Recurso de Amparo interpuesto por SACM contra la Sala Tercera

! " #$
%
&'('') *"+ ,- '
!)'('!(".'!/)" & % )+'
!) & 0+'%& % &" .'% !/ (/+" & . +" '!)+ / )" "+
1
$ ("!)
+ %
$. ,"+$ "+)&"+& % (#&/% & '& !)
'
&&
"+ (+'
)" +('0'&" ! %
(+)+2 & %
%
%
*+ &
& 3" )" &
4-''0%
5"%'"
6$ % +(/++!) '!)+ / " +(/+" & . +" ("!)+ %
, . !'5 )7 8/ ! 3" )"
!)+'"+
+"!7 % 9
! " # 5'!& %% ! +/! "%'('
)/&& )+0 :"$ +" +
/ "+ + % &':+"! 8/ !" "&2! +('0'
+&'(* "%'(')/&$ "+(/ !)" ! % ;3'! !
!)+! )& % "& + /&'('%
+( /! !)!(' ("!& ! )"+' ! /("!)
+
<
5%%")
'! .; & &"( =" & &'()&" "+ +>7! "%'(')7 %
%
+( + 8/
%'.'! + % +3')
+" &
5%%"? '! .0 +3"$ !
(*" % &'
:+"! 8/ !"
"&2 / +'
.'+$ ! +>7! & 8/ &'(* !)!(' +"( & $&'
+(). !)$& % 5/ !) &
'!5"+. ('7! & % "& + /&'('%
% +(/++'& . !)'! '!5"+. ('7! /, '!
/:('7! /! %2.') ). "+%$ ("%"(;!&"%" ! /! '. " '0'%'& & + )/
+
("! 3/'+ . % "$ , ).0'#! % '. " '0'%'
& & & )! + (( " %"
+-'('
"
5'! !('+"
8/'+'78/
+"): /'!&'-'&/ %'& &, / & +(*" %
+"! %'& &$
'. 3 !$'!)'.'& & , /)"& )+.'! ('7! '!5"+. )'- $, 8/ !" ') ")
+" . ( !'."
8/ %
+.') 0/ ( + +")(('
7! !) - !)/ %
% '"! & / & +(*"
5/!& . !)%
"%'(')78/
& (% + ("!%/3 + % +(/+"
,
"++ "%/('7!& %
@*+ & &
)'.0+ &
$ &'"(/+" % +"( "
"%'
('
)7 % '!5"+. ,% ("!) )('7!("++ "!&'!) 45"%'
"
6
A !5"+.70 :":/+. !)"$
B$ ! /("!&'('7!& + '
& !) & %
%
+( + &
%
"+) / +. & / )'(' 4-''
0%
5"%'" < <<6$8/ "+ !)!(' & % +'
0/! %
/ +'"+ +'
. +" ! %$ (('7! 3/!& $& ! " #$& %
< & & &'('.0+
&%
<$ ("!& !7 C
/! ! & &" =" & +''7!,")"+37 % 0 ! 5'('"& %
:(/('7! ("!&'('"! %$ "+/! +2"&" & (/ )+" =" '(* !)!(' 8/ &7 5'+. "+
!)!(' & %
%
+( + & % "+) / +. & / )'('
D < E @$& %
A< *+ &
&
)'.0+ &
@ " ("! ) ! %" +3')+" $!' +(*'-" & %
% $8/ % +(/++!) * , "%'('
)&" % %'.'! ('7! & %
!)!(' ("!& ! )"+' & %
+'0/! % " 0'! & %
!)!(' & %
%
+( +
&" 8/ ("!& ! & :(/('
7!
("!&'('"! % & %
! $ &8/'+'7 5'+. > %
&
)
'.0+ &
<$& 0'7 * 0 +
(/. %'&" %
&
)'.0+ &
("!5"+.'& &("!%" )0% ('&" ! % +)2(/%"
& %
, & % 3')
+" , +(*'-" /&'('% , +( & !) & %
% ! % . )+'$ %
% >"& %" &'> =" + /%) %'
( 0% $ "+%"8/ % )
#+.'!" + %'.'! + % +(*'-",
+3')+" - !( * ) %
&
)'.0+ & %
3+37 8/ ("!5"+.
/" %
".''7! &
/!)" ! %
! % "5'('"
$%
!)!(' +"!/!('&
"+%" )
+'0/! %
!%
"! &"(/. !)" F0%'(" $ "+%" 8/ !"
" '0% %)++ /
("!)!'&"!' %'.'! +% & )"&"+3')+"" +(*'-" "! '& +78/ !" * !-'"% !)&"
%" & +(*" 5/!& . !)% & % . +&" "%'
(')
7& (% ++ '
!%/3 + % +(/+"
"!) )7BG9$ ! /("!&'('7!&
"& +&"B ! +%2'
." '! 2.') & /. & %
9 !(" 9 ( ! " #
4-''0%
5"%'"
6. !'5 )7 8/ !" ("! ) ! %"
+(*'-" & % 9 !(" 8/ + + !)$8/ % . +&" * , + !)&" "%'
('
)+
. % " & .; $ % +(/++!) !" '
!&'(7 + 8/# / )" ("!(/+7$" (/;% "5'('! &
+(/+" */. !" +(* >7 / "%'
(')
/&$ "+%" (/ % '. " '0% '!&'-'&/ %'> +%" 37
8/ / + + !)& '. '& + !)+/! "%'(')
/& ! /! ( " ("." % & )/&'"$ !
-'+)/& 8/ / + + !)&" !" /)'
%'> % +("+& (+'.'! % & % ( !&'& )" + /! / )"
("."F!'("(+'
)+'" + & ( +)+ % ' "5+( % )
+0 :""!"$ '!"8/
- %"+!/!
+' & % . !)" + %%" "%'('
)78/
& (% + '!%/3 + % +(/+"$
<
!%
/0 )!('('7!& % +"( "
& () %
* !"0 +- &"%
+ (+'('"! % 3 %
3')
+&" '! ) "0"?,$
9
) . +"
+ !)7 + :+( +("!)+"% "0+ %
'!5"+. ('7! 8/ ') ! % 0 & & )" & %
%
+( + & % "+) / +. &
/ )'(' % (/ %
!(/ !)+ &' "!'0% ! % &'+(('
7! % ()+7!'
( HHH "& +
:/&'('% 3"(+I % )+( +I$ ! -'+)/& 8/ $ !
0 & &)
" ("! ) % D")" &
% &
('7!
D < E @$8/ ("!5'+.7 %" + / %)" ("!)+ % . +&" ! %
!)!(' & %
(('7! 3/!& & % +'0/! % / +'"+ +'
. +" ! % &
! " #$&
%
< *+ & & &'('.0+ &
@ &'('"! %. !)$ & . !&7 % )/)% & %
& +(*" % )
+0 :"$ / $ ! (+')+'" & % +(/++!)$ % 9
! " #$/)'%'>7
5%%"
+ +(* > +/! "%'('
)
/&& . % 78/ +)!&'7 + !)+
G G
9
+% - !(' + &'+'.'+ % + !) +(/+" & . +"$
)'! ! "+ (+&'
)&" %" '3/'!)
6 &'!) !)!(' & % +'
0/! % / +'"+
+'. +" ! %$ (('7! 3/!& $& ! " #$& %
< & & &'('.0+ &
<$
% . +&" 5/ ("!& ! &" "+ /!
! & &" =" & +''7! "+ % & %')" &
("* (*" '. +" '" '
.'."$% ")"+37 % 0 ! 5'('" & % :(/('7! ("!&'('"! % & %
! "+/! +2"&" & (/ )+" =" 4'!5"+.
5"%'" < 6 6 &'!) !)!(' & %
%
+( + & %
"+) / +. & / )
'(' D < E @$& %
A< *+ &
&
)'.0+ &
@$ &8/'+'7 5'+. >
5%%" 4'!5"+.
5"%'" < 6 A6 %
&
)'.0+ &
$& 0'7 +(/. %'&
!)!(' ("!& ! )"+' 4'!5"+. 5"%'"<A6
6 ! % 0 & & )" & %
%
+( + & %
"+) / +. & / )'(' 8/
!(/ !)
+ &' "!'0% ! % &'
+(('7! % ()+7!'( HHH "& +:/&'('% 3"(+I % )+( +I$
/ & ("! /%)+
!)!(' & %
% &
('7! ! % 4* (*"'!("!)+"- +)'&"6
G G
9
)'. ! '!& ." )+&" %" '3/'!) &
+% - !(' + ) + "%/('7! 6C/ % +(/++!) * , + !)&"/! "%'(')/& !)
%
%
+( + & % "+) / +. & / )'(' + 8/
%'.'! % +3')+" & %
!)!(' ("!& ! )"+' 8/ ') ! /("!)+ !% 0 & & )" &
&
(*"4%"
/)" 6 6C/ % 9
! " # * , ! 3 &" +('0'+/! "%'('
)/& & . % " & %
+(/++!)$ "+8/ ! /("!)+ ') /! !)!(' ("!& ! )"+' 4%" /)" 6
D
9
G
J
E
D
% +"( .'!)" & & )
" +"! % $ / )+).'!)" ! 3+!& 0
& & )" , /
&'5/ '7! !% "('& && '!5"+. ('7!)(!"%73'
( $ '!&/& %3/! / "! /!("!5%'()"
!)+ % %'0 +)&& '!5"+. ('7!$% )+! +!(' , /0%'('& & &.'!')+)
'
- K 3F!
% ( " & /:)" & & +(*" +'- &" " !) , 7+3 !" F0%'(" , %" & +(*" %
*"!"+ '!)'
.'& && %" ('/& & !"
) & +(*"5/!& . !)%$ " )/-" ) %
L4M 6 /+3 ("." /! + / ) % .0'!) 3%"0 % & 5%/'& >'!5"+. )'- 8/
-'.0'!) 8/ * / )
" ! !)+&'
(*" % 57+./% )+&'('"! % & +")(('7! %"
& )"
+"! % $ + -"%/('"! + ! )!('
7! % ! ( '& & & /)'%'> + !/ * ++.'!) 8/
+.')! 3 +!)'
> + % & +(*" 5/!& . !)% & %" ('/& & !"
& ('&'
+8/'#!$(/;!&"$&7!& , 0 :" 8/#, (/;%
& )" 4D")"
$& %
@ *+ &
('+(/! )!(' )'! ("!)()" ("! /
& :/!'"&
6
) !)!(' $
('%. !)$'%/ )+)'- ! %" 8/ +
& % & +(*" / $("!( &'7
() % %( !( , ("!)!'
&"
L4M 6 % & +(*" 5/!& . !)% & )"& +"! 52'( " :/+2&'( ("!"( +%" 8/ ("! )
"0+ %% $ / 0'! " & +(*" ! (/ %8/'++3')+" " +(*'-"$& )
"& ! )/+% > $
'!(%/ " . (;!'( $ % ()+7!'( " '!5"+. )'> & $
F0%'
( " +'- & ? 2("." %
5'! %'& & 8/
'!5"+. ('7! & )'! , 8/
. % & F!'
( . !) + &'
(*"
5'!$ % (/ % & !& +;& % ! )/+% > & % +3')+" !(/ )'7!4M 6 "+ / +)$5/ !
%
!)!('
< $& %
<A@ *+ &
& :/%'" &
$&"!&
)0% ('+"!$ (% +. !)$ % +3% , +'!(''" 8/ * ! & (/. %'+
5'! &
3 +!)
'> +% +")(('7!& & )"
2$ !)
+ ")+ (" $ /0+,7% "0%'3 ('7!8/
% '!5"+. & % ! ( '& & & +("3 + % '!5"+. ('7! , %" & )
'! )+'" &
'!5"+. ('7!?& % '. "+)!(' & /("! !)
'.'!)"?8/ " & )"
! & (/ &" ,
+)
'! !) ! +% ('7!("! % 5'! %'
& & + 8/
* ! "0)!'&"?8/
5'! %'& &
% 32
)'. ? % 3 +!)2 8/ % '!&'-'&/" . !)!3 % &' " '('7! & / +" '
'!5"+. ('"! ?% +"*'0'('7! 0 "%/) & &'-/%3 +( )3"+2
+)
'(/% + & & )" $)%
("." %
+5+!('
/ % $+%'
3'" , "%2)
'( , ")
+" & )"
! '0% ("."
& ('.'!)
" ":/'('" & - %"+4+ ()"& %" (/ % % &' " '('7!8/
)'! +;
./(*".; 5/ +) / )
"8/ 5()! % +&/()".; 2!)'."& +"! %'
& &6
D
. "(" "&+2! "0-'+ 8/ & 0 ')
'+/! & (/ & :/ )'5'( ('7! "('% +
+("% ()+ %" & )" 8/ +(% . 8/ +(/++!) K("!)
+"% & % ()/ ('7! & %
/)"+'& & :/+'&'(('"! % , % )+! +!(' & % +"( " $!'8/ % 5'! %'& & 8/
+)!& "0)! +("!% +("% (('7!* & +% 32
)'. ,8/ "+ !& $ % )
+).'!)"*
& +! ( +'" + %"3++
"0:)
'-"$& *28/ % &
+( +
!( '
& &$
&
+( % + / / )" 8/ . + % )+).'!)" , &")$& ) ."&"$& /!
( +;()+& ). "+%'& & / /)'%'> ('7! ! %" 8/ + () % % >" & )! !(' & %
'!5"+. ('7! $
('%. !)$'%/ )+)'- %
!)!('
& %
@ *"+
&%
& !"-'.0+ &
$8/ = %"%" '3/'!)
L4M 6% '!5"+. ('7! , & )" 8/ / & ! + )!'&" ! %" +(*'-" & %
!)+" &
!5"+. ('7! "%'('%$+% ('"! &" ("! /! +"! % 8/
% )+'0/,7 % (".''7!
& /! * (*" & %'()'-" 4'
!('" (6, 6$ "+/! )'. " & )+.'! &"$.; '." & &'>
="
+)
'+& / !")('7!$- !('&" % (/ %$ '!5"+. ('7!& 0 +( !( % & ?,%
'!5"+. ('7! 8/
)'! ! +% ('7! ("! %
!)!(' &'()& "+%" +'0/! % &
/ )'(' 4'!('"&6& % +)2
(/%" 6$ % % >"& 0 + "+ % .'."8/ +'3 % )! !(' &
%" & )" ! % 3')
+" &
%'!(/ !) & % +3 !'." & !- )
'3 ('7! /&'('%$
&'> ="
+)
'+& % (/. %'.'!)"& % ("!& ! 4M 6N
! %" 8/
) +)
'(/% ++ ()$& 0 + %)+ 8/ % 5(* ! 8/
'!)+ / " ) +"( " & . +"$!" * 02 )+! (/++'&" % % >" & ( &/('& & & %
("!& ! 9 :" ) '!)%'3 !('$& ( +) %
% 8/
* , +"&/('&" % 3+-'" 8/
+(% .
D
9
G
D
9
G
D
% +)
2(/%"<
& %
, & % /+'&'(('7! "! )')/('"! %$ % (+ + ) +"( "$&' / " - +'"
+8/'')" & &.''0'%'
& & ! +'. + %/3 + 8/ %
!)'& & " +"!
+'- &
O ()F ! " & 0 ! ()/ + ! :+('('" & 5/!('"! " ") )& F0%'( O( " ! % (/ %
% . +"!" &'5+!(' & % )"&"8/ % . +"("!)
+ 7+3 !" " +-'&"+ F0%'
("
!)!)" % /:)"& & +(*" +'- &" ()F ("." '5/ /!"& %%" '!" )+) &
) *'7) '$, % /:)"& & +(*" +'- &"& * (*""& & +(*" )
; !/! " '('
7!
& "& +$ % . +" +; +"( & !) F!'
( . !) ("." +. &'" /0 '&'+'" & %
% 3'% ('7!(".F! ' (/. % !")+ &" ("!&'('"!
68/ %" +. &'" :/+'&'(('"! % ("./! !" ! /5'('!)
) *'7) ' / "!
8/ $ ')'!&"+. &'" +"( % ("./! "+%" 8/ %
+) "&+2!&'(/)'
+/
+)! '"! $ % + /%)&" & % :/'('" + /%)$ (% +. !)$ '! /5'('!) " !)+'"+$
'. %'( +2 8/ %
+) !" %"3++2 )'5( + / +)! '7! !' /! "0)!'!&" /! 5%%"
5-"+0% ?068/ %" +. &'" :/+'&'(('"! % ("./!
! )+&2"
)" 8/ F!
')
'!&" +"( &'.'!)" :/+'&'(('"! %
("./!
& (/ &"
+
)'5( + %
+)! '7! & % )/)% &"$ % + /%)&" & %" .'." +2 )+&2" +"&/('
#!&" % '"!
& &'52('
% " '. " '0% + +('7! ! %" 8/ + () % 9
! " #$ % +(/+"
+ /%) '! &.''0% ! -'+)/& 8/
"('& & !" !(/ !)
+ ! /! " '('7! & "& +
+ ()" & % . +&" E'! %. !)$("!-'! = % +8/ $ ! %" 8/ + ()
)
+(/++'&"$!" ') +/ 0 %3/! 8/
+.') (+&')+ 8/
* , +"&/('&" %
3+-'" +(% . &" "+ % ("!)
++'
"$ % + + !)!) % 3 % & % "('& & (('"! &
! 37 ! / ("!) )('7! 8/ / + + !)& * , -/%! +&" & +(*" 5/!& . !)%
%3/!" & % . +&" / $!" "%" % +(/++!) ".')'7 = % +(/;% 5/ % "5'('! &
+(/+" */. !" 8/ +(* >7 / "%'(')/& & . % "$ '
!"$ "0+ )
"&"$ "+8/ %
+"( &'.'!)" + /!). !) /)'%'> &" + - %"++% "%'
(')/& !"
:/ ) %" & %
0 !(" (('"! &"4("!) )('7!-''0% 5"%'"
6
D
+(/+"
J
"+"% +'
" & %"
& (% + '
!%/3 + % +(/+"
/ )"$
'
. "! & (% ++ '! %/3 + %