English

Impact of the invasive plant Syzigium jambos (Myrtaceae) on patterns of
understory seedling abundance in a Tropical Premontane Forest, Costa Rica
Gerardo Avalos1,2, Kelly Hoell1 Jocelyn Gardner3, Scott Anderson4 & Conor Lee5
1
2
3
4
5
The School for Field Studies, Center for Sustainable Development Studies, 10 Federal St, Suite 24, Salem,
Massachusetts, USA 01970-3876.
Escuela de Biología, Universidad de Costa Rica, 2060 San Pedro, San José Costa Rica. Fax: (506) 207-4216,
[email protected]
Center for Environmental Studies, Kellogg House, Williams College, Williasmtown MA 01267 USA.
School of International Relations, University of Southern California, 3518 Trousdale Parkway, VKC 330 University
Park, Los Angeles CA 90089-0043 USA.
Santa Clara University, Department of Biology, 500 El Camino Real, Santa Clara CA 95053 USA.
Received 25-VII-2005.
Corrected 12-I-2006.
Accepted 22-III-2006.
Abstract. Habitat fragmentation, along with other human-induced disturbances, increase the vulnerability of
native habitats to be invaded by aggressive, ecologically released, exotic species. Syzigium jambos (L.) Alston
(Myrtaceae, Rose Apple) is an important invader still spreading throughout Hawaii, the Antilles, Central and
South America. This study examines the effects of S. jambos on plant understory diversity in a 25 ha Tropical
Premontane Moist Forest in Atenas, Alajuela, Costa Rica, a protected watershed that supplies drinking water for
several human communities. Our final objective is to develop a management strategy combining water protection with the preservation of a representative sample of the original plant diversity in the area. Thirty 2 X 2 m
plots were distributed throughout the Municipal Forest maintaining a minimum of 10 m between plots, and 2
m from trails, to sample all understory seedlings and saplings of S. jambos, Coffea arabica (coffee) and tree
seedlings. We found a clear dominance of S. jambos over all other understory plants. Of the total 1 285 sampled
plants, S. jambos comprised 51%, coffee seedlings represented 14,78%, being the rest tree seedlings. Syzigium
jambos had the highest density (5.46 plants/m2, S.D. = 6.44) compared to tree (3.67 plants/ m2, S.D. = 3.44) and
coffee seedlings (1.58 plants/ m2, S.D. = 2.13). There was a highly significant negative relationship between the
relative abundance of S. jambos and tree (r2 = 0.52, p < 0.00001) and coffee seedlings (r2 = 0.28, p < 0.002).
The abundance of coffee seedlings did not affect the abundance of tree seedlings (r2 = 0.01, p < 0.58). Since
the canopy of the Municipal Forest is relatively closed and composed of a monolayer of trees with almost no
overlapping crowns, we found no relationship between canopy cover and the abundance of S. jambos. The height
distribution indicated that the majority of S. jambos individuals were seedlings and saplings (height ≤ 1.5 m),
with only 4.6% classified as adults, (height ≥ 2 m). The results show a clear role of S. jambos as an aggressive,
invasive species within the Municipal Forest. This invasion is enhanced by both the ecological characteristics of
the species and the fragmentation of the forest by coffee farming around the site. Among a variety of management possibilities, an ecosystem-level approach of manually removing S. jambos over time while replanting
native species appears to be the preferred strategy, given the intended continued use of the Municipal Forest as
a source of drinking water and as a representative sample of the original vegetation of the area. Rev. Biol. Trop.
54(2): 415-421. Epub 2006 Jun 01.
Key words: Syzigium jambos, invasive species, forest management, water quality management, Costa Rica.
The spread of invasive, exotic plant species, especially when coupled with widespread habitat alteration, continues to be the
major threat to global biodiversity (Soule
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
1990, D’Antonio and Vitousek 1992, Goodwin
et al. 1999). Invasive plants are endowed with
suites of ecological traits that allow them
to spread rapidly, infiltrate alien ecosystems,
415
and out-compete native plants, taking over
their niches and often removing those native
species from the ecosystem altogether. These
traits include a short juvenile period, early and
almost continuous, profuse reproduction, widely dispersed seeds, high initial germination, fast
growth rate of seedlings, shade tolerance, and
capacity to self-pollinate (i.e., Miconia calvescens, Meyer and Florence 1996, Rejmanek
and Richardson 1996). Many of the best invaders are “r-strategists” because the majority of
invasions take place in human-disturbed areas
(Baker 1974, Rejmanek et al. 1996).
Syzigium jambos (L.) Alston (Myrtaceae,
Rose Apple) is a small tree (10-15 m) native
to Southeast Asia that has been introduced into
the Hawaiian Archipelago, Southern Florida
and the Neotropics due to its importance as
a shade tree, edible fruits and showy flowers
(Amshoff 1958). It has become an aggressive
invader species in Puerto Rico, the Dominican
Republic, and Hawaii, where it dominates forest stands, impoverishing the native flora and
increasing the risk of extinction of endangered
taxa. It represents one of the 40 most aggressive invasive angiosperms listed by Rejmanek
and Richardson (1996).
In Costa Rica, S. jambos is traditionally
used as a living fence and, less frequently, as
a shade tree for coffee plantations. It is pollinated by bees (Lughadha and Proenca 1996)
and dispersed by a wide variety of birds and
bats. S. jambos produces abundant fruits with
polyembrionic seeds (1 cm in diameter), and
shade tolerant, flexible seedlings able to resist
mechanical damage (Di Stefano et al. 1998).
In addition, it has a high tannin concentration,
being highly defended against herbivores (Di
Stefano et al. 1998). These conditions have
facilitated the colonization of disturbed forests
adjacent to coffee plantations in the Central
Valley of Costa Rica (Di Stefano et al. 1998)
where it potentially outcompetes slow-growing
tree seedlings for light, nutrients, and space.
Following an infiltration pattern of invasion
(Wilson and Lee 1989), S. jambos has found
favorable conditions in disturbed forests, such
416
as lack of predators and pathogens during the
first stages of regeneration, and appropriate
conditions for germination and seedling establishment. The small, fragmented forests still
surviving in the Central Valley are drained of
native tree species due to higher rates of local
extinction and recruitment limitation (lack of
enough reproductive adults and seeds failing
to arrive to safe sites) and are prone to being
dominated by exotic, invader species. In this
study, we analyze the impact of S. jambos
on patterns of understory seedling diversity
and density at the Municipal Forest of Atenas
(Alajuela, Costa Rica), a 25 ha forest fragment surrounded by coffee plantations, and
discuss alternatives for the management of
this invader species.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Study Site. The study was done at the
Municipal Forest of Atenas, Alajuela, Costa
Rica (9o58’21’’ N, 84o26’24’’ W) in October
2003. This 25 ha tropical premontane moist
forest fragment (1 013 m in elevation) benefits from permanent protection due to its
importance as a source of potable water for
neighboring communities. The topography of
the forest is diverse, ranging from flat terrain
to steep areas of 45o slopes. The Municipal
Forest is a late successional forest of about
40 years of regeneration. The forest is connected to other small forest patches only along
7.8% of its perimeter, whereas shaded coffee
plantations line 56.5% of its border; the rest
is bordered by Highway 3. Canopy height is
close to 25 m, and two well-defined strata can
be distinguished. The forest maintains 119 tree
species distributed into 51 families (Brassil
et al. 2000), but it is dominated by secondary successional species such as Anacardium
excelsum, Luhea semannii, Ceiba pentandra,
Zanthoxyllum sp., and Bravaisia intergerrima.
In addition to abundant S. jambos seedlings,
we observed an infiltration of coffee seedlings
coming from nearby plantations.
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
Density of S. jambos. To measure the
density of S. jambos, we used 30 plots of 2 X 2
m distributed throughout the Municipal Forest
following the outline of the trails. Plots were
separated by at least 10 m and were located at
least 2 m from the edge of the trail. Within each
plot, we measured the number and height of
all S. jambos plants and recorded the diameter
at breast height (DBH, 1.3 m) in individuals ≥
2 m. In addition, we located all seedlings and
saplings from other species within the plots
and recorded their number. The percentage of
canopy cover above the plot was measured
with a spherical densiometer model C (Forestry
Suppliers) held in the middle of the plot and
pointing south.
abundance of coffee seedlings was transformed
using the square root transformation to fit
the normal distribution (Shapiro-Wilk test =
0.94, p = 0.1). In addition, we explored the
potential of coffee plants to become invaders
by looking at the relationship between relative
abundance of coffee seedlings per plot vs. the
abundance of tree seedlings (excluding S. jambos). Probability values for these regressions
were adjusted using the Bonferroni correction
following Rice (1988). All analyses were done
using the JMP IN statistical software version
4.0.4 (Sall et al. 2001).
Population structure of S. jambos.
Histograms were inspected to determine the
distribution of S. jambos in different size
classes. If height distribution is concentrated
on small size classes (i.e., plants ≤ 1.5 m),
it could be that S. jambos has the ability to
germinate and survive in the shade but is suppressed to move to higher size classes by low
light conditions. To determine this, we related
the abundance of different size classes with
the percentage of canopy cover. We expected
seedling and sapling height to increase with
increasing canopy aperture.
Impact of S. jambos on understory
diversity. Of the total 1 285 sampled plants,
S. jambos made up 51%, coffee seedlings represented 14.78% and the rest was made of tree
seedlings. Thus, it was not strange to observe a
relatively high density (5.46 plants/m2, S.D. =
6.44) of S. jambos throughout the sampled area
(120 m2), which was higher than the average
density of tree (3.67 plants/ m2, S.D. = 3.44)
and coffee seedlings (1.58 plants/ m2, S.D.
= 2.13). The high values of standard deviation reflect negative interactions between the
abundance of S. jambos and that of coffee and
tree seedlings since plots that were dominated
by S. jambos had few seedlings from the other
two. Congruent with this, we found a significant negative relationship between the relative
abundance of S. jambos and tree (Fig. 1a) and
coffee seedlings (Fig. 1b). However, the abundance of coffee seedlings did not affect the
abundance of tree seedlings (Fig. 1c).
Impact of S. jambos on understory diversity. We used linear regression analyses to test
the significance of the relationship between
the relative abundance of S. jambos per plot
and the relative density of other tree seedlings,
as well as the significance of the relationship
between S. jambos and coffee seedling and sapling relative abundance. If S. jambos is taking
over the space in each plot, we will observe a
negative relationship (high density of S. jambos
vs. low density of tree and coffee seedlings).
The relative abundance of seedlings from tree
species was transformed following the Box
and Cox transformation (Draper and Smith
1981) to control the heterogeneity of variance
with increasing sample size as reflected in an
initially atypical residual pattern. The relative
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
RESULTS
Influence of light conditions. Levels of
canopy aperture varied between 55-92% with an
average of 73.76% (S.D. = 10.25%). The canopy at the Municipal Forest is relatively closed
and composed of a monolayer of canopy trees
with almost no overlapping crowns. We did not
find large gaps of significant importance (i.e.,
above 30 m2). Shade conditions were prevalent
throughout most of the study site. Accordingly,
417
Fig. 1. Regression analyses of the abundance of S. jambos vs. the abundance of tree and coffee seedlings, and of coffee
seedlings vs. the abundance of tree seedlings in the Municipal Forest of Atenas, Alajuela, Costa Rica.
we did not find a significant effect of variable
levels of canopy aperture on the abundance of
S. jambos seedlings (r2 = 0.002, p1,28 = 0.77),
abundance of tree (r2 = 0.0001, p1,28 = 0.94)
and coffee seedlings (r2 = 0.006, p1,28 = 0.67).
However, we observed the absence of S. jambos seedlings from sun-exposed forest edges
and high light environments. It seems that
seeds germinate and seedlings develop better
under shade conditions (and thus, have difficulty colonizing open habitats), but to move
to higher size classes, plants need a significant
increase in radiation.
Population structure. The population
distribution in size classes of S. jambos is
dominated by seedlings under 50 cm in height
(Fig. 2). Individuals above 1.5 m (juveniles
and adults) were rare, although we detected 29
potential adults (individuals over 2 m, representing 4% of the sampled population) out of
the total sample of 655 individuals. Although
they were not represented in the sample, we
observed more tall individuals on the edges
of a coffee plantation. It is thus likely that the
invasion into the Municipal Forest occurred
through the reproduction of adults escaping
from coffee plantations and farms, as well as by
animal dispersal of fruits. This combined strategy is termed “infiltration invasion” by Wilson
and Lee (1989). Fifty percent of the sampled
population is less than or equal to 30 cm in
418
Fig. 2. Height distribution of individuals of S. jambos at the
Municipal Forest of Atenas, Alajuela, Costa Rica.
height, 75% is under 64 cm, and only 10% is
above 117 cm. The higher aggregation of seedlings took place around taller individuals.
DISCUSSION
Syzigium jambos had a clear negative
impact on understory seedling diversity at the
Municipal Forest of Atenas. Plots dominated by
S. jambos had few seedlings from other species
(including the other potential invader, coffee),
which were concentrated in areas free from
seedlings of S. jambos. Coffee seedlings are
becoming abundant and are entering the forest
as a result of dispersal by bats. Like S. jambos,
coffee seedlings are also shade tolerant, and
although they did not occur in such high numbers, over time they have potential to become
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
dominant in areas of the Municipal Forest that
are close to coffee plantations (Fig. 1b). Shade
tolerance gives S. jambos (and coffee) the
capacity to invade even undisturbed forests, or
forests in advanced stages of regeneration, as
long as coffee plantations are nearby. Similar
trends for shade tolerant invaders have been
observed in temperate (Wyckoff and Webb
1996) and tropical areas (Meyer and Florence
1996). In addition, the low herbivory levels
observed in S. jambos (DiStefano et al. 1998)
due to the high tannin concentration could have
the potential to deter the establishment of other
tree seedling species due to allelopathic interactions, similar to the case of the introduced
nitrogen-fixing tree Myrica faya that inhibits
the germination of the native tree Metrosideros
polymorpha on the island of Hawaii (Walker
and Vitousek 1991). Since most of the understory is dominated by S. jambos (51% of all
understory plants), it is very likely that the
primary consequences of the invasion affect
the first stages of regeneration of canopy trees,
since areas dominated by S. jambos had a low
density of canopy tree seedlings. Although the
Atenas Municipal Forest is relatively large
as compared to other forest fragments still
surviving in the Central Valley of Costa Rica
(i.e., DiStefano et al. 1998), it shares many
of the problems of small fragments, such as
the scarcity of reproductive adults, increased
inbreeding depression, and recruitment limitation. To be of additional value to the local
communities, these forests need to be managed
to increase the level of diversity of understory
seedlings, plant native trees by hand, and protect the forests from fire and from the invasion
of exotic species. The removal of exotic species is recommended only if the local human
communities want to preserve a sample of the
original forest habitat by implementing restoration practices. If this is the case, the removal of
exotics must be done cautiously with careful
consideration of the maintenance of the ecosystem functions already being performed by exotics such as S. jambos (Westman 1990, Gordon
1998). These functions include production of
food for vertebrates, soil stabilization, and
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
effects on water-holding capacity and water
percolation of soils. It is very likely that a sudden removal of S. jambos will impact the water
holding capacity of the soil, especially considering the steep topographic conditions present
at the site. A much healthier strategy will be to
begin selecting representative species of the
area, establishing nurseries, and planting seedlings by hand, since forest isolation makes it
unlikely that natural regeneration will proceed
rapidly. At the same time, a consistent removal
of seedlings and adults of S. jambos already in
the forest should be implemented. More effective control programs at this stage will emerge
from managing the entire forest from an ecosystem point of view, rather than focusing
on individual species (Hobbs and Humphries
1994). We do not consider the introduction of
biological control agents targeting S. jambos
the best management strategy, due to the possibility that biological control agents may switch
hosts over time and that one of the documented
biological control agents, the fungus Puccinia
psidii, is very aggressive (Tessman et al. 2001)
and likely to switch hosts within the Myrtaceae
(Rayachhetry et al. 2001). Although DiStefano
et al. (1998) and Rayachhetry et al. (2001) did
not find significant leaf damaged provoked by
this fungus, Tessman et al. (2001) report annual
outbreaks of Puccinia psidii in Brasilia, Brazil,
that cause major leaf, flower and fruit mortality. The elimination of large-scale mechanical
removal and biological control as options
leaves manual removal of S. jambos as the
only suitable management technique for the
Municipal Forest. A successful management
plan would involve removal of seed sources
outside the forest coupled with removal and
replacement of S. jambos within. Adult S. jambos could be removed sparingly over time and
replaced with native tree saplings. Removing
saplings surrounding the adults is another possibility to ensure that species other than S. jambos will grow to adulthood. This will increase
the overall diversity of native tree species
by decreasing the sheer number of S. jambos
saplings. A drawback to this plan is that it
is highly time and labor-intensive, requiring
419
a devoted volunteer staff or long-term paid
positions. It does, however, offer the ability
to adjust management strategies in the shortterm to address changes in the overall balance
of the ecosystem.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We thank Nolan Quirós for suggesting
work on this system and the School for Field
Studies for their logistic support during the
period of the study.
RESUMEN
La fragmentación del hábitat, junto con otros disturbios antropogénicos, aumentan la vulnerabilidad de
los ambientes nativos a la invasión por especies exóticas,
agresivas y sin controles ecológicos. Syzigium jambos
(L.) Alston (Myrtaceae, Manzana Rosa) es una invasora
importante que todavía está extendiendose en Hawaii, Las
Antillas, Centro y Suramérica. Este estudio examina los
efectos de S. jambos sobre la diversidad de plantas del
sotobosque en un Bosque Húmedo Premontano de 25 ha en
Atenas, Alajuela, Costa Rica, una microcuenca protegida
que suple de agua potable a varias comunidades. Nuestro
objetivo final es desarrollar una estrategia de manejo que
combine la protección del agua con la conservación de
una muestra representativa de la diversidad de plantas
original del área. Distribuimos 30 parcelas de 2 X 2 m en
el Bosque Municipal manteniendo una distancia mínima
de 10 m entre parcelas y 2 m lejos de los senderos, para
muestrear las plántulas y brinzales de S. jambos, Coffea
arabica (café) y árboles. Encontramos una clara dominancia de S. jambos sobre las demás plantas de sotobosque.
De 1 285 plantas muestreadas S. jambos representó 51%,
el café abarcó 14,78%, siendo el resto plántulas de árboles.
Syzigium jambos tuvo la mayor densidad (5.46 plantas/m2,
D.E. = 6.44) en comparación a plántulas de árboles (3.67
plantas/ m2, D.E. = 3.44) y de café (1.58 plantas/ m2, S.D.
= 2.13). Hubo una relación negativa entre la abundancia
relativa de S. jambos y las plántulas de árboles (r2 = 0.52,
p < 0.00001) y café (r2 = 0.28, p < 0.002). La abundancia
de las plántulas de café no afectó la abundancia de las
plántulas de árboles (r2 = 0.01, p < 0.58). Ya que el dosel
del Bosque Municipal es relativamente denso y se compone de una monocapa de árboles casi sin traslape entre
copas, no encontramos relación entre la cobertura del dosel
y la abundancia de S. jambos. La distribución de altura
indicó que la mayoría de los individuos de S. jambos eran
plántulas y brinzales (altura ≤ 1.5 m), con solamente 4.6%
clasificados como adultos, (altura ≥ 2 m). Los resultados
420
muestran un claro papel de S. jambos como especie invasora muy agresiva en el Bosque Municipal. Esta invasión
es favorecida tanto por las características ecológicas de la
especie así como por la fragmentación del bosque causada
por plantaciones de café alrededor del sitio de estudio.
Entre las diversas alternativas de manejo, consideramos
que debe usarse una estrategia a nivel de ecosistema, y
remover manualmente S. jambos a la largo del tiempo y a
la vez sembrar especies nativas, considerando que el uso
programado para el Bosque Municipal es ser fuente de
agua potable y proteger una muestra representativa de la
vegetación original del área.
Palabras clave: Syzigium jambos, especies invasoras, manejo forestal, manejo de la calidad del agua,
Costa Rica.
REFERENCES
Amshoff, G. 1958. Myrtaceae. Ann. Missouri Bot. Garden
45: 93-201.
Baker, H.G. 1974. The evolution of weeds. Ann. Rev. Ecol.
Syst. 5: 1-24.
Brassil, E., B. Burris, S. Godlove, M. Martin, O. Merrow,
H. Rectenwald & M. Rust. 2000. Floristic composition, species richness, and vertical structural attributes of El Bosque Municipal de Atenas. School for
Field Studies Center for Sustainable Development,
Directed Research, Atenas, Costa Rica. 15 p.
D’Antonio, C.M. & P.M. Vitousek. 1992. Biological invasions by exotic grasses, the grass/fire cycle, and
global change. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Syst. 23: 63-87.
Di Stéfano, J.F., L.A. Fournier, J. Carranza, W. Marín &
A. Mora. 1998. Potencial invasor de Syzigium jambos (Myrtaceae) en fragmentos boscosos: El caso
de Ciudad Colón, Costa Rica. Rev. Biol. Trop. 46:
567-53.
Draper, N. & H. Smith. 1981. Applied Regression Analysis.
Wiley, New York, USA. 709 p.
Goodwin, B., A. McAllister & L. Fahrig. 1999. Predicting
Invasiveness of Plant
Species Based on Biological Information. Conserv. Biol.
13: 422-426.
Gordon, D.R. 1998. Effects of invasive, non-indigenous
plant species on ecosystem processes: lessons from
Florida. Ecol. Appl. 8: 975-989.
Hobbs, L.J. & S.E. Humphries. 1994. An integrated
approach to the ecology and management of plant
invasions. Conserv. Biol. 9: 761-770.
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
Lughadha, E.N. & C. Proenca. 1996. A survey of the reproductive biology of the Myrtoidea (Myrtaceae). Ann.
Missouri Bot. Garden 83: 480-503.
Soule, M. 1990. The Onslaught of Alien Species, and Other
Challenges in the Coming Decades. Conserv. Biol.
4: 233-239.
Meyer, J.Y. & J. Florence. 1996. Tahiti’s native flora
endangered by the invasion of Miconia calvescens
D.C. (Melastomataceae). J. Biogeogr. 23: 775-781.
Tessmann, D.J., J.C. Dianese, A.C. Miranda & L.H.R.
Castro. 2001. Epidemiology of a Neotropical rust
(Puccinia psidii). Plant Pathol. 50: 725-731.
Rayachhetry, M.B., T. K. Van, T. D. & M. L. Elliott. 2001.
Host range of Puccinia psidii, a potential biological
control agent of Melaleuca quinquenervia in Florida.
Biol. Control 22: 38-45.
Walker, L.R. & P.M. Vitousek. 1991. An invader alters
germination and growth of a native dominant tree in
Hawaii. Ecology 72: 1449-1455.
Rejmanek, M. & D.M. Richardson. 1996. What attributes make
some plant species more invasive? Ecol. 77: 1655-1661.
Westman, W.E. 1990. Park management of exotic plant
species: problems and issues. Conserv. Biol. 4: 251260.
Rice, W.R. 1988. Analyzing tables of statistical tests. Evol.
43: 223-225.
Wilson, J.B. & W.G. Lee 1989. Infiltration invasion. Funct.
Ecol. 3: 379-380.
Sall, J., A. Lehman & L. Creighton. 2001. JMP Start Statistics:
A guide to Statistics and Data Analysis using JMP and
JMP IN Software. Duxbury, California, USA.
Wycoff, P.H. & S.L. Webb. 1996. Understory influence of
the invasive Norway Maple (Acer platanoides). Bull.
Torrey Bot. Club 123: 197-205.
Rev. Biol. Trop. (Int. J. Trop. Biol. ISSN-0034-7744) Vol. 54 (2): 415-421, June 2006
421