0>!:#5'$#67$'!-:#S$%)"/:#T.)$():#UVVX:#-1#YWM#)1#2,#/'=$.8.)"#%/#3<"1#O%#%/0.#0$.)'4E
9&12#;.3)#42.#-.%&.9&12#*(#".+#$.".<%.+#(2#94%+&-.+K#L2#3%&(3)#0".,12#;.<".#*(#WM?@N#IXY#=>?@N#IXY#
ZHXN>OJX[#\.%9U.#\4."#,%.*49(#(+,.+#$.".<%.+#9)')#,%.<.])C#$.".<%.#B#$".2C#,D%'&2)+#S4(#2)#$.%(E
4%!#$%;,%C.$#4"!#/';(4(%!0%#;'%$N.#,"#&'%#/%Z.,.#?,.0>!1
JR# *%$64,(0":#[\$.+3%!0"/L:#%!#]"!$.)"#2++%$/#7.!#^%)1_:#8$-&902)-$9$-&+',-$"'6#0"$-#B:#S$%)"/:#
^.*%&*C#_```C#a#_K
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
90
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%&'()*+#,-./-0-1"2#,3.4/#56-,787393,2#:/#,";36#<6=17-1>?#5@A:-3632#<>6#
!"#$%&$"'#()*#+,-,.$%)*/%0)#&%1)%2%/*-%3*#,)#,!#4*5%-*.#,)#/"$()%+*+#&,16)#!*#
7-%/*#!"#$%&'()8#9&,#/")/,:-"#:(,+,#-.*+(/%.&,#:".#3%.-(+'#-,$:!*);*'#:.(<
+,)/%*#"#&,)&*-,;=#:,."#-*$5%>)#-%,),#,!#&,)-%+"#+,#,&:?.%-('#$,)-,'#%)-,!%1,)/%*'#
,";-@:6B"2#6"C8/#D#<3/,"E-3/7>?#F-3/3#@39#,:,7"/7-G>#$%H'#A:3#,-./-0-1"#1>6"<
;0)'#*!$*#"#,&:?.%-(#,)#-*)-"#*(+(#+,#!*&#,$"/%"),&#@#+,!#&*5,.8#9)#+%/4*#&,+,#
%)-,.%".#&,#/"$:.,)+,#!*#()%+*+#+,!#+,3,)%.'#+,#*4?#A(,#()"#.,A(%,.*#%)3,&-%1*.<
&,#*#&?#$%&$"#B#,-?2#I#JKJL2#":/#,-#/>#,3#3,#1"<"C#@3#M"99"6#9>,#9BE-73,#@39#"9E"#
B#,-?2#I#NOL?#
PQ>E4/# "# 7>@>,# 3,# RS# $%T'UV*'W2CD# ,&# +,/%.'# ,!# /"$:.,)+,.8# E!# 4"$5.,#
F,&->#+,&:%,.-"#"#+".$%+"F#!,#:,.-,),/,#,&-*#/*:*/%+*+8#E2%.$*#G,.H/!%-"#A(,#
9"#$%&'()*+#3,#9"#,:<63E"#<360311-8/#<"6"#39#M>E;63#X#,-?2#I#JJYL?#Z,7"#<36031<
/%0)#,&#*-,)+,.#*#!"#/"$6)'#,&-*.#+,&:%,.-"'#/"$:.,)+,.#!*#()%+*+8#9&-"#,&#!"#
,";->#3/#39#M>E;632#<:3,#[36=19-7>#,3#,-6G3#@3#9"#3\<63,-8/#RS#)T$&'#<"6"#1"<
.*/-,.%;*.#!*#,I/,!,)/%*8
!"#$%&'()*+#3,#:/>#@3#9>,#7]6E-/>,#E=,#6-1>,#@3#9"#0-9>,>0B"#.6-3."#<"6"#
/*.*/-,.%;*.#!*#()%+*+#+,!#:,)&*$%,)-"'#@*#A(,#,I:.,&*#!*#.,!*/%0)#+,#!*#()%+*+#
,)#!*#+%3,.&%+*+J#KL"$"#'!).$/*$).#"*)#,&-H#,)#)"&"-."&#!"#3%3%,)-,#@#!"#$(,.<
-"'#*&?#/"$"#!"#+,&:%,.-"#@#!"#+".$%+"'#!"#M"3,)#@#!"#3%,M"=#:(,&#>&-"&'#*!#/*$5%*.'#
&")#*A(>!!"&'#@#*A(>!!"&'#*!#/*$5%*.'#&")#>&-"&N8CO#P"#A(,#.,&%+,#,)#!*#&,+,#+,#
!*&#,$"/%"),&#@#+,!#&*5,.#,&#()*#/"$:.,)&%0)#()%3,.&*!'#*#&*5,.'#!*#/*:-*/%0)#
+,#!*#.,!*/%0)#+,!#-"+"#/")#-"+"8
9I%&-,# "-."# /")/,:-"# A(,# 2(,# $*@".$,)-,# (&*+"# ,)-.,# !"&# 1.%,1"&# :*.*#
+,)"$%)*.#!*#,I/,!,)/%*#+,#!*#/"$:.,)&%0)'#+,!#/(*!#G,.H/!%-"#&,#"/(:0#:"/"8#
Z,73#1>/13<7>#3,#'TV^'2#A:3#<"6"#39#1",>#<:3@3#76"@:1-6,3#1>E>#/!0'/-#"#:,)&*.8#
G,.H/!%-"#&0!"#&,Q*!*'#:".#,M,$:!"'#A(,#%)-(%.#+%2%,.,#+,#*/($(!*.#/")"/%$%,)-"&#
B#,-?2#I#NKL?#_"E;-]/#@-13#A:3#"73/36,3#"#9>#1>E4/#3,#M";9"6#3/#1>/0>6E-@"@#
/")#!*#%)-(%/%0)#B#,-?2#I#JJNL?#`>#>;,7"/732#1>/#399>#[36=19-7>#/>#3,19"6313#@39#
-"+"#,!#&,)-%+"#:,/(!%*.#+,!#%)-(%.8#9&#R*.$>)%+,&#()"#+,#!"&#:.%$,."&#,)#&,Q*<
9"6#9"#<633E-/3/1-"#@39#'TV^'#063/73#"#1:"9A:-36#>76>#E>@>#@3#1>E<63/@36?
R*.*#.,2,.%.&,#*!#:.%)/%:%"#+,#()%+*+#@#*#!*#/"4,&%0)#+,!#-"+"#R*.$>)%+,&#
M";9"#@3#RS#a'#D#@3#Vb'c*2#9>#A:3#3,#D#39#,36?#Z9#'TV^'#3,#39#E>@>#@3#1>E<63/@36#
*A(,!!"#&'(.(*d#Pe#3,7"/@>#":,3/73,2#<"6"#39#'TV^'#9",#1>,",#3,7=/#<63,3/73,?#
f:3,#/>#,3#-/7366:E<-6=#9"#1>M3,-8/#@39#3/73#1>/#39#3/73eW?CC#P*#%)-(%/%0)#/*:<
-*#!*#()%+*+'#:*.*#!"#/(*!#)"#.,A(%,.,#!*#:.,&,)/%*#+,#/*+*#:*.-,#+,!#-"+"8#E&?'#
CD# 12/+?2#I#JJg?
CO# 12/+?2#I#hi?#Z9#,:;6"D"@>#3,#EB>?
CC# R*.$>)%+,&'#KR",$*N'#,)#L").*+"#911,.&#P*)#B,+8S'#3"*.,/45*","*.6-(*"#-%0/#"*.!'#T.,+"&'#
j"@6-@2#YKKK2#I#N2#GG?#JkY?
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
91
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&'"'#'(!#)(%*"+&(%,-.#(%#(!#/"*-#'(#0"1+2%&'(*.#)"1(/&(*(#"3$(!!"#$%&'"'#
4"/5"#3$(#6&(,7*/8(#/1&,&/"9":#;*,"#8"#*&'-#$%"#'(#!"*#&%,(1)1(,"/&-%(*#'-+&<
%"%,(*#'(!#)(%*"+&(%,-#'(!#(!2","=#(!#/"+9&-#3$('"#(>/!$&'-#'(#!"#&%,$&/&?%#'(!#
*(1:#@&/8"#(>/!$*&?%#)"1(/(#/-!"1*(#(%#!"*#)"!"91"*#'(#0"1+2%&'(*#"/(1/"#'(#
!"#(,(1%&'"'#'(#!-#3$(#(*=#A0$(*#*&#*(#B(%(1?.#%-#(*.#%&#(*#*&#8"#'(#*(1#(%#"!BC%#
+-+(%,-#D$,$1-E:FG
6-#-9*,"%,(.#!"#$%&'"'#3$(#0"1+2%&'(*#1(D&(1(#%-#(*#!"#'(#!"#"9*,1"//&?%.#
!"#$%&'%()%&'%*&)#"+,(-%.&%/012/%#$%)!%3$4*)+)#3"'%)53&,!"6'%#"%*7"4'7"'%()&%8$4<
91(.#"*5#/-+-#,"+)-/-#!"#$%&'"'#'()(%'(#'(#"!B-#,"!#/-+-#$%#&%,$&1#)"1,&/$!"1:#
H!#/-%,1"1&-.#)-13$(#!"#$%&'"'#'(!#)(%*"+&(%,-#(*#)(%*"+&(%,-#!"#!"#$%&'"'#(!#
8-+91(#)$('(#/-+)1(%'(1#!"#/-8(*&?%:
9!:%3$4$%;)7<3&"+$%!)='&'%&'%*$!">"&"('(%()%,#'%?@A/BCDE%*)3,&"'7%()&%($7<
+&'-#I3$(#*?!-#)$('(#A)1&4",&7"1*(E#)-13$(#)1&+(1"+(%,(#(*#/-+C%#"#,-'-*#
F%'&%+$($GH%I'74J#"()!%+'4>"J#%'K"74'%L,)%)&%/0ME%*,)()%!)7%+,7>"$%N#$%-H%O%PH%
4:# JK:# L*,-# *$/('(# /$"%'-# *(# '(M"# "D(/,"1# C%&/"+(%,(# )-1# !"# )"1/&"!&'"'# '(!#
()6)#"7% N3K-H% O% QH% 66-% RSTU-% VW,'&4)#+)% !)7:'% *'73"'&% !"% &'% "#+,"3"X#% !)% '"!&'!)%
"!!(%'(#!-*#(%,(*.#/-%#!-#/$"!#*(#(>,1"4&"15"#(%#$%#)*($'-/"+&%-#/-+-#(!#'(#!"#
%"'"# N#$%-H% O% YH% 66-% ZPSZYU-% ['!% )&% "#+,"7% 3$4*7)#()% &'% ,#"('(% *$7L,)% 3'*+'%
,"%,-#!"#4(1'"'#'(!#,-'-.#/-+-#!"#"+9&4"!(%/&"#'(#!"#-)&%&?%#N#$%-H%O%ZH%66-%\YSRZU-%
O?!-#+('&"%,(#(*"#1(!"/&?%#5%,(B1"#'(#!-#/-+)!(,-#(%#*$#'&4(1*&'"'#(!#)(%*"1#
8$+"%-#!!(B"#"#/-%-/(1#!"#$%&'"'=#AP-#3$(#)$('(#)(%*"1*(#(*#!-#+&*+-#3$(#
'L,)&&$%*$7%&$%3,'&%)5"!+)%)&%*)#!'4")#+$-%.#%)K)3+$H%K,)7'%()&%)#+)%]^_%#$%8'<
!!"1Q*#(!#(%,(E:FR
P"#$%&'"'#'(!#)(%*"+&(%,-#3$(#+$(*,1"%#S(1Q/!&,-#T#0"1+2%&'(*#/-%'$M-#"#
)1(B$%,"1*(#"#0!",?%#T#H1&*,?,(!(*#*-91(#!"#*&,$"/&?%#N&'()&K#'(#!"#$%&'"':#P"#!(/<
,$1"# 3$(# 2*,-*# C!,&+-*# !!(4"1-%# "# /"9-# '(# "3$(!!-*# )1(*-/1Q,&/-*# /-%'$M-# "#
*7$>&)4'+"`'7%&'%*$!"3"X#%()&%*)#!'4")#+$-%a>!)76'4$!%F'%)#%)&%*""("(+#'(#
0!",?%#T#(%#(!#!&91-#!#'(#!"#,"(-$.&'#-#'(#H1&*,?,(!(*#$%"#&'("#9"*,"%,(#'&D$%'&'"#
*-91(#S(1Q/!&,-#T#0"1+2%&'(*=#(!#)1&+(1-#(*#(!#D&!?*-D-#'(!#'(4(%&1#T#'(!#D!$M-#
"9*-!$,-.#(!#*(B$%'-#(*#(!#D&!?*-D-#'(!#"9*-!$,-#1()-*-:#U+)!5/&,"#T#(>)!5/&,"+(%<
,(#*(#)1(B$%,"%#0!",?%#T#H1&*,?,(!(*#/?+-#8"#'(#)(%*"1*(#!"#$%&'"'#'(!#,-'-#
)"1"#(4&,"1#/"(1#(%#$%"#'(#(*"*#'-*#)-*,$1"*:
0!",?%#4"/&!"9"#1(*)(/,-#'(!#A!$B"1E#(%#3$(#*(#(%/$(%,1"#!"#$%&'"':#O(B$1-#
(*,"9"#'(#3$(#'(95"#)1(/"4(1*(#'(#-+&,&1#,"%,-#(!#/"+9&-#/-+-#!"#)(1+"%(%/&":#
b$#% )&% K"#% ()% #$% $4"+"7% #'('% 4,)!+7'% L,)% )&% cAd0E% ()% &'% ,#"('(% )!+<% )#% &'!%
D-1+"*:#6-#-9*,"%,(.#*$#,(*&*#/-11&?#(!#1&(*B-#'(#*(1#*-+(,&'"#"!#+&*+-#)1(M$&/&-#
"!#3$(#2!#*-+(,&?#"#0"1+2%&'(*:#L!#)1(M$&/&-#'&/(#3$(#!"*#D-1+"*#*-%#!-#"!!(%'(#
FG# /0'!-H%O%YH%6-%\eFR# /0'!-H%O%YH%66-%RfSRP-
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
92
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#!"$%!#&'!'"(")*+",!$-%"'%".+"/!"#"$%&'()&$01"2%$*3"%+"$&4*$3",!$!"2#!-5+"#!"
.+&'!'"%)",!-%+-%"%+"#!)"6*)!)3"!#"&4.!#"7.%"%#"6!89&*1":#"#.4!$"'%"#!".+&'!'"
!"#!$#%!#$&#'()*+(,#%!$#&$-&.#/0123!#4"5&#60-/1!7%!#5&-8947#!$#%!:!791;#<$#
)&-&*"%+"%#"7.%"'%)6!+)!"#!".+&'!'"%)3"%+-*+6%)3".+!",*)&6&5+"'%+-$*"'%"#!"$%!;
#&'!'1"<*")%"-$!-!"'%".+"#.4!$"6%#%)-%3")&+*".+"#.4!$"*!)!&*+,-=#*+>?@#?+AB;#C081!#
%)-*"'&6%"2#!-5+="/>*"7.%"%+"%#"?89&-*"&+-%#&4&9#%"%)"%#"9&%+"$%),%6-*"'%"#!"&+-%;
#&4%+6&!"("'%"#*"7.%")%"&+-%#&4%3"%)-*"%)"%#")*#"%+"%#"?89&-*"@&)&9#%"$%),%6-*"'%"#!"
@&)-!"("'%"#*"7.%")%"@%01AB">!".+&'!'"'%#",%+)!8&%+-*"%)"%#"?89&-*"7.%"8.%)-$!"
-*'*"!),%6-*%(%."'/(#DEF'+GH#!7#"3#$3-970"9%&%.#!"#%!691.#!$#-9"-0#I-8950#%!#
#*",%$6&9&'*1
C%"!DE"7.%"#!",!$-&6&,!6&5+"-.@&%)%"7.%"%)6#!$%6%$)%3")%4F+"2#!-5+3"0-)!'""
'%"#!"6*8.+&'!'"%+-$%"#!)"G*$8!)"("#*)"%+-%)3",.%)"#!",!$-&6&,!6&5+"6*$$E!"%#"
$&%)4*"'%"%)-!9#%6%$".+!"#('!*1*2)"'%"#!"$%!#&'!'1"2#!-5+",$*,*+%3",*$"#*"-!+-*3"
7.%"#!"&+-%$$%#!6&5+"(".+&'!'"%)"&+-$E+)%6!"-!+-*"!"#!)"6*)!)3"6*8*"!#"D*89$%="
JK#"9#6&%&#37&#%!#$&"#L01-&"%-$%&)%#-)$(/*-)!""("+*",.%'%"'!$)%"%+"*-$*")&-&*"
-I"# 23!# !7# $&"# &$-&"# MKN# 6&%&# L01-&# "!1O&.# !7# !L!650.# 37&# 379%&%KP;AH" :#"
,%+)!8&%+-*"%)"6*8F+I"+&")%"8.#-&,#&6!"%+"6!'!"%+-%3"+&")%"%)6&+'%"'%#"!#8!1"
>!"%)6&)&5+")5#*"%)",*)&9#%"%+"#*"8!-%$&!#1
2!$%6&%)%"#%4E-&8*3")%4F+"%)-!"&'%!3"$%-$*-$!%$"%#"'.!#&)8*"7.%"*9)%$@?9!;
8*)"6*+"C%)6!$-%)"D!)-!"#*)"4$&%4*)1"J.+7.%"#*)"4$&%4*)"+*"-$!-!+".+"'.!#&)8*"
).K%-*;*9K%-*3").)"-%)&)"@%$)!+")&+"'.'!")*9$%".+!"'&)-&+6&5+"%+-$%"#*"!9)*#.-*"
("#*"$%#!-&@*3"#*",$&8%$*"("#*",*)-%$&*$3"#*"&+85@&#"("#*"6!89&!+-%1"L!89&M+"J$&);
-5-%#%)3",*$"%K%8,#*3")%"G.%$N!"!"!'*,-!$"%)-!"'&)-&+6&5+1"O*+6&9%"#!".+&'!'"6*8*"
*+QG.#607#$0#63&$#$&#-&5!19&#R6&/5&8$!#-!%9&75!#$&#,STU>T(GR#V&#%!#"!1#"0$&;
-!75!#6&3"&#%!#$&#%9:!1"9%&%=#J<7#!L!650.#!$#*+QG#!"#370#W.#/01#5&750.#"9#5&-8947#
G.%$!".+!"#!"8!-%$&!3")%"D!9$E!"!6-.!#&N!'*")*#!8%+-%"!7.%##*",!$!"#*"6.!#"#!"
8!-%$&!"%)-!9!"%+",*-%+6&!01AP"Q&".+&'!'"("8!-%$&!"G.%)%+"#*"8&)8*3"+*"D!9$E!"
#!"8.#-&,#&6&'!'"7.%3"'%"D%6D*3"@%8*)"/!")&8,#%)"*K*)"@&)-!01
:#"$&%)4*"'%"%)-%"'.!#&)8*"#*"!'@&$-&5"-!89&M+"2#!-5+1":)"2!$8M+&'%)3"%+"%#"
'&?#*4*",#!-5+&6*"'%#"8&)8*"+*89$%3"7.&%+")%R!#!".+!"!,*$E!"!"Q56$!-%)=")&%+;
%0#/!7"&-9!750"#$&"#L01-&".#X6Y-0#/0%1O&7#6&3"&1#$&#/$31&$9%&%#%!#$&#-&5!19&Z#
2#!-5+"+*"'%)!$$*##!"D!)-!").)"F#-&8!)"6*+)%6.%+6&!)"#!"-%)&)"6*+"#!"7.%"$%);
/07%!#!"5&#08[!69Y7.#/!10#$0#/060#23!#%96!#!"#6$&19L96&%01=#JK#-36V0#-I"#[39;
6&*)*" 8%" ,!$%6%" #*" )&4.&%+-%=" %)-!)" G*$8!)3" !" #!" 8!+%$!" '%" 8*'%#*)3"
AB" 2#!-5+3"3-#4+,*1(3"S$%'*)3"T!'$&'3"AUUV3"WX!"BUY"9;61
AH" 2#!-5+3"5('/6)*0-$3"S$%'*)3"T!'$&'3"AUUA3",1"ZVA"91":#").9$!(!'*"%)"8E*1
AP" J$&)-5-%#%)3"7-!(.8$*1(3"S$%'*)3"T!'$&'3"AUUV3"[XX!"A3"ZUH\"9"VZ;VA1
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
93
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&"'"&("&()%(&%*+#%)",%-./!"#$%&'(#%)*+,#-.#/(01.1#%)#23+20.#1%#-.#4.*%5
#0%1("&(*%&*2(34567/(89*%(0&$%&"&'0%(&2('2&*#%:0"&"()%(+&0;%;(;")(!"&9%#/(!"#
$%&'()#$%)*%&%+%#(#"(#&(*,)("%-(,#.#-+#6/%#%)7#80%3*.4%(*%#-.)#9+34.)#(+#1.(#
3.:;(#1%#-.#2-/3.-01.1#%(#/(#)%(*01+#<./).-#=#-0(%.->#(+#+?)*.(*%,#-.#2-/3.-01.1#
%)#/(#1.*+#<04%(*.1+#%(#-.)#9+34.)7#@)*+#-+#4/%)*3.#A-.*;(#&3.<0.)#.#-.#10.-B<5
*0<.#1%#-+)#&B(%3+)#4.=+3%)#1%-#./01'*(7
8;4+#)%#1.#-.#10C%3)01.1#.#2.3*03#1%#-.#/(01.1#(+#%)#/(.#0(*%33+&.(*%#.2+5
3B*0<.#2.3.#-+)#&30%&+),#2/%)#-.#/(01.1#=#-.#10C%3)01.1#)+(#1.*+)7#@(#-.#2%*(034
'1+(#0()0)*%#D30)*;*%-%)#%(#6/%#%-#2304%3#4+*+3#(+#%)#<3%.1+3>#%)#230(<020+#1%#
*+1+#*02+#1%#4+C040%(*+#=,#(+#+?)*.(*%,#(+#%)#.6/%--+#.#2.3*03#1%#-+#</.-#)%#1.#
%-#1%)2-.:.40%(*+#1%#-+)#%(*%),#(0#)/#.-*%3.<0;(,#(0#)/#./4%(*+#+#10)40(/<0;(,#
(0#)/#&%(%3.<0;(#=#<+33/2<0;(7#@-#(5,%""/#(#$()*1)#6%#"/#+,("#)%#23+1/<%#%-#<.45
?0+#%)#.-&+#2.3*0</-.37#E+1+)#%)*+)#<.4?0+)#*0%(%(#-/&.3#&3.<0.)#.-#4+C040%(*+#
1%#-+)#0(10C01/+),#1%#*.-#)/%3*%#6/%#%-#2304%3+#4+*+3#2.3%<0%)%#)+?3.3#.-#%F2-0<.3#
-.#.34+(G.#1%-#<.4?0+7
$0(#%4?.3&+,#6/%#%-#2304%3#4+*+3#(+#&%(%3%#%)+)#<.4?0+)#(+#6/0%3%#1%<03#
6/%#(+#)%.#230(<020+#1%#%--+),#)0(+#6/%#)/#.<*/.3#(+#)%#.&+*.#%(#-+)#<.4?0+)#
2.3*0</-.3%)7#D30)*;*%-%)#4/%)*3.#%(#7+%)+(#6%"#("8(#<;4+#%-#2304%3#4+*+3#%),#
1%#H%<H+,#%40(%(*%4%(*%#+)%(6/),#4.)#(+#%(#%-#)%(*01+#1%#&B(%)0),#)0(+#1%#
<=6>?@/(8&()%($%*"#0%(9"(9%&%)(#%-#<.4?0+#1.1.#)/#2+*%(<0.-01.1#=#2.3*0</-.305
;%;A(")(!#0$"#($2*2#("9(<=6BC6DE@(!2#(9+(%'*2(F(+&0;%;/(8)(!#0&'0!02('2&GH2#$%#
)2( $I)*0!)"1( 90&( 9"#( '%+9%( "J*#K&9"'%( %)( *2;2L( M-( %&# "(# &(*,)("%-(( N-O( "J09*"(
.1%4I)#+*3+#230(<020+,#%-#<./).-#=#.<*0C+#.-#6/%#<+33%)2+(1%#H.<%3#*+1.)#-.)#
'29%9(N-O("9*"(I)*0$2("9(%($%&"#%(;"(+&%(61'$/'1+1:&#;(<1*,("#<+4+,#2+3#%J%45
2-+,#-.#-/:K#*.4?0B(#-.#-/:#H.<%#%(#<0%3*+#4+1+#1%#-+)#<+-+3%)#%(#2+*%(<0.#<+-+5
3%)#%(#.<*+L7!M
N+#6/%#.9034.(#A-.*;(#=#D30)*;*%-%)#%),#2/%),#6/%#%-#230(<020+#1%#/(01.1#(+#
%)#/(#2+)*/-.1+#1%#-.#3.:;(,#(0#-+#+</-*+#1%*3I)#1%#.-&+7#O0#%-#?0%(#2-.*;(0<+#(0#
%-#2304%3#4+*+3#.30)*+*B-0<+#%)*I(#.--%(1%#-.#(.*/3.-%:.7#$/#3%-.<0;(#<+(#-.#4.5
*"#0%(F()%(34567(#%;0'%("&(P+"(")(!#0&'0!02(%'()%(34567($09$%/(8&(9+(0&$%&"&'0%(
10<H+)#230(<020+)#/(090<.(#%-#*+1+#2+36/%#'/&#"(#+"()16(6#1%#-.#<+(90&/3.<0;(#1%#
-+#2.3*0</-.3>#)/#/(01.1#%)#-.#1%#-.#-/:7PQ
!"# A-.*;(,#=()8>&16%'-1(/$?#+1*?,#27#RP!#17
!M# D30)*;*%-%),#7+%)+(#6%"#("8(,#S3%1+),#T.1301,#!QQP,#UUU,#V,#WPQ#.#RQ5R"7#@-#)/?3.=.1+#%)#4G+7
PQ# X.-%#-.#2%(.#H.<%3#H0(<.20B#%(#-.#(%<%)01.1#1%#2%().3#%-#)%(*01+#1%#-.#-/:#1%#-.#6/%#H.?-.(#
A-.*;(#=#D30)*;*%-%),#.)G#<+4+#+*3+)#*.(*+)#2%().1+3%)7#@C01%(*%4%(*%,#%)*.#(%<%)01.1#(+#<+42%5
*%#.-#23%)%(*%#%().=+,#2%3+#6/0%3+#)%Y.-.3#.-#4%(+)#6/%#-.#-/:#)%#*3.*.#1%#-.#C%31.1,#-.#</.-#)%#
<+42%(%*3.#<+(#-.#/(01.1#1%-#2%().40%(*+7
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
94
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$%&' "#' ()' *+,-./01' "#' 2#3%4(567' 8' "#(' -9:;-' "#' <)3$=>5"#&?' <()6@>'
47>45A#'()'B>5")"'"#('C#>&)$5#>67'47$7'D0E-90FG'H&6)'4)C)45")"?'IB>67'47>'()'
5>6B545@>?'#&'()'J>54)'KB#'#&6%'LM'3#N#35")')'()'9O/PFQ?!"#$#%&#'($%#()#*()+,-&#
C(#>7G'<)3)'!35&6@6#(#&'()'B>5")"'"#('C#>&)$5#>67'#&'R:S+PF?'KB#'>7'&@(7'#&'B>'
C#>&)$5#>67'&7A3#'()'9O/PF?'&5>7'KB#'#>'&T'$5&$7'6)$A5=>'#&'9O/PF'8?'C73'(7'
6)>67?')B67U5>6B545@>'7')B67UC#>&)$5#>67V'LM&5'W#('C35$#3'$7673'5>$@X5(Y'#&'()'
.&*$#/0*#(1.(%*$2#*(#3,()*$#$#*4#/,*/&#5#*6#3()*$/,()+&#(*#3()*$/,()+&#-(#
3()*$/,()+&78!9
:*+&*#/&-&*#-(%#3()*$/,()+&#;',(;&#*&)#3$'+(#-(%#3%(1&#+$)#$/3%,&#.&)#(%#
<6(#.&/3'()-4$)#%$#6),-$-8#=&'#(%%&#%&*#*6/$/&*#$#%$*#)&.,&)(*#-(%#3()*$'#()#
%$#/&-('),-$->#!"#$%&'()*+('!$+('()*$,%-('$)*+(,.(')*/(,0(,)*&,.!1&-(,8#?&#<6(#
/6(*+'$)#(*+&*#.&).(3+&*#(*#(%#$@0)#@,%&*A@,.&#3&'#-(36'$'*(#-(#%&#3$'+,.6%$'2#
<6(#)&#<6,('(#-(.,'#,;)&'$'%&2#*,)&#/&*+'$'#*6#$,%(#'&2$(,%"8#B,)#-6-$#(*#+$)#
-,@4.,%#.$3+$'#(%#3',).,3,&#-(#6),-$-2#.&/&#-(.,'#$%;&#-(#C%8#:%%&2#)&#&D*+$)+(2#)&#
*(#-(D(#$#-(@(.+&*2#.$'().,$*#&#,/3(-,/()+&*2#*,)&#$#<6(#%$#6),-$-#-(%#3()*$E
/,()+&#(*+0#()#*6*#3'&3,&*#%4/,+(*8#F&#(*+0#%,/,+$-$#3&'#)$-$#$G()&2#*,)&#<6(#
.'($#5#'(.'($#*6*#%4/,+(*8#:)#*6#$/D,;H(-$-#'$-,.$#*6#(*3(.,@,.,-$-2#*6#$6+&E
.&).'(.,A)8#?$#6),-$-#)&#+,()(#6)#I),.&#*,+,&#-(*,;)$-&2#$#/()&*#<6(#(%#+&-&#
*(#.&/3'()-$#.&/&#*,+,&8#B&D'(#%$#6D,.$.,A)#-(#%$#6),-$-#-(.4$#J',*+A+(%(*#%&#
*,;6,()+(8
K$#-(#3()*$'*(#-(#<6C#/$)('$#%$#)$+6'$%(L$#-(%#+&-&#3&*((#(%#D,()#5#%$#3('@(..,A)2#
&5'47$7')(Z7'&#C)3)"7'8'#[5&6#>6#'#((7'$5&$7'C73'&T?'7'47$7'#('73"#>G'\]?'6)('X#^?'
"#' )$A)&' $)>#3)&?' 47$7' B>' #I=34567_' <B#&' #(' A5#>' "#' =&6#' #&6%' #>' &B' AB#>)'
-,*3&*,.,A)2#5#%&#(*#+$/D,C)#(%#;()('$%2#5#.&)#/0*#'$LA)#C*+(8#M*+(2#()#(@(.+&2#)&#
(1,*+(#3&'#.$6*$#-(%#&'-()2#*,)&#(%#&'-()#3&'#.$6*$#*65$8
N&-$*#%$*#.&*$*#O3(.(*2#$P(*#5#3%$)+$*O#(*+0)#&'-()$-$*#.&)G6)+$/()+(#-(#
.,('+&# /&-&2# 3('&# )&# -(# %$# /,*/$# /$)('$2# ),# *6# (*+$-&# (*# +$%# <6(# 6)$# .&*$# )&#
+();$#'(%$.,A)#$%;6)$#.&)#&+'$2#*,)&#<6(#$%;6)$#+,()(8#:)#(@(.+&2#+&-$*#%$*#.&*$*#
(*+0)#&'-()$-$*#.&)G6)+$/()+(#$#6)#@,)#I),.&8!!
J',*+A+(%(*#*(Q$%A#/65#D,()#%$#.&R(*,A)#.&)#(*+$#-&D%(#@&'/$#-(#.&/3'()-('#
%$#6),-$-#-(%#3()*$/,()+&>#,)/$)().,$#5#+'$*.()-().,$8#:)#(*+&#*,;6(#$#=%$+A)2#
$*4#.&/&#()#%$#'(%$.,A)#-(%#R&/D'(#.&)#(%#.&*/&*8#B,#%$#6),-$-#-(%#3()*$/,()E
+&#3('+()(.(#$%#+&-&2#S3&'#<6C#(*$#6),-$-#%(#*('4$#$G()$#$%#*('#R6/$)&#<6(#
6)$A5=>'N73$)'C)36#'"#('67"7_'`5'()'B>5")"'"#('C#>&)$5#>67'C#36#>#4#')('a7$E
!"# =%$+A)2#3(+456$!&2#TUU2#V!!#(EV!W#$8
!9# J',*+A+(%(*2#7(%&89.$!&2#XUU2#Y2#"Z[W#D#!W8
!!# :5$/82#XUU2#"Z2#"Z[V#$#""E"\8
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
95
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$%&'("%)*+%,#%-#"./%/0#1(%#,%2(3($%-4#13(%)*#%#,%5(6!"#%34"47#%-*%'#1-/"%/%,/%
!"#$%"&'(")*+,-".*/%'0$!#".*#1'!'!*"*&"*-".'*&"*,1.,"*1!#'%%20"!#'3
8495/%412#""(7/12#%9(6:1%-#%('(1#%/%/)*#,,/%'"#7*12/%)*#%'"#2#13#%6(-;
2"/"%#,%<"/9/-(%3#%,/%41=#-247/94>1%3#%,/%=#"3/3$%,/%9*/,%34"./%6?-%(%6#1(-%,(%
-47*4#12#@%&9>6(%3/"%"/A>1%3#,%'"4194'4(%3#%*143/3%9*/13(%B/%2(3/-%,*9#-C%-#%
2-.'%4"*5$'*'&*62,-%'*'.*&1,1#"72*8*5$'*'.#"*1!4'.#10"91:!*.'*6"*"02#"72)*;.#"*
'"#7*12/%24#1#%-*%'"('4(%-#1243($%'#"(%#-%64('#D%E/%'"#7*12/%9(6:1%)*#%6#%
412#"#-/%3#-2/9/"%#-$%6?-%!4#1$%#-2/%(2"/@%&9>6(%1#7/"%#,%'"4194'4(%3#%*143/3%
-4% 9(6'"#13#6(-% )*#% #,% !"#$%&% #-% 2/12(% #,% '"4194'4($% 9(6(% ,/% =42/,43/3% 3#% ,/%
'($&)$)*<1&2.:<19")*="*,"!'%"*'!*&"*5$'*>&"#:!*<2%,$&:*'.#"*/%'0$!#"*5$'*!2.*
6"9',2.*'.*71?<"!"*'!*.$*1%2!@"A*BC*D!2.*7'E"%',2.*92!4'!9'%*92!*#"!#"*<";
94,43/3%3#%)*#%#,%9/6!4($%,/%=43/$%#,%/,6/%F%#,%'#1-/64#12(%1(%#-2?1%"#/,6#12#%
'"#-#12#-%#1%,(%)*#%#-%2(2/,6#12#$%F%)*#%1(%=4=#%14%'4#1-/$%-41(%)*#$%-(,#61#%
8*,"E'.#$2.2F*9"%'!#'*7'*1!#$191:!*'.#?*5$1'#2*8*'.#?#192)G3GH
***
E/%*143/3%3#,%'#1-/64#12(%24#1#%34-2412/-%346#1-4(1#-%)*#%"#<4#"#1%/%,(%
64-6(D%I(3#6(-%34-2417*4",/-%9(6(%346#1-4(1#-%(12(,>749/-$%54-2>"49/-%F%34/,>;
749/-D%J9#"9/%3#%,/%*143/3%3#,%'#1-/64#12(%#-%#=43#12#%/,%6#1(-%#-2(@%)*#%#,%
3#-3(!,/64#12(%3#%#-2/-%346#1-4(1#-%1(%#-%/!-(,*2/6#12#%9,/"(D%E/-%46',49/;
94(1#-%'#9*,4/"#-%3#%9/3/%'#1-/3("%9"#/1%"#<#"#194/-$%3#"4=/94(1#-%F%7#1#/,(;
7./-%#1%*1%',#K(%$*+,-%+.!&D%J,%64-6(%24#6'(%1(2/6(-%)*#%5/F%*1/%2#13#194/%
<4,(-><49/%/%5/9#"%,(%)*#%-4#6'"#%-#%5/%5#95(L%2#13#194/%)*#%14%#-2?%(9*,2/$%14%
#-%#2+"#/D%M/1%9(19"#2/%9(6(%,/%34=#"-43/3%#-%,/%*143/3D
E/-%34-2412/-%/6!47N#3/3#-%)*#%(!-#"=/6(-%2/12(%#1%,/%1(94>1%3#%*143/3%
9(6(%#1%,/%3#%'#1-/64#12(%1(%-#%('(1#1%/%,/%9(19"#94>1D%J6!47*(%=4#1#%3#%
+#.$*5$'*.10!1<19"*"&*%'7'72%*7'C*8*7'*+,-/%+,&0&%)*#%)*4#"#%3#94"%O#12"#%
(2"/-%9(-/-O%6(=#"-#$%5/9#"%(%/92*/"D%E/%*143/3%3#,%'#1-/64#12($%0*-2/6#12#%
'("%-#"%,(%6?-%9(19"#2($%46',49/%*1%6(=#"-#%#1%2("1(%'/"/%!*-9/"%,/%/'"(K46/94>1%
/%-*%9(6'"#1-4>1%F%#K'"#-4>1D%P-2#%"(3#/"%54-2>"49(%F%34/,>749(%#-%,/%6?K46/%
'#"<#994>1%3#,%5(6!"#D
P1%#-2/%41=#-247/94>1%1(%5/F%9/!43/%'/"/%,/%#K9,*-4>1L%14%-4)*4#"/%'/"/%#,%
)*#"#"%#K9,*4"-#D%E(%9(6:1%1(%3#0/%1/3/%<*#"/D%Q49(,%3#9./@%BI#1-/"%#-%9(6*14;
9"%3*="*92,$!19"91:!*'.*$!"*'H/2.191:!*ICJ*>'!."!72F*'&*62,-%'*'H/2!'*"&*.'%*
ICJ*/2%5$'*K&*,1.,2*'.#?*'H/$'.#2*"&*.'%*ICJ*>'%2*9$"!72*"9#L"*91'!#@<19",'!;
GH% I,/2>1$%1-2$)%+$%R"#3(-$%S/3"43$%TUUT$%''D%THV%#;THW%/D
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
96
Aldo Guarneros Monterrubio
!"#$"%$&'()*"$+,"$"-./'0"$1%$2"*$3"$(10"*1$')4"!561$0'$3"41$3"$"-./'0"*2"$1$
27$(52('89:;$<5$&"('2$3"$3"41*$1%='$>,"*1$3"$%1$,05313$3"%$/"021(5"0!'#$"2!'$
2"*71$%1$"-?%,2565313$@"%$"2!1*$3'*(53'A9$B1$1?!5!,3$5035>"*"0!"$10!"$%1$,05313$3"%$
/"021(5"0!'#$1,0+,"$!1()5C0$"2$,01$/'25)5%5313$3"%$&'()*"#$0'$&1?"$(D2$+,"$
3"41*$50?'(,05?13'$"%$/*'/5'$2"*$3"$+,5"0$506"2!5=19$E2!1$/*"!"025F0$3"$2'%5/.
252('#$"(/"*'#$05$25+,5"*1$2"$/,"3"$?,(/%5*$1$?1)1%53139$G*"0!"$1$%1$65!1%5313$
3"$%1$,05313$3"%$/"021(5"0!'#$"%$152%1(5"0!'$27$"0!*1H1$%1$1='0719$I52%1*2"$"2$
1,!'2,/*5(5*2"9$B1$1?!5!,3$!"#$%&%"'%(")$*$3"$%1$>*1=("0!1?5F0$3"%$/"021(5"0!'#$
+,"$"2$14"01$1$%1$>5%'2'>71#$27$/,"3"$/"*(5!5*2"$&1)%1*$3"$1='!1(5"0!'#$/"*'$0'$
/'*+,"$1='!"$"%$/*50?5/5'$3"$,05313#$250'$/'*+,"$1='!1$2,$/*'/5'$1%?10?"9
E653"0!"("0!"$!'3'$/"021(5"0!'$"0?,"0!*1$2,$('!561?5F0$1$/1*!5*$3"$13.
6"*21*5'2$!"F*5?'2#$127$?'('$2"$>,031("0!1$"0$(1"2!*'2$J$"+%,-.$3"%$/"021*9$
E0$%'$"-/,"2!'$1+,7$&"$3"21**'%%13'$%1$/'2!,*1$3"$1%=,0'2$/"0213'*"2$10!5.
=,'2$J$('3"*0'2$?,J1$?'0>510K1$"0$"%$/*50?5/5'$J$"0$"%$/"021(5"0!'$("$/"*.
(5!"0$ ,01$ ?'(/*"025F0$ ?'(L0$ 2')*"$ %1$ ,053139$ E2$ /'25)%"#$ 3"23"$ %,"='#$
1&'031*$"0$"2!1$506"2!5=1?5F0$3"23"$%'2$("35"61%"2$J$%'2$?'0!"(/'*D0"'29$E2!'$
+,525"*1$ 3"21**'%%1*%'$ "0$ '!*'$ ('("0!'#$ 0'$ ?'0$ 1>D0$ 3"$ "*,35?5F0#$ 250'$ /1*1$
"-/%5?5!1*$%1$,05313$3"%$/"021(5"0!'$"0$'!*12$C/'?12$+,"$!1()5C0$1/'*!10$?%1.
*53139$I25(52('#$"0$"2"$('("0!'$2"*D$/"*!50"0!"$2"*$(D2$"-/%7?5!'$?'0$%1$*".
>"*"0?51$1$%'2$136"*21*5'2M$(12$0'$/1*1$0"=1*%'2#$250'$?'0$"%$>50$3"$('2!*1*$
?F('$%1$'/'25?5F0$!1()5C0$1/'*!1$,053139$E%$/*'?"3"*$&1$3"$2"*$C2!"#$J1$+,"$%1$
,05313$3"%$/"021(5"0!'$0'$!'(1$,01$/'2!,*1#$05$*"&L21$'!*129$N'$&1J$356"*2'2$
3'(505'2$05$3"$%1$,05313#$05$3"%$/"021(5"0!'M$1%$("0'2$0'$50?'0"-'29$B'2$352.
!50!'2$"0>'+,"2$0'$1?!L10$?'('$%70"12$/1*1%"%129$E%$/"021(5"0!'$"2$,0$('65.
(5"0!'$+,"$3"0'(50'$%)$*,#"+%*)$-9$E2!"$?'0?"/!'$25=05>5?1$,0$!#-&*.-/?'0!50,'$
3"/1?'/%1*$"0$%1$/1%1)*1$%'$+,"$/'*$27$(52('$J1$"2!D$1?'/%13'9$E%$50!"=*1(5"0!'$
2"$ 31$ "0$ *1KF0$ 3"%$ 1,!'?'0'?5(5"0!'$ +,"$ %1$ >5%'2'>71$ 25"(/*"$ &1$ ),2?13'$ J$
25"(/*"$*"0,"619
E0$"2!1$2,?50!1$"-/'25?5F0$&"$3"413'$3"$%13'$!1()5C0$%1$"-/%5?1?5F0$3"$%1$
!"#$%$!&$'()&*&+',($-./01$!&$2&!&/0&$.$34567$+.8.$8.).$)1$19201-&0$!&$"(')&)$
3"%$/"021(5"0!'9$<50$"()1*='#$"2$?%1*'$+,"$"2!1$5031=1?5F0$0'$"2$14"019$O,".
3"$2"*$+,"$%1$/1%1)*1$0'$"-/*"2"$"0$2,$/%"05!,3$%1$,05313$3"%$/"021(5"0!'$J#$
0'$')2!10!"#$0,0?1$3"41$3"$"0?'0!*1*$,01$>'*(1$"0*5+,"?531$3"$2"H1%1*%'9$O"2"$
1$%1$('31$1?!,1%$P1,0+,"$0'$"-?%,2561$3"$"2!'2$L%!5('2$!5"(/'2P$+,"$05"=1$
%1$/'25)5%5313$3"$3"?5*$(D2$"0$!'*0'$1$%1$6"*313$J$2,$%,K#$&1?"$>1%!1$%1$?'0>510K1$
>5%'2F>5?1$/1*1$?'0!50,1*$?'0$%1$*"0'61?5F0$J$%12$*"6'%,?5'0"2$>5%'2F>5?129$O'*$
L%!5('$+,5"*'$2"H1%1*$+,"$J1$"0$0,"2!*1$C/'?1$%1$*"6'%,?5F0$"2$/1!"0!"$"0$%12$
:;$ E3,1*3'$N5?'%#$0#1$%&"/2*/'"/#"(3)/.%+43'%&"#$ GQE:$;<9'+.:$=>>?:$@$A:$BCDBEF
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.
97
La unidad del pensamiento
!"#$"%&'%!()*+*,-*!.(/0(!"(,"%&(%+(+1#1!(%&-"2$%3%(*+(4%-(&$&3*(+1(31&!$5*.(
!"#$ %!&'%!()*"#+$ ,)')-./01)*%!(%+$ )$ 2!$ !"#$%&'$( )$*+%,'$( +,-$( ./!)!"!0$+$
,2%#$1"!$3)$4)!)!10)$-%$3)$-0*%!#0.!$3.401)$#0%*,'%$%#(5$3)$,"#06030-)-+$*0%!7
(')#$8)9)$3"4"#+$-%$-%10'$:*5#;<=>
Fecha de recepción: 11/02/2013
Fecha de aceptación: 10/05/2013
=>$ ?01)'-"$@"'!%&&%'+$:A3$,'"63%*)$-%3$#%'B$#2#$),"'C)#$%!$3)$"6')$-%$A-2)'-"$D01"3;+$E%#0#$
)*-*(1)'*-()1-(%+(#-*61(6%(713'1-(%&(8"+1!189*:(;<="31:(>?@@:(A(@B:(@>CD(E+(!$,-*F*61(%!(591D
EN-CLAVES DEL PENSAMIENTO, año VIII, núm. 16, julio-diciembre 2014, pp. 79-97.